By far our queen prime rib was one of the best we have ever had. The cut was generous, the seasoning was wonderful, rich aus ju, tender. The petite filet mignon was terrific too. Both cooked to perfection at medium rare. The lighting was soft and romantic. Even though the tables were full the noise level was low, light music in the background. We could talk easily. Wait staff was very attentive. We even got free cups of clam chowder - maybe because it was our first time there. We highly recommend and will return. read more

It's been a while since I've been to the Log Cabin. Nothing has changed, it remains an excellent place for a tasty home cooked meal. I got the chicken parm, chicken was tender, red sauce yum and the pasta cooked to perfection. For an appetizer I chose the French onion soup, wow! The service has always been so great. Everyone that has ever waited on us has been charming and very attentive. This is such a special place to go and eat. We've been to a fair amount of great restaurants, this one is top notch! The waitress also was kind enough to take our pictures next to the bear by the fireplace. It's a very cozy place with a fireplace, warm lighting, and lots of hunting trophies on the wall. read more

Log Cabin Inn - French onion soup - Seafood Near Me - Wellsboro, Pennsylvania

See all

Decent food, but extremely salty. No particularly healthy options. On its own, the cheesesteak was pretty good. But since I didn't order a cheesesteak, but was given one instead of the chicken sandwich I *did* order - and charged the higher amount when I said I'd just keep it so I didn't have to wait even longer - I'm really not sure how to rate it all. You can get a good cheese steak. If all goes well, you'll enjoy it. All didn't go well for us. read more

We were up for Dickens weekend. A group of us came here for dinner Saturday night. It wasn't very busy. We were seated and the waitress came over. We ordered our drinks and we're served water. So far so good. She came back to take orders for appetizers. Two people ordered and she turned and walked away from us as I was trying to order. I didn't want an appetizer I wanted the onion soup. When she came back I was able to order. She also then took our dinner orders Apps came out. The clams casino were good according to the person who ordered them. The mozzarella sticks were not good because they were warm, not hot and the cheese wasn't melted inside. The onion soup was absolutely disgusting. The broth wasn't dark and beefy looking or tasting. The color looked like dishwasher. I'm not exaggerating. There was no flavor at all. The onions which should have been thin and soft ( sautéed) were big and hard as if they were just tossed in and not cooked. And it wasn't hot. Lukewarm at best. I love onion soup but this abomination was awful. Honestly Campbell's would have been better. The others had vegetable soup that came with their dinners. They said it was good but lukewarm also. One of the persons in our group very politely told the owner and she didn't respond. Nothing. She just glared. A few of us ordered steaks. I and one other ordered the Delmonico steak. I will say it was the only good thing about dinner. It was a huge piece, cooked to perfection, tender and delicious. I had the mushrooms with it and they were great too as was the baked potato. I didn't care for the way that we were offered only a baked potato or sweet potato or fries or vegetables. You couldn't get a vegetable and potato. The others said their main courses were very good too. The other complaint I have is that they don't give a dinner salad. I've NEVER not had a salad with dinner when out. I guess they're being cheap. No one bothered with dessert so I can't comment Will we all go back again? In my opinion it's not worth it to have tasteless lukewarm food. If I do go back I'll only have the steak and baked potato I'm only giving 3 stars because of the steak being good otherwise it would be one star. Date of visit: December 2024 read more

Everything the food the service the ambiance and the place needs to be cleaner didn't like it . read more

Log Cabin Inn - I know it looks good but it wasn't - Seafood Near Me - Wellsboro, Pennsylvania

I had the pleasure of eating here for Mother's Day. The atmosphere is what makes this place special. The food came out not quite hot enough for my liking but they were busy so I may give them another try. read more

See all

We've been eating here every time we take our RV to Pennsylvania. Our most recent visit was on 08/22/23. I've read some negative reviews regarding other's experience here. I must say that I totally disagree. The staff couldn't have been more friendly or courteous. The service was stellar. And, the food was prepared perfectly. The atmosphere is casual, rustic and very laid back. Perfect. My wife and I had a thoroughly enjoyable evening, and will definitely be back next year. read more

See all

Went to dinner Friday 5/31 and it was great. There were 10 in the party we did have reservations. We were seated right on time. Our waitress was over right away to get us all started. The food was great, everyone loved their meals! Our waitress was back a few times to make sure we were ok, got more drinks and she did it very easy. She knew her stuff! A few of us took suggestions from her and were not disappointed. read more

The Log Cabin is one of our favorite restaurants; Jessica was our server tonight and did an excellent job. The food could not have been better three of us had the prime rib and my wife had the filet; excellent all around. read more

Great as always! Service is great. Drinks were outstanding. I had the Delmonico and the wife had the salmon special. French onion soup was outstanding. read more

This was a recommended spot for dinner so we thought we had to try it out. I think we had the right expectation given this is a smaller town with few options. I would say this place landed right at the 3-3 1/2 star rating as it is rated. I love Yelp! Anyhow, there are large portions for the steak and especially the Prime Rib. Our prime ribs were cooked perfectly and were delicious. The sides were fairly standard for a place like this and not on par with the city/large town based steakhouses. I would also note that they do run out of various items as you read about in the reviews. When we were there they were out of one of the Steak specials but I think it was a blessing in disguise since we later found out the steak was ground sirloin. :-) What did stand out was the Waitress/Service. She had an incredible table side manor and really made our visit and dinner a stand out. She made recommendations throughout the meal and she was very attentive in terms of checking with us, cleaning, etc. She was genuine in her approach and lended credibility to everything she offered up through the dining. I don't know that we would go back and seek the place out, nor if we are in the area whether we would choose to do a "repeat". read more

Excellent meal... onion soup was on point, I had the Delmonico which was cooked perfectly and was well flavored. The log cabin was beautiful and very cozy. I also had a piece of my mothers trout and it too was delicious! Service was FANTASTIC read more

See all

Had Friday night reservations for a group of 6. The restaurant was pretty full but our service was friendly and relatively fast. I had a craving for prime rib but our waitress came back to tell us they were all out. We were given bread rolls, corn bread and cole slaw while we waited for our meals. All of bread came at room temp and the cole slaw was nothing special. My second choice as my entree was a Delmonico steak, medium well with a baked potato. The steak was a huge portion and cooked as requested. Other meal choices such as fish, chicken parm were well received. However, one dining partner let the waitress and manager know that her chicken dish was gristly and overcooked. They took a few dollars off that meal. It seems this is a local favorite in the area. read more

My wife's meal was pretty good, as were the dinner rolls, cornbread, slaw, and clam chowder that were brought out before the main course. However, the beer on tap(there was only one) was flat. I ordered the Delmonico steak and was served a sirloin. what a disappointment that was. I got the mac and cheese as a side but didn't eat it because the past was so overcooked and mushy. We will stick to the Wellsboro House and Timeless Destination. read more

Food was great. My daughter and I share wings and a small pizza. Service was also good. Loved the bar area, would definitely recommend and will go back! read more

This review is just unfortunate. I made reservation( recommended) It was tuesday. For 6:30. We arrived on time and were seated by 7:50. We were a part of 4 but our other 2 were enroute. When (pam) seated us she inquiries about our other 2 guests. I assured her they would be arriving by 7:40. She failed to tell me that the kitchen would be closing. As time progressed she eventually said the kitchen is closed we can no longer take orders. So,being that there is no cell service in bum f!#k I needed to use their landline to call my family that has been driving for 12hrs to not come because the kitchen is closed and at 7: 30 they could no longer order food. What! If Pam informed of that when we sat down I would have have ordered something for them. NO WORRIES. FOOD WAS MEDIOCRE . As was the entire menu. Wouldn't go back. They also didnt have one of the wines they advertised. read more

I called ahead and advised them I had a group of 18. I was told there was room for us and that the full menu was available. Upon arrival I was looked up and down by the hostess and she told me they didn't have any room for us. There were approximately 10 patrons sitting down and about 40+ available seats. She realized we were all Hispanic and refused us service. Told me she had reservations booked and pointed at a book that the pages were blank. She CLEARLY refused service because we were Hispanic. As a Police Officer of 22 years who has served our Country with honor and integrity i am outraged by this behavior. You should revise your attitude and be inclusive to all communities. We are Professional family oriented individuals and should get the same treatment everyone gets. read more

Absolutely worst restaurant iv ever been to. Owner was very rude. They were out of pasta. How is that even possible? Steaks were very low quality and tasteless. Chessy mashed potatoes were out of a box. The soda was watered down. I could go on and on. There wasn't one positive thing about this place. Oh they then tell you there is a 3.25% up charge for using a card to pay when they bring the bill. Instead of being upfront about it. This place is absolutely terrible go to the welsboro steakhouse and get a good meal. read more

We love to visit this restaurant when visiting Wellsboro/ Galeton. The ambiance is so quaint and cozy! Especially during the holidays! The food is great and portions are a nice size. Can't wait to go back this season! read more

I don't know what has happened, but this used to be a great place to eat in the Northern Tier. Now, no salad bar and tomato soup with cornbread and roll is offered with the main entree. If you don't like or can't eat tomato soup, there is no substitute side offered - making your above $35.00 meal consist of a steak and baked potato. Ridiculous!!! read more

Awful place! I was stupid enough to go back giving them the benefit of the doubt -but never again. I am a local and like to support local businesses, but I am tired of how RUDE the staff/owners are! read more

Quaint out of the way place. Service was wonderful. Best steak I've ever had. My only regret was I couldn't eat it all.

Very ordinary food and cocktails. Our experience was not at the level of many reviews. Their soup special was a macaroni tomato, but it came with the meal regardless. I ordered their French onion soup, which is supposed to be a house specialty, but they brought out the macaroni tomato soup as well. I don't get that. The onion soup broth was flavorless, the onions hardly cooked and still crunchy. Not even close to being caramelized. No salad or vegetables were available with our meal. My Delmonico steak was done to my specification medium rare, but was a bit chewy. My wife's scallops over angel hair were good. We both agreed this was a three star. read more

They got us right in on a Saturday afternoon even though we didn't have reservations. It was very busy, so I'd suggest reservations. My husband had the Steak Alaska. It was a delicious perfectly cooked filet topped with delicious homemade Alfredo sauce and seafood. The waitress shared that it's their best seller, which makes sense because it is out of this world delicious! I had the prime rib, which was also cooked perfectly and well-seasoned. Both meals were served with corn bread, soup, and pasta salad. We ordered the mozzarella sticks for an appetizer. Service was fast end friendly. I highly recommend the Log Cabin! read more

My husband and I went here for our most recent anniversary dinner - it was our first time here - and we had a great experience. I recommend making a reservation though, if we hadn't made one we would not have been seated that night, it was a Saturday evening. Our waitress was a lovely lady, friendly and helpful - and had a great disposition. We each had the salad and soup bar, my husband had a steak and I had one of the fish dishes, both were good, cooked to order and flavorful. The cocktails were excellent (as my husband had a few...), and the wine selection was pretty decent. It was a wonderful evening, a semi-casual event with friendly down-home staff. I would definitely go back. read more

See all

Food was delicious and got plenty of it! Big servings. Should've made a reservation but still seated us in 15 mins on a Saturday night!

Made reservations 3 days in advance for Friday night 5 pm 4 people , they called me Friday to advise me that they could not seat us at 5 but to come in at 6pm . I told them I had been their before at 6 pm and the place Was over crowded and we waited 2 hrs for our food .They suggested to come in at 5 and seat in the bar . Arrived 4:30 got seat in bar no problem ordered 4 dinners 8 drinks (( drinks very small so order doubles or two)) this I knew and expected 3 dinners good 1 fish dinner over cooked tasted like cardboard told waitress she called manager manager stated there was nothing wrong with my dinner I told her to try it , would not change it no sense arguing with a moron payed bill and left ((never to return)) this so called manager should go to high school and get an education on how to treat customers read more

This has been our go to place for a nice meal for about 4-5 years during Wellsboro's Dickens Weekend. Knowing that this year was different due to COVID-19, we decided to eat here on Friday, December 4th with a reservation at 6 pm. The restaurant was slightly more than 1/2 full and it appeared that the total capacity to be seated was greater than the allowed 50% of capacity. What was definitely apparent was that diners were not being seated at least 6' apart. There were also at least 4 groups that came in during our time without masks and were allowed to be seated. We also noticed that they do not wipe the menus after each use. As for the service, we have had better. The server was nice but not exactly attentive. The restaurant itself has closed the salad bar due to the pandemic and not sure if they prices were adjusted accordingly since this was built into the price. Each person does get a plate with cornbread, roll and cole slaw. We asked what the soup of the day was (which was previously included with the salad bar) and ordered two cups. She never brought them and when our meals were served we asked to have them taken off our bill. She explained that it was included, which we didn't know, but that we should have reminded her to bring them. Guess it was our fault??? She did bring cups of soup as we were eating but at that point, didn't want them. Had we known they were part of the meal, we would have ordered appetizers. Towards the end of the meal we had placed our empty soda glasses at the end of the table wanting refills. The hostess/owner? took the glasses and never brought them back. She assumed we were done with them even though our meals were still in front of us. As for the food, my steak was good. My wife order the chicken alfredo. The pasta was good but the chicken was dry and not much taste. In all honesty with their attitude towards diner safety, can't say that we will be in a hurry to return any time in the future. read more

My wife and I were in Gaines for a long weekend and had dinner here our second night. The first dinner we had was at the old antlers inn just down the road and it was the worst dining experience of our lives, so we didn't have high hopes for the little town of Gaines. Wow! Were we wrong! This place is fantastic! Seafood trio app: delicious. My prime rib: amazing, certainly one of the top 10 I've ever had. Yes, it was that good. Wife had the steak Alaska: it was so good I wasn't allowed to have a bite. Our server (her name escapes me) younger, curly blond hair (I think) and a couple of tattoos. She was fantastic! We wanted for nothing the entire night! We never order dessert because we try to watch what we eat but this place was soooo good we decided to get desserts to go. Lemon meringue pie was just like Grandmom used to make, pretty sure this place stole her recipe. Haha. Wife got some chocolate peanut butter thing, again, too good to share. If this place wasn't a 4hr one way drive for us it would be our new favorite place! Word to the wise..... get reservations. We tried to go the previous night (after our terrible "dinner" at old antlers) just to be turned away for no reservations. Hostess was very pleasant and made reservations then and there for us for this meal. Place, people, food: total class act! Wish I could give it 10 stars. read more

I suppose this restaurant is every bit as good as the reviews say...and it was also recommended to me by a local. But don't bother going without a reservation! I was disappointed that my party of three was turned away at the door by the hostess because we didn't have a reservation, despite the fact that it was before 5:00 pm and most of the tables were vacant. We ended up at The Steakhouse in Wellsboro and did not regret it. The food there was great and we had a wonderful time with great service. read more

Bug in our food. My husband ordered the mussels and scallops and was nearly finished with his dinner when he discovered a bug swimming in the broth. Obviously, he lost his appetite. Sadly, the waitress came and said that it certainly couldn't have happened in the kitchen and said she would get us our bill. They offered us a tour of the kitchen so we could make sure. No manager came to the table. The waitress seem to think that telling us that it didn't happen in the kitchen was some sort of consolation, and would make everything all better. To the customer who had eaten nearly all their dinner, this didn't solve anything. We expected much better from this restaurant where we had gone to celebrate our 25th anniversary. No manager came to make the situation better. We will never go back there again and have told all of our friends and family in the Lancaster area the story so I'm sure that they will pass it on to all their friends as well. read more

Two of us went here on a Friday night in July at 8pm. There were only a few tables occupied, but we were told that without a reservation we would not be seated. The woman was very rude. She said she had a large party due in soon, but we counted seats, and they could have easily accommodated the two of us. We left and went to the Antlers next door, where we were told that many of their customers arrive with the same story. Just for fun, I called the Log Cabin and tried for a reservation. I got a similar story. I was surprised that at no point did the woman apologize or say she was sorry or suggest another restaurant. So on the phone, after she rebuffed my attempt to get a reservation without apology, I asked her if she was sorry. She seemed puzzled, and asked what I meant. I said, "I mean, are you sorry that you can't accommodate us?" And she replied, "Are you an asshole." I doubt I will ever attempt to go to this place again. It blows me away that someone in a service industry can be so utterly oblivious. My advice if you are considering this place: skip it and go to the Antlers next door. The staff is friendly and the food is good. read more

Cute little place out in the middle of no where! It is very cozy inside and with the music they play it almost puts you to sleep haha! I had the steak Alaska and it was very good! I liked that our meals came with the salad bar which also had soup on it too. There was a decent selection of things! Definitely a good place for a date night. read more

We were camping at the PA Grand Canyon in Wellsboro, PA and were looking for a good place to eat for our "last night dinner." What a great restaurant seemingly in the middle of beautiful nowhere! The menu was interesting and varied, the prices reasonable, the food absolutely delicious! The owner, Dan (our bartender as we waited to be seated), recommended the Sicilian Seabass special...it was as delicious and mouthwatering as he promised!! Thank you Dan! The Inn had a relaxed and casual atmosphere and the waitstaff was friendly. We were by ourselves, but it seemed to be family and kid friendly also! The only downside to this place is that it is 170 miles from home!! read more

Nice decor. Red, white and blue focus. Menu covers it all - fish, seafood, meat, pasta and chicken. The chicken was very moist and seasoned just right. Salad bar was typical - nothing super special - but good. Desserts were very good - apple pie was not too sweet with a good pie to filling ratio. Others in my party enjoyed their meals as well - steak was cooked just right, both chx and eggplant parms were exceptional. read more

See all

Will never step foot in this restaurant again. They took a 7 pm reservation for 10 and then yelled at 2 in our party who were at the bar ordering drinks because they need to get "this process moving because we're closing at 8 and I have to go". Never once did they tell us that when we made the reservation and when asked why they took us we were told because that's all they had. We were treated extremely rude. She told us to just pay for our drinks and go. Then when I mentioned we didn't all even get drinks she told us she'd "just eat it". My friend handed her a $100 and we left. She told us good luck on finding somewhere to eat. While I and my 9 friends were looking forward to a filet mignon dinner because we were told that's what they are known for..the party next to us said they had to wait forever for their food, we won'tbe back. I have never been treated so poorly and so rudely. Can't comment on the food but after experiencing that service I won't be back. In this age of covid when restaurants and servers are trying to recover you turned away a party of 10 on a Tuesday night..your loss. read more

This place is awesome! We have been going here for years. It is located near my dad's house. If you are familiar with the area you know that there are not a lot of great restaurants in the area. This is a diamond in the great outdoors. It is a 7 hour drive to visit family and I look forward to dinner at the log cabin! The steaks are great and fish dishes cannot be beat. To be honest, I don't think we ever had a bad meal. If you are in the area stop by, you will not be disappointed. read more

Split the cedar plank salmon and blackberry salmon because we couldn't decide. Both were excellent!

Stood in the front (waiting) area for 13 minutes when the owner finally came out into the waiting area to greet us and tell us she was full. Hire a host. read more

This place got such wonderful reviews and I don't like to go to the same place two nights in a row when I'm on vacation. I'm really sorry that I went to the trouble of showering and coming here after my 60+-mile ride on the nearby Pine Creek Trail. First surprise: Bar isn't open during the week. Don't worry, you can still get a drink; however, if you're dining alone you'll be overlooked if you choose to stay. Second surprise: No wifi. When you're on your own, sometimes you've gotta look to what I call my iGuy for a little engagement, perhaps to post a real-time Yelp review. Not so at the Log Cabin. The decor is quaint and rustic. After the hostess took my beverage order (must've been the desire to sit at the bar--I looked like a typical bar fly in clogs and a down vest, let me tell ya!), the only waitress came by seconds later to take my dinner order. I hadn't really had time to look, since I discovered that iGuy was incognito. I told her that I hadn't looked, and then she told me that she had a table of 6 that just walked in, and I told her not too worry. I decided and I began to worry when I was making quick progress on my glass of Chianti with no food in my belly. I finally flagged down the hostess, who reminded me that I wasn't in a hurry. I KNEW that, but I was being ignored. I finally placed my order and was then told to go take advantage of the salad bar. They did have some yummy cauliflower salad that I'm sure wasn't healthy, but it was something to go with my iceberg lettuce. I finished it and waited for my entree. In the meantime, the waitress and hostess engaged every other table, asking them where they were from,etc. Crickets in Baby's corner here. When I got my entree, it was an overcooked plank salmon. I paid $1.00 for the plank. They also got another glass of Chianti. (Keep the wannabe bar fly happy, right?). I ate all of it because I was really hungry. It even took a while to get my check. I'm usually pretty generous with servers when it comes to tipping. That didn't happen tonight. She got 15%. I'm sure the table of 6 they so lovingly catered to took up the slack. Dining solo? Go the Old Antlers Inn. I wish I'd gone back there tonight. Two or more in your party? Maybe they'll care about you and your experience will be better than mine. At least I hope so. read more