My grandma and grandpa who have lived here for over 20 years swears by m&m and having company in town with a broken vehicle I looked them up. Read these reviews on here and was concerned about sending my visitors to them! We double checked with my grandparents who were shocked at all of these reviews and went to see the people at m&m ... My father in-law hates other people looking at his truck and being with out tools he was at the mercy of m&m and never left his phone in case they called him. We were able to get the truck back in a short amount of time and my father in-law was thrilled! He said that he 100% will go back to them of ever the need! Now, my vehicle is in need of some help as it needed a new water pump. They were able to get a new part in for me and even willing to come in on a day the shop was closed so I can get my car and not be with out a vehicle longer than I need to be! What great people! Ignore these negative reviews and go see the great people at m&m on BPK read more

Parts done last so much for lifetime warranty! And phone disconnected Don't trust these folks read more

M & M Motors - Text of costs for water pump with "lifetime" warranty - Tires Near Me - Big Pine Key, Florida

I was having an issue with my 2016 Silverado. I went up and I talked with them and they told me what they thought it was and we made an agreement and a schedule. I dropped the vehicle off they took care of everything changed the oil do a complete tuneup and I have not had the problem that I was experiencing prior to having it worked on. They were very customer oriented, excellent customer service. They communicated with me well and explained everything that they were doing and done. read more

Horrible experience - would not recommend- had to call the police due to miscommunication with elderly lady at front who told mechanic to do a diagnostic job for my belt sound, when all I agreed on was an oil change. Came to pick up my jeep and rude Elderly mechanic started yelling and cursing and threatening. MAKE SURE YOU GET IN WRITING THE SERVICE YOU REQUEST AND THE AMOUNT. Save yourself the money and headache and go somewhere else. read more

Outstanding and very honest!!! Just moved to Big Pine from Marathon. We had an issue and the best part is they tell you the facts, no messing around. This is the real thing !!! Please support and make them known in the community. Deb read more

Man is this place great! If it weren't such a long drive from Pensacola, we'd bring the cars here every time. We were leaving vacation in Key West but woke up to two flat tires. We pulled in to M&M and we're greeted immediately even though there was a little line. They looked at the car and told us where we could grab a sandwich for lunch - we walked around the corner, ate a sandwich, came back and it was done! BAM $20(plus some well deserved tip!) and we were out! Highly recommend - incredibly kind and communicative and quick, reasonable, quality work! read more

Highly recommend! Despite being busy, they made a point of looking at our truck while we were in town on vacation. Very knowledgeable and fair! I can't say enough good about the helpful folks that work here! Thank you! read more

I would never recommend this shop to anyone! Dishonest and clearly try to take advantage of Woman and Seniors! My wife was told her vehicle needed brake parts replaced that were still in perfect working order! When I asked to speak to the mechanic that made the determination about those parts I was told they do not allow customers to speak with their technicians. In what world is a customer who is having work done on his/her vehicle not allowed to ask or be shown what the problem is with that vehicle? Clearly a case of dishonesty and horrible business ethics! read more

Wow! I have met the best people at M&M Motors. They are friendly, professional and reliable. Got a busted water hose on my way to Key West on Thursday. Barely made it past the Seven Mile Bridge. (Not a place you want to break down), trust me on that. The tow truck came and took my vehicle to M&M Motors. Everyone was awesome. From the tow truck driver to the M&M Family. I call them that because they were all great. They went above and beyond to accommodate me. Couldn't find a water pump for me until the next morning. They suggested places to stay, where I could get great food and to offer a vehicle so I wouldn't be stranded. Again, my sincerest gratitude to everyone at M&M Motors for all your help. I would tell anyone that needs their vehicle fixed in the area, to go to M&M Motors. Thank you very much. Cynthia. read more

Just as we were pulling over 7 Mile Bridge we got a low tire warning. We found M&M Motors and they had us fixed in no time for only $10.

Dishonest! I was told I needed work done on my car that was unnecessary (brake calipers) The owner was nasty and her mechanic was vulgar when my husband asked for an explanation. Needless to say we took the car elsewhere and were reassured the calipers were fine! I was also charged $118 for that dishonest diagnosis. As the other reviewer stated, "started out nice but ended hostile and snotty" read more

Great customer service. I brought my Jeep Wrangler in my radiator was shot. They put in a new one and all was fine for a couple months. But in the third month it over heated on the road. Got it back to check it out with them. They couldn't find a thing after pressure checking it. Left it over night and they found the thermostat had a buildup of too much silicone. They fixed that and put in a new one FREE of charge. Tim was great assuring me that if anything else happens to bring it back. That's the first time I've left the mechanic not feeling ripped off. They are a class act. read more

This is a family run operation, and their customer service really shows that. We were on vacation and had the check engine light come on on our car. We took it to M&M, who despite being busy, did a quick diagnosis and a temporary fix. The temporary fix worked for a while, but the light came back on, and we didn't want to risk driving 500 miles pulling a trailer without a permanent fix. So M&M arranged to order the parts, and we made an appointment to come in the next morning. To save us downtime sitting there, they put two mechanics on it, and got the job done in about half the time it otherwise would've taken. Additionally, their prices are very fair, and everyone was very friendly. We loved their two big dogs, and they insisted on introducing them to our large dog. If you're going to have a breakdown, you should hope it's near this place. read more

Great people and more than fair prices ..and you got to love the dogs ...this is the best garage in the Florida Keys

Been a customer over the years. But now find them rude, not helpful and abusive on the phone if you are not happy with them and your problem does not have lots of money attached. read more

I had an issue with my rental car yesterday when I was driving home from Key West when the check engine light came on that my coolant was low. Not knowing much about cars, the rental company told me to go to M&M. They could not have been more accommodating. They diagnosed the problem and had me back on the road in almost no time. The people there could not have been more helpful or nice given the problem with my rental car. I would highly recommend them to anyone in the area. read more

Elizabeth and Rita are simply the best when it comes to customer service, and they really knew how to "rally the troops" and get the proper mechanics working on the truck. It is now in perfect running condition and it will be smooth sailing from here on out. We are grateful that M & M is right in the FL Keys and able to take care of all our truck and car needs. They are honest and hard working. They accommodated the necessary work schedule and were right on the money with the estimate. In this day and age, when you don't know who to trust, it's nice to know that this business is one that can be trusted! We would recommend them to anyone looking for quality auto repair and top notch customer service. read more

Going to a new mechanic is always stressful and being from out-of-town we hoped we wouldn't get taken advantage of. M & M didn't disappoint! We went in with AC issues in our car. We waited for our car to be looked at and relaxed in the office with some coffee and conversation. After an hour, Bob came in and explained everything to us. He was extremely frank and honest with the diagnosis and what needed to be done. If anything else goes wrong with our car (while we're down here) I feel confident in taking it back to them! read more

As we were driving through to the Keys our low tire pressure light came on. We were in the perfect place if you ever need help. The people here were amazing! Thank you for your fast service and big hearts! read more

This company changed my way over due oil and I asked them to check a door that would not open. Told me hinges were rusty and they oiled it. Got it home and noticed my door was all cracked and broken so when I brought it back they claimed it was like that, I hired another company to check NO rusty hinges no oil.. They lied.. The truth is there so called mechanic forced the door open and broke my door panel.. They actually told me they refuse to do business with me in the future. Stay far away..I never yelled or accused just asked. Ritas employee told me my tires were defective and the wrong size also.. Took it back to Island Tire all lies again.. Just WOW read more

I have been driving for almost 50 years and have lived in a dozen cities around the states. Finding a trustworthy mechanic has always been a concern when we moved to a new place. It was no different when we retired to the keys years ago. Keeping our cars running since Hurricane Irma has been a challenge of knowing when to repair them and when to buy something new. I really appreciate the wisdom and experience of these mechanics! They have saved us hundreds of dollars over the last 18 months! I wouldn't go anywhere else! read more

RIPOFF RIPOFF RIPOFF I carried in 2 small trailer tires and wheels and 2 new tires. These crooks charged me $50 to mount the 2 tires. A 10 minute job at the most. read more

Beware of the friendly face at the desk. Went in to get air conditioning fixed on my truck and paid $120 plus to have it estimated and diagnosed. Said was compressor and $800 to replace and charge system, labor included for drying system before charging it. Next day I was told that there was metal in the system and it was going to be another $250 plus for cleaning system and new dryer and filter. At home later that day got a call and was told condenser was clogged and another $350 to replace and clean system. Next day was tol fan that cools system needed replaced and another $350 before he would charge system. Beware!! read more

The woman in the office where very rude to my wife and I and their prices on tires are ridiculous! I would never go back to this shop again! Stay away ! read more

Used to be great but the management changed and it is really below my minimum expectations, even for the keys :-( I had been taking both of my vehicles there for regular service since moving here a few years ago. Service was always done correctly and at fair prices. Sadly, it has taken a sharp turn for the worse with new management (possibly the original management minus their front desk guy, I really don't know). I always went in with a check list written down, what I wanted checked, serviced, what type oil etc... Always was like clockwork before the change a few months ago (around summer 2014) Last visit, the pits! Half of the items not done, she said oops! Charged almost double my previous bills! I won't go back, ever! read more

Got stranded nearby and grandpa suggested this place. We limped the car there on a back road and once there, they took amazing care of us. They stopped what they were doing to help us and see what was wrong, and were incredibly nice and helpful. About half an hour later we were on our way for a very reasonable price! read more

This place is a major rip off. They charged me a 40% markup over what the retail price was 2 blocks away at NAPA and it was delivered free. I mentioned this and they just said tough shit. Do not go to this place to even have your oil changed. read more

We have used M&M for 30 years, but since the "original" owners took it back over-(who knows if this story is true) we had a bad experience. I drove the car in to be diagnosed and said not sure if worth fixing, its really old. They came back with an estimate of nearly $1000 for a fuel pump and were very snotty when I said no, not worth it. Said they had ordered parts already and tried to muscle me when I said no, not paying $1000. Then she said, well the car doesnt start now, how will you get it out of here? So the car will not start(!!??!!) and I have to have it towed. I paid them $90 for the diagnosis also. Started out nice, but ended up hostile and snotty. read more

Updating my review as this establishment is under new ownership. It has taken a complete nose dive from the previous service. Employees are rude and unhelpful, prices have more than doubled, and service quality has taken a drop off a cliff. read more

Pleaseee Please do yourself a favor and not go to this place. Trish is one of the rudest meanest woman on this island. They have never heard of customer service. They tried charging me 200 to fix a tire. Very rude and unhelpful. read more

EXTREMELY RUDE PHONE STAFF!!!! I am new to the area and just called for a simple quote for a synthetic oil change and the person on the phone said it was $20 plus the cost of filter and oil. When I asked if I could have the total cost given my vehicle make and model, she said she didn't have it. I said I would leave my name and number and could she call me back with an exact price. She them stated she could not it now, but I needed to know the engine size. She told me to look under the hood but I couldn't find the engine size under the hood so I said that I would look elsewhere. She stated "Good Luck with that." Very sarcastic, hostile and definitely unhelpful! I am sure that she had the ability to get the engine size from the VIN but didn't want to make any effort. read more