ONE OF THE WORST PIZZA PLACES IN BETHLEHEM My boyfriend and I decided to try this pizza joint since people would always talk about how great it is. Our usual go to is Oliverios. I made an order around 530 and was told food will get to me in about 45 mins so I was okay great. I ordered 5 hot buffalo wings, 5 honey buffalo wings and a medium margherita pizza. The food came in about 40 mins and I was super excited to try it. I opened the pizza box and it looked really good. As I started to take the slices out from the box to plate. All of the topping just slid right off. The pizza was good but cold. I was expecting a nice hot pizza. We live right next to hotel Bethlehem so it's not like they had to travel far. I opened up the boxes for the buffalo wings and were given 2 flaccid pieces of celery in the two boxes. The wings were also cold. The wings were described as "jumbo" wings but when we actually saw them. They were not jumbo at all and were a pretty sad excuse of a buffalo wing. At this point in time, we have both become extremely frustrated and decided to call them and let them know. The guy who was on the phone was extremely rude and said that the pizza was delivered in 37 mins and it shouldn't be cold. NEWSFLASH IF the food was good and hot we would not have called and wasted our and their time. But that wasn't the case. His excuse was "that we were not the only delivery that they had to make today". My boyfriend then told them so you have a busy weekend and your quality isn't up to par. He requested for a refund since we didn't pay for cold food. The guy on the phone rejected our request and offered to make a new order right there and then or comp us for the next time we order from there. We declined the offer because if the food sucked the first time around what would make us get it the second time. My boyfriend demanded his money back and tried talking to the guy. The guy ended up hanging up. This is the one and only time we will ever order from there. If you want good and hot pizza that does delivery please go elsewhere. read more

Uuuum yum!!! First time ordering from Lehigh Pizza and I was happy with the food. It was cold when it arrived but that was more Grubhub than Lehigh Pizza. Even re-heated it was fabulous. The hot wings were spicy, flavorful, and tasty! We got a regular cheese pizza and it was yummy also. Will come back again! read more

Great pizza. Fair prices. Good Service. Overall would recommend to anyone wanting a great pizza place in Bethlehem. There online ordering process is simple and convenient. Delivery is very prompt. Overall one of my favorite places in the Lehigh Valley for pizza. read more

This is my favorite pizza place in South Bethlehem. It's not to die for or anything, but I think it's definitely better than your other options: Campus Pizza is just gross and sketchy, Domino's is overpriced and their crust is too thick, and I've had bad customer service experiences at Sotto Santi. The pizza is quite good, but what really sets this place apart from other pizza shops in my mind is that the rest of the menu is really great as well. I LOVE their veggie parm sandwich and cheese fries. There's a lot of other options to check out too: something for everyone, even if you don't feel like pizza. It's a friendly sort of place and there's adequate dinner seating if you want to eat in. Also, free delivery is definitely a plus! The staff are friendly and I haven't had any problems. read more

Only reason I'm giving 2 stars is the sauce was pretty good. I ordered 20 wings and extra sauce. I didn't get the extra sauce, only got 19 wings and one of those wings was extra tiny. It seems like we got the end of the bag of wings. They lost my business and won't ever go again. Added insult to injury the person that took my order and handed my order gave me attitude. read more

What a horrible experience I had at Lehigh Pizza, Bethlehem, PA. I came in at closing time and everybody wanted to go home I was willing to take the leftovers (plain and 2 pep) in the front to make a pie so they didn't have to make another one and the guy, charge me almost 2 times more than what a pie cost, even more than a pepperoni pie. I don't feel cheated out of money or pizza but cheated of an opportunity for me to receive and them to offer great customer service. I will do my best to let the valley know of my experience read more

Haven't set foot inside this establishment since they tried to serve us disgusting "floor pizza." There was only one slice of broccoli white pizza left, even asked us what else we would like in place of a second one bc that was all he had. Watched him drop it on the floor before placing in the oven. Then put on top of other slices! And when we confronted him he started screaming like a lunatic and told us to leave. 5 witnesses. We all saw it, we are appalled. None of us ever went back. And saying it was a false claim on the other witness's review is a flat out lie. This may have been years ago when it happened but, it still is burned into our memory. You should be ashamed. And with the amount of take out people are getting now it should be reviewed. read more

My band plays in and around Bethlehem and we stop by Lehigh Pizza for a late night snack. The last three times we were there the Pizza was excellent! Great individual funky slices. Staff is great! FYI, I am from NYC and have been exposed to REAL pizza! This place is really good! read more

Lehigh Pizza serves the best New York style pizza I have ever eaten! I don't understand some of the reviews. It sounds like some of the customers don't have good taste. More for me. Thank you, Lehigh Pizza. read more

They have beer delivery and have great white pizza w Broccoli. Not overly garlicky (even though I love garlic) and perfect blend of cheeses.

Very dissapointed! I have been ordering for years. The last few times have been awful. I order out and usually get my order pretty quick. I ordered tonight and waited an hour and a half. Cold as I assumed it would be. So now I have to warm my food up. Bill was 50. Tipped 58. Called to let them know. Watever kid works there answering phones says. Ok, not a care in the world. Well guess I gotta find a new pizza spot to order from. 58 dollars later and cold food! Don't think so read more

This place had the best pizza that I could find near the Lehigh campus. The student special was $7 for a large cheese pizza delivered to your dorm. I thought their pizza was far better than Campus Pizza and definitely worth the extra $2. read more

This place is small and dirty. I got a sausage pizza and the sausage tasted like it was rotten. I don't doubt that it was because the restaurant is so dirty and unorganized. Also, the people who work here look really scary and act like they don't care about what they're doing. The manager was yelling at one of the employees while I was there. Bad memories. I don't care how close it is to the Lehigh campus, it's not worth going to. Not going back. read more

The pizza for me was only worth 2 stars, but the staff were really friendly and I appreciated joking around with them. Pizza wasn't hot, or even warm if I'm being honest, but the crust was good. Good amount of toppings, but not great flavor. This place is no nonsense, good sized slices, paper plates, grab your own pepper flakes and/or beer. My kind of place if the pizza were better! read more

We've been getting delivery from them for several years, and the pizza had always been great and the cheese steaks pretty good; however, the past four deliveries of cheese steaks have featured the chopped steak with huge clumps of fat and gristle. I told them about it at least twice, but they continue to use this sub-par steak for their sandwiches. If I were a student using the place just for pizza and beer I would rate them higher, but any business that doesn't care about their reputation and quality deserves no more than 2 stars. read more

The eggplant parmesan pizza is super amazing! I love that they have pizza by the slice and vegan options (even if the cheese they use is a little sweet, it's great that they have that). Delivery is fast too! read more

Anyone who rates this place high either than 1 star either works for Lehigh Pizza, or havent eaten at other pizza places around the area. Never cooked well enough, topping freshness is questionable, oh, and they are by far the most expensive. read more

So nasty. Pizza was terrible. I just arrived in Bethlehem for graduate school and I've quickly figured out that this place is for drunk people. I won't eat here again. read more

Okay, I've had their pizza now about seven or eight times, either for work-related events or with friends on a Friday night. The convenience of free delivery is great, but getting a pizza warm is still a chance that you take by ordering from here. Also, the pizza is consistently okay - not great, but pretty good (although my friend really likes this pizza, so maybe it's just not my style?). read more

OK this rating is based on the fact this is a PIZZA SLICE place, this isn't a place you go for dinner. They without a doubt have the best slices (and selection) in Bethlehem, yes other locations (NY) has better slices and Soto Santis has cheaper slices but all considered you want a slice, especially after the bars, in Bethlehem you stop here. The beer selection also is great, although usually you've had enough by the time you hit this place. Realize your just going for a slice (and maybe some fries and pierogies which are good) and its definitely 4 stars. Don't bother ordering anything else. I especially like the eggplant slice, one of the best slices I've had ANYWHERE. read more

Great cheesesteak! I live in Georgia and occasionally visit Bethlehem for work. My boss took us out for a quick lunch one snowy day (clearly it was more of a dusting to people from PA) and I thoroughly enjoyed it. This place is really good. I've gotta learn that in PA they have green peppers not bell peppers, they also have hot peppers instead of jalapeño peppers but I digress, give it shot. read more

We usually order delivery from here when we don't feel like going out to Franks. The free delivery has been awesome, especially during these colder days. The garlic knots are awesome, as is there plain pizza. This place is great if you're in the mood for greasy cheesy food to eat with beer. read more

Good pizza, fast delivery, burgers are pretty good, the wings were also good. The wings I ordered were honey buffalo and they were amazing. Cheaper than the major pizza places, I will definitely order from here again. read more

Great pizza, open VERY late, in a location convenient to most hangouts in Bethlehem. Yep, this place wins!

For so many people bragging about this place, I found it very average for the first time I was there. I orded the chicken cheesesteak with the works. The sauce was bland. The chicken was not seasoned. The bread (a key to any hoagie) was average. I tried a piece of the pizza friends ordered and it was anything but "the best in Lehigh Valley". Again, very average stuff. In a pinch, I would recommend this place but not otherwise. read more

Went there this past Wednesday . I had a ham and swiss club. Nothing crazy . Was actually pretty good. So good that I am writing about 2 days later . My boss got a chicken parm sandwich and said it was the best he has had yet. If we are in the area again .definitely be back read more

Went here to eat during the storm (dumb I know) but they were open and it was nice to talk to someone and get warm and eat pizza. Everything was hot great selection of pizza drinks and beer. read more

These guys will make you whatever they feel like and not what you ordered. Be prepared for them not to care when asked to fix anything and good luck getting a refund. I will never eat at this place again. Absolutely the worst service for less than ok food read more

Worst Sicilian pizza. Obviously a frozen/ not fresh crust. Toppings were less than half what u would expect and they cost double on a Sicilian. We were excited to move within Lehigh's delivery area but we would rather get pizza from Nicks. Super disappointing. read more

Lehigh Pizza is what you call standard Pizza fare. When you walk in, the first thing you notice is the register is pretty cramped, especially with a line. If your going for slices, Lehigh has basically a glass window with pies where you can pick your slices. Slices range from cheap to about $3 a slice for the more high end varieties. The place also has a full pizzeria menu for what you would expect from the area. Nothing crazy, but nothing horrible. Pizza is good, and service is usually fast. Most days even at lunchtime I can get two slices heated up in 5 minutes of less. It also features enough seating for the crowd. It's not as good as Sotto Santi, but then again it takes way less time to get your food. So if your in a rush and you want a pizza fix, lehigh will suffice. Otherwise Sotto Santi is your best bet. read more

Not the best, but better than Campus Pizza on southside. They have some decent pizza and their Greek pizza isn't bad. If i'm going to get pizza in the area though, I'm going to north side. read more

Lehigh pizza will always be my number 1 spot, and is the only place I recommend to everyone for pizza in the area. Took a summer a couple years back and ate at almost every pizza place in the area with a group of buddies, Lehigh Pizza was easily a unanimous decision for #1. The pizza tastes amazing and is the perfect amount of crispy aswell, but is not overcooked. I make sure to get some every time I come visit the area. Legendary in my book, and p.s. the slices taste better than pies for some reason! read more

We were just passing through PA and decided to swing off the highway for a bite. We all ordered pizza by the slice. It is good pizza, not the best, however they had many toppings to choose from. If looking for variety, give it a try. read more

One of my local favorite places for a quick lunch. I get slices of pizza, usually 1, but if I can't decide between the white veggie or the spinach and mushroom I get 2! Greek salads are large and tasty. Take out is not as good as eat in....... The best slices in the Lehigh Valley! They do have an impressive wall of beer, but don't call the crap that they sell "wine" ! read more

I've ordered here a few times now and they have great service and food. They have a reasonable delivery charge

Their pizza is pretty good. I had Eggplant pizza and a meat lovers and both were better than what is offered in Stroudsburg. The pizza slices did look like they were sitting out for a few hours but still tasted good. read more

Pizza here isn't bad at all. Large to-go beer selection. Wings are nothing spectacular , even though they say they were voted the best wings (pretty sure that was in like 98) Worth trying, but God help you if you are on the North Side and are getting delivery. read more

After going consecutively following last years and this years Cars n Coffee events (where there's - serious lack of food service), we can say it's a favorite amongst our group to sit with good pizza, beer, and good conversation while watching the crowds leave the event. The selection of beer and ciders is very diverse. You shouldn't end up with a bud light...unless that's what you like. read more

Great food! The pizza is great, the sandwiches are great! Ordering online is quick and easy. You can also track your order online. Best pizza in the area by far! read more

Lots of varieties of pizza available by the slice at the counter. Fast service. The artichoke & tomato pizza is amazing!