I would never order anything from Luigi O'Grady's again. Their prices are above industry standard while their portions continue to get smaller. There are many other delis in the area who offer better food and better service. I'd rather go to the supermarket deli before I visited this place again. read more

I got the eggplant mozz and peppers sandwich months and months ago and I thought about it ever since, I today just now got the samqhixh and it was still just as good if not better. They put some balsamic on it and it's just perfect like the best Sam which I've ever had in my whole entire life like the first time I got it I thought about it ever since. Idk HOW they make the fried eggplant so delicious like I'd buy weekly if I didn't live so far away. Come here buy the eggplant sandwhixh and enjoy. You won't regret it I promise you- trust me read more

We order from them regularly. Their sandwich's are great. They have a very wide selection of sandwich's to choose from. From time to time we also order their hot lunch meal specials. Recommend you call ahead to place your order. If you want a great sandwich this is the place. read more

I went to get a corned beef sandwich and took one bite and had to spit it out. The meat was brown; I don't know what they did to the food. All the help is unfriendly as well as the owner who always had an evil look. I don't patronize this place any more. read more

Ordered a sandwich, when I opened it up the sandwich was soaked in grease. The bread was even falling apart because it was sitting in a pool of grease. Tried to take one bite and physically couldn't eat it which is disappointing because I've been wanting to try this place for years. Maybe just a bad day for them but I'm still hungry and down $20 :( read more

Just had a party for 20 people and ordered the sandwiches, they did a great job, everything was delicious. The meats and even the tuna was great, highly recommend! read more

Always a great place to stop in for breakfast sandwiches or subs. We have had their catering as well. Love the food and staff. Best roast beef and salads around ! read more

First let me say that whenever I go take out food I get a new menu because prices change rapidly. I had a menu I dated a month ago. It had a sandwich that I ordered saying it was $14 I went there today they had no new menus and the sandwich was 17 dollars nearly a 25% increase in a month the woman at the register said it was 3 months ago they changed their prices okay it's still a 25% increase which is unwarranted since boar's Head produces all of their meats and cheeses in the United States and there bread is Rockland bakery in nanuet. So tariffs does not affect the price of the food. Apparently Luigi O'Grady's thinks people in the area are stupid. I expect imported meat and cheeses at those prices. They are price gouging at this point other places do not charge these prices and I noticed over time the place has less walkin customers. They cater to catering. Well I'm sure they are also getting ripped off. They are a bunch of liars and cheaters. And oh by the way there is no Luigi O'Grady. In 2022 they had a class action Labor violation not paying overtime to their employees. This is how greedy they are. And most of their employees seem to be immigrants so they are taking advantage of them which is evil. I went there for years I'm not going there anymore. The owners are evil greedy slobs. I don't like feeling this way for a place I went to for years and enjoyed but now it's time to move on. I cannot support these evil greedy people. I also find it insulting that they use the word Luigi in there store names. It's to try to attack the population of Italians in the area and I being Italian I'm extremely insulted. I would boycott this place. read more

i was at rockland for vacation and i decided to go to this place for brunch the staff turned a normal bagel into a sandwich with cheese and it was so good that i cant even finish it read more

Got delivery roast beef sandwich & brownies. Sandwich with the horseradish sauce was soooo yummy! And despite a few too many sprinkles for my personal taste, the brownies were perfect texture and scrumptious read more

My pepperoni and swiss hero was fully loaded and took 2 days to consume. What was also fully loaded was the price...$14. High prices must be the new norm. read more

Received catering from Luigi O'Grady's for a family repast. It was absolutely delicious. Delivered on time, piping hot, and with all the accoutrements needed. Everyone was raving about how delicious everything tasted and it was the first time that family was asking for containers of left overs to take home. Definitely will be our go to for catering any family party! Thank you so much! read more

I am giving a rating of one star for one reason - I used a credit card and they added a 4% surcharge to my bill. In the digital world we live in everything is becoming based on digital payments. I know that there are credit card charges for using the card but it seems that prices are increasing and credit card surcharges are being added. Paying $12 for a sandwich then a 4% surcharge is getting a little ridiculous. I understand that business was tough during the pandemic and that supply chain issues exist but I really don't understand the fee especially with all of the increased pricing that has been done. Businesses are starting to take advantage of the economic news. I must say that the service staff was great. Food was awesome as usual. read more

Delivery via online order was quick although I find it asinine that they have a $10 minimum for PICK UP. Got the half grinder...er...hero and small soup combo. Clam chowder was very good. Prosciutto Mozzarella half sandwich was good, but a bit plain since I'm fairly sure it was supposed to have roasted peppers on it too. Sandwich was stuffed to the gills though. read more

Fantastic l, FRIENDLY service, and sandwich quality top notch. Very consistent now! Great coffee too and a nice setup! They've now proven themselves that change for the better is possible and have made me a repeat customer again! Great job! read more

They do not skimp on the meat in your sandwiches. Best deli I've been to, nowhere else compares

I have gone to Luigi Ogradys consistently for the last 17 years and I always enjoy the food. The macaroni salad is fantastic, the grilled cheese with bacon is great and the Italian combo is the best read more

They make the best sandwiches in the county, if not in NY. I love that one can order by number and each sandwich is made individually to order, they way I like it. I am so spoiled by this place!! read more

Had a couple of there sandwiches recently and they've been spot on! Today I picked up a few containers of there red skin potato salad for a family gathering, and it was a hit!I also love the fact that they sell local honey and it's reasonably priced too! read more

See all

Michelle is absolutely wonderful. I've been ordering from Luigi's for years. The food is impeccable. The staff is very friendly. The store is immaculately clean. I highly recommend! read more

We ordered sandwiches and some sides for a family party at our house. The food was excellent and Michelle was so helpful. We will definitely order again!! read more

apparently having a good review has placed this into the deli to never visit again. I paid extra enough to have another hero and received nothing. one hero wasn't cut. not coming here again, sad shame. whomever made my food should be fired. read more

Luigi O'Grady's - paid for extra additions that they left out. other hero was ignored to be sliced but had a note it was. never returning again. - Delis Near Me - Pearl River, New York

First time here. I'm very impressed. The place looks clean. They have a large menu. Prices look good. I had a bacon and egg and Home fries on a roll and it was loaded up and very good. read more

Sandwiches are usually very good, thats it. Very slow service and extremely disorganized. Not friendly at all. Seems to be slipping lately, not sure if new management or what. Avoid the family dinner special, the chicken parm was nasty, the chicken was rubbery and extremely overcooked, the pasta ala vodka was mushy and tasteless. The salad was nice though. I ordered for 5:30 and waited 1/2 hour only to find it luke warm. I guess they reheat to order from frozen. Will not try the family dinners again. read more

The First time: Coming for the first time was not as enjoyable as people told me. Probably because they were busy. Employee attitude not the best. they take your order with a sense of "get out of here". Now waiting for the food, it felt like forever, mostly for one egg sandwich. Maybe because they were busy and i get it. Sandwich were good, nice and big. It can feed you for a whole week The Second time: I came in probably within 30 min of closing. I just needed ice. Before coming in, I heard yelling and conversation of sex which I don't like to hear. i get it, its down time but you guys are not closed yet. Looked like you guys were drinking but its not my business. when getting the ice i thought it will be different from last time but you still get the same sense of not being wanted. Just needed my ice. The Third Time: I came in for lunch time, ordered a number 5(great sandwich). There was a mother, her child, and some union workers waiting for there sandwich. Seemed like it was not busy but yet I still had to wait 20 min for the sandwich. The same type of atmosphere like last time I came in. A lot of cursing. There was a child there listening to all that(not cool). Also i noticed that one of the workers dropped one of the meats on the floor and put it back on the cold cut machine(at least clean it!)and went on with there order. Sandwich was promising Customer service garbage i wouldn't come back to Ny to experience this again. Pearl river is supposedly the town of nice people. I guess not at this deli. read more

They have every facet needed to be a successful deli. However they fail in 2 key aspects: 1) The service is terrible. The workers all stand at the far end of the deli away from the cash register. So if you come in and need to pick up an order or just need to pay for a coffee you will be rudely ignored until you go track someone down in the back. Sometimes they look right at you and don't care to ask if you need help. Paying for your order is the longest aspect of coming here which makes zero sense. 2) They roll their sandwiches. One of the strangest things I've ever experienced. Instead of stacking the cold cuts on one half of the sandwich, they lay them across both sides so when they close up the sandwich you get a ball of meat in the middle with an outside layer of cheese. This ends up causing you to get full bites of just meat or just cheese. They must train staff to prepare sandwiches this way too because it's always the same. Sandwich integrity is very important and they clearly don't understand that. read more

I remember the days when they were in their old location (a few stores down closer to the bowling alley) where the line was out the door if you didn't call ahead to place your order for lunch. Now you can wait inside the comfort of their new bigger place next to the coolers. The food hasn't change over the years, overstuffed sandwiches at an affordable price. I always go for the #5 (chicken cutlet, bacon - can never go wrong with it, lettuces, tomato, and mayo) with a side of chili ;) read more

Luigi O'Grady's did a last minute catering job for Big Brothers Big Sisters and it was fantastic. The food was delicious and incredibly affordable considering the quality of the food. I highly recommend them and will definitely use them again! read more

WHOA! That's a lot of meat. Ordered a sandwich I've loved since my teenage years. Pepperoni and Provalone, Lettuce and Tomato, Mustard, and sopping wet with Oil and Vinegar. Thanks Luigi O'Grady. Excellent sandwich. Great feel to the place too. Do you yelp a good deli? This is a place for you. read more

Unbelievably disgusting establishment. This is the second time my husband, our children and I have been patrons of this establishment. Somehow this time around was an even bigger disappointment. The bread was stale yet had a distinct sogginess caused by the innards of the sandwich, regardless of what you order. The second and final time we went, my child was served moldy egg salad. Safe to say we won't be back. 2 stars for the two friendly roaches we encountered. read more

Just canceled my order with Luigi O'Grady's. I went in yesterday and placed an order and after I paid for it, I realized the prices on their invoice were significantly higher than those on the website. When I questioned it, I was told the prices on the website were wrong. I pointed out that they still need to honor those prices since the online menu was what I used while placing my order and figuring out my costs. The staff said she would have someone get in touch with me the next day. Today, someone from the deli called and said she spoke with the owner and the owner said she would not honor the prices from the website. She also said that she would rather lose my business than take a loss on an order. So, that's what she did. Not only did she lose my business, but that of my friends and family who have used that deli for numerous catering occasions. On a side note the prices were not just a few dollars higher, the price charged was over $10 more for each tray, a rather significant increase. It should also be noted that the incorrect prices were still up on the website today, even though they were aware of the problem. After canceling the order I called Munno's Deli and got the same food for much less. read more

Simply put...The best hero sandwiches in Rockland Country, bar none. Bread from the Bronx. Boar's Head cold cuts. Outstanding hot foods (try the Hot Chicken Parm.). Going anywhere else should not be an option! read more

It shouldn't take an hour to make a wrap. Orders are coming out progressively slower and slower as time goes. Won't be coming here any more.

I always cook on Thanksgiving and was going away this year so we ordered the complete dinner. Everything was sooooooo delicious - turkey was moist, potatoes, sweet potatoes and gravy so good! Would definitely order it again! read more

There was a time in my life when walking into a deli was an exceptionally pleasant experience. I will also add that was a fine time for many foods including fresh vegetables and fish that elderly people could afford but that's for another blog LOL. I'm not sure if it was influenced by my choice of outfit or something stuck to my face (out of my vision of course) but I couldn't help feeling the workers staring at me, failing to say a word. It took me 10 minutes to figure out where to order because of it! It felt like a staring match! And I have horrible vision! My eyes. Were. Very. Dry. I could take it all personally or I could mention how hard it was to receive even a smile from anyone behind the counter. This element of this particular deli was MOST concerning. A true threat to the development of a fine deli sandwich. Could this be the downfall of my #7? Well, I'll tell you it was. This establishment needs a revamp on their spirits as to not allow such tragedy! You better bet this Grandma ain't settling for another experience like this again, or a disappointed grandson on the job. Am I right people!? Let's make these places what they used to be and make sure our kids and grandkids are alright! They know not how their sadness could take a sandwich from hero to zero! Somebody cheer these people up! read more

Most of the time a really great lunch sandwich. But I text ordered and asked for an Italian combo but to substitute the ham for turkey. But I got him :( read more

I hired Luigi O'Grady's to cater my wife's 50th Birthday Party Party which was last night. What a fantastic experience!! I went for the formal package with hot and cold buffet, appetizers, Sheet Cake, coffee/tea and waitstaff!! The service was exceptional and the food was amazing! AMAZING!! EVERYONE raved about the food!! Also, Jeanette was so great to work with family on beginning to end! Thank you Luigi O'Grady's for making this a party to remember! read more

Oh man I really like how they help with local fundraisers so we often get the family dinners but the last couple of times, the food was really not very good. For the most recent order, we got the meatloaf family dinner and it was really really salty. I almost wanted to return it but we were in a rush so we just "dealt" with it. The time prior we ordered fried chicken but the pieces were so tiny! The wings and legs look like they came from a baby hen. *Sigh* I think we will try again but what is with the quality of the food? read more

Had a party for 30. Ordered a few trays (meatballs, sausage & peppers, Chicken marsala with rice) as well as a 3ft round hero. Everyone loved it. The Anti-pasta salad was a great side too. Love this place. read more

Great sandwich's and breakfast Rolls. A great deli with major service issue's. lots of People taking orders and one cooking and a manger walking around with a pen behind his ear doing nothing 2.You have to walk to back to get your order taken and then jog back to front to pay for the time you get your food you can eat a slice from next door and have a cup of Coffee from D Donuts.3.Half the store taken up with half full coolers.Tip for owner open up the back kitchen and leave all you staff hands on with making the food after they take the orders for faster service ... read more