It makes me sad writing this because I'm from the area and grew up coming here but the quality from this year compared to last year has sadly gone down hill... the fried pickles used to be homemade and are now completely different and taste like every other restaurants, the homemade quality made a world of difference! My son's burger was overcooked and the fries were soggy. My footlong tasted fine. The service was good. I just think the same love that goes into their other restaurants should go into this one too, that's just my personal opinion, raised prices for subpar food. I miss the old school feel of how the diner used to be! read more

I wish I would've took pictures because this place was awesome the food and service was absolutely amazing. I had the perch dinner I would like it fried a little harder but the taste and seasoning was spectacular. The ambiance was okay I didn't care for the carpet on the floor so it made the place a little dusty I had dust on my phone but took as extra seasoning lol I'm kidding but I wouldn't suggest them removing the carpet. I was with a party of 6 and an all equally enjoyed our food. The bbq chicken fried chicken wings were great - I love breaded chicken. They have at least 5 fry option to choose from curly fries to fresh cut fries (I was amazed lol) I just wish it was so far from me. We stopped here after a trip to oak beach. If we decide to drive 3 hours will definitely be back. Wonderful experience!!! read more

See all

Lefty's is a family owned restaurant located in Caseville Michigan. Always good service and the food is good as well. The GKs love the chicken fingers in the sporty car box. read more

I love Lefty's for a quick breakfast or lunch. They do have a really good perch dinner, but they do get busy so you need to get there early. Homestyle cooking with very friendly weight staff. If you're in Caseville, you need to go there at least once. read more

Great Food and Great Service at a Fair Price. We take the family and our grandkids to Lefty's in Caseville for great breakfasts as well as delicious cheeseburgers fries and shakes. Nice atmosphere and it's very clean. We strongly recommended Lefty's Diner in Caseville to anyone who Walt's a great hassle free meal. We Love Lefty's ! read more

Great food For decent prices. The service is great and Friendly. And the overall experience is fantastic.

We ate outside in a covered patio area that used to be a drive-in. My friends and I had burgers, fries, curly fries and onion rings along with a pop. I had the Lefty's super deli burger done deluxe style with onion rings. Both were good to very good. Both my friends said there burgers were good but one said the regular fries were soggy. Inside is the classic 50's dinner set up. Outdoor seating is low top patio tables and picnic tables. I can't recall if they had wifi. Good, friendly service. Pricey. My meal with drink was $21.19 before tip. Side lot parking. I may return when I'm back on the area or try to find a spot with a little better price point. read more

See all

Good food, nice daily menu, large portions. Closed at 7pm, but lots of locals. We had the Special: wet burrito and nachos Kids had foot long Coney (not on kids menu) and fries and kids cheeseburger (double burger). read more

See all

Their award winning cheese burger was absolutely garbage. I have never had a burger as gross as this. I've been around along time and this was nasty. The service was quick, clean environment etc. but stay off their cheeseburger. read more

I loved it, can't go wrong with a good diner. For the price as well I thought it was a good deal

Lefty's is a busy, little place. We stopped in for dinner. It was full. People of all ages were dining here. It's decorated in a bright, beachy kind of way. We had perch dinners and they were well prepared, and tasty. One negative, the carpet was flithy with dropped food and napkins and such. They also seemed short of help for the number of people dining. read more

We both ordered burgers. The presentation was surprisingly good (this is a diner and I expected burgers in the plastic basket with grease papers). The burgers were excellent! Although two burgers, onion rings, and two drinks were $35 - thankfully, everything was tasty. Service was great. We traveled with our two dogs and sat outside. Saved this place so we can go back. read more

See all

Cute retro diner with good food and service. One of the few places open around here on a Monday morning, too, which was greatly appreciated. The breakfast I had was great. The biscuits and gravy were tasty with nice fluffy biscuits. Their bacon is thick cut, and cooked just right. read more

Lefty's Diner - Eggs over easy with biscuits and gravy - Diners Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

Outdoor seating in the back made me feel more comfortable with COVID distancing measures. Servers had bandanas to wear but didn't really use them, so they aren't strict about safety. They are, however, very attentive with service and the quality of food is better than most roadside diners and fast-food options, so a solid 4 stars, but I do wish there were some additional precautions observed. Ask for the hand-cut fries read more

See all

Carryout lunch today from Lefty's. Burger, fries, Cole slaw - all very good! Quick, friendly service. I'll be back! read more

Lefty's Diner - Diners Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

This is definitely one of our top picks in Caseville. The menu is extensive, really offering something for everyone. Most recently, we enjoyed several different appetizers rather than ordering an entree. We loved the house cut fries with chili and cheese, as well as the beer battered pickle slices! The pickles were sliced thick with the crispiest batter. We also loved the standard order of mini tacos. We look forward to trying the milkshakes and some of the award winning burgers on our next visit! read more

Lefty's Diner - Chili Cheese Fries with House Cut Fries - Diners Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

See all

Good food, prices, and service. Great home made French fries. Will definitely be a repeat customer.

Took forever to get our food yet again. Burnt hashbrowns and undercooked bacon. Our waitress was awful and on top of all this it is over priced. Brutal. read more

WAY OVERPRICED! I got takeout for two footling chili dogs and two orders of curly fries. Very slow, and it didn't strike me as very clean. The hotdogs were literally shriveled and pretty brown, with very little taste. Bun was way over toasted, but somehow soggy. My whole family was in the bathroom frequently for two days after that food. The curly fries were pretty tasteless, and fairly small portions for $5 an order. What's going on is the owner charges these outrageous prices for this substandard food because she's catering to the wealthy that come up to stay on the lake for the summer. I'm going to go to Walt's in town in Caseville next time, I hear the food is very good and not expensive. read more

Lefty's used to be the place to go in Caseville. The food is ok but now way over priced for what you get. Price does not match the overall experience. Sorry Lefty's but you have priced yourself out of my market. Mark read more

Decently ok is about all I can give. It's not terrible and it's not great. Just kind of ok. Pricey for what it is. $8 for some fancy fries which I didn't care for at all. Someone else might like them tho. Overall a big "meh". Pro is that they have way more seating available than our preferred restaurant. read more

We came on a summer Monday night and the place was packed. Friendly staff did a good job of getting us seated and served. We had loaded fries, chicken strips, onion rings and a patty melt. Everything was great. read more

Good local diner. Good prices. Beth Anne is beautiful and great to her customers. Will be back soon

I came with a party of six, we had called ahead and were told there was open seating out on the patio, when we got there, the host told us to go see ourselves on the patio, and there were only tables that needed to be cleared off, so we had to go back in and ask the staff to clear them off for us. Our waitress was friendly, but the downside was that it took 40 minutes for us to receive our food. Considering that it is simple diner food, eggs, bacon, toast, omelettes, etc. it was wild how long it took and I had to call the waitress to see when our food was coming, she did not come to check on us during our wait time till I asked her. I understand that it is a small town and it was a Sunday morning, but 40 minutes is pretty unreasonable and it would have been better service if the waitress had came to check on us or explain about the wait time during our stay. The food was decent and average, your classic diner breakfast. Nothing bad, nothing to write home about. read more

When I go somewhere out of town, I like to eat at a local establishment. Since I was in Caseville, everything seemed to be about cheeseburgers, so we came here. It's a somewhat musty old diner with tiny tables and a lack of air conditioning, but the service and food was very good. We went there on a mid-Tuesday afternoon, and the place was packed. The burger I had (listed as a "2005 champion") seemed to be no different for a burger at any other place, and it was kind of small. Perhaps, I should've ordered a bigger burger. My wife had some burger with ham on it, and she liked it. She ordered onion rings, which were huge portioned and among the best we've ever had. We were in and out rather quickly and only spent $30. read more

Lefty's Diner - Diners Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

Very good burger and hard to beat. Real good meal while just passing through town. Chili fries are the best around!

A great spot to stop after a long day at the beach. I ordered the bases loaded burger, and it was delicious. I will definitely be back! read more

Lefty's Diner - Bases loaded burger - Diners Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

I heard rave reviews of the deep fried pickles here and had to make a visit! Twice. The deep fried pickles were delicious! Not the best I've ever had, but damn good! We were actually here for breakfast (and the waitress still let us order the pickles- bonus). The décor of Left's is standard Caseville. Bright pink, flamingos, and 1950s overkill. The coffee was a step above diner quality. Breakfast was average and cheap. Less than $5 for 2 eggs, hash browns, bacon and Texas toast. If you are in town, stop in for the pickles! read more

Although the food is good and the prices are appropriate, NOT ONE SERVER WAS WEARING A MASK and they don't enforce patrons wearing masks when when entering or walking around the restaurant. Horribly stressful! We WONT be coming back anytime soon. read more

Lefty's is a staple of Caseville. One of my absolute favorite places to go when I'm here. Have been eating here all my life. Never gotten a bad meal! read more

We stopped here this past Saturday while taking a drive around the thumb area. We were looking for somewhere that we could get some food and probably eat in our car, as we had our two yorkies with us At Lefty's we could eat outside under a roof and our waiter said the dogs could sit at our table I had the cod fish dinner and my husband had a burger and hand cut fries. We were very surprised at how good the food tasted and was well worth eating there. Our dogs were happy to be comfortable outside the car and in a shaded spot. The restaurant for indoor sitting was open too and both areas were filled with customers which usually means it's a good place to eat Will stop there again when we are ever in Caseville. read more

This place is amazing. Fries and burgers delicious. Also the best onion rings we have EVER had! Giant shakes we could barely finish. And the service was great. Special shout out to Garet our waiter whose customer service was on point! We will be back whenever we're in Caseville! read more

I am a regular at Lefty's. Today is different than any other as it is Mother's Day and in the middle of COVID-19 quarantine. We got fast friendly service. We ordered chili fries, wet burrito and chicken wings. We got plenty to share for 3. Most important I didn't have to cook. Stay safe. read more

The perch sandwich was tasty. I'm not sure if the fish was farm raised or lake perch but it was tasty. read more

Lefty's Diner - Lefty's menu 10/14/20 - Diners Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

I wasn't sure when we walked through the door. They were pretty busy. We waited five minutes or so and we're waited on. We both had the chicken, bacon, Swiss sandwich with fries. Do not pass up the fries. They are homemade and scrumptious. The sandwich was really good. Overall nice little place to fill your belly. read more

Lefty's Diner - Chicken, bacon, Swiss sandwich and fries. - Diners Near Me - Caseville, Michigan

This is the place for fried food in casevile Michigan. They have it all fish, cauliflower shrimp, they fry it all. Big juicy burgers as well. And omg that large Sunday was no joke. Once the dale JR pin ball machine is fixed this place will be a 11. read more

Overall it just was an okay experience. There was two of us and I got my food first and then we waited 5 minutes for the other persons food. We went for breakfast and they were busy but we could literally hear them arguing over our meals. Also our server was wearing flip flops and I was so deathly afraid she was going to slip because they were all running around. Food was just okay as well. Not terrible but wasn't anything I would have to go back for. read more

Still perfect after all of these years. I always had the foot long hot dog and onion rings at the original drive in in the 1970s. Here it is 2019 and it's still great. The dogs, rings, the perch (on Fridays) are all great and service is just as good. Don't miss out, so today and make sure you eat the onion rings. read more

The food wasn't horrible but the service was extremely poor. After waiting 20 minutes we had to ask for help just to get drinks. We then proceeded to wait another 5 minutes before getting any help... overall not a great experience. read more

For a "just a diner, I give it 5 stars.... you walk in to a feeling of the 50's and the friendliness of "Cheers", where everybody knows your name. My parents live in Pigeon (the next town over from Caseville), on Sand Point and I am roughly 2 hours south of Pigeon so we often find ourselves eating Leftys. The menu has several options like an omelette, burger, pulled pork sliders or meatloaf and mashed potatoes. The service is great, if the servers are busy and running around they likely breeze by to check on you, but they still do.... I have been in the business for years, one thing I notice often is cleanliness. The building may be old and about to lean over, but it's clean from what I see. I also know that their food is fresh and I've never had a bad meal there. The flatware/China are meeting the same fate as the building & some menu items come in a red basket, the prices are reasonable, so for that my daughter can eat her chicken fingers out of a basket for now. Keep on going Leftys. read more