My wife and I have been on a search--quest if you will--for the best Key Lime pie. Silly us. We figured it would be somewhere in the land of Key Limes--Florida. Nope, they are made right here in Smyrna, Georgia. Even with the GPS--this place was hard to find. They do not keep even and odd street numbers on the same side. We ended up driving by it twice, before giving up and calling them. Turns out they are located between Amazon and a little Gun store which I found out on leaving was Glock. What could be more American than a pie factory and a gun factory as neighbors for each other. Anyway, the key limes are squeezed fresh on the premises. They had something like ten different pies they make, though some were out of stock due to lasting effects of Covid. They do not ship their pies any longer, so if you are going to want them shipped you are going to have to find a concierge service to do it for you. This is not a pie shop. This is the factory where you go to the plixiglass window and get your deep frozen pies. The lady who waited on us was very polite, full of Southern 'niceness'. They only take cash or checks. No credit cards. What makes it the perfect Key Lime Pie? Color(pale green), taste, sweet, but yet tart, pie filling almost like a truffle, but not as firm, but melts into a slow gentle explosion with your taste buds. And finally the crust, which I have no idea how they make but is so tasty, and resists becoming soggy, and has little morsels of crunchiness. Only thing it needs is a dollop of whipped cream which I took care of forthwith. read more

Love these pies! I usually keep my freezer stocked with a variety of mini pies...yum! Their receptionist is very friendly! read more

Excellent taste and convenience. Kenny has key lime locked in and a great pie! We use it for our club meals/deserts.

I recently worked here and unfortunately had a very disappointing experience. I had a family emergency and was out Monday and Tuesday, but I made sure to communicate with my supervisor, Penny. I even asked if it was okay to return on Wednesday and she said yes -- so I came in and worked both Wednesday and Thursday. During those days, they were trying to figure out a brand new machine that was very stressful and constantly messing up. I stayed and did my part to help get things going even though it was chaotic. Then out of nowhere, on Thursday at 1:30 PM just 30 minutes before the shift ended Penny told me HR needed to see me. I asked her why and she claimed she didn't know, but clearly she did. I was blindsided when HR terminated me with no real explanation. It felt like they only brought me back for those two days because they were short-staffed and needed help with that machine, and once they didn't need me anymore, they let me go. I showed up, I communicated, and I did the work. I just wish I had been treated with more honesty and respect. read more

Weirdest tasting key lime pie. It's like super sweet lime scented yogurt in a mushy graham crust.

Best key lime pies out here taste like it's from key west!!! Delicious, great peoplw

I was somewhat disappointed. The Key Lime pie was short on LIME. I was expecting something a little more "tart." I purchased mine at Kroger in Atlanta. Perhaps I'll try another dessert, something with chocolate next time. Stephanie P. read more

I love Key Lime Pie so when I heard about Kenny's, I had to try it. Verdict? Delicious I've bought their pies at their main location in an office park on Highlands Parkway and at Kroger on South Atlanta Road. Their cold pies are amazing. Smooth and creamy. Not too light and not too heavy. The crust is substantial enough to hold the pie together. The subtle lime taste is authentic and not overpowering like those fake-tasting, fake-looking key lime pies around town. I've also had their Peanut Butter Pie covered in chocolate and in a chocolate crust. Oh my goodness. Pure Heaven. Kenny's Pies put a smile on my face. =) read more

See all

My sweet Kenny heard my most private thoughts of how to combine my shared love of both his Chocolate and Key Lime pies. As any good lover should he answer my longing with something better than my own desire. a key lime pie with a chocolate graham crust. I dare not tell you the levels of ecstasy we've reached together. I care enough to share his creation with you. Go get a Pie ,dammit. it'll make the world a better place. read more

Picked up a key lime at Kroger. Blown away. I'll have to visit them in Smyrna sometime and get the full selection. Great work Kenny and team! We will continue to seek y'all out. read more

I'm a fan of their key lime, as well as the peanut butter pies. Absolutely the highest quality prepared to perfection.

By far the greatest pie I have ever bought. Picked it up at Meijer on a whim and OMG it was so delicious. Looking forward to my next one. P.S. it was the 10" Peanut butter with Chocolate crust and topping. read more

I just discovered the key lime pie at Kroger a few weeks ago and I've been addicted since! I will literally make a trip to Kroger if I run out. Even my kids know NOT to touch my pie! I thought it couldn't get any better until I just discovered y'all have a store/restaurant in Smyrna and that y'all have many other pies to choose from. I promise you, as soon as I save up some extra money (lost my job due to covid), the kids and I are taking a trip to Smyrna and we're going to buy one of everything! I. CANT. WAIT. Amazing filling! AMAZING crust! I'm definitely hooked! Thank you!!! Kayla H read more

Kenny & Company, I was grocery shopping at my local Food Lion located in Inwood, WV. and your lovely green label on a Peanut Butter Pie caught my eye, I dont know when or how your AMAZING pies became available in my area, but Kenny KEEP THOSE PIES COMING!!! It was absolutely the best pie I've ever had !!! Im the kitchen manager at a local restaurant, and have been employed as a cook for many years so I definitely know a good pie . Now that I've had the opportunity to try the Peanut butter I'm going to need a promise from you Kenny, promise that your pies in a variety of flavors will continue to be available in my area. Dont be a pie tease Kenny, thats not nice Don't force me to take a week off to travel to Georgia to stock up on pies!! Simply an amazing product, delicious!!! Thank you, Amy Patton read more

I'm not one for key lime pie but my finacee is more in love with it at times then he is with me! So I grudgingly made a trip out to Kenny's to pick him up a little treat, but when I arrived to my surprise they also sold chocolate creme pie! Score! The location is not an actually bakery shop, more like the company headquarters. When you enter there is a tiny window where you purchase your pies though, and they only accept cash or check. The treats come frozen so you have to wait a bit for them to thaw out. The Mr. raved about the key lime pie, although I didn't taste any. The chocolate creme pie..well that is another story!! It was super rich and creamy, but there was something about the crust I didn't care for. All in all 4 stars for the key lime pie, which must have been good! Because it was consumed by only one person in less than 3 days! read more

Being a connoisseur of all things decadent, I have to admit that Kenny's Great Pies has the BEST Key Lime pie I have ever tasted. The crust is a perfect combination of graham and butter, a sublime marriage of crunchy and light. The pie filling has the most unbelievable creamy texture. It is just thick enough to stand on its own, but so creamy it melts in your mouth like a fine Belgian chocolate. The Key Lime flavor is absolutely divine. There is not even a hint of aftertaste, reminiscent of chemically based pie flavor. The lime is fresh and tart with just a touch of sweetness. Absolute perfection! I also tried their new addition, the Chocolate Creme pie. Holy moly, people! What a delight! The crust was the same as the Key Lime, just delectable, and that chocolate creme filling! Wow! The texture was creamy and mousse like, with less air and more chocolate. Every bite was better than the last, and for a mere $7, you can take home one of their tasty, yet "cosmetically challenged" pies. I don't know about you, but I am not attracted to pie by way of looks, but flavor, and the flavor here can not be beat. Honestly, I would not call these cosmetically challenged at all. I thought both of the pies looked great and would not know the difference between an imperfect and a regular pie. I will definately forgo the traditional pumpkin pie this year, and indulge the family with these very special pies...both of them. read more

I just wanted to write you and let you know I have been trying to find out where CPK get's their Key Lime pie. I have been trying to find for 5 years. Finally, a waiter here in Grapevine Texas told me. You guys have the best I have ever had. I have traveled from Chicago, Atlanta, and all over Texas and no one comes close. Keep up the great work! read more

Well, these guys are gonna be my downfall: Kenny's has expanded their selection by adding chocolate cream pie with regular and chocolate graham cracker crusts. When I stopped by last week, there was actually a list of about 8 kinds of pies but I can't remember them all now. Costs seem to have gone up a bit and the "cosmetically-challenged" seem to be less available. The regular sized small pies cost me $8. Oh well, that's fine. Well worth the price. BTW, these guys are right next to Glock, the gun manufacturer. I don't know why that seems important... just seems funny to me. read more

Hands down the best key lime pie I have ever had (outside of the one at Houstons Restaurant). These tasty little treats are pretty cheap. While I didn't actually go to the building to try them out, I was hooked once I got the chance to sample Kenny's pies. I had a bunch of different flavors....key lime pie, mango key lime pie, and also a chocolate concoction that I cant remember, but I know it was equally amazing. I think the smaller pies are around $2-$3 bucks. You cant beat em... read more

I feel like I've been had. Not only does this pie not taste anything like key limes, it tastes like some sort of artificial lime scented cleaner. It's not worth the money or the calories. read more

I got my first Kenny's from Kroger. The Key lime pie was very rich and creamy. It was too rich for my taste but everyone else liked it. Very reasonable (around $8?) for what you get. I will buy it for next get together. read more

Kenny's Great Pies - Desserts Near Me - Smyrna, Georgia

Have always loved their Key Lime, but this week I had their Strawberry Lemonade pie. Oh My Gah! It's fantastic and a great pie for Summer. Great as a gift, too! Love it! read more

I bought the pie from a Foodtown in Red Bank, NJ. My expectations for a grocery store bought key lime pie are typically low, but this pie is delicious! The crust is very good and the filling is just the right flavor and texture. It's not too sweet, which I find many grocery store pies to be. This pie was such a pleasant surprise. I'm eating a slice for breakfast right now =). read more

Key lime was delish. Not a fan of tart pies but excellent crust and filling. Pleasantly surprised, purchased at Kroger's in Marietta.

I love Kenny's Key Lime Pie. I first had it while living in Atlanta and was knocked out. My very clever spouse tracked down the Kenny's and once back in Washington state, we periodically order a half dozen of the pies next day shipped to us. I especially enjoy eating them in the dead of winter as a reminder of better weather to come. They make spectacular take alongs to dinner parties or potlucks, eliciting moans of pleasure. I cannot recommend them highly enough. Get some today. read more

Have you ever been to Ted's Montana Grill, Atkins Park, O'Charley's or any Longhorn Steaks in Atlanta and had the key lime pie for dessert? Well, you're smokin' crack if you think they actually make that pie but you have to admit that it is REALLY GOOD! I did a bit of sleuthing (pays to know the owner of some of these establishments) only to discover that one company HERE IN SMYRNA makes them! Kenny's Great Pies (formerly known as "Kenny's Key Lime Pie") has a long history in the Smyrna area. They're now located in the business district of Highlands Parkway between South Cobb Drive and the East/West Connector and get this, folks...THEY SELL TO THE PUBLIC!!! That's right! You can stop by there (during business hours) and pick up a pie for that dinner party or holiday dinner! You can't tour the facility so don't go planning a huge field trip for your third graders. As a matter of fact, you can only go in the front door and there is a window where you order your pie, pay the person your cash and they take it directly out of the freezer and you're back on the road in 2 minutes! YELP HINT!!! Ask for the "cosmetically challenged" pie and you can get it for $7/pie! Don't be a freakin' snob people. Admit it that you have actually bought "irregular" clothing before and you had to search to find what was wrong with it! You may find that a "cosmetically challenged" pie has a small crack in the (sinfully delicious) graham cracker crust or that the pie filling is a little off centre. Your guests will never know the difference and if they do, shove a fork full of key lime in their PIE HOLE and they'll shut up in no time! They also carry a Mango Pie for those of you who don't care for Key Lime and I think those are $1 more (cosmetically challenged, of course). I've not had that one so I can't speak for it's quality. But for the key lime? One bite and your mouth suddenly develops its own gravitational field. You cannot eat just one bite! If you're on a diet, just allow yourself one indulgence and you'll thank me. You'll be the star of your holiday party if you show up with one of these pies! If you're traveling for Thanksgiving or Christmas, you can easily ship them as they're already listed in the "Freezes Beautifully" section of your favourite cookbook! Seriously, this not-so-well-kept secret is a gem. Your guests will be eyeing that pie at the dessert table like a cheetah eyes a gazelle with a limp. Go get yourself 2 or three for the holidays! I have six in my freezer right now so I'm set for the next month so I'll leave it with the rest of you to go fight it out to get your share! :) read more

Just bought a Kenny's key lime pie this evening at Kroger. It looked homemade and good. I am enjoying a slice as I write. This is just delicious! read more

I honestly was not that impressed with their pies. I purchased 2 - chocolate creme and key lime. I can makes both of these pies a hell of a lot better. read more

I work 10 minutes from Kenny's but didn't hear about it until I was eating at the Columbia Restaurant in Ybor City in Tampa, FL. I had a delicious key lime pie and asked the waiter if they made it in the kitchen. He said, "Don't repeat this but they come from Kenny's Pies in Atlanta." I think I have also had their Key Lime and Mango Pies at the Cuban Diner in Marietta. I'm going over there after work to bring home a Mango Pie! Yum! read more

Been to Key West and had the REAL Key Lime pie and I must say this is the business people!!! So refreshing on a hot day or just when you have a sweet tooth! I got my first one at Taste of Smyrna and I am luvin it! read more

I can vouch for the Mango Pie. It is better than Heaven, hands down. It is the same pie that is served at R. Thomas. I am so glad that Kenny's sells to the public. It is WELL worth the drive and the flavor can't be beat! read more

I like key lime pie, but I LOVE Kenny's Key Lime Pie, and to find out that you can purchase pies at a discount, wow that is out of control. The lady who helped me with my selection was wonderful too, also this place is located next door to Glock, how does it get any better than that !!! read more

Well I just tried their peanut butter pie last night at Figo and it is the most perfect combination of sweet and PB on an Oreo- type crust with chocolate ganache on top that you will ever put in your mouth. My only complaint, I didn't get enough of it! Just found out that they sell to the public and their office is right near our house. I'm in deep trouble. read more

I LOVE Key Lime Pie and Kenny's is the BEST! I wish all retailers would carry them but so far, I've only been able to find them at Kroger. The mini's are easy but not enough to satisfy my sweet tooth! LOL! The crust is perfect, the creamy texture of the pie melts in your mouth...not too sweet, just perfect! read more

I stopped by their booth at Taste of Smyrna and only got one Peanut Butter Mini pie. If I had of known they were as good as they were, I would have brought the booth out! I got home and took it out the freezer and it was too die for! Creamy, crunchy and delicious! They have a loyal customer in me FOREVER! read more

My office is just down the street from Kenny's so someone seems to bring in their pies at least once a month. These pies go faster than any dessert, cake, pie or sweet that ever makes its way into our office. EVERYONE loves Kenny's Pies! SOOOOOOOOOO GOOD! It's almost unbearable to wait around for them to thaw out enough to eat. read more

Ehhhh. I bought 7 pies for Thanksgiving....was hoping for better than I would get from Publix or Kroger. Considering this place was a bit out of the way, and I had to leave to go find an atm because they only take cash or check, quality and cost of the pies, I won't be going back. The pie wasnt bad, just not worth the extra cost and effort. read more

The best lemon & chocolate silk pies ever! Every year they are at The Taste of Smyrna & the entire staff is extra friendly! They sell a great quality product! read more

Best pies ever! Key Lime is awesome and the peanut butter chocolate is AMAZING! Best pie I've ever tasted.

OMG !! ( I hate the overuse of this abbreviation but seem to have lost my prickly attitude behind this pie!) I tasted Kenny's Mini Key Lime Pie at a breakfast meeting... yes, breakfast. All I can say is the sun rose, theheavens open wide and I was complete. The meeting host gave me a couple for the road and, while I ate the first one at home, I searched the net for local vendors. And what did I find? Kenny's pies are made in smyrna, GA... a short drive from anywhere in Metro-Atlanta. Well, Kenny and I will definitely be seeing a lot of each other... reviews boasted of a fabulous Chocolate Silk pie and a Peanut Butter pie too.... read more