The fudge is really delicious. I compared the Howse's sample of dark chocolate fudge with Kilwin's…read moresample of dark chocolate fudge and the Howse's sample was markedly better (better flavor and creamy texture, while the Kilwin's was sweeter and more grainy). I also tried the Kilwin's regular chocolate fudge which was better than the Kilwin's dark (better texture) but still didn't taste as good as the Howse's fudge. The downside is that Howse's is more expensive, $14.75 per slice, so $29.50 for 2 slices, whereas Kilwin's is about $23 for 3 slices. On the day that I went, Howse's had more fudge flavor options than Kilwin's.

Terrible customer service mid fudge expensive everything i hear yelling from the back when I went…read morethere 10/10 wouldn't recommend

Headed over after the Jack Pine Lumberjack show, the ticket stubs had coupons for fudge- Win/Win!…read moreGrabbed pizza from Fox's Den pizza and enjoyed some ice cream. Marshall's staff was friendly & helpful - highly recommend the cherry cordial fudge!

Of all the MANY fudge shops in Mackinaw City (we counted 7!), Marshall's wins our vote. Not only…read moreare they actually making fudge on premises and on display, they are the most welcoming, friendly, and informative shop. The staff all went out of their way to satisfy our curiosity about their vast selection of fudge, candies, chocolates, and flavored popcorn, but they also provided us with tips and ideas of other things to do in the area. A shout-out to Brittany for her fantastic hospitality! We actually went to Marshall's twice!

How cute is this little ice cream/fudge shop! We were itching for something sweet and walked past…read morethis darling store. They were making the waffle cones fresh, you never see that! So of course we had to try one. We got a scoop of the turtle cheese cake and petoskey pothole. They were perfectly creamy and the flavor just bursted in your mouth. We also got a caramel apple for the little, they certainly weren't disappointed. The store felt like a blast from the past with an antique and classic feel. The service was polite, well organized and kind. I want to go back and try more ice cream flavors and fudge! If you're in town on a hot day, definitely stop in this ice cream store!

Where the locals go great flavors, you can order from the park side and stand outside or go inside…read moreoff Howard Street. Better prices than Kilwins and better quality. Their waffle cones are so good! Try anything with cherry and chocolate or the Caramel Coffee Latte. Their team is always friendly. We have a tradition of stopping in after the parade on the 4th of July, with a line out the door both ways, and they are all still smiling even if it's 90 degrees from customers letting all the A/C out. The owner always works the holiday too. And I mean always, this is a 15-year tradition, and a great experience every time!

While staying in mackinaw city on vacation, we stopped here pretty much every night; we love…read morekilwins ice cream. The staff are very friendly and even though the store is small they have an exit on the other side after you pay to help the line move along. The area is great- its right by mackinaw crossings so we were able to shop and let our child play on the playground after enjoying some icecream. Plenty of parking in the lots nearby when we came (in summer on a weekend).

The Toasted Coconut ice cream here is one of my favorites! Highly recommend trying it!read more

I love their double chocolate expresso fudge. Friendly services. Clean shop. Live fudge making…read moreexperience.

Amazing, fast service and yummy fudge, taffy, and caramel popcorn!…read more As soon as we arrived, the staff behind the counter were so friendly and offered to help us and gave us free samples of the fudge. The fudge samples were a generous amount and so good! We decided on the double dark chocolate fudge, assortment of taffies, and caramel corn (with peanuts). We loved the experience and would recommend it to all tourists of the island!

Even the artwork displays the level of quality they have. With ai artwork along their walls, it's…read moreplain to see why their products taste horrendous. They make homemade icecream despite not seeming to know what they're doing in that department. And their fudge isn't that good either, which explains why they refuse samples for health reasons despite doing samples (only one per customer) with their icecream. If they cannot do fudge samples in a clean and safe manner then I have concerns about their cleanliness. According to yelp they got marked down by the health department for not washing their hands so maybe that was for the best. I wished I noticed the ai art originally because it'd at least warn me that their products, and frankly their workers, were disappointing at best. I assumed they would know how to do either icecream or fudge in Mackinac City but clearly not.

Cheap ingredients and cheap hot fudge sauce, hot fudge sauce was cold poured from plastic…read morecontainer, felt ripped off from this place, definitely not premium fresh made ice cream

$33 for 3 pieces of fudge. $15 brittle boxes…read more The store in town sells Moomers Traverse City cherry ice cream (that waa deeeeelishus).

They don't say too much when you come into the store- I guess to let you browse but it was a little…read moreawkward. No prices are posted anywhere - she said 'it has to be weighed' - how about just a sign with the normal lb price somewhere besides the scale? So sharing here- $25.95/lb for just a single slice purchase. This is a gift for our family reunion so will weigh in on taste later. They do have specials - I've posted the current ones, but you have to buy quite a bit more and we just don't have room for anything else at the moment. Smells amazing in here tho.

Sadie's Ice Cream Parlor was the perfect sweet ending to my first day at the Grand! The hospitality…read morewas just as warm as you'd hope, with friendly staff who made choosing from their wonderful variety of flavors a fun challenge. I chose the Peanut Butter Mackinac Fudge, and it was pure creamy goodness--rich, decadent, and packed with generous ribbons of peanut butter and chunks of Mackinac fudge. Every bite was absolutely delicious and left with wanting more! One of my favorite things is how conveniently Sadie's is attached to the Grand Hotel. As a hotel guest, it's was a treat to grab my ice cream and (after 6:30 p.m while dressed according to the evening dress code), enjoy it while relaxing in the beautiful Parlor. It adds an extra touch of charm to an already memorable Grand Hotel experience. Whether you're craving a classic favorite or a signature flavor, Sadie's is absolutely worth a stop. Delicious ice cream, genuine hospitality, and an elegant setting made it much more than just a place for dessert.

Sadie's ice Cream Parlor was quite the treat. It's really expensive but everything is on the…read moreisland. The restaurant is cute. I got the chocolate chip croffle. It is a croissant pressed in a waffle iron. I've never heard of it before so it's definitely unique. The line is always really long, but it moves really fast.