Everything about this place is great from the staff to the food to the prices! I recently did an online order and once it was time to pick it up, I started my journey over to the restaurant! Parking was very easy to find and there is a nice amount of signage to find this place without getting lost at all. The interior was very nice and decked out in New York items. I loved that the TV they had in the place was playing old style teenage mutant ninja turtles episodes because who else loves pizza more then them (and me). The tables were nicely spaced out and there was a few other people waiting for their orders so it was a little busy. I did have to wait longer then expected and got asked multiple times what I was there for so the communication amongst them was a little rough but all of them were very friendly. I decided to get a pizza and garlic knots. Their 6 garlic knots are about $7 dollars. They were very good but I do wish they had a little more oil on them because they were a little dry to me. The pizza was very delicious! A 12 inch pizza was $17 for a plain cheese. The cheese was melted wonderfully and the crust had a nice crunch to it. my only thing was I am not a fan of sweet sauce and this pizza has that flavor to it. it was good but I don't think I would order a pizza from here again, personally. It is also a thin crust style, again which I am not a fan of, but was tasty nonetheless. read more

See all

As a lover of pizza, I find Little Mikes to be one of those top-tier places to eat. located in the Shoppes at Cleary, this quaint place packs a lot of flavors, starting with the service, definitely one of the best I have been a part of, the servers took our order with accuracy and kindness. I started with the garlic knots. OMG, they were perfect: crispy on the outside and deliciously soft on the inside. After 5 minutes, there were none left. I ordered a 13-inch pizza and gave it a 9/10. It had the right amount of sauce and cheese. However, the bread was a little bit too floppy. Bitting into it was not my favorite part, but once I got past that, the flavors were booming!!! Overall, Little Mikes's amazing customer service and bold flavors are definitely signs of a restaurant worth visiting time and again. read more

See all

Little Mikes is a small pizza place in Plantation next to Central Park off cleary blvd. We decided to eat in and try it since it's literally across the street! It was two of us and we ordered the garlic knots and large size pizza- the Boss! Pizza had lots of veggies and meats. Very friendly service and we enjoyed the music in the background. Oldies we love. Lots of Sinatra. Menu is big and we can try other dishes next time. Pie was so huge so we took home half. Very tasty and overall good experience. Pizza was a tad soggy and full of toppings. Next time I'll ask for little more cooked. read more

Little Mike's - The Boss. Large - Pizza Near Me - Plantation, Florida

PIZZA OH YEAH... Absolutely a top pizzeria for the books... This tiny neoteric pizzeria in the Shoppes at Cleary packs a big punch of flavor and unmatched hospitality. Met with the friendly smiling server, Karen, who took my order. I sat at one of the four interior tables where I noticed a tin bucket of white chalk that you use to draw on the table while waiting for my anticipated slice - Karen condoned this inviting gimmick by drawing an "X" on my table. Huge slice of cheese pizza with heavy sauce, light garlic flavor, and lightly chared bottom with a crispy cornicione. (Warning) Let the slice sit for at least three minutes before taking a bite since scorching hot. The huge puffy roll was dripping in fresh garlic and made up for the light garlic on the pizza slice. The gender neutral bathroom was clean with contemporary facilities and a stone back splash. Loved this pizzeria and will return soon. read more

See all

Service is great. Pizza is yummy with great ingredients. There's a fair amount of seating inside. I visited on a Friday to pick up an online order. The staff was attentive despite the phones being off the hook & the revolving door of pickups for to-go orders. Pick up was easy. read more

Little Mike's - Cute sign - Pizza Near Me - Plantation, Florida

We genuinely had high hopes going into Little Mike's in the Shoppes at Cleary after browsing the reviews on YELP. After all, a 4/5 rating is nothing to shy away from. Unfortunately, our first (and probably our last) visit, did not reach the 4/5 level for the one item we ordered - a medium mushroom pizza, ordered to eat in. For good measure, we'll start off with the positives: 1) our order came fast and hot; 2) our server was attentive and tried very hard to please us; 3) the pizza tasted OK, in terms of flavor of sauce and cheese, although having lived in the NYC area for 20 years, it did not match up. Some of the reviews stated that they likened their pizza to that found in New York. We would love to ask what part of New York they came from, as our experience in 4 of the 5 boroughs and several nearby NY/NJ communities were far superior. The crust was at least 3/16" to 1/4" thick in places, which is not "thin," as stated in a few of the other reviews. In addition, the pizza was cooked underdone (as opposed to "baked lightly" or "not burnt"), and thus the crust's consistency was a bit pliable and "doughy." Our final complaint on our order was what we considered to be an insufficient amount of mushroom topping. We are accustomed to at least half of the surface of each slice to be covered with the topping. That was not the case with ours (see picture of 2 uneaten slices). One should not be able to count the mushroom slices on each piece with one hand and have 3/4 of the slice just like a "plain cheese" style. As residents of the area who entertain family from out-of-state (and yes, one of those families is from New York), we continuously are on the lookout for tempting spots for them to try. Sadly, this eatery is not one we plan to take them to. read more

Little Mike's - Pizza Near Me - Plantation, Florida

Great ambience, but my issue lies in the food. I bought a cheese slice and I was extremely disappointed, I shall break down what went wrong. Firstly, adding Parmesan and oregano without the customer asking for it is a big no no. I was shocked to see Parmesan and oregano already added, you don't add that to the slice unless requested before hand. Secondly, the slice was soft. The cheese tasted weird and slid off the slice and the dough tasted old. I'm sorry but bottom line, a slice needs to be better than this specially for $3.20 even a 99c slice in Times Square would be better. I'm sure this is a one off but this was outrageous. In addition, I started to feel weird after eating that slice and I'm sure it was the cheese and tomato sauce. read more

Little Mike's - Front desk - Pizza Near Me - Plantation, Florida

I picked up a take out order last night for a 20" meatball pizza. It was ready for pick up at the designated time and was fresh out of the oven. The counter person was very nice and there were a few others picking up at the same time. The pizza was cooked well eventhough it had a big flop factor. The sauce is a bit sweeter than the traditional pizza that I am used to. I don't know if I would get the pizza again but maybe try some other menu items. read more

Little Mike's - Pizza Near Me - Plantation, Florida

See all

The pizza is decent for south florida, it's fine. The Sicilian pizza I just got was really not good, cheese all over the place and not formed to the pizza. Just not good quality at all, avoid that dish. It's fine. There are other options in the area. read more

It's nice to have another pizza place around the corner. I'm not sure how I felt about the sauce on this pizza, it didn't taste too tomato in nature, not that I'm saying that is a bad thing. I felt it was almost like a sweetish cheese type taste. I'm a fan of thin sliced pizza so this certainly did the trick, however a negative for tough and somewhat very dry dough. Service was above average, pricing is where it should be and the fact that there is plenty of parking makes it a plus. There are a few tables inside if you wish to dine in. Open rather late making it a good choice in this area. read more

Little Mike's is a new spot in a small plaza with sufficient parking. They have a handful of dine-in tables with a nice modern Italian pizza place decor. Service was polite. I ordered a small cheese pizza to-go. I waited roughly 15-20 minutes. It was good but not NY pizza and nothing I'd run back for. read more

See all

Stopped in for a quick bite on a Saturday and was impressed! The lunch combo - 2 slices and a drink for $6.99 - was a steal. Plus, the complimentary hot garlic knots were a lovely surprise. The pizza slices were incredibly filling, with a thin crust that reminded me of authentic NY-style pizza. I've been searching for pizza like this in FL for ages! Ordering was easy, and the servers were friendly. Only minor note was that the chairs could've used a quick wipe-down from the previous customer, but nothing major. There were lots of NY styled items to showcase - My favorite was the clean restroom with the yellow taxi cab painting. Overall experience was excellent, and I'll definitely be a regular here. Highly recommend trying the thin crust NY-style pizza - you won't be disappointed! read more

See all

5 stars on the pizza. Wow! I've been meaning to order from this place for awhile and tonight I finally got the chance. Ordering online was seamless. Delivery was timely and pizza was top notch. Be aware: the large size doesn't play! It's ginormous and we ordered two. My party of 6 didn't even finish a whole one. My only complaint is that the Buffalo wing sauce was sub par. The wings were cooked nicely but the Buffalo sauce was the side and I didn't care for it. This is not a dealbreaker for me. I'll just stick to the pizza, which is phenomenal. read more

See all

This place is a 10 out of 10!!! Kanye (sp) has exceptional customer service skills. He was extremely attentive and super helpful. We have been having trouble finding a decent pizza shop that reminded us of home (North Jersey/NYC) and Little Mike's is it. Not only was the customer service remarkable.. the food was amazing. We order a pizza pie and a chicken parmesan hero. We ate at the restaurant and we were given garlic knots where were also super tasty.. The restaurant is well kept and the bathroom facilities are also clean. I hands down recommend this place and will certainly be back.. Can't wait for my next visit to Sunshine State.. Little Mike's will definitely be a part of my journey.... It's worth the trip. read more

I've had Little Mike's on my radar for the past few weeks, and tonight proved to be the perfect time to place my pickup order. I ordered and paid online and received confirmation via email with my time to pick up. I made my way over super excited to sink my teeth into my Sicilian Pizza with onions. When I walked in, the place was very clean and inviting looking whether you choose to eat in or take out. The young lady at the register brought me my order, and I took a quick sneak peak before heading out. My pie (a thick square deep-dish pie topped with sauce, cheese and onions) was an absolute thing of beauty! When I got home I dug in, and guys... not lying when I say it was one of the best Sicilian pizzas I've ever eaten. The sauce was so flavorful, the crust nice and crisp, and the edges were smothered with the perfect amount of fresh garlic. Seriously, run, don't walk to Little Mike's the next time you're craving some topnotch pizza. I look forward to returning to try their other menu items (which look equally delicious). Welcome to the hood, Little Mike's! You've secured a top spot in our tried and true to-go menu. read more

See all

This ex NYer approves! It's definitely a welcomed addition to the area. NY style pizza and garlic knots are so hard to find, but this spot definitely is as close as you can get. Love the chalkboard tables and give you something to do while you wait for your food. I loved the wall decor sign, too. The owner, Mike, was handling the Friday night rush very well. He took the time to check on those dining it while still being attentive to the take out orders. For food, we, of course, had to try the cheese pizza. I loved that it came with a cold cheese topping. It brings me back to my days in NY. For $16.99, you get a regular sized pie. We also got a ceasar salad and garlic knots loaded with garlic. This is definitely going to be my new go-to for pizza. It's going to do very well in Plantation! Can't wait to go back for more. read more

See all

If I could give this place 0 stars I would. My boyfriend ordered 2 pizzas and there was a misunderstanding with the prices and sizes. My boyfriend expressed that and the guy stated he still had to pay for them but that's not what we wanted. He forcefully tried to get him to pay for something we did not want and tried to still pay for what we initially wanted. Never again. He also ran outside to chase my boyfriend to pay when he did not even receive anything from them. read more

Yum! Got takeout tonight and ordered a pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms, boneless wings and garlic knots Pizza was yummy! A little heavy on the sauce for my liking but cheese to topping ratio was good. Boneless wings were not greasy and nice and crispy. Garlic knots were chewy and had a good garlic flavor. I will be back! Love having a decent pizza place in the neighborhood. read more

Little Mike's - Pepperoni and mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Plantation, Florida

Awesome, big pizza for a good price. Highly recommend this place for pizza lovers.. the staff are really nice as well .

Love this place!!!! I have only tried the Pizza and the Garlic knots and they are the best!!!! read more

Little Mike's - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Plantation, Florida

See all

Really good pizza and we order at least once a week - BUT they have been super cheap with the toppings and it's gradually getting worse. The pizza is obviously the best in the area since we keep coming back but after today's disgrace to pepperoni pizza I may have to start branching out read more

Little Mike's - 1 pepperoni? Really? Tragic. - Pizza Near Me - Plantation, Florida

How did this place get 4 stars ? This pizza lacked any flavor , it also was super greasy in a bad way There were zero customers dining in or taking out (first red flag) Pizza was so soggy and tasteless Typical bad florida pizza Been in florida almost 30 years and still haven't found a go too pizza place ( tried a ton of places ) New England pizza is what I grew up on LOL read more

Little Mike's - Soggy , greasy tasteless pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - Plantation, Florida

Really good pizza. Reminded me of my youth. Thin crust, great sauce with great toppings. Going back tomorrow.

The pizza and calzone are amazing. Love the garlic crust on the calzone. Entree's are very good as well and nice generous portions...

Chicken parm on hero tasted like it was frozen with undercooked breading. Pinwheels are great. Caesar salad no croutons.

Went in as we saw a video to try this place out, We ordered shrimp scampi, margarita pizza, garlic bread, chicken wings, and a Greek salad-the food was all great. The scampi was very well cooked, the Margherita pizza was well-balanced with respect to fresh ingredients, the garlic bread was soft, though flavorful, and the wings were crispy enough. Fresh Greek salad packed with flavor. Great food and friendly service, will surely come back. The setting was your typical small pizzeria, with some oldies playing in the background which we did like. read more

See all

The restaurant is adorable and being able to use chalk on the table is so fun! We had a server who went above and beyond with my daughter and even showed her how to roll pizza dough!! She loved it. The food was 10/10 and is everytime whether we dine in or order out. We always get wings and pizza and they always come out delish! read more

Little Mike's - Daughter rolling dough - Pizza Near Me - Plantation, Florida

I have been looking for months for a place that ordered the best quality products for their restaurant, no cutting corners. Just excellence in the products they wanted to deliver. It's definitely Little Mikes!!! Their crust is perfection, fresh spinach not frozen thawed out. Sauce was delicate not over powering. We had the calzone. It in itself was deserving of 5 stars We can't wait to try other things. read more

We have been hearing about this place for a bit now and have been eager to try it. We ordered take out and got their pepperoni pinwheels, their Sicilian cheese pizza, and an order of fried Oreos. The pinwheels come with a side of marinara for dipping and these were definitely the star of our order. They were very tasty and I would recommend getting them. The sauce didn't have much flavor though. Our Sicilian pizza was pretty bad. The crust tasted almost like it was stale or something. Again, sauce didn't have a great flavor. Fried Oreos were decent. I think this is something you have to order in house to get it fresh when they come out. They come with a side of condensed milk which was a first for me and it was good! We won't write this place off until we try a regular pie and see if we have a better experience. The staff was very friendly when we called to place our order and the order was ready quick. read more

See all

I'm not a pizza connoisseur but I know the difference between good and bad pizza. Little Mikes pizza in plantation hit it out of the park. I'm impressed best pizza since I've moved to Florida that was 8 years ago. Don't change a thing this is now my go to spot read more

Got the large Stromboli and fried Oreos wasn't bad but cold by the time we got home.Oreos were very good and tasty.I definitely want to come back and try the pizza.Very clean and welcoming place when you walk in.I definitely will be back.I love good customer service and nice small businesses.. read more

New-ish spot in Plantation. A very welcomed pizza join even in an area that is very crowded with pizza spots. We've ordered from here a few times and the food has always been delicious. We get a large pepperoni pizza with some garlic rolls. The pizza is fantastic and the garlic rolls have proper garlic on them. The prices are also great for the quality of food you receive. There are a bunch of spots in the area that have lost their mind when it comes to pizza prices. As for service, I've never eaten inside, we've only done to go but the person who has answered the phone and served us has always been nice. Overall, I would recommend this place if you are in the area. read more

Got my entire order wrong & over charged me for no reason. Nothing was correct on the order. Will not go back.

Great food. Had the white pizza, wings, fried Oreos, and garlic rolls. All very good.

We had an amazing waitress Brooke', as busy she was on Saturday night she was very pleasant and and attentive .. the food was very good as always !! read more

First time trying little mikes pizza it tasted like a glorified frozen pizza, sorry little mikes won't be a repeat customer.

All I have to say, is why does this little hole in the wall, not have a line out the door? Excellent Pizza! For those of you that do not like greasy (olive oil) pizza this may not be for you. However, I love this place! The pizza is thin crust pizza, and had FLAVOR! I will definitely be back! And don't think I did not see Zepole on the menu. The only bomber is they close at 10pm. I would love to stop by for a slice or two after a Panther game. Another thought is I love Sicilian Pizza, currently not offered by the the slice, but I will be ordering a whole Sicilian Pizza. Bravo Little Mike's. I love you guys! read more

I read the reviews so I was a little hesitant BUT I'm glad I ordered here. First, it was a reasonable wait. Not 45 minutes. The pizza is made perfect for me. Similar to Jacaranda Pizza which is usually a go-to for me ... but their wait was too long. I am very happy I ordered from Little Mike's and will now order more often. Thank you! read more

This is the third location down here in S Florida. No such thing as too many good pizza shops. Puzza tasted great. I would definitely focus this location on takeout. Coke no Mtn Dew LOL, but you know I had a cold one in my truck. read more

See all

I ordered small pizza, half sausage and pepperoni will say tasty on side with meat, other side bland, and certainly not NY Style, so don't expect it. read more