2 stars, and I'm being generous…read more I came in with a friend and my toddler around 3:15 on a Saturday afternoon. We left at 4:45. There were maybe three other tables in the entire place. We started with the arancini, advertised as house-made risotto. The breading was too uniform and too thick to be house made by anyone who's actually made arancini. The center wasn't warm. The risotto inside was dry. The marinara was cold. I've had good arancini. This wasn't it. We ordered a medium pizza -- pepperoni and mushroom on half -- and waited. And waited. At some point our server came out to tell us the pizza had to be remade. I had a hungry, increasingly cranky toddler being held together with graham crackers. By the time the pizza finally arrived, he was done. The pizza itself: the pepperoni is listed as Liguria and it did cup, so I'll give it that. But the top of the pizza was swimming in oil -- more than pepperoni alone accounts for -- which suggests the cheese isn't doing any favors. The sauce and crust were genuinely good. I didn't hate the pizza. But the service? I've waited tables. I know how it works. I watch things. When we declined to order alcohol, our server's smile dropped noticeably. After that, he checked on us far less than the other tables -- and there were only three of them. We ran out of water. The manager came by, noticed our empty carafe, and filled it himself. That told me everything. The pizza had barely landed on the table before our server reappeared with his ordering device, Cheshire grin in full effect, check already sliding toward us. I told him I wasn't done yet when he asked about a box. His response? "Just want to make sure you're taken care of." That's a strange thing for an attentive server to say. A good server would have walked away and come back. He hovered. When we were actually ready to leave, there was no one to flag down -- my friend had to go find the server and the owner, who were hanging out together in the back, just to get a box. Two women with a toddler, mid-afternoon, three other tables in the restaurant, and we couldn't get water refilled or basic attention -- but we could get the check shoved at us before I finished eating. The crust and sauce have potential. Everything else needs serious work. One more thing worth noting: Google sits at 4.8 stars while Yelp comes in at 3.8 with a pattern of reviews that either love it or hate it. A full star gap between platforms is a meaningful discrepancy. Google reviews are anonymous and anyone can leave them -- draw your own conclusions. The Yelp split tracks with my experience. Your mileage may vary, but mine did not.

We use to love the pizza here. The last 2 pizza were extremely sub par…read more New staff, cheaper ingredients and yet another local restaurant to mark off the list of places to dine. sad

A hidden gem! Small place but big flavors. Every bite was delicious and the staff treated us like…read morefamily."

The pizza used to be great with the original crust but the last 2-3 crusts they have tried have…read moreruined it for me. They used to make the dough in house but now it's a Food Services of America or Sysco. I make pizza dough all the time and it takes all of 10 mins to mix it up and then a few hours to rise. The crust decision has to be purely financial decision and not based on taste or texture. The hot dogs are really good though.

Ordered delivery one of my pizzas the briskinator was so burnt as to be inedible. The Sweet Like…read moreHoney was just poorly put together and very underwhelming, missing 2 of the 3 cheeses (brie, pizza cheese) described on the menu, cut very unevenly the crust is very tough and overcooked. The only reason it's 2 stars is because the alexander was fine.

this is a really nice place to drop in and grab a slice or a whole pie, i think the wings are a…read moreshow stopped. service is very friendly and the food is wildly tasty for everyone. had dinner with my brother and sister in law and it was really quiet and fun to catch up.

I think they used to call this restaurant The Slab and it was just a pizza parlor back then…read more I went with the intention of getting pizza, not knowing they had may have had other things on the menu. So I don't know the menu because I didn't request one with my curbside pickup. I got a very large slice of pepperoni, and it was tasty. Good sauce, crust with the right chew and crisp. Thick but not too heavy. A bit greasy from the pepperoni but that just added flavor! They did a curbside delivery so I didn't have to get my walker out to go in. I would do it again when I'm in the mood for a slice.

Stopped in for a slice and also got this blackberry basil danish and OMG it's the best danish I've…read moreever had! Can y'all please open up a full bakery too

My second time here. First time I for the prime rib dip. It was excellent. On my second visit…read moretoday I get the best and unique Philly I have ever had. I did not realize that it had BBQ sauce on it when I ordered it, I tend to be a purist and would have asked for it not to be put on. But OMG I am so happy it was there because it was SO good. Salty, a touch of sweet and spice with lots of brisket. It is a messy overflowing sandwich so I don't recommend driving up mount Walker while trying to eat it. You will likely go off the edge because you can not put the sandwich down! I will be back for more and trying other offerings. Place was super clean with an excellent vibe.

The food was so good. The brisket had really good flavor. The barbecue on it was nice and had a…read morelittle bit of heat. The meatloaf sandwich is absolutely phenomenal. Not like any other meatloaf I've ever had. The potato salad. The homemade potato salad was so good and had great flavor you can tell it's definitely homemade. The butterscotch cookie was nice and soft and had just enough butterscotch in there. The bathrooms were super clean. The lady working register was super friendly, and the guy that was behind cooking was awesome sat and visited with us and told us about the area definitely welcoming. I must stop shop.

Picked up at closing. The owner offered me a discount because "he's always grateful for the first…read moreand last customer of the day." I put that discount and a little more into the tip jar. The pizza must have been awesome because my teenager ate all but one slice before I got to it!

Sometimes you just want a greasy pizza and not some work of art pizza that you don't know whether…read moreto eat it or take pictures of it. This pizza isn't flashy nor gourmet tasting and I don't think that's the point of this place. The employees are friendly and funny the atmosphere is sparse with the emphasis on the kitchen, being the main attraction. This pizza is mid range, it's not going to wow you nor impress you. I'm looking for a pizza and not a spouse I want a greasy pizza sometimes and this did the trick!

Let me start by saying if I could rate a 4.5 stars I probably would as I was on the fence here. I…read morereally liked the pizza. We had a cheese pizza with ranch sauce and the ranch sauce was excellent as was the sour dough crust. From a balance perspective there was a lot of crust around the edge so I would definitely suggest adding some ranch to dip it in. Of course, that will cost you extra. We also purchased a dessert brownie and it was good. I feel like their pricing on their menu board could be more clear as we had to ask on some items. They also were out of drinks as they said their vendor did not come to fill them. While they can't be blamed for this, it did cause us to have to drive to the gas station and get drinks to bring back for when our pizza was ready. Seating is non-existent inside and very limited outside with little to no shade in the evening. At the point of this review the restaurant also does not accept American Express. Just a heads up for those business travelers or American Express customers so that you are aware that you will need a different form of payment here but in another swerve they also DO NOT accept cash.

I swung by here more out of convenience than anything else. It wasn't on my bookmark list but since…read moreI was right by it going to Bainbridge Island Brewing I figured it would save me time in scrounging around for food later. What drew me in was their sign that they did pizza by the slice. I always like these kinds of pizza restaurants because I don't necessarily want a whole pizza. I got a slice of cheese pizza and a slice of pepperoni pizza. The pizza was pretty good, I've had better but it wasn't bad and it got the job done for me with getting a meal out of the way. I liked the outdoor seating and the Autumn weather felt cooperative in having a nice dining experience outside near the restaurant.

One of the best pizzas we've gotten near Port Orchard! The flavor combos were interesting, but the…read morelet's be frank was great! We also got a side of ranch which was dilly & good. I'd skip the artichoke dip next time. it was alright, but could definitely use more flavor.

I had seen some positive reviews on the Toad House and wanted to stop in. My mom remembers eating…read more'grinder' sandwiches when she and dad first married and attending North Dakota Stare University. We got a sandwich and ordered a pepperoni pizza also. The sandwich was made on their own focaccia bread, plenty of meat, veggies, and sauce. Very good. Plenty of pepperoni and cheese on a thin crust brought a smile to our face. We have plenty for a second meal and a midnight snack. Definitely going back for more.