You must eat here. One of best meals in Italy. They really elevate the food. Saw good reviews on…read moreYelp, but only a few. Could not have been happier. Staff friendly and professional. Prices reasonable. Food fantastic. Appetizer polenta with mushrooms. Good. Main meals were great. Pork with figs and caramelized onions. Beef with prunes. Bothe melt in your mouth with complex flavors. House wine very reasonable and great price. Town is beautiful. Definitely come here.

My friend and I were in Pitigliano for four days, and had lunch at Il Grillo our second day on the…read morerecommendation of our new friend Claudia Elmi. We shared a ricotta pie with saffron sauce appetizer and a pork roll, ending with a wonderful cake dessert; our meal was so delicious and the ambiance so charming that we returned for dinner our last night. Even though we didn't have reservations and they were fully booked, Roberto was kind enough to find a spot for us -- and for the second time, we weren't disappointed. This time we started with polenta with porcini mushrooms; I had pork shank with roasted potatoes, the pork so tender it fell off the bone. My friend had the rabbit stuffed with fennel potatoes, which she declared exceptionally good. We shared a plate of roasted vegetables and had a lovely bottle of local white wine. The staff was very attentive. It's a most attractive restaurant, very affordable, with a creative and delicious menu.

We had the house wine. It was very good. The meat and cheese starter was good. Service was good. My…read morehubby had the Carbonara, and thought it was the best he's ever had. The pasta was perfect and the ciangale was cooked perfectly. I had the eggplant parmigiana and the smoky cheese center was perfect.

Stopped in for lunch. The staff was friendly and the food excellent. We had the octopus to start…read moreand the Chiangalle Ragu and carbonara for mains. Wouldn't change a thing. Everything was excellent.

My husband and I enjoyed a wonderful lunch here of Tuscan antipasti (a very generous platter of…read morelocal meats and cheeses) followed by homemade ravioli stuffed with potatoes and served with truffles and pecorino, and perfectly cooked, very thin and delicate pappardelle served with wild boar ragu. All our dishes were excellent, and we washed them down with a half-carafe of the house red wine (shockingly delicious, and only €4)! We were stuffed from our feast but couldn't pass up the dolce course, a pastry stuffed with an orange, walnut, and honey filling and then sliced--apparently a specialty of Pitigliano. We also really appreciated that the restaurant's inside rooms are housed in a tufa cave, which was very atmospheric and welcome on a chilly December day. We would love to return for another excellent meal when the gorgeous patio overlooking the gorge below is open!

Friends and I dined here in October 2017. We didn't have reservations and had spent some time…read moreexploring the town. The posted menu looked good. Down a set of stairs we came upon a beautiful outdoor garden/dining area. We dined inside, as it was quite cold out. Lovely setting, inside the tufo rock. Nice typical Tuscan menu. We ordered crostini with tartufo but received two orders and we were charged for it. It should have been complimentary since we didn't order it. I had caco e pepe and then a scallopini dish with mushrooms; and my friends and I shared a side order of spinach. All very good. We shared a half carafe of white wine. Our waiter later showed us the tunnel area below the restaurant, which was pretty neat to see. Our meal came to 26 euros each, pretty typical. I wish I had discovered this place earlier on in my trip, as it would have been lovely to have lunch outside in the garden area.

A great evening with great service and great food. We do not speak Italian. We made our way…read morethrough the menu, Server was patient and allowed for recommendations and us to agree. Well done.

Amazing dining experience in this small rustic Osteria! Chef Julio masterfully cooks Bistecca Alla…read moreFlorentina to perfection in his wood fired oven! Pici Con Ragu Di Cinta Sense e Tartufo is a must try. Authentic Tuscan food! Atmosphere is very cozy with shared tables.

Great dining experience. One of the best meals we had in Montepulcino. We ordered the steak, which…read morewas perfectly cooked and a couple of sides which were also delicious. The house red wine was quite good.

Spent a couple of hours at La Pappalpomodoro together with a full house, mostly families enjoying…read morefood and each other. The owner created a fine atmosphere and served us kindly and with humour. Everything we had tasted good but came maybe a bit early on the table. A few minutes more in the kitchen could be recommended. If so I'm sure it would have been a pleasure for taste and texture. But you have to enjoy a restaurant you leave with a smile on your face. If not so much for the food, more for the people you met and talked to.

The restaurant was located in a quiet area. We decided to eat outside. We started with the seafood…read moreplatter, where everything was raw. It came with oysters, three types of shrimp, shrimp paste, three types of ceviche, and a carpaccio. My favorite was the carpaccio, which had pieces of freeze dried raspberry on top. The only thing I didn't like was one of the ceviches. We had a plate of fried calamari and shrimp next. The batter was excellent! Lastly, we had a pasta dish with clams. It was simple but delicious. I would say this restaurant was the highlight of our time here in this port city.

Great experience. Wonderful friendly and helpful service. Terrific seafood risotto and anchovy…read moreburrata. Tuna tartar with a great bottle of Lazio white wine