You know the joke about how women never know what they want to eat? Well, the thing is, we do know what we want to eat, it's just that we want 2.5 chicken nuggets, half a plate of boar cheek ravioli, a sip of an old fashioned, and oh wait, let's throw in a single potato from a pot of dakbokkeumtang while we're at it. Fellow ladies, if this sounds like you, La Merenda is absolutely the place for you. This restaurant, to me, really epitomizes Milwaukee's growth in terms of the culinary scene. So to the naysayers from big cities (as I once was), I say, "but do you have a place where you can enjoy indigenous food, Wisconsin cheese, and sambal goreng under one roof? I think not."
My partner and I came here for a casual date night after hearing a lot of great comments about this restaurant. This restaurant is intimate yet warm, currently with ample space and tall plastic dividers between every table for COVID safety (much appreciated!). There is also a small bar and cozy lounge area in the front. It looks like they have lovely outdoor seating in the area, but unfortunately we came on a very foggy and cold day! Seems they have a complimentary valet service which we missed, but there is plenty of street parking around the corner.
To be honest, we were a little skeptical at first looking at the wide range of dishes on the menu- there was such variety that we weren't sure that the restaurant could pull off this diverse an array of dishes well. But this skepticism quickly was dissolved as we tucked into our first dishes- the manoomin salad [$15] and seared trout [$15]. I was really excited to try the manoomin salad because it's really hard to find indigenous-inspired dishes anywhere in the US, and I'm happy to say that it exceeded expectations. The trout was crisp and delicate, and listen, I absolutely abhor salad, but I would eat the manoomin salad by the bucketload if only my stomach had the capacity. There was something just so addictive about the flavor and "dry" textures. All of that, plus the wojapi (which my partner proclaimed with dismay that now this would be something he would be craving forever) made this one of the best things I've ever eaten. The seared trout was great too; again, perfectly cooked fish in a savory, salty dashi. I'd just note that the vegetables were a little overcooked. We thought it was a little too salty when it came out, but when eaten with rice, it was delicious. The last dish to complete our first round was the jerk pork loin [$14]. The pork was cooked well and served with an exquisitely spiced mashed sweet potato side. I think this didn't pack as much of a punch as jerk from a Jamaican restaurant would, and the dish overall would've benefited from an additional component since it was pretty simple (just the pork and the sweet potatoes). However, what was on the plate was well-executed.
After this great start, we had to go for a second round, of course. The duck confit poutine [$14] was another dish I was excited about because I love poutine and I love duck...so of course it was a must-order. The portion was really generous with this dish, but I don't think it was quite what I envisioned. Not sure about the use of goat cheese curds and the gravy was not quite what I'm used to, but I'm also lowkey a poutine purist and I don't want to gatekeep a restaurant trying to have fun with a dish. We finished with the Argentinian pork belly [$14], two succulent pieces of pork belly confit with chimichurri over some very garlicky mashed potatoes. I wish there was a lot more chimichurri with this dish in order to balance the savory and fatty flavors of the pork and potatoes, but overall still good. I will echo previous reviews and note that most of the dishes were pretty salty, but overall we liked everything, with the first two dishes being our favorites. After 5 dishes, we were absolutely stuffed and had no room for dessert (sad!)
For drinks, I had an apricot rum punch [$10], and my partner had 2 beers [$5 each]. Service was friendly without being overbearing; both my partner and I were very pleased with the attentive and considerate service.
Something I hear a lot from people here is that they really want to try ethnic food but aren't sure of where to start or are hesitant about branching out. I think La Merenda is also a great option for those who are curious but maybe don't want to commit to a full dish for the cuisine of interest. The food is not as authentic or flavorful as it would be at a restaurant that specializes purely in one cuisine, but the dishes here are a great way to get a feel for the flavor profiles. But for those who consider themselves already adventurous or global eaters, La Merenda is still sure to please with its wide variety of well-executed dishes that pay homage to their cultures of origin while finding roots in locally-sourced ingredients. I absolutely look forward to my next visit and can't wait to try the other offerings on their menu! read more