Lamp Lighter Inn has always been my favorite place to stay in Carmel. I have been visiting since 2011 and have stayed many times.
Unfortunately, my recent visit at the beginning of August 2024, has left me disappointed.
The inn still has one of the cutest and picturesque exteriors in Carmel by the Sea.
Other than that, not much draws an appeal over other places to stay in Carmel.
Their pricing is comparable and even more expensive than other hotels/inn around the Carmel-by-the-Sea area. So to see them start cheapening out on enjoyable experiences, is sad.
1. They stopped doing the cheese and wine social hour. This is a standard and tradition among Carmel hotels that guests LOVE. Almost all of tother inn/hotel in Carmel provides some sort of evening wine social/happy hour. This was always provided and has since been stopped. I can only assume stopping this is to save money but it is definitely one of the unique, fun, and cute appeals Carmel hotels provide.
2. The breakfast leaves much to be desired. The breakfast consisted of: Instant Quaker oatmeal, basic yogurt, apple/bananas, and a few bread/danish items that did not look fresh and local. The worst offender, the only creamer option for coffee, was coffee mate. There was no half and half or other milk options. This is very disappointing as most people have moved away from unhealthy/chemical loaded choices.
Other hotels I have stayed at, put a lot more effort into the breakfast. Offering champagne, local/fresh danishes and bread, fresh juice, arrangement of fruits, homemade items, and even warm breakfast items. We opted to skip both coffee and any breakfast item here, and buy it at a local coffee shop.
3. The rooms are incredibly noisy. I have stayed in 5 different rooms and all can expect to have noise. The stand alone cottages offer less noise, mainly just street/pedestrian noise. If you stay in one of the rooms that attaches, expect to hear every single noise from your adjoining neighbor.
4. Another odd noise issue, around 9/930 at night, in the housekeeping area, dishes were being unloaded. Dishes were clanking and making loud noises at this hour, seems very odd. If only "breakfast" is provided, why are the dishes and kitchen items being taken care off, later at night? Breakfast ended at 10 am...doesn't seem like the most appropriate time.
5. We had a dog, paid the dog fee, but had to ask for the included "amenities". Which is basically a blanket.
Again, this hotel is very cute and everyone stops to admire it as they walk by. The Carmel-by-the-Sea experience has been stripped from the stay now days. Very disappointing to see, as this was a great place to stay. When so many other places offer so much more, I would say, I wouldn't choose to stay here again. read more