Brought the family here for the first time over the weekend. There was nobody in line, so we got…read moreserved right away, and the employees were very nice. The kids got scoops, the wife got a shake, and I got a sunday. With all the reviews and history, I think I over hyped this place. The ice cream was average, not outstanding as I was expecting. Even though we will be back to try more flavors.

I had no idea that there was Graeter's near Polaris, not did I realize they had so many flavors…read morenow. I also did not know that this location had a drive thru....But they DO! To all of that. I was looking for a good shake. I drove towards Chik Fil A as my kids like their shakes. Well, right next door was Graeters! No brainer to get a shake from Gaeters vs well, really anywhere. They had lemon meringue ice cream. Uh, YUM! I had them make a shake with it. Let me tell you... chef's kiss. Delicious. Oh I for-see this being a big problem for my scale, jeans, etc. Lol. I will be buying lots of these. Lol. Mmmmmmmm.

Another stop along the greater Columbus ice cream/froyo trail. Reminds me of a place I loved back…read morehome. Plenty of places to seat inside and a few outside. Today's visit featured a variety of tart, sweet, and chocolate flavors. I went with birthday cake, white chocolate strawberry and pistachio. White chocolate strawberry was hands down the best flavor! Pistachio had an unusual after taste and the birthday cake tasted like vanilla. The toppings bar had a good variety of dry toppings. My favorite was the cupcake bites which you usually don't see. Not enough fruit toppings. The price per ounce was a little more than I expected. Overall not a bad place for some fro-yo. Tip: If you are looking to get more than one flavor, pick up a divider! First time I had ever seen once. Tip 2: Pull the handle slowly since the fro-yo comes out rather quickly and don't want to overfill your cup before you load on the toppings.

The Orange leaf has really great yogurt and tons of toppings to choose from. The decor inside is…read morereally cute and colorful. The space is open and not cluttered an plenty of parking outside. The yogurt cups are self serve, but the toppings are behind the counter.

Got to try Phyllis Ann's ice cream, located in Polaris Mall. I was excited to try them since they…read moreare a family owned business and I had never noticed the shop before. They had 16 flavors like cookies and cream, super hero, and monster cookie play dough, and some of the more complex ones like the strawberry cheesecake and blueberry waffle cone are an additional $0.99 upcharge. They also have hot dogs , bagels, and walking tacos. The space was very big, with a wall of snacks on the side wall. If you want to try the flavors, you can do so in the back area but since the ice cream itself isn't visible it was a bit roundabout since you had to see which flavor you wanted to try from the front, go to the back to try it, and then come back to the front to place your order. There were a lot of place to sit and eat, and the seats were comfy! The texture of the ice cream stood out to me because of how soft it was. It was almost like eating whipped cream. The flavor of the chocolate chip cookie dough was sweet and strong, with chunks of cookie dough, but the texture was a bit too soft for my liking. The portion size was pretty big. I don't know if I would try it again but the convenience of it being in the mall was good since you could explore other places and shop while you're there.

Sofi's Mini Donuts offers a fun and tasty experience at their kiosk in Polaris Fashion Place. This…read morekiosk is easy to spot when you come through the entrance with Brio on one side and Molly Woo's on the other side. The 10 topping choices were impressive, choosing from glazed, chocolate, Nutella, mallow creme, dulce de leche, M&Ms, Oreo, Kit Kat, Fruity Pebbles, or Graham Cracker. I enjoyed watching them make the donuts right in front of the customers. I got the cinnamon sugar donuts and they were delicious.

Not the best things in the world but they knock the sweet tooth out for a bit and served quickly!read more

Stopped into Coldstone on a wintery-mix night and was the 2nd customer in there. For some reason,…read moreit took forever for me to get greeted/helped as both people were working on the person in front of me's 2 item order. Once I was helped, the service was nice, and I got my ice cream quickly. I wasn't offered a lid, which was odd, but all well. The ice cream was delicious as always. Next time you're in, definitely try the chocolate cake batter if they have it!

I hadn't been in a Cold Stone in over 10 yrs! So obviously a lot has changed. They have a huge…read morearray of flavors. I liked how they had pictures of the options you can create. They have some Halloween specials pumpkin bread and more. The prices seem expensive to me. Though the waffle cone bowls that are dipped in chocolate and sprinkles is delicious and a clever design! The lady who helped us was sweet and kind and helpful.

Strawberry milkshake is soo good but the serve is horrible!! The girl was so rude! I asked "can I…read moreplease have a receipt?" Her reply "if you WANT one?!" So rude!! Even if the yogurt is so good here I will NOT come back!!

Over priced for the quality and size of the product. Have to pay for every topping and they only…read moregive a small scoop for each one. I got coconut and it was stale and in large clumpy chunks. No one wants to have to pay $1 for their first topping!

Attended on grand opening day about 20 minutes before closing. They were moving everyone through…read morereally quickly. I felt a bit rushed to order and get out of the way. It would have been helpful for staff to make suggestions or quickly go over menu options. But, everyone is doing their best on a stressful evening. We ended up with just scoops in a cup, but I'm excited to explore the menu more next time and try a sundae or dipped waffle cone. We tried 3 flavors total: campfire s'mores, cookie dough, and mint cookies & cream. Campfire s'mores was definitely the star of the show with large marshmallows and graham cracker chunks. The cookie dough was also good as the base tasted like cookies and the dough pieces were large. I wasn't very impressed with the mint cookies & cream, but I can't put my finger on why. I just like the flavor at other locations better. Overall prices seem pretty on par with other local premium ice cream shops. Although it seems this location is cheaper than the others around central Columbus when looking at online ordering?? Overall, looking forward to coming back to try more unique flavors and seasonal specials!

Johnson's real ice cream has been around for sometime but stopped at the one on home Rd and O boy…read morewas it fantastic. Rich creamy ice cream the way it should be made. Not cheap but well worth the money. Highly recommend this place for a cold treat. Staff was friendly and helpful. Milkshake's were great! Nothing bad to say about this place should do great .