We were in Oxford for one night and decided to check out Lost Pizza to see what all the great reviews were about. Being from the Houston area, we have yet to find pizza there we truly enjoy. We came in a bit after 8, they close at 9, and we were greeted by friendly staff. We ordered a medium Kujo thin crust and had two side house salads with blue cheese and had a couple of draft beers (a Parish Pure Tropics IPA and a Good People West Coast). The salads were crisp and fresh, and if I could have received a gallon of their blue cheese dressing I would have bought it. It was EXCELLENT and I'm a picky blue cheese dressing girl. I'd love to know what brand it was! The pizza was hot, came out quickly and very good. The crust was perfect and the sauce was delicious (not too little, not too much). The beers were ice cold. Lastly, we were there right up to the time they closed and we were not made to fee rushed, at all, and we were asked if we would like another beer or dessert, meaning, stay longer if you'd like! Service was great. Side note: hubby accidentally left his base ball cap there, we were on the road by 5am this morning. I messaged them, they found it and are shipping it to us. Refused me offering to pay or send a label for the cost to ship it. Again, excellent service and kind folks! read more

Decent pizza with friendly service. I'm a bit of a NY pizza snob so for me, it's not quite NYC good but the best option I've found so far in oxford. It's got a fun vibe and lots of seating both indoor and out with an upstairs and rooftop. read more

Lost Pizza - Oxford - Half cheese half pepperoni and mushroom thin crust pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oxford, Mississippi

If you order a build your own tell them extra whatever meat toppings otherwise you'll basically have a cheese pizza with a sprinkling of meat here and there. read more

If I could rate this location a negative (1), I would. I was in Oxford for work and decided to grab a pizza before heading back to the hotel. I placed my order inside at the front counter at 8:02PM. I understand it's a college town with a lot of young adults working there. That being said - it was more like disorganized chaos. I sat patiently and watch customers being ignored at the front counter. The blonde-haired young lady with the ponytail has the absolute worse attitude. I surmise that she has to be related to the owner because how else can anyone explain with her rudeness, she is still gainfully employed there?! I walked up to the counter at 8:44PM and inquired about my pizza, The same young lady rudely stated, "Who did I ask?' ASK?! I was waiting on my name to be called. I am the customer. Of course, by this time the pizza was less than desirable...It you like bad service, a bad attitude and a bad pizza - this is your place! read more

I loved this place! I ordered a cauliflower crust pizza with pepperoni, olives and mushrooms and it was delicious! My dad and sister shared the Otis pizza and they ate way more than I expected! The garlic bread was not as garlicky as I was hoping, but it was delicious! Kind of like focaccia bread! It was raining outside after we sat town under the awning, and the staff kept coming to make sure we were doing okay as there was plenty of room outside. read more

Lost Pizza - Oxford - Cauliflower crust make your own - Pizza Near Me - Oxford, Mississippi

See all

We live minutes from here so will typically do takeout. However tonight we decided to dine upstairs. The bar was empty except for another couple so grabbed seats there. Front and center so couldn't miss us. The two bartenders look at us and not a word. No menu, "busy and we will be right with you", nothing. We sat there as they laughed and told stories to each other. Had time to grab our own menus, scan the code for drinks. 10 mins of no acknowledgement and we finally decided to leave and eat elsewhere. Different if you're busy as I'd get it but just sitting there chatting, laughing and not even acknowledging your customers-completely unacceptable. read more

Pizza was just OK nothing spectacular. Wings were good. Service was pretty good as well.

Great pizza and tamales. Try the olive bread too. Good wings too. Upstairs bar is cool.

Very good pizza! It was a casual setting, really nice night to sit in the patio with our large group. Walked up to the counter to order and pay, servers brought everything to the table. It was an easy and seamless process. The cheese sticks could be a little better, but I loved the Popeye pizza and my son's Buffalo chicken pizza was good as well. read more

Ngl I forgot to take a photo of the food, it was amazing though! I got the jerk wings and the small El Diablo *chef kiss*. If I go back again I'll update this with pictures, but 10/10 recommend if you're in the area. read more

Decided to give this place a try, even though I'm not a fan of my local Lost pizza. This place is by far better than other experiences I have had. I got takeout so I can't speak to the ambiance much other than it seems like a pub. The service is why I am giving it 4 stars instead of 5 because they were not that friendly when I was picking up my order and took too long just to give us our pizza. For food, I got the BBQ pork pizza, but subbed grilled chicken on thick crust. It was surprisingly good, and so were the garlic bread sticks. I'd go here again. read more

Atmosphere is great. They have nice lights and a cool sitting area. Service is average. Asked the person at the register for advice on food. Did not give me any. Then my food took 45 minutes for just 12 wings with no update on where it was. Wings ended up being decent. read more

Food was good. Fast and casual vibe. Patio is the best part on a nice day. Downstairs is self service but upstairs has servers.

Friendly staff, fun place, great food! Order at counter and sit or head upstairs for table service. Don't pass this place if you don't like pizza, sandwiches and pastas were delicious! Highly recommend! read more

It is crowded for a reason-great pizzas! Go to place in Oxford and worth the wait. Don't forget there are seats upstairs as well.

Great pizza! Good atmosphere for a laid back place to with your college kids. I love the Popeye pizza and the pepperoni with honey.

Great pizza! Highly recommend. Best in Oxford by far. You can't go wrong with Lost Pizza

Ordered via phone for carryout, no problem. The person that took order was fine, not overly nice but fine. I ordered a 12 piece wing and 2 medium pizzas; a happy hippy and a Kujo The wings were small but very good. I give them 7/10. The happy hippy pizza was the better of the two, I give it a 6/10. The Kujo was below average. I give it a 2/10, wouldn't order it again. Overall relatively average food The big turnoff for this location was the prices. 12 small wings and two (smallish) medium pizzas for $65 without tip. Objectively, that is very expensive for wings and pizza. I don't know if the prices are different locations but the Oxford location, on the edge of campus seems to be gouging students who are spending their parents money. read more

If you're trying to order, don't bother calling. They don't answer the phone. According to their employees, they turn it off when they are busy. Their website also doesn't work. read more

My family's and team's favorite restaurant and our go-to. Pizza is always delicious and staff is always accommodating. We love going upstairs to sit and the bar. Does get busy on weekends and staff can be spread thin but always worth the wait. The manager here is phenomenal and it shows. read more

Good pizza. Went in late on a week night when we were in town visiting Ole Miss. we tried a few appetizers which were average. Smalls were just the right size to share. Good atmosphere upstairs. read more

We really liked this place a lot. We had planned on eating outside or doing take-out, but inside the tables were very well-spaced and everything so clean that we felt very comfortable dining inside. Order at counter, then food and beverages delivered to your table. Service was friendly and excellent, and the pizzas were some of the very best ever. My wife raved about her gluten free crust with pepperoni, artichoke hearts, ripe olives, and roasted red peppers, and I was every bit as happy with my Lucille, grilled chicken, bacon, fresh tomatoes, and ranch dressing drizzle. We had a couple of glasses of the house Cabernet Sauvignon, which was quite good. Tab was $40 before tip. We plan on making this a fairly regular lunch spot when we are in Oxford for football weekends. read more

This is a place where you order your food then sit. No one explained that you place your square waiting buzzer on a placemat at your table for them to find you. That would be the worst part. When you do this, then they know where to deliver your food. There was a waitress who noticed us sitting and she was nice and explained. They should have asked if we had been there before (only reason I reduced a star and can't give half stars). The Greek salad was amazing and enough to share for two. It had a lot of flavors and we couldn't get enough of it. We ordered the thick crust Happy Hippy and it was delicious as well. Definitely recommend this place. The reviews here were okay and we took a shot. The ambiance was cute. This is not a place to sit down and watch sports. The TV was muted and you had to read closed caption. The music was great to listen to. Great level for talking with your family/friends. read more

Ordered two smalls pizzas one was completely wrong, while the other one was a cheese pizza and only half the pizza had cheese on it, all this after waiting 45min for the food to come out. read more

Lost Pizza - Oxford - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oxford, Mississippi

Always great pizza and great service! Highly recommend! I call ahead and it's always ready when I arrive. It's still fresh & hot when I get it h read more

Very nice pizza joint. I had the Mr G sandwich with homemade chips. Very tasty. The place was busy around 1pm on Sunday, so plan ahead. Lots of kids and families there on Sunday. read more

A family member was very intent an addiment that I'd love this pizza from there. So he called in ordered a large Otis(all meats) and a large pit master (BBQ) and i will say as 1st timer it was very good an great tasting pizza but when he asked what i thought thats what i said tho adding if i had to critiuqe it ' It seemed all the toppings were mostly centered an did not cover all the pizza crust which was 2 to 3 inches of nothing but maybe a little sauce on all the outer crust.. It so happen when i said that he replied yea i noticed that too. Anyhow I will say I'll eat it again after all its good pizza I'll jus make sure to get the money's worth & I will ask it be completely covered to crust's edge with toppings ordered. read more

Great pizza and great atmosphere! I enjoy the bar upstairs for football games. Love coming here when I'm in Oxford.

We enjoyed our experience at Lost Pizza. The pizza was delicious! The servers bring the food to you at the table after you order and pay at the counter. The beverages are also self-serve. We are looking forward to our next visit. read more

I enjoyed my outdoor shaded seating at this restaurant. The Lola salad was crisp and the Jerk wings were nicely cooked. The bar area is not open during the day so only bottled beers are available. Plenty of parking was available at this time. I will return! read more

Lost Pizza - Oxford - Jamaican Jerk Wings - Pizza Near Me - Oxford, Mississippi

See all

First day I ordered a 30.plus dollar puzza with extra sauce. It was bread with a few toppings. A frozen puzza from walnart would have been better. 2nd day I go back for wings super bowl Sunday. They don't ask bone in or boneless I get boneless which I did not want. They had no remedy. Customer service at its finest. LOL. Maybe hire someone over 16 years old. Lost my busibess! read more

The staff is super super nice and the pizza is super yummy. The crust is so crispy and the sauce is so awesome. I absolutely love the pit boss pizza read more

See all

Get the Popeye, thick crust with ranch dressing on the side. Thank me later. Wish they were open later, but phenomenal pizza! read more

Great local place! Our son is a student at Ole Miss and loves to eat at this place with his friends during the week and with his family when we're in town. Great food and great service. Food is well priced and delicious. Love the atmosphere too! read more

Order is always ready on time when ordering online and the wings in every flavor are fantabulous. Found my fave pizza place in Oxford!

My food was very much undercooked. The manager was super rude to not only the customers but also the staff. I expect so much more from a restaurant in a hospitality state. As a manager myself I treat consumers and fellow employees very respectfully. I believe his ego is unethical and he forgets to treat others as he would like to be treated. I'm very disappointed in this service Lost Pizza should reconsider its management position here in Oxford. It seems that he struggles to keep the store together, I saw dirt on the table as I was seated and had to clean it off myself. Poor customer service overall, I will be contacting corporate to let them know. I am most disgusted and disturbed about his tone towards people. Lost Pizza do better please Oxford is a beautiful city. The one in Starkville has so much better service. read more

I enjoyed this place. Casual, enjoyable, great food and relaxing atmosphere. The service was great.

Service upstairs is very slow, waiter/bartender is discourteous and disorganized. I witnessed him being rude to customers and colleagues alike. Some in my group never received their orders. The food is very good but I won't be back until service improves. read more

I've eaten at this restaurant at least fifty times. Lost Pizza is consistent, tasty, and affordable. I like getting the personal pan pizza and the wings with land shark sauce. They have a dollar pint of PBR special that's always active too. The seating upstairs is great and the service is excellent. I'm so happy that Lost decided to set up shop here! read more

AMAZING pizza!! the restaurant was busy but not one staff member came up to us to take our drink/food order. we had to flag someone down to get anything including the check. other than that, great place!! read more