Good pizza. We got a mushroom & garlic pie. Quick Nice & friendly staff. Always a nice place.

Always enjoyed the food. Do not like that the woman at the front decided to put $5 of my change in the tip jar on her own, even though that is what I would have done myself. To do that and run to the back is sneaky. Don't think I didn't notice. I recommend bringing exact change. After careful consideration, I will no longer contribute to their tip jar. read more

Food is absolutely amazing service and great food. The young lady that works there she is the sweetest thing ever I absolutely love that girl she's a sweetheart read more

excellent wood burning pizza, great service and cozy place. We got the plain pizza and it was perfectly cooked. read more

Teresa's - excellent wood burning pizza!! - Pizza Near Me - Mount Bethel, Pennsylvania

I really enjoyed the gnocchi in pink vodka sauce I got here. Not a whole lot of ambience but meh the food and service are great. Building itself is quite beautiful and cozy construction though. read more

Food is very good, service not so much. On one occasion I was told pizza would be ready for pick up in 40 minutes. I showed up 50 minutes later and they hadn't even put my pie in the oven. A few weeks later I called and got a busy signal. I called back a minute later and let the phone ring at least 15 times with no answer before hanging up and ordering elsewhere. read more

Basic pizza place with less than friendly staff. Stuffed pizza is good. 50/50 chance they burn your order

The food gets worse and worse. Zero taste for the pizza. Muscles are the same. Now I understand why the dining room is empty on a Friday night. If I could give it no stars, I would. read more

As a local never again. 2nd time in 2 years we have tried this place and just as disappointing as the first time. Ordered a Stromboli and got a loaded calzone? Burnt on the bottom also? There sauce is great but wveeything read more

Teresa's - Our "Stromboli" wtf - Pizza Near Me - Mount Bethel, Pennsylvania

See all

Teresa's is a really nice spot for Pizza in an otherwise very limited food landscape. Let's face it, there aren't alot of take out options in this area. So when you come across a Great Pizzeria like Teresa's you definitely have to give it the well deserved props it should get.   I don't travel out this away alot anymore so this review only represents this one time experience but let me tell you the Pizza here is extremely delicious. The Meatball Pie and Sausage with Mushrooms Pie that we ordered were winners. And they don't skimp on the toppings either.   Plus I noticed a Yuengling sign in the window and you gotta love a place that serves Beer with your Pizza. And That's the name of that tune!!  Come and get your Munch on!! read more

See all

Teresa's has greatb*italian tood and exceptional cheese steaks (1 "large" will feed 3 or 4 people. I've mostly done take out, which is very good. Favorites are the lasagne, chicken Marsala and penne Alfredo with chicken, although I can also recommend the frutti del mar with its clams, scallops, mussels etc. in either marina sauce or white clam sauce. All the seafood was sweet and tender and tasted extremely fresh . The entrees all come with a salad, bread, and your choice of pasta. You can dine in there (they have a limited bar--wine & beer), but it's more popular for take out.The prices are quite reasonable and portions generous. read more

The pizza here was delicious and the woman at the front was very friendly and helpful. I was glad that they took some covid precautions as evidenced by requesting people who enter to wear masks and having a plastic curtain around the area where you order food from but it was disappointing that I could see that the people in the kitchen were wearing their masks hanging from their ear and not even attempting to put the mask over their mouth or nose. Perhaps this area as a whole isn't taking covid as seriously as we are in Philly as we saw many establishments in this area where people were not wearing masks. read more

Teresa's - a restaurant with tables and chairs - Pizza Near Me - Mount Bethel, Pennsylvania

We are locals in the area, and we were recommended Teresa's by the owner of the Westgate Mall Pizzeria. Firstly, I want to say that we had exceptional service from Jossalyn. She was our waitress and juggling many tables simultaneously, but she was very friendly, helpful, and offered refills for us. As for the food...Meh. Our table ordered two margherita pizzas. It was ok. Not great. The crust was crispy and thin (which was was nice) and I can appreciate a crispy crust. But the pizza itself was sloppy and the cheese just fell off because the sauce was not thick enough and also nonexistent. We had tasteless sausage as a topping. The consensus was that there would be other pizzerias in the area that we would think of for dinner over this one, and I have to agree. Teresa's really has nothing to separate itself from the many other mediocre pizzerias in the Slate Belt region. Average is the word. read more

It's the best in area for pizza/Italian but at same time theres not much in the area. But still better then anything in Bangor as well I believe for Italian. Pasta I would recommend Tortellini Bolognese and their margherita pie from the wood burning stove which they only do after 5pm. read more

This place is disgusting. It used to be a good, little spot to go to. Pizza was always good. They did stromboli like no other. Steak sandwiches used to be a another go to. Not anymore. Absolutely foul. They've been steadily declining over the years, but my parents would tolerate it and I'd occasionally join them when visiting. Yesterday was the last straw. First off, check the pic. They don't even know what the top and bottom of a roll is. I could determine the top and bottom of a roll blind-folded. That sandwich is sitting and made on its side. Forget the fact that it was plain, boring, and accompanied with some cold rubber cheese. My mom was gonna just suffer through her chicken meal. She had me taste it. I said no. Nope. I was pretty angry, to be honest. My mom didn't want to make the drive back, and she's not one to waste. I'm not either. I don't recall the last time I sent food back, but this was that bad. I was not having it. This is why I don't go out that often. It's almost like the people eating there have never had a decent meal, so they don't know what good is. I wouldn't feed that garbage to my dog. I wouldn't it offer it to the neighborhood raccoons. If you've ever cooked a partially frozen chicken breast, you'll understand the next statement. The chicken was clearly cooked (probably in a microwave - not even kidding) partially frozen, then tossed in some batter, and probably cooked over a skillet. It was like chewing on hard rubber. I calmed down a bit, but we made the 15 min drive back. I told them it was absolutely disgusting and pointed out some of the issues. The one kid (he's been there for years, and he knows better) didn't argue. He simply stated, 'Yeah, I have to give you a refund'. If they hadn't, I would have just left the food there. Wasn't eating it, that's for sure. At least they gave us a refund. But we will NEVER be going back. The old dude at the front (toothpick Sal I think is his name) has let that place go down hill since he set fire to Dough Boys. (Kidding about the fire, but it's entirely plausible.) I'd give a 0 if I could. Do yourself a favor and do NOT eat here. Ever. I wish I was kidding when I say you'd be better off with a microwave dinner. But don't do that either. read more

Teresa's - Made on its side. If you don't know the top and bottom of a roll, you should not be cooking. - Pizza Near Me - Mount Bethel, Pennsylvania

This is pizza et al commensurate with the best true East Coast goombas offer. Their brick oven pizza is fab!

We love it here. We've only ever done take out but it's always been very good. Currently waiting for my husband to bring home tonight's dinner. My only complaint thus far has been the Alfredo. Very bland but still edible. Getting new items today so we'll see! read more

so I did an online order to bring dinner to my mother's place. I ordered an ant pasta, which was very good. I ordered a chicken sandwich with lettuce, tomato onion, which was good. I ordered two sausage rolls for my mother and I ordered a Sicilian special, which was my mistake. I wanted just a plain Sicilian pie. notes section. I did ask for the Sicilian to be well done. When I open the sausage rolls, they were so burnt and disgusting. My mother was unable to eat them. We basically had to pull the pork and the cheese out of the roll. They were un edible. My wife loves everything that was on the Sicilian pizza, which was not well done and did not have any taste. It's a shame. I should've driven the sausage rolls back and asked for my money back. I typically don't leave reviews on yelp, but felt this was necessary. read more

Excellent pizza, coffee, friendliness, politeness, price, and service, after visiting Klein's farm from New Jersey! Located at a strategic place, between Klein's farm and Del Water Gap, so you can visit the farm first, have lunch here, and then burn those calories by hiking at Del Water Gap. Suggestion to Teresa's: perhaps once a week, you may consider putting CNN on, instead of Fox News. :) read more

What happened to Teresa's? A once great place to grab a pie or Sub....last visit the pizza was floppy and undercooked (even after ordering "well done/cook extra), and their Chix parm, was like eating rubber (1 bite, then tossed to the wildlife, who wanted no part of it either). Where is the old man!?!?! Sorry Teresa's, you're off the list. read more

Atmosphere is okay to sit in but for take out this place is horrible. I am local and loved this pizza place when it was dough boys but after the transition into Teresa's the service went way downhill. Always crowded, angry people, they forget and loose orders what seems to be quite a lot. Only person who seems to ever be working is the older gentleman in the front with the pizza. If you want a good pizza, the plaza down the street has Mt. Bethel pizza and the service is 10x better! read more

Teresa's was formerly Doughboys; however, after Doughboys burned down (twice!) when the owners ultimately decided to rebuild, they changed the name. The menu is basically the same as it was when it was Doughboys but now with a few more dinner additions. Our family favorites are their ham/cappicola subs on crispy crusted bread but soft inside, sausage sandwiches, their pierogies, cheesesteaks and of course their pizza. The day after Christmas, Mom was pretty tired after having made a huge dinner the night before, so for this 2nd night of family gatherings, we made one huge order to Teresa's. We ordered the following: 2 pizzas, 1 sausage sandwich (me), 3 chicken parm sandwiches, 2 veal parm sandwiches, 1 eggplant parm sandwich, 3 orders of mozz sticks, 3 orders of pierogies, 1 order of fries and I believe 1 order of chicken fingers and fries. Dad and the younger brother drove to pick it up and returned shortly. They were so excited to have our business, they threw in a free cake. However, the reason they lose a star is because none of the sandwiches were labeled. So someone accidentally got the chicken parm mixed up with what they thought was the veal parm and a little chaos ensued. Good thing I ordered sausage, eh? At the end of the night, we still had about one whole pie left over but it tastes just as good warmed up the next day for lunch/dinner. Hopefully Teresa's won't fall under the curse of the old Doughboy's and succumb to some sort of fire. I want it to last because the food here is delicious and priced well. *** And as always, photos to follow. My brother kept asking me why I was taking photos of local places that we go to all the time. He just didn't get it. read more

Teresa's - a sign in front of a house - Pizza Near Me - Mount Bethel, Pennsylvania

See all

Got take out from here while visiting my friend. so I can't say too much about the establishment. The pizza was ok, nothing too exciting. It was a bit greasier than I've had but the sauce was ok. They didn't skimp on the sausage like some pizza places do which was good. My friends girlfriend got the gnocchi soren/pavora pasta and salad which looked pretty good as the salad was fresh too. The letdown here were the buffalo wings we got. They weren't spicy, nor were they saucy. They were edible... but definitely not the best wings, these were like C grade. Not worth the almost $10 per 12 price. So maybe some of their other offerings are better but this just seemed kinda like your everyday pizza spot with not so good buffalo wings. read more

Teresa's - Half sausage pie - Pizza Near Me - Mount Bethel, Pennsylvania

See all

Being from New York we had to stop at the abstract company down the block for a closing on our new properties. We got there early and we stopped at this pizzeria and found the food totally amazing (as we are Italian). Between the pizza and the other food we were totally caught off guard as we figured it was going to taste like cardboard yet we ate it all ..So ,if you're in the area and you're from out of state pull into the parking lot and treat yourself to a nice pleasant tasty atmosphere..I neglected to mention it is five minutes off route 80 right before heading into the Delaware water gap read more

New in town..love brick oven pizza. Went in made order. Pizza was made in regular oven not brick wtf..sign says brick oven pizza...old man behind the counter was getting in everyone's way just standing there..getn in the way of the cute blonde...pizza came out was over 20 bucks. Took it home was ok but nothing to brag about. Coming from jersey I guess I was hoping for atleast good pizza..one and done. Oh I got half pepperoni.. the pepperoni slices were small..like I said one and done read more

Great local pizzeria. We eat here almost every Sunday. Our go to order is the Sautéed spicy calamari.....excellent. The staff is always very accommodating and friendly. Prices are very reasonable. We would definitely recommend Teresa's for a tasty casual meal. read more

The wait to pick up a phoned in order was 45 minutes...after getting there 25 minutes after calling as they said. Line was out the door so you sit there sweating for 20 of the 45 minutes until you could get into the air conditioning. There weren't even many people there, just horrible horrible service. To top it off, I get home and open the pizza and it was not the pizza I had ordered...The food is nowhere near as good as almost any other pizza. The service is miserable and very unfriendly. Absolutely ridiculous experience. Have been going here for years but this was the straw that broke the camel's back. Teresa's has always been the "oh i want pizza but I don't want to drive the extra 10 minutes to a different pizza place" type of night. But seriously, drive that extra 10 minutes. read more

We are so lucky to have such great New York pizza in our little country town. Thats because the owners are really Italian from Naples , the birth place of pizza! read more

The best pizza around! & sausage rolls! Been coming here since I was 14 I am now 44 years old!!

I have never in my life experienced something this vulgar, so people need to know about this. I walked in here on a Sunday afternoon to order a pizza, and the owner I believe, was standing at the counter, next to the where the pizza is prepared, CLIPPING HIS FINGERNAILS. He did not even notice I was standing there trying to pick up my pizza, and he continued to do this for at least two minutes while I was right there. I was so disgusted I couldn't even eat the pizza after leaving there. I will NEVER go back, and I don't recommend anyone going here for anything, if they blatantly do that in the open, who knows what they do behind closed doors in there. read more

Should have moved here 55 years ago! Superb food, service, price. Highly recommend their pizza pies. What a find! read more

See all

My first experience at Teresa's, not good, very disappointed with the pizza itself. Brick oven should have completely cooked crusty dough. Ours was chewy and totally tasted like raw flower. It really had no flavor you're looking for as a pizza pie. Really wanted to give this place a chance. It will have to wait until we're ready for a second chance. Calamari was frozen rings and only so so. read more

When they get the order correct the food is good. But as of recently they can't seem to get orders correct. When they read the ticket back to you while ringing you up it is correct so they need to retrain the kitchen staff read more

Placed a take out order. Was told 35-40 mins to pick up. When arrived 35 minutes later was told the order was not even started yet and it would be another 40 minutes. I told them to just cancel the order. Before I could even say a word, the Girl working behind the counter asked me not to yell at her because she was getting yelled at all night. I asked to see a manager and was told they were not available. I went elsewhere. Sent a message via Facebook and Email via website and was told that the person who monitors the accounts cannot do anything but give the feedback to the owner but there would be no return call or reply. Just think this is all around bad service. read more

The food is great but the prices on the web menu are not right. When I order and look at the prices it should be the same when I pick up the food! read more

I have been her twice. Today and once a year ago. The food was delicious both times and the staff was very friendly. Tonight I had the Shrimp Russo and my wife had Chicken Pavarotti. We were very satisfied. We are from Northern New Jersey and have been to many great Italian restaurants. Theresa's is on par with some of the best in NJ. read more

One of many pizza places, one of the few I am sure not to revisit. Pizza was ok, typical NY style pizza, nothing special, might as well not have had staff there. Asked for a fork and had it thrown on the table, I guess I should be thankful I didnt get it thrown at my head. Ignored just enough, to make you want to walk out. Went there because of all the good reviews, makes me think to revisit my trust issues. I usually dont review, but this a well deserved 1 star. read more

Best pizza in the area...hands down! The dinners are delicious too. "Crabby Sal" is part of the ambiance! Love it.

Not bad for out of NY pizza. Attentive wait staff. Fast service. Grandma's pizza was good but cheese was too clumpy & can off with one bite. The Sicilian was too doughy & some of it felt like it was undercooked. Garlic rolls were right on & their side marinara sauce was delicious. Cheesesteak sandwich too thinly sliced, but flavoring was on point. All in all would stop by here again. read more

Price hike most expensive pizza more than New York. $20 for a sicilian pie outrageous