After four years as a resident of Liberty Mill, I can honestly say I am relieved to have moved out.
When I first moved into the community, it was a pleasant place to live. Unfortunately, over the last few years, the atmosphere changed dramatically. Instead of feeling like residents were valued, interactions with management became increasingly hostile, and what should have been routine concerns often turned into unnecessary conflicts.
One of the most concerning issues was maintenance entering my apartment without following my clearly stated access instructions. Every maintenance request instructed staff to knock or call before entering and to wait for a response. Those instructions were repeatedly ignored. On one occasion, maintenance entered my apartment while I was in the shower. Instead of addressing my complaint and reinforcing proper procedures with the maintenance staff, the leasing office later deleted my maintenance requests from the resident portal, removing the documented access instructions I had submitted. I followed up with management with no response to the missing request. To this day, I find that extremely concerning.
The lack of transparency continued after I moved out. I applied to become an authorized resident in another apartment within the same community and was denied. Initially, I was told it was due to an alleged pet policy violations. When I requested documentation, Arianna admitted in writing that no lease violations or written notices had ever been issued during my four-year tenancy.
The explanation then changed to an alleged video received during the week of my move-out that supposedly showed my ESA dog off leash. I was never notified of this during my tenancy, never given an opportunity to review the footage, and never given an opportunity to respond. The original denial referenced "instances" of violations, implying a documented history, yet management later acknowledged there were no official records or violation notices. As someone who consistently paid rent on time and maintained my lease for four years, it was disappointing to be denied based on an informal allegation that I had no chance to address.
The issues didn't stop there. After management learned I was in a relationship with another resident, my boyfriend received a lease violation alleging that I was living in his apartment without authorization. When he requested evidence supporting that allegation, none was provided. Shortly afterward, I received a parking notice claiming my vehicle was parked on the property without authorization. It felt as though assumptions were being made without verification, and complaints were being acted upon without supporting evidence.
Another concern involved communications from Arianna indicating that apartments would be entered to look for evidence of smoking without the advance notice required under the lease except in emergencies. That, combined with my own experience of maintenance entering without following my access instructions, left me with serious concerns about respect for residents' privacy.
Ultimately, my boyfriend felt compelled to file complaints with Allegiant-Carter's corporate office and the appropriate state agencies regarding these issues.
I understand that apartment communities have rules, and I fully support reasonable enforcement of those rules. What I do not support is inconsistent enforcement, lack of transparency, acting on unverified allegations, and failing to provide residents with notice or an opportunity to respond before decisions that affect their housing are made.
I hope Liberty Mill takes resident concerns more seriously in the future and focuses on rebuilding trust through professionalism, accountability, and transparency. Based on my experience, I cannot recommend this community but it seems as though they are going the right direction with Arianna no longer there. read more