What a great find - thank you fellow Yelpers! Very nice menu options with a lot of healthy choices.

Very good food with very helpful and friendly staff! Stop by even if you are just passing through - well worth the stop!

I stopped here with family on our way back from Pawhuska, OK (to see Pioneer Woman Mercantile). They have a nice menu with lots of variety! I got the Tear it Up Trav Panini. A little spicy kick and yummy! I also tried the Asian fusion salad for my side. The staff were all very friendly and helpful. read more

Lucy's Two - Sandwiches Near Me - McAlester, Oklahoma

This place is awesome. Just a cute little sammie shop but everything is homemade with love and it taste like it. So delish. Just 1.6 miles off 69 easy for traveling through and quick super friendly service, too! It will be a regular stop from now on. read more

Enjoyed the Sonoma panini and the potato salad! It was nice to be back at this local spot.

We were looking for a quick local spot during a road trip and found Lucy's Two on Yelp. Reviews were good so we gave it a try. We are so glad we did! My husband had the panini club and said it was delicious!! I loved the champagne chicken salad. Lucy Two's was better than we could've hoped for. Thank you!! read more

Food is great. Soup and a sandwich just hit the spot. Friendly atmosphere. I would definitely recommend this place.

We stopped in on the way home from a long road trip and are so happy we did! The owner was friendly and very helpful. The kids meals were perfect! A little cup of delicious soup, some crackers and mandarin oranges with a half sandwich. The chicken salad was yummy! I got the pretzel sandwich, which was delicious! We finished with the bread pudding and ordered a second, it was so good! Definitely recommend stopping by if you're passing through. read more

Owner operated and very friendly. Love the tornado wrap! Wait on food is very minimal. Call in orders always timely.

Best food in Mcalester...literally everything homemade...Strawberry glace pie didn't last long enough to be photographed...fresh fruit with homemade crust. Pretzel buns to die for. Please eat here and don't patronise the corporate crap places like Subway. The honey mustard sauce is homemade, tomato soup is homemade, Asian salad is delicious and homemade. Founded by the grandkids of an Italian grandma you will get as much local info about the area and history as you want. Service is off the charts good...best I've had in years and we live in downtown Dallas...many excellent places. Must stop. Also located in historic downtown which is kind of cool read more

Lucy's Two - Sandwiches Near Me - McAlester, Oklahoma

See all

Sandwiches were very tasty. Fast service and friendly ladies! Great find while traveling through town. My wife hates, HATES carrot cake and there's she said was amazing!!! read more

This was a perfect stop for our family on our drive from Texas to Missouri! Right when we walked in, we were greeted with a smile and a warm welcome! The service was fantastic and everyone working was kind and charming! The sandwiches were great and we loved the potato salad and fire roasted vegetable soup! If we are ever in McAlester again, we will be back!! read more

What a treasure! Traveling thru Oklahoma on 69, not a lot of dining choices. Found this restaurant in the Oklahoma dining guide. Our group enjoyed the white bean chicken Chile, the tomato bisque soup. The soups are served with their homemade "fiery crackers". No worries, not mouth burning fiery, just the right amount of fiery. Sandwiches that we thoroughly enjoyed was The Blue Moon, The Tear it up Trav, the Auld Smiles - loved the names of the sandwiches almost as much as the sandwiches. The selection of desserts ... I don't even know what to say ... homemade like your Grandma made. Mouth watering! The staff were all very welcoming. EVERYTHING we ate was delicious. So delicious, we purchased many things to go, just so we could taste it all again later. read more

Good business to eat at and food is very good. I have eaten here once and been to a baby shower here once and both times had food from this business and has been good. read more

The food was amazing! I cannot wait to go back. Staff was super friendly and the set up was awesome. I would highly recommend eating here. I live over two hours from Lucy's and I would make the drive just to eat here! This is the perfect stop for lunch! Try to soup and fire crackers! Also, the carrot cake was serious! It was big time! The best most delicious cake I have ever eaten in my life! Go here and you will not be disappointed - really wishing the owners would consider a Lucy's three in Yukon, Oklahoma! read more

Lucy's Two - Sandwiches Near Me - McAlester, Oklahoma

great vibe and food -- will stop again on way thru town!! I went with pretzel bun sandwich and it was fantastic.

I think this is a great lunch spot! It's tucked away perfectly in the center of the city. I actually walked pasted it at first. But when I got in I felt a sense of welcoming there. The service was great and the waiter attended to my needs and new I was a first time customer and helped me along the way with my order and gave me a drink. The food was excellent and anytime my job sends me that way I'm stopping by! If you live in the city it's no reason for you to not know about this place! read more

Spontaneous stop on our way to UARK. Great Menu, food and service. Everything was fresh and we all loved the flavored crackers We will be back. read more

I was traveling through from Texas to Tulsa and was in need of some lunch that was not fast food. I looked them up here on Yelp and it sounded good enough to stop. I'm so glad that I did because I had one of the best salads I've had in a long time. I got the prescription which was kind of a mix of Asian salad but with feta and apples. I scarfed it down so quick, eating every bite! They also have some amazing looking homemade desserts. Next time I head that way, I'm stopping in again. read more

Don't waste your time. We drove off the highway to find this place based on great reviews. Nowhere to be found at this address. Tried going to their website and it was still up but called phone number and it didn't work. It's like the restaurant disappeared. read more

We stopped here passing through. Both had corn cake that was excellent. My tomato soup was lukewarm and bland, served with a plastic teaspoon instead of a soup spoon. The very friendly service moves it from three stars to four. read more

Lucy's Two - Sandwiches Near Me - McAlester, Oklahoma

This is one of my favorite places in McAlester. Fresh salads, sandwiches, and soup, and the service is fast and friendly! My wife and I went in on a cold day, had the Sheriff's salad and mushroom soup, and it was really great! I will be recommending this place to others and visiting again soon. Third trip here, and I had the sheriff's salad again (which I like better than Matt's Salad), and the tomato soup. Both were fantastic, as usual. read more

We got off the highway on way to Fayetteville and so worth it. Discovered quaint, cool McAlister, OK, and this restaurant. Food was great and huge menu -- couldn't decide. Great service. Will definitely go back -- be sure and check closing time. We almost missed out. read more

Fabulous food and even better people. The sisters are amazing. Super sweet, helpful, vivacious, and so much fun.

Grandma taught these girls how to cook and love on people. Coffee yum food yum. Tomato soup and fire crackers double yum. Don't miss this stop read more

Lucy's Two - Grandma Lucy taught these girls how to cook and love on travelers. Coffee yum food yum tomato soup & fire crackers. Don't miss this stop!! - Sandwiches Near Me - McAlester, Oklahoma

Great food and staff is so friendly! We were driving through and wanted something not fast food. This place was perfect! Lots of options! Yummy homemade desserts! Very clean! Will be back the next time we are passing through! read more

A great place for a light lunch while traveling. Owners are extremely friendly. Will stop again.

Fabulous, fresh food, the atmosphere and people are great! Go on Thursday for the Sweet Corn Cakes, but go early cause they go fast! read more

Very nice diner, have lots to choose from. The staff was very friendly. If you are planning a day downtown recommend a lunch here.

Traveling thru on our way to Dallas and we wanted something besides fast food. This restaurant is so worth the stop. Everything is homemade. I had the quiche of the day with homemade tomato soup that was fabulous! This is a must stop! read more

My friend found this restaurant while we were on a road trip to Arkansas. It is about 3 miles off the main highway but well worth the little detour. I had the tomato soup bread bowl and carrot cake. Both are delicious homemade items. The soup is a simple creamy tomato with grated Parmesan cheese served in a fresh bread roll hollowed out, of course. Tasty and filling and I knew I had to try a dessert to go. The lady suggested carrot cake and told me they sell a lot of it. I can see why it is sweet and loaded with nuts and fruit and a very generous portion too. There will be no dieting here but you only live once. My friend had a roast beef, Parmesan cheese and sun dried tomato panini. Excellent flavor complemented with a pepper sauce. We both were so happy to have stopped here bringing a good omen to a long journey. We will be back! read more

Excellent hand made sandwiches, paninis, and wraps. Great place for lunch in Mcalester!

We all ordered sandwiches and panini's. They were fantastic!!!! Service was amazing. Finished our experience w a slice of carrot cake. Wow!!! Salads looked beautiful. Small town sandwich place.....wins in our book. read more

I wish I could eat this everyday but my budget won't allow for it ha ha!

Don't have time to stop? MAKE time! This was a delicious and HAPPY spot! My family of four stopped in on our way to Eureka Springs, Arkansas. Lucy's had something to please mom, dad, a 13-year-old, and a 16-year-old: Champagne Chicken Salad, The Beast Sandwich (Roast beef, roasted red peppers, and other yumminess), MiMi Sandwich (chicken breast on a pretzel bun and other trimmings), and a BLT. Who knew a BLT could be life-changing?! Might've been the sundried tomato bread! The roasted edamame salad and Texas caviar sides did not disappoint! Get it to-go if you must, but don't leave without their ridiculously amazing Carrot Cake or Cherry Cobbler! My kids are still talking about how friendly everyone was. After only 45 minutes, we felt we'd always known each other. We shared with Natalie that my son commented he wanted another MiMi sandwich for his dessert, and then she went and made him one to-go! We are so happy our family experienced Lucy's for both the food and the people! You'll be blessed if you do too! read more

See all

I wish quiche day was EVERYDAY! I Love their vegetarian sandwich on pretzel bread and the veggie quiche! It's soooooo qood I usually order 2 , on for now one for later . The hot crackers are always delish as well! read more

My absolute favorite lunch spot in town; I can't go a week without getting my Lucy's Two fix! Their home made salad dressings are all so great along with all the homemade soups! You get good quality food and lots of it for your $$$. My absolute favorite is the Caesar salad, they don't skimp ya on portions either, salads are huge!!! read more

I have a chicken salad sandwich along with a couple of loaded baked potato soup and it was all delicious. Extremely friendly owner and and made to feel welcome as a traveler.. read more

Lucy's is legit! Both sandwiches we ordered were really tasty, service was super fast and friendly, and everything seemed really fresh. Great lunch in McAlester! read more

Not only was the service incredible from all of the sweet women that work here, the food was great. We asked a local where to go and they pointed us directly to here and we are glad we stopped. The prices are great as are the portions. read more