We rented a house that they manage on behalf of an owner. After signing the lease and getting the keys, we did a walk through and saw that the tub was still dirty, there was mold in the refrigerator, dust on the ceilings, stains in the carpet, paint overspray that's on the floors and light fixtures, and my favorite moisture under the flooring where the toilet 'sits' in one of the bathrooms (the front of the toilet is held up by a piece of wood). Then as we went through the move-in check list we discovered that the kitchen sink was stopped up. I guess this would account for that mold that was in the refrigerator as there was nothing with which to clean it. How was this clogged not detected before we moved in?
I'm not sure if they even did a move-out check list before we moved in because one of the major items that we were on the hook for after we moved out was something that was pre-existing. We were told that we should have made them aware of the issue. Okay fine and maybe they need to improve their move-in check list as there's no where to document damage to countertops in the kitchen. Given that the place had not been fully cleaned out when we first visited this house in Brownestone as evident of an adult potty right there in one of the bedrooms and trash in the kitchen area, I should've known a thorough walk through had not been done prior to us taking possession. Or maybe they just don't care.
We were also on the hook for lack of yard maintenance. When I asked them for proof they sent me not an invoice, but a picture of house that wasn't even the house that we rented. So you're telling me that the landlord and KPM do not know what the house looks like, but are adamant that we did not maintain the yard. We were on the hook for a unidentified house's lack of yard maintenance and were told the owner was generous with the amount that he charged.
There were two other things that we were held responsible for and guess what, we hold ourselves accountable for that. Speaking of accountability, I'm not going to go into the fact that they were adamant that I had not returned that key when I said that I did. After showing them my timeline of the date in question per my Google Maps history the narrative changed, but it still was not acknowledged that we had not heard a peep from them within 30 days after we moved out and were no longer in possession of the property (not even with an interim list). I thought there was some law against that? After considering legal options, I just didn't and don't have the bandwidth to pursue.
During the 17 months that we rented this house, it felt like we were submitting a maintenance request every.single.month. I'm not talking some minor stuff. I'm talking about the kitchen sink that didn't drain (this was right after we moved in), raw sewage backed up in the tub and shower (this happened twice...seems to happen after heavy rains so maybe they should take note of that), they didn't have a carbon monoxide detector installed (this is the law btw), the refrigerator leaked (leaked for over a year and it's as old as the house), leaking roof, toilet water constantly running (once it was finally fixed our water bill was reduced drastically), leaking water heater (it's as old as the house and it did its duty; time to be replaced)...In the beginning they were good at responding, but after a while I guess they were like here we go again (maybe they were just overwhelmed with requests from their other properties). It got the point that the appliance company mentioned that they had been out to the property a number of times. Shout out to Cliff because he was spot on with the issues every time he came and he was efficient. Also, I understand things happen and they can't predict when things go sour so I won't fault them on that entirely.
My take away from this experience is to document.every.single.thing and submit it to them ASAP...otherwise they won't believe you even if your tongue was notarized. read more