Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Install the Yelp app

    It's easier on the Yelp app

    The Colorful Cookery

    5.0 (25 reviews)
    Pizza

    Add Review

    Call

    Directions

    The Colorful Cookery Pizza Restaurant Photos

    The Colorful Cookery - Look for the sign on Main St in Berlin Ohio - Pizza Near Me - Berlin , Ohio
    The Colorful Cookery - Pizza by the slice, anyone?! - Pizza Near Me - Berlin , Ohio
    The Colorful Cookery - From the side of Berlin's oldest building built in 1817 this sign gives you the info you need - Pizza Near Me - Berlin , Ohio

    +42

    The Colorful Cookery - The entrance is in the rear of Berlin's oldest building built in 1817 - Pizza Near Me - Berlin , Ohio

    THE COLORFUL COOKERY ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Inside

    Inside

    2 Photos

    Outside

    Outside

    8 Photos

      You might also consider

      Sponsored

      Dairy Queen Grill & Chill

      $

      3.5 (6 reviews)

      Zed J. said: Food is always great and relatively quick every time I've been, of… read more

      Taco Bell

      $

      2.3 (11 reviews)

      Tory R. said: I love Taco Bell! Always have, always will! For quick, cheap Mexican… read more

      More like The Colorful Cookery

      Add video

      Recommended Reviews - The Colorful Cookery

      Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

      Start your review...

      Yelp app icon
      Browse more easily on the app
      Review Feed Illustration

      Reviews With Photos

      Gluten-free cheese bread

      Gluten free pizza was good , gluten-free cheese bread was OK. Plenty of cheese toppings were good. We also ordered a regular four topping pizza it was good.

      Entrance
      Sharon H.

      You have to be looking for this place to find it! It does not sit on the main drag but rather sits in a walkway between buildings. There is signage on sidewalk that will direct folks to the door. It is basically a counter to place your order and a drink fridge. There are 2 tables right outside the door. The menu consists of mainly pizza with specialty pizzas as well as lots of toppings to design your own. We had a specialty pizza that was basically a deluxe. It was delicious with lots of toppings. Nice airy crust with flavorful sauce. Great place to grab something other than Amish style food.

      Pizza
      Mariana A.

      Amazing pizza! Very nice small place. Great service! Cannolis were sooooooo good!!!!! 100% recommended!

      Pepperoni pizza
      Bridget B.

      All I can say is that this pizza is delicious. I come up once a year to Amish country to shop and stay. I have gotten their pizza each time, and it has been delicious every time. Lots of great flavor, and I definitely recommend picking up a pizza from here if you're in the area. I make it a point. There is no dine in, but we always take it back to wherever we are staying and have it for dinner. I'm so happy I stumbled upon this little spot.

      This is the bubble waffle with peanut butter and chocolate. It was amazing. The warm waffle with ice cream was a perfect blend.
      Nicholas N.

      Wonderful friendly service by Heather! We got the Stromboli and The House. Amazing flavors. The Stromboli was my wife's favorite. The House is spicy. Pizza by the slice for lunch or order a pie. The bubble waffle was amazing! This is definitely going to be our favorite treat this summer.

      Look for the sign on Main St in Berlin Ohio
      Stephanie H.

      Thanks to The Shopper paper that gets delivered every Friday in Holmes County Ohio, I discovered The Colorful Cookery! There is a Facebook page with offers. Today's and tomorrow's offer includes the house specialty pizza 10" for $2 off! She has pizza by the slice, and bubble waffles with ice cream and many toppings! She also makes Stromboli! Her gourmet pizza delighted my hubby and I earlier tonight! The house specialty pizza has some heat but the favorite part for my 73 year old hubby was the sauce which is a mixture of sriracha and ranch dressing. We can't wait to get more! You can see photos of her menu on Google and some photos of her foods! She makes it easy to grab something and keep waking while you eat! This tiny shop is in the rear of Berlin's oldest building built in 1817!! It feels great to support local businesses and I can't wait to see this busines

      Phenomenal pepperoni pizza via delivery.
      Tammy E.

      Huge shout out to your establishment!!!! We ordered delivery to our campground, less than an hour prior to closing (sorry). Ordered a pepperoni pizza; kids devoured it! The cheese was amazing, the sauce was ample but not over powering. Daughter had the S'mores Bubble waffle, supper yummy and I believe the pic speaks for itself. Ordered delivered directly to our camper, arrived even a bit early. Next time we camp at Scenic Hills, you will be getting another order! Thank you and Happy Easter.

      Peanut butter!!
      Ashley S.

      We stopped here in hope for some pizza but sadly they were ill outs Dough. I couldn't leave empty handed so I did get a waffle. It was delicious. I hope to come back someday to try the pizza.

      Peanut butter chocolate bubble waffle.
      Miles M.

      Love this place!! The servers were very friendly and full of energy. The sausage and jalapeño pizza was delicious and a fantastic price. We also got three different bubble waffles ( breakfast club, peanut butter chocolate, and berries) all were delicious and great sizes. 100/10 would come back.

      The House pizza

      See all

      Photo of Gina D.
      Gina D.
      Elite 26
      49
      137
      370

      1 year ago

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Tracee P.
      Tracee P.
      Elite 26
      76
      74
      225

      2 years ago

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Keith H.
      Keith H.
      Elite 26All-Star
      141
      102
      801

      2 years ago

      Helpful 1
      Thanks 0
      Love this 1
      Oh no 0
      Photo of A V.
      A V.
      0
      12
      11

      1 year ago

      Helpful 1
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Sharon H.
      Sharon H.
      Elite 26
      81
      307
      250

      3 years ago

      Helpful 2
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Mariana A.
      Mariana A.
      205
      24
      27

      2 years ago

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
      Photo of D L.
      D L.
      0
      6
      3

      2 years ago

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Bridget B.
      Bridget B.
      Elite 24
      9
      160
      816

      3 years ago

      Helpful 3
      Thanks 0
      Love this 2
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Abigail H.
      Abigail H.
      0
      28
      6

      2 years ago

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Nicholas N.
      Nicholas N.
      0
      14
      17

      5 years ago

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 1
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Stephanie H.
      Stephanie H.
      Elite 18
      238
      76
      550

      6 years ago

      Helpful 1
      Thanks 0
      Love this 2
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Tammy E.
      Tammy E.
      26
      104
      114

      4 years ago

      Helpful 1
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Ashley S.
      Ashley S.
      13
      178
      496

      5 years ago

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Miles M.
      Miles M.
      3
      12
      18

      5 years ago

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Julie W.
      Julie W.
      0
      2
      0

      2 years ago

      Great addition to Berlin Ohio. The hand tossed crust is delicious and you must get a cannoli or two!

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 1
      Photo of Victoria M.
      Victoria M.
      0
      6
      0

      3 years ago

      This small shop is very good. The staff was so nice! The pizza was very good. It was fresh and fast.

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Erin W.
      Erin W.
      0
      2
      2

      4 years ago

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Jodi L.
      Jodi L.
      Elite 22
      117
      154
      25

      5 years ago

      Helpful 1
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Jefferson H.
      Jefferson H.
      0
      3
      0

      5 years ago

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 1
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Stacey H.
      Stacey H.
      107
      28
      1

      5 years ago

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 1
      Photo of Yolanda E.
      Yolanda E.
      0
      20
      10

      5 years ago

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Lia G.
      Lia G.
      0
      9
      0

      5 years ago

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Eric A.
      Eric A.
      0
      4
      0

      4 years ago

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Dee M.
      Dee M.
      0
      1
      0

      4 years ago

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0
      Photo of Dennis C.
      Dennis C.
      0
      2
      0

      6 years ago

      Helpful 0
      Thanks 0
      Love this 0
      Oh no 0

      More info about The Colorful Cookery

      • 4829 E Main St

        Berlin , OH 44610

        Directions

      • (330) 641-3799

        Call Now

      • Hours

        What time does The Colorful Cookery open?

        The Colorful Cookery opens at 11:00 AM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.

        What time does The Colorful Cookery close?

        The Colorful Cookery is closed on Monday and Sunday.The Colorful Cookery closes at 6:00 PM on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday.The Colorful Cookery closes at 7:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.

        Mon, Sun ClosedTue-Thu 11:00 AM - 6:00 PMFri-Sat 11:00 AM - 7:00 PM

      • Payment methods

        Does The Colorful Cookery take credit cards?

        Yes, The Colorful Cookery takes credit cards.

      • Food & Alcohol

        Does The Colorful Cookery serve alcohol?

        Yes, The Colorful Cookery serves alcohol.

      • Outdoor Amenities

        Does The Colorful Cookery have outdoor seating?

        Yes, The Colorful Cookery has outdoor seating options.

        Does The Colorful Cookery have parking?

        Yes, The Colorful Cookery has parking options.

      • Other Amenities

        Does The Colorful Cookery have free WiFi?

        Yes, The Colorful Cookery has free WiFi.

      Ask the Community - The Colorful Cookery

      Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

      Table Rock Pizza - Nashville Hot wings

      Table Rock Pizza

      4.5(22 reviews)
      0.1 mi

      This pizza is so good. I went back two days in a row. Definitely recommend trying it outread more

      Made a quick stop here to share a small old world style pizza. It was baked in a brick oven, with…read morefresh ingredients including basil and tasted great! They have appetizers and salads we did not try but everything within sight also looked fresh and good. If you like brick oven pizza, give them a try, very good pizza!

      Photos
      Table Rock Pizza - Order at the counter.

      Order at the counter.

      Table Rock Pizza - Left half Buffalo Chicken. Right half Americano.

      Left half Buffalo Chicken. Right half Americano.

      Table Rock Pizza

      See all

      Park Street Pizza - Plant based chicken wings

      Park Street Pizza

      4.8(217 reviews)
      8.9 mi
      •$$

      We ordered online, which I would say was the best online ordering experience I've ever had. The…read moredetail that went into their website, you can edit everything so well and customize your order down to a T! They thought of everything. They are very busy, so pick up was like an hour and 20 after we replaced and then we still had to wait 20 minutes when we got there. But it was very much worth it and I would just plan for the wait. The French fries were bomb. Good fries, cooked well, great toppings and well distributed so you didn't get a bunch of naked fries. The cheese was good, not some crappy cheese sauce. It was like shredded. The pizza was delicious. It was a thicker crust and it had great flavor. Even the smaller pizzas you could split in 2 so you can try 2 different specialty pizzas. We got half Romeo (but switched out the sauce for white olive oil sauce) and half right primo pepperoni. The Primo was the bomb. The red sauce was so good, pepperoni cups were plentiful. The Romeo was different since it was a seasonal, had pistachios on it so had to try it. I thought it was good but didn't compare to the Primo. Also ordered garlic parm boneless wings that would be a problem if we lived here. The tiramisu was good, but I'm a connoisseur so I'm a little more picky. I thought it needed more espresso flavor like a wet layer at the bottom. I would 100% come back here. Great take out to go back to the Airbnb!

      Best pizza I have ever had..and I have had a lot of pizza! If you are in the area this is…read moredefinitely a must eat!

      Photos
      Park Street Pizza
      Park Street Pizza - Pesto pizza

      Pesto pizza

      Park Street Pizza

      See all

      Berlin East of Chicago Pizza - Medium Deluxe Pan pizza

      Berlin East of Chicago Pizza

      3.2(36 reviews)
      0.2 mi
      •$$

      We stopped on our way through town after a day of shopping on our way to our Airbnb. We ordered…read morechef salads, a pizza with pepperoni and sausage and an order of cheesy bread. Everything was a 10 out of 10 service was super. Clerk was friendly. Would highly recommend this place. We ordered it for takeout.

      We ordered a pizza to go by phone. The employee answering was polite & helpful. This is the second…read moretime we've ordered from this location. Our medium deluxe pizza was ready when we arrived. It was delicious both times we've ordered. We would definitely eat here again.

      Photos
      Berlin East of Chicago Pizza - Pizza bar

      Pizza bar

      Berlin East of Chicago Pizza - Dessert

      Dessert

      Berlin East of Chicago Pizza - Salad bar, delicious wings and pizza

      See all

      Salad bar, delicious wings and pizza

      The Wood Fired Pizza Company - BS Salad, flying pig pizza

      The Wood Fired Pizza Company

      5.0(7 reviews)
      51.2 mi

      Wood Fired Pizza Company is a fantastic place to grab lunch if you're lucky enough to be close by…read moreto where their food truck happens to be on a given day. Follow them on Facebook so you know where they will be setting up next! I was lucky enough to have them show up near where I work and decided to give them a try. I had the buffalo chicken pizza and it was beyond amazing. It's fun to watch them make it from start to finish before putting it into "Bella", their mobile wood-fired oven. The staff are nice and happy to answer any questions about the menu. Prices are quite fair for what you get, with pizzas at $10 (and each one is enough for a big lunch for one or a reasonable-size lunch for two), breadsticks with marinara at $8, and cannolis for $3. With food trucks, communication with potential customers is essential, and they do a spectacular job of keeping in touch via social media about where they will be and when they sell out so you aren't left hanging. This is an underappreciated quality, so I want to make sure I am recognizing them for their skill in this where many other mobile vendors fall short. If they are close to you, you absolutely must try them, no excuse not to! Overall: 5.0 stars ----- Pros: - Amazing pizzas, and very cool unique options for them! - Great value for your money. - Good service. - EXCELLENT communication via social media. Cons: - None, really. I wish they came to Wheeling more, though I totally get that they have to go where they know they are most likely to sell out. Good for them for their success!

      We visited the waterfront hall location in Wheeling for lunch. Fast service and absolutely amazing…read morefood! Highly recommend the Bianco and flying pig pizzas! The building is absolutely adorable, full of history and beautifully decorated.

      Photos
      The Wood Fired Pizza Company - Cheese breadsticks

      Cheese breadsticks

      The Wood Fired Pizza Company - Margherita pizza

      Margherita pizza

      The Wood Fired Pizza Company - Menu

      See all

      Menu

      Main Street Pizza & Subs - '80s ball

      Main Street Pizza & Subs

      4.8(10 reviews)
      8.2 mi

      My wife broke her ankle so it was my turn to cook. I…read morehaven't had this pizza in a while. All of my kids worked here (first jobs). I've always loved the pizza there. Today was no disappointment!!! They knocked it out of the park!!!!! Thanks!!!!

      We found this pizza joint on Yelp. We are visiting the area from Michigan. The pizza was so…read moredelicious and well worth the 8 miles to pick it up. The cheese is amazing and the sauce is great. Definitely will be back on the next trip.

      Photos
      Main Street Pizza & Subs - Was in an office and had to have this picture

      Was in an office and had to have this picture

      Main Street Pizza & Subs - Hamburger, bacon , and green olives.

      Hamburger, bacon , and green olives.

      Main Street Pizza & Subs - Was in an office and they gave me the sticker having too much fun

      See all

      Was in an office and they gave me the sticker having too much fun

      Heini's Cheese Chalet - Cheese samples

      Heini's Cheese Chalet

      4.5(91 reviews)
      1.1 mi
      •$$

      Cheese, cheese and more cheese! One side of the place is alllllll the cheese. The other is the…read moregift shop. There are so many varieties of cheese available. Everything like traditional cheddar and swiss to more unique options like veggie, and buffalo wing. Most of the cheese had samples. It was a perfect way to get a sense of the differences between some of the varieties (standard vs smoked vs aged for example). Most cheese could be purchased in blocks, slices and cubes. They also had some beef stick options, dips and cheese fudge. I had never heard of cheese fudge before so was very intrigued. It had a different texture and flavor than traditional fudge but was definitely worth trying. They also have traditional fudge on the other side of the store. There were workers behind the counter actively packing cheese and willing to answer any questions you might have. Much like other tourist attractions, you have to walk through the gift shop to get to the cash registers. The line was kind of long, but it moved fairly quickly. This was a great stop with a lot of tasty products. Definitely recommend a visit!

      Stopping at Heini's is an Amish country tradition. What was always great about this place, was…read moretheir samples. You could try all the cheeses and take home your favorites! COVID guidelines took that away, but I'm happy to report the samples have returned Locally made from fresh ingredients, you will find some of the best tasting cheeses here. Plenty of other interesting items as well, like nuts, candies both new and classic and many other things for the eager tourist.

      Photos
      Heini's Cheese Chalet
      Heini's Cheese Chalet - Cheese making

      Cheese making

      Heini's Cheese Chalet

      See all

      Olde House Cookery

      Olde House Cookery

      5.0(1 review)
      0.0 mi

      Enjoyed their gluten free pizza! Service was quick and people were super kind. A hidden gem just…read moreoff the main strip! Enjoyed the outside seating area.

      Charm Pizza - To go soft serve flavors

      Charm Pizza

      5.0(1 review)
      3.9 mi

      The pizza is fresh and hot. Can order by the slice or whole pizzas, they have specialty pizzas as…read morewell as buffet certain nights of the week. Staff is very friendly. Restaurant is clean. They all have soft serve ice cream and treats. They offer take home quarts and larger of soft serve flavors. They also offer sandwiches, wraps, and salads. Many locals eat here.

      Photos
      Charm Pizza - Food menu

      See all

      Food menu

      McKelvey's Pub - BBQ Chicken Pizza

      McKelvey's Pub

      4.0(13 reviews)
      6.5 mi
      •$

      No trip to Amish country is complete without a stop at one of the friendliest pubs featuring the…read moreabsolute best bar pizza you've ever had!

      We came here two nights in a row. First night just for drinks, but everyone's pizza around us…read morelooked good so we came back! Have their Supreme Pizza! So much great flavor! I love a thinner crust, so theirs was perfect for me. Staff was very friendly and everything was very clean! Fun atmosphere

      Photos
      McKelvey's Pub - Receipt with remarks and no tip

      Receipt with remarks and no tip

      McKelvey's Pub
      McKelvey's Pub - Inside bar

      See all

      Inside bar

      Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

      Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

      1 review that is not currently recommended

      Photo of Melanie R.
      Melanie R.
      0
      6
      0

      3 years ago

      The Colorful Cookery - pizza - Updated May 2026

      Loading...
      Best of Berlin

      Things to do in Berlin

      People found The Colorful Cookery by searching for…

      Restaurants in Berlin, OH

      Breakfast & Brunch in Berlin, OH

      Breakfast in Berlin, OH

      Amish Buffet in Berlin, OH

      Lunch in Berlin, OH

      Dinner in Berlin, OH

      Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt in Berlin, OH

      Barbeque in Berlin, OH

      Pizza Delivery in Berlin, OH

      Vegan in Berlin, OH

      Romantic Restaurant in Berlin, OH

      Allergy Friendly Restaurants in Berlin, OH

      Ice Cream in Berlin, OH

      Stromboli Pizzeria in Berlin, OH

      Takeout in Berlin, OH

      Vegetarian Food in Berlin, OH

      Family Restaurant in Berlin, OH

      Chicken Dinner in Berlin, OH

      Salad in Berlin, OH

      Chicken and Waffles in Berlin, OH

      Heated Outdoor Seating in Berlin, OH

      Take and Bake Pizza in Berlin, OH

      Salads and Sandwiches in Berlin, OH

      Breakfast & Brunch Outdoor Seating in Berlin, OH

      Browse Nearby

      BEST of Berlin , Ohio Parking near The Colorful Cookery

      BEST of Berlin , Ohio Restaurants near The Colorful Cookery

      BEST of Berlin , Ohio Cocktail Bars near The Colorful Cookery

      BEST of Berlin , Ohio Coffee near The Colorful Cookery

      BEST of Berlin , Ohio Breakfast near The Colorful Cookery

      BEST of Berlin , Ohio Desserts near The Colorful Cookery

      BEST of Berlin , Ohio Things to Do near The Colorful Cookery

      BEST of Berlin , Ohio Dinner near The Colorful Cookery

      BEST of Berlin , Ohio Shopping near The Colorful Cookery

      BEST of Berlin , Ohio Thrift Stores near The Colorful Cookery

      Browse Brands

      Brands by name

      Browse Articles

      Articles by date

      People who viewed The Colorful Cookery also viewed

      Photo of Park Street Pizza

      Park Street Pizza

      217 reviews

      $$

      Photo of Main Street Pizza & Subs

      Main Street Pizza & Subs

      10 reviews

      Photo of Amici's Pizza

      Amici's Pizza

      2 reviews

      Kraus Pizza Strasburg

      11 reviews

      Jesana's Pizzeria

      2 reviews

      Johnny O's

      2 reviews

      Photo of Boone Creek Wood Fired Pizza

      Boone Creek Wood Fired Pizza

      1 review

      Photo of Uncle Primo's

      Uncle Primo's

      102 reviews

      $$

      Photo of Canal Street Diner

      Canal Street Diner

      79 reviews

      $

      Photo of Pine Tree Barn Restaurant

      Pine Tree Barn Restaurant

      93 reviews

      $$

      Loading...
      Loading...