Now known as AMYs Pizza small town pizza joint…read more Affiliated with the one in Spring Arbor. and they do not have a credit card machine onsite. so they call your CC # over to the Spring Arbor store on a cordless phone, and now everyone on the internet knows it too. Pizza is quite good . Delivery avaliable Calzones are awsome. price is average.

Have been here a few times and it's always been pretty good. I got delivery once and it was pretty…read morequick and fair considering it's a small business. When I sat down to eat, I remember thinking that the decor was a little weird but still a good place to sit and eat. The woman who was there could have been friendlier but still great food. Value - 3.5/5 Staff friendliness - 4/5 Atmosphere - 4/5 Food quality and taste - 5/5

An Institution! This place has the most incredible small town/bar/pizza/Italian vibe EVER!…read more Cascarelli's has more roots than a Michigan root cellar and you can take that check to the bank and cash it. The Caprese salad is to die for and I hate fresh tomatoes. I'd even take seconds if it was offered. The balsamic dressing is a work of art and there is no doubt that the basil was just on the plant the other day. If your looking for pizza than look no further than Cascarelli's. There just isn't anything better in this part of Michigan. Frankie's Pie, specialty pizza, includes Baked Balls and should be a priority in life! Please make the trip to Homer Michigan for the hidden gem. You won't regret it!

Great food and service. Stopped by for lunch and was not disappointed. I had Franks Italian…read moresandwich and a side of homemade pasta salad. The portions were large, and the food was delicious. The menu is large and double sided. I'll definitely be back to try other items. If you're in Homer, this is a great choice.

Best Pizza on earth, not even kidding…read more The service is good and they make the pizza pretty fast. Don't eat inside, it's pretty loud and there's not really anywhere to sit, just go eat in your car or something.

we will not be coming back to main street again we've been having small issues the past few times…read morebut after a long day i didn't want to cook so i ordered what we always order, a large pepperoni pizza with extra pepperoni but i got a regular pepperoni pizza no extra meat. I did have to wait an additional 20 minutes (making it 45 minutes i waited for a pizza) because no one can call out a name when the order is done. the pizza was done as i came in but it sat and got cold while i waited 5 foot from it. im disappointed with having to stop supporting a local restaurant but i can't put up with this anymore

The food is good for sure. Majority of staff friendly,…read moreoutgoing and helpful. A few things that if addressed would be great....prices are a bit steep, almost to dark in the room (VERY difficult to see/read menu), put lighting on tables if going to keep that dark / and charging for ranch dressing for dipping sauce for already pricey pizza and offered by wait staff ??? Crazy and greedy imo $$$. Be great if tall and short size cocktails be offered $5/$10, especially in Bloody Mary's...and in the bloody Mary's olives, small tomato, and a dill gherkins, get rid of the dill pickle skin is too tough too even bite through and ditch the big ol' pepper (a waste as most people don't like them). All menu items about 10% overpriced, good food but then you also expect your patrons to add a 20-25% gratuity on top of the already inflated check total Can definitely recommend the food, but a few issues addressed would make the place a 5 star rating imo.

Wonderful waitress , friendly , helpful and fast service she was the best and adorable food was…read moregreat as usual!!

It was OK Pizza, but not the best in town. We tries the pizza several times and it was OK. Not a…read moremust eat place.

This is one of the best pizza joints in Brooklyn. They are consistently good. Always made to your…read moreorder without mistakes. We prefer the thin crust. The staff is friendly. Delivered pizza can be problematic as they often have only one driver. We prefer to pickup. The price and value is way better than any other pizza biz in town. Highly recommend!!!

Sauce has wayyyy too much garlic Excessive garlic doesn't…read moremake it authentic Last delivery took over a hour

Great pizza for a good price. Two large two topping for $30! Warning it can get busy on weekends…read moresince there's only a couple pizza joints around. Surprisingly good ice cream parlor too.

Mass C salad was amazing. fresh and the dressing was fantastic!!! Had with grilled chicken for a…read moregreat lunch!

I've been going here for over 20 years and for good reason- the Pizza! My most recent visit was…read morevery enjoyable with great service and cold beer. It's a local mainstay- definitely fun every time

Bryn is awesome! Excellent service. Could add Coors to the…read moremenu though. Great food definitely recommend the Pesto wings. .

Went here after seeing all the great Yelp reviews, and yep... the hype is justified…read more The pizza was very flavorful, and the ingredients seemed high quality. I'd give it a solid 7.8/10. My only complaint? I wish the crust was a little crispier. But hey, apparently I'm a tough crowd. We also tried the smash burger, and everyone LOVED it. Juicy, cheesy, and seriously delicious. The burger actually reminded me of the old Steak 'n Shake burgers before they changed the recipe. And if you know, you know. Overall, very good food, good ingredients, and definitely worth the stop. I'll gladly defend that 7.8 pizza score , but the burger might have pushed the overall experience even higher. We'll absolutely be back the next time we're in Ann Arbor!

Great pizza! Great crust! Great toppings! Dripping with cheese!…read more Don't pay attention to the 1 stars, they're poopy pants.

The most delicious super greasy pepperoni rolls. Dripping with cheese and grease. Find coupons…read more Cheap food. Pizza kind of sucks but hits the spot at midnight. Get extra sauce these people so cheap they don't hardly put sauce on pizza. Bootleg nasty pizza. 5 stars

Best pizza and best wings. Be sure to order on web…read more On time based on estimated pick up.

nothing special.. your average pizza. if you are getting the wings, be aware they are baked not…read morefried.