We ordered online, which I would say was the best online ordering experience I've ever had. The…read moredetail that went into their website, you can edit everything so well and customize your order down to a T! They thought of everything. They are very busy, so pick up was like an hour and 20 after we replaced and then we still had to wait 20 minutes when we got there. But it was very much worth it and I would just plan for the wait. The French fries were bomb. Good fries, cooked well, great toppings and well distributed so you didn't get a bunch of naked fries. The cheese was good, not some crappy cheese sauce. It was like shredded. The pizza was delicious. It was a thicker crust and it had great flavor. Even the smaller pizzas you could split in 2 so you can try 2 different specialty pizzas. We got half Romeo (but switched out the sauce for white olive oil sauce) and half right primo pepperoni. The Primo was the bomb. The red sauce was so good, pepperoni cups were plentiful. The Romeo was different since it was a seasonal, had pistachios on it so had to try it. I thought it was good but didn't compare to the Primo. Also ordered garlic parm boneless wings that would be a problem if we lived here. The tiramisu was good, but I'm a connoisseur so I'm a little more picky. I thought it needed more espresso flavor like a wet layer at the bottom. I would 100% come back here. Great take out to go back to the Airbnb!

Best pizza I have ever had..and I have had a lot of pizza! If you are in the area this is…read moredefinitely a must eat!

My wife broke her ankle so it was my turn to cook. I…read morehaven't had this pizza in a while. All of my kids worked here (first jobs). I've always loved the pizza there. Today was no disappointment!!! They knocked it out of the park!!!!! Thanks!!!!

We found this pizza joint on Yelp. We are visiting the area from Michigan. The pizza was so…read moredelicious and well worth the 8 miles to pick it up. The cheese is amazing and the sauce is great. Definitely will be back on the next trip.

Really great pizza! Made exactly as we requested. The ingredients were super fresh. Very nice…read moreperson took our order we called in and picked up, super friendly. Give them a try!

On our trip the first place we stopped was The Colorful Cookery. We had one slice to see if we all…read morewould like it. Definitely order a whole pizza! We also had a side salad that was delicious. The service was quick and the crust on the pizza was delicious.

The food is amazing! I'm very proud of this business. The service is very good, the workers are…read morekind. Overall the place is amazing, and I highly recommend.

Good little mom and pop pizza joint. Never a super long wait to get your food and it's always good…read more Only complaint is that sometimes they don't bake the pizza as long as I would like and it's very soft and flexible which makes it hard to eat. Just ask for longer bake and it will come out slightly crispy. Do wish it had indoor seating but takeout only works too.

This place is so good! It's located in the heart of Kidron. Just make sure you call the right…read morelocation because they have two. This review is based only in the Kidron location. My go to see the Jo-Jo's and they are so delicious. Pizza and sandwiches are in great quality! I promise you'll never be disappointed!!

It's deja vu all over again! Whitmer's is pretty good pizza! And decent wings! And, I feel so bad…read morefor them, I think I'll go buy them a clock - they must not be able to afford one... EVERY TIME WE ORDER, but especially delivery, our food is 20-30 minutes later than quoted. Now, mind you, I don't mind waiting for the correct time. But I REALLY mind being told 45 minutes, calling the store after 55 minutes and being told "I'm pretty sure the driver just left so it should be within 10 minutes." A) Pretty Sure? B) ITS NOT OKAY THAT YOURE ALREADY LATE. An apology would go a long way... If this didn't happen EVERY TIME! Thing is, it's not any better if you pick-up - just plan on stopping 30min later than quoted and you'll be fine. So, I'm going to buy Whitmer's a clock. I'll pay for it with the money I save on tips from poor service and on going to Subway instead. But remember - the food is actually pretty good.

The pizza is always good, I've been going here since a child with my family…read more Recently though I've been hearing a few things about the restaurant, like the manager not washing her hands before preparing food, coughing on food, and even picking at her face and continuing to prepare the food. Anytime I've ever been in the pizza place it's been clean and tidy but I will say that occasionally the person taking your order isn't the friendliest, but that just been a few times. I'd definitely say go here if your looking for good pizza, but watch who's preparing your food if the rumors are true.

I have long wanted to go to a Fox's, since I've had VW Foxes. I need to park one in front of their…read moresign for a photo op someday. Not this time- we just had it delivered- but I'm glad I tried it. We were staying in Amish country, and things close early on Saturday (and are often closed Sunday.) We had a late lunch so needed a late dinner, and didn't want to head back out. Thankfully, a couple of pizza places in Millersburg deliver out into the wilds. We just had a large pepperoni, thin crust, well done. Phone service was great, and delivery was on time with a hot pie, right to our room. The pizza wasn't gourmet, but it was a solid simple pizza: good crust, cooked just right, good cheese, good sauce with a little kick, good toppings. Price was reasonable considering the situation. We had some left for the morning. I will definitely be back to a Fox's somewhere, for pizza and pix.

We ordered a pizza to go by phone. The employee answering was polite & helpful. This is the second…read moretime we've ordered from this location. Our medium deluxe pizza was ready when we arrived. It was delicious both times we've ordered. We would definitely eat here again.

One of the best buffets we have ever been to. Got there when the buffet first started so…read moreeverything was fresh hot and delicious. They kept things filled in pretty well for the number of people eating. Our server could not have been nicer and worked very hard. We will come again for sure when we are in town!

This pizza is so good. I went back two days in a row. Definitely recommend trying it outread more

Made a quick stop here to share a small old world style pizza. It was baked in a brick oven, with…read morefresh ingredients including basil and tasted great! They have appetizers and salads we did not try but everything within sight also looked fresh and good. If you like brick oven pizza, give them a try, very good pizza!

I grew up on Coccia but I think I also bought my last pie from them. How is it even food safe to…read morehave pizzas stacked on tables baked hours ago? No instructions, either. The woman in front of me said that she heard that the dining room was going to reopen. The woman behind the register complained loudly that no one wants to work anymore. Not sure how all of the other restaurants in Wooster manage it, but they seem to...

The worst pizza I ever had was here .I do not like to smell garlic when I eat pizza .You might as…read morewell call it garlic pizza because it is over powered with garlic.I eat pizza that has garlic in it but this stuff knocks you over with the smell of garlic. I can not enjoy anything that reeks of garlic that much .

To start, you could cook chicken up until you close. I called tonight at 8 and they were already…read morecleaning the fryers and they don't close till 9. Sounds like the night crew doesn't care about serving customers, just getting out for Saturday night! This place keeps going downhill.

We traveled from out of town for a swim meet at Wooster College, and I needed to feed 53 swimmers…read morebefore we returned home. Austin helped me get our order ready. They made 53 pizzas and delivered them to our bus driver. The swimmers loved the pizza and gave me credit, but it should go to Gionino's. "This pizza is banger!" Everything was excellent, from the pizza to the service. There wasn't a single mistake.