I was able to check this place off my pizza list because my brother and sister in law chose it as…read morethe restaurant for after wedding rehearsal. That being said- we were in the private back room ao I cant speak too much to the atmosphere. The food came out rather quickly. There was pizza, supreme, pepperoni, cheese pizzas, meatballs, salad, garlic bread and stuffed breadsticks. The stuffed breadsticks were out of this world. Meatballs were tasty but nothing that was like crazy amazing. The salad was good and unique, had the famous redskins peanuts the are famous for. Pizza was also good. Good crust and a neutral sauce.

An Institution! This place has the most incredible small town/bar/pizza/Italian vibe EVER!…read more Cascarelli's has more roots than a Michigan root cellar and you can take that check to the bank and cash it. The Caprese salad is to die for and I hate fresh tomatoes. I'd even take seconds if it was offered. The balsamic dressing is a work of art and there is no doubt that the basil was just on the plant the other day. If your looking for pizza than look no further than Cascarelli's. There just isn't anything better in this part of Michigan. Frankie's Pie, specialty pizza, includes Baked Balls and should be a priority in life! Please make the trip to Homer Michigan for the hidden gem. You won't regret it!

Best Pizza on earth, not even kidding…read more The service is good and they make the pizza pretty fast. Don't eat inside, it's pretty loud and there's not really anywhere to sit, just go eat in your car or something.

we will not be coming back to main street again we've been having small issues the past few times…read morebut after a long day i didn't want to cook so i ordered what we always order, a large pepperoni pizza with extra pepperoni but i got a regular pepperoni pizza no extra meat. I did have to wait an additional 20 minutes (making it 45 minutes i waited for a pizza) because no one can call out a name when the order is done. the pizza was done as i came in but it sat and got cold while i waited 5 foot from it. im disappointed with having to stop supporting a local restaurant but i can't put up with this anymore

Awesome salads!!!! Greek salad with feta is so good!!!…read more Pizzas are very good too! We like the thin crust Greek pizza

Well to start if you give them a time, it will always be early. Which is a good thing. I live in a…read morerural lake community, so not many places that will deliver. It's 5 miles. The bad, Dough is raw. So I tried to work with them . I used to make pizza myself many years ago, many. So I would specify, well done. In my world that means run thru 2 times. No. Not bad Pizza if you order Thin. Taste great. Great staff. Only thing if you like a nice crispy pizza, order thin crust and cross your fingers. Such a hurry... Never got a thin well done either... Have a air frier now, make's a difference, but I pay 25.00 for what used to be a 14.00 deal. Just wish it was done..,.

Omg. We drive over a hour at times for the subs!! SO GOOD. Small town service in that they know…read moreyour name! Highly recommend!!

Meh, I love a thick crust but this one was black on the bottom and underdone on the top. The…read moreservice was very nice but the place could use a deep cleaning and a little sprucing up

We recently picked up some take out subs for a small group. Boy, are Cavoni's grinders huge! Yum…read more We ordered a couple clubs and a veggie. The only complaint was that one person thought there were too many olives on the veggie grinder. Otherwise, we all LOVED the club grinders. The right amount of meat, cheese, lettuce and mayo. The bread/bun was the right size, as well. Not too thick. Thanks for a great meal. We've heard great things about your grinders. Now we have confirmed the deliciousness. I'll be back to try the other sandwiches. Nice work!

It was our first time here. I asked the server for a recommendation, and she steered us toward the…read moresubs. When I looked around and saw the quality-looking subs, we ordered an Italian sub, a Bbq chicken pizza, and onion rings. The pizza had big chunks of flavorful, moist chicken. The sub was filled with meat and oh so flavorful! The restaurant is in the Kroger strip mall, has a robust stream of take-out, and lots of basic seating. When I told my colleagues the about my meal the next day at work, they shared that Cavoni's has been in business for years! Who knew?! We'll be back. p.s. The onion rings were legit!

Great pizza! Great crust! Great toppings! Dripping with cheese!…read more Don't pay attention to the 1 stars, they're poopy pants.

The most delicious super greasy pepperoni rolls. Dripping with cheese and grease. Find coupons…read more Cheap food. Pizza kind of sucks but hits the spot at midnight. Get extra sauce these people so cheap they don't hardly put sauce on pizza. Bootleg nasty pizza. 5 stars

WOW CHOW!!! The…read morepizza was really EPIC! Rare to get real hand tossed pizza anymore. Will rerun soon!

Dark Horse is a solid step up from your average local bar. Their house beers are very popular. The…read morefood is also really good - it's not just stereotypical "bar food". I've have their pizza a couple of times and highly recommend it! The restaurant itself is kind of small, which means it can feel a bit crowded some nights. One fun aspect of Dark Horse, however, is that the walls (and ceilings!) are lined with custom mugs, each belonging to a Dark Horse regular. This gives the bar a special charm that makes it feel unique. Something to note is that the service can be pretty slow when they're busy.

We had the meatsa pizza . It was delicious. They notify you just about the time it is to come out…read moreof the oven. Personally, my wife and I like ours a cooked a bit longer. But that is a personal preference. A good value

Terrible service, and the owner was extremely rude. I asked about a gluten-free pizza and the owner…read moreproceeded to make fun and make rude comments while I waited for my food.

The Bent Prop Pub is a great little restaurant located right on Coldwater Lake. It has ample…read moreparking across the street and a boat dock that can accommodate ~6-7 boats for lake access. We dined upstairs (Pub on lower level) and had some excellent food. The Garlic Breaded Cheese Curds are amazing (cubed cheese) and recommend either/or Marinara and Ranch. The Pretzel was also very good, but the standout was the bar cheese sauce, which appears more of a creamy fondue than straight cheese wiz and was very flavorful. Main dishes were the Pollock Fish Basket with Fries, Chicken Quesadilla with Lime Rice and the Steak Bites App with a side of Broccoli. Everything was very good,l and the food was hot and service super fast. Staff was extremely friendly and knowledgeable and dining right on the lake is always a plus. Plus we didn't have a wait arriving at 6:30ish on a Saturday evening. Bent Prop Pub earned a five star review due to its food, ambiance, staff and being a nice little gem of a restaurant and pub tucked away in a sleepy section of the Eastern shore of Coldwater Lake. Would definitely go back when we are back up in the area.

They've closed unfortunately before the season. Was great! It's now called something new. Tipsy…read moreturtle I believe haven't been yet.