Always enjoy a small, intimate, funky country restaurant that takes pride in several signature…read moredishes. The steaks and rack of lamb were marvelous, and a team approach to waitstaff ensures great service. If you are in the area, go. We met a delightful couple of approximately 80 yrs young that drove a bit just to get the Escargot! Gotta love that!

First, definitely make reservations so you get a seat at a table. If there is any room for…read morewalk-ins, you are almost seated at the bar. If you like that, still call and request it. If you are not a steak eater, there is plenty on the menu for you too. However, go for the steak! We go a few times a year and it never disappoints. Dress is casual, kind of an old looking dive bar vibe with great food. People are nice, servers know their menu and can make good suggestions if you're a first timer. Reasonably priced for everything except the steak. With the steak, you're paying for quality. Always a great meal, and almost always leftovers to take home. We've never had dessert because dinner is so filling, so no review on dessert here.

Great food and service is always on point. Can get loud on Saturday nights just do to room…read moreacoustics, otherwise cozy and friendly.

On a dreary, chilly Saturday afternoon in March, stopping in at the cozy bar at Chesapeake Tavern…read morewas just what my wife and I were looking for. This was our first time here and we really liked the place. Our bartender was very friendly and provided info on the building being over 200 years old and new ownership taking over 2 years ago. I started off with a Kane IPA, my wife had a Toasted Almond. The beer was easy, but he did a great job making her drink. We each had a bowl of broccoli cheddar soup, then we shared the Maryland Crab Nachos. The soup was ok, but those nachos were fantastic! So different from anything we've had. The dinner menu here looks very good also. We'll definitely be back!

I have tried almost the entire menu since it has opened. Ralph and his staff make you feel like a…read moreregular every time. Best lunch value in the county and glad I live close

Very happy with our visit today The Pier is very simple,…read morewith tasty food, and a great selection. Lobster rolls were great & flavorful. Lobster bisque had depth and wonderful! We found our seafood place and are looking forward to our next visit!

Great quality, variety (if they do not have the fish you want, they will try to get it), and…read morecompetitive pricing. The staff is extremely helpful and entertaining too.

Come here!! Mike is so kind and helpful. Fish is fresh and I'm excited to enjoy it tonight. I got…read morethe ahi, halibut, and hamachi would 100% recommend.

BEST shrimp cocktail anywhere!! Great seafood and service!! Family favorite! Always a hit!!read more

Love the breaded haddock dinner. Three large pieces of fish with french fries and coleslaw…read more Delicious! But be aware, it is cash only and takeout.

Came here as my friend wanted to make fish for one of our dinners. Overall, we were happy with our…read morepurchase. BOFM upon entry has two nicely spread out ice troughs full of fresh fish, shrimp, scallops, and more. We were told that the owner makes regular trips to New York to obtain the seafood and that all are not farm raised but wild. I cannot guarantee that, though. The place smelled like it should and not of old product or unclean. Our staffer made nice conversation with us and was nice that he had some common things with my friend that they could discuss. The prices were on par with what I could possibly get in Philadelphia at the Reading Terminal Market but may be considered high here in the Poconos. We got some trout and bluefish. They prepped the fish how we wanted it. My friend also picked up some Branzino for the ride back home. Our dinner was excellent!

Quirky personality but product always hits the mark. I have…read moreclam bakes and order 200, 300, 500 clams at a time. He always has them and they are always wonderful. Fish looks beautiful. I always say I'm going to try it and then never make it back.

I'm in love w/ this chain. I've been to 3 different locations, always a good meal! Ordered Live…read moreLobster Special, per my usual. Shrimp, clams, lobster all cooked perfectly. Corn, broccoli (add-on), potatoes also cooked perfectly. All swimming in the delightful Flamin' Special butter sauce. Still can't believe you can have a full seafood feast for the same price as a couple of Domino's pizzas. Clean interior, friendly staff. Located in the busy Walmart shopping Center.

Our waitress was great. We were there about 1pm and it was rather empty on a Saturday. The other…read morepatrons looked extremely pleased with their seafood boils. It's clean and cutely decorated with an ocean theme. The garlic bread appetizer was melt in your mouth perfect. The seafood po boy was on a very fresh bun and full of flavor. The onion rings I opted for were too hard, not tasty. My friend said her seafood Alfredo was good, a smaller portion, but nothing she would race back to try. I would come again to try something different.

we had Karen as our witches she was awesome. Our food was good and we had the big boil. Come out…read moreand enjoy some great food.

We have been coming to this restaurant at least 1 or 2 times a month and have never had any issues…read moreuntil we ate lunch here on 9-5-2026 around 1:30pm. Our waitress named Cassy 7 on our bill. If she waits on you make sure that she does not add on extras that you do not want. She will ask if you want corn and potatoes with your meal and if you say yes she adds on extra portions of each. Corn for $4.00 more and Potatoes for $3.50 more (They are already included with your meal). When she brought out our food we asked her why we had so many pieces of corn and potatoes with each meal and she said that is what we wanted and I explained to her we only wanted that comes with the meal and you brought us way to many. She said no problem and that she would take them off of our bill and I explained that we did not order and extra food and she said that its ok and that they would take them off of our bill when we paid. Well when the bill arrived nothing was taken off and We asked her about it and she said that she would have it corrected and then came back and asked me for payment and I asked for a copy of the bill before I paid and she had taken off only part of the extras and I told her that she needed to take the rest off of the bill and she stormed away and then 2 other ladies came to the table and told us that we had eaten the extras and that we had to pay for them. WE DID NOT EAT THEM!! I explained this to them and they said the waitress had counted the food that was left and we had to pay for the missing pieces and that was that. We were lied to and tricked into ordering add ons that we did not eat. I paid the bill and explained that we would never come back here again after this mess. It's not the money that matters. It was how we were treated. YOU JUST LOST A LONG TIME CUSTOMER OVER THIS! Just beware when you order so this doesn't happen to you!

Butcher's Grill is always such a tasty surprise! Second time here and it never lets me down!!!The…read morefood was absolutely delicious and came out super quick. If you don't want your entrées coming out with the appetizers, just give them a heads up, because the kitchen moves fast here. We started with the mushroom dish and a hearty soup...both full of flavor and the perfect start to the meal. Then came the star of the night: the lamb chops. Perfectly seasoned, cooked just right, and melt-in-your-mouth good. Everything we tried was fresh and satisfying, the kind of food that makes you want to go back the next day. The service was on point- Friendly and attentive, and the whole space has this quirky, cozy feel, like you're sitting in your grandma's living room with its mix of chairs and warm, homey vibe. It's also BYOB, which is always a win. We brought a bottle of wine that paired perfectly with the meal. Overall, Butcher's Grill is a must-visit if you're in the area. Great food, quick service, and a cozy atmosphere that makes it stand out. Can't wait to come back!

Overall cute whole in the wall butcher shop restaurant. They were very nice but the food was okay…read more Husband for the rib eye and he said it was great. Everything else (chicken, salmon, burger) was overcooked. I would stick to the steaks. Seems like their speciality. The food presentation was great tho! And seems like locals love it. We came for an early dinner so they were able to accommodate us but it was busy by the time we left.

I believed going into this place that it didn't seem highly rated for food, but seemed to be more…read moreof the location and aesthetic... I feel that I was pleasantly surprised. First off, this is truly indicative of Sussex County--off the beaten path, luscious, green... a dining experience that is elevated because of its location--if you are able to request a window seat, I would advise in doing that because we definitely enjoyed the beauty of the mountains and were entertained by the deer that came to graze right outside of where our table was located. I appreciate the history.. location.. service was quick and pleasant (Tina was our server). Food was decent enough.. we enjoyed the bread--though some parts seemed a little hard--and I recommend putting out salted vs non salted butter. Salad bar has a decent variety. My New England clam chowder was really good. My seafood platter with salmon, scallops, and shrimp was ok. The seafood was a little fishy for me. The cook said he tried his best to get my salmon to medium, but it was more well done. I appreciated that they informed me of their efforts. The shrimp were well done. We skipped dessert.. Would I return? It is super far from us at about an hour and forty minutes away, so because we weren't wowed by the food, it was nice to visit once.

Today is July 26, 2026 and we just had dinner at Walpack Inn and I gotta tell you the food was…read moreamazing. Tina was our service server and she was incredible the view the atmosphere and just all around Great experience. The Walpack Inn never disappoints and their food is just amazing