This is an old school nostalgic restaurant. Even though it was opened in 1978, its decorations looks older than that. They have a few parking spots in the front, all of which are handicap spots. They have a decent amount of parking spots in the back. There is a decent sized dining area that is decorated like it is the 1960 with old school memorabilia and Coca-Cola stuff. If you are dining in you must place your order at the counter first. I decided to dine in. There are two counters, one on each side of the restaurant, only one was open during my visit. I guess that is where they get the "twin" in its name. The restaurant serves salads, pizza, burgers, spaghetti and other Italian entrees. I got the lasagna, which came with bread and a salad or you could substitute the salad for extra bread. They did not have fries. But they did have potato wedges, which is what I got to complete my meal. It took about 10 minutes for me to get my food and they brought it to my table. It was fresh and hot. The lasagna was small and tasted ok. I have had better, and I have had worse. The potato wedges were pretty good. They do not come with catsup though. You have to request it. All in all, this is a neat little mom and pop diner. It really takes you back. I think that it does miss the mark on table service though. I am glad to see that they got with the times and do now accept credit cards, as a few years ago they did not. I always love supporting local. read more

We were presenting at the school next door so decided to grab a quick lunch during the break and this spot was given as the best option. We arrived a few minutes before they opened but they were quick to welcome us and get us started on the options. Once you enter there is a counter where you order with a menu on the wall as well as a board with lunch specials. I got the spaghetti with marinara which also came with a substantial salad and garlic bread sticks. There are several rooms for seating with both booths as well as tables. The decor is very fun and festive and definitely Coke oriented! We weren't seated too long before our meals were brought to the table, and things were hot and fresh and smelled wonderful. My spaghetti was an ample portion with a lot of sauce which I mopped up with the tasty bread. The rest of the party are their food with gusto so I'm assuming they liked it. It is a fun spot for a quick lunch or dinner and they had lots of options for hot sandwiches or cooked food. read more

See all

Absolutely love Kasey's. Great family owned business. You can never beat a classic coke in a glass bottle. We enjoy the pizza and bread sticks but the sandwiches are great too. They have good specials as well. read more

5 Stars because its worth it. We always stop at Kacey's when visiting the GRents. I love the atmosphere. Its like traveling back in time the minute you walk in. There is soon much Cocoa Cola memorabilia that you find yourself walking around the entire shop. There are 2 sides to irder from this joint. one side is dedicated to pizzas, and the other to sammiches subs and extras. I like this concept. It cuts down on a lot of time and you van have your apps before you neal comes. Or if you're like Bean, your app is your meal. the pizza skins here are so delicious. They are always our starter. I came for the pizza. My medium pizza w 3 toppings and well spent $18. The pizzas are massive and the baked in goodness just warms my heart. I've not been disappointed w a meal since I've started eating her. After our meal, we stayed a bit to play tic tac toe. Kaceys encourages family fun time! I kicked Beans butt per usual. She took me to my fan Greenwood ice cream shop Mrs. Curl. You all may know that from previous reviews. Bottom line, if you're in Whiteland head down to Kaceys. read more

See all

Kasey's Twin Eatery is a quaint little food spot in Whiteland, IN. We were directed here by a friendly local guy while looking at some antique gas station signs near by. The place is a small little eatery decorated in Coca Cola memorabilia. The set up is a little weird at first; you order pizza at one counter and all your other food at another counter. We ordered a large pizza with hamburger and black olives as well as 2 orders of spaghetti for the kids. The pizza was amazing; a close cousin to a Chicago style pizza with thick thick mozzarella cheese on top. The crust was perfectly browned and the tomato sauce was just right. The spaghetti was also really good. A mound of buttered spaghetti noodles complimented with a nice robust marinara sauce. Each plate came with a big tossed salad and Italian bread on the side. This was a great unexpected find while on vacation visiting the area. All my Hoosier friends and family are lucky to have this close by. read more

Kacey's Twin Eatery - A large pizza from Kasey's Twin Eatery - Pizza Near Me - Whiteland, Indiana

I wasn't too impressed, as I first time customer, but it's likely I will return for a second impression. I like the interior, although a little dim in the dining area. I wouldn't call this a typical dinner date spot. I do want this place to stay around, since it's great business for the Whiteland Community. Here's a few things I liked: Pros: Front counter gave me a large foam cup for just water! Amazing...now I didn't have to make multiple visits to the refill station. The amount of bread was generous, although a little too buttery. Interior decor was decorated well with a Coca-Cola theme. It wasn't boring, but had lots of memorabilia to look at. Cons: The Lasagna was a little bare without much of a ricotta layer. Cheese layer was spotty...not a full layer. The salad was as cheap tasting as possible: not tasty shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, and shredded cheddar cheese. Also came in foam, like the drink. They are too foam happy. I'd rather see paper cups that can be better recycled. Why can't they use regular drinking cups that they can wash? They only accept cash, not credit/debit. I would recommend to try yourself to get your own personal opinion. Next time, I will try pizza. read more

Kacey's Twin Eatery - Lunch Special: Lasagna, Salad, and Bread - Pizza Near Me - Whiteland, Indiana

See all

I don't know why I waited so long to try this place out! I love mom and pop joints and this place definitely fits the bill. They have a pretty large menu, with pizza, sandwiches, and pasta. Plus, the decor is pretty sweet, it's a mini Coca Cola museum, the walls are covered with memorabilia. I generally always get the spaghetti lunch special. For $8.04 (after tax) you get a large plate of spaghetti, garlic bread, a salad, and a drink (free refills). You have to place your order at the counter and get refills yourself, but they bring your food out to whatever booth or table you're at. Oh another big thing. Cash or check only! read more

Alright, I've lived within biking distance, if not walking distance to Kacey's for about eight years now, a little longer. In that time, I've been to the establishment three times. My partner, who has lived here for...well...lots of years...I'm not sure when Kacey's came to being so I'm not sure who was first...anyway, he has always warned me against it. I've officially determined he was making the right call. First and foremost, the obvious complaint is that it is a cash or check only establishment. I totally understand, I really do. Small businesses can't necessarily make the investment required to take credit and debit cards. But...it still sucks. Sorry...it just does. The first time, I went in with my partner...this was years ago and after a couple years or so of subtly convincing him to go, btw...but I got him convinced! Once we were inside and placing our order, it took me about five minutes to realize why he didn't enjoy the place. The person behind the counter was seriously rude and acted completely inconvenienced by our presence. But the food was alright, not too unreasonably priced and basic fun Italian. Okay, whatever. Fast forward a couple years, I've convinced myself it was just a bad day at the establishment, it's time to support the local business yet again despite the prior experience. Exact.Same.Happening. Employee, rude and inconvenienced. Me, completely uncomfortable and regretful that I decided to patronize the establishment but the food wasn't bad and the prices were fine. Yet again, fast forward years later, to only a few days ago. I suppose this is where the real review begins. All these years later, cards aren't accepted. Whatever, I knew that, I went to CVS to get cash specifically to get Kacey's because I really wanna support them. Luckily, this time, the cashier wasn't overtly unfriendly. Not friendly, just not unfriendly, which I think it totally fine, I just want to order food and not feel as though I shouldn't have walked into the place. I'm not lookin' to make buddies. However, they were cleaning the parking lot, which is fine, but the downside comes later. I get my food and, btw, the cashier was nice enough to even bring it out to me and hand it directly to me. No shouting from the counter or subtle eye rolling, just, take my order, help me with the menu a bit when I didn't realize the menu out wasn't the full menu, then bring me my food...she is the _only_ reason this isn't a one star review. I get my food and start for the door, where the men apparently in charge of the lot cleaning just sorta cut me off as I'm walking and shut the door behind them. No, I don't expect the door to be held open for me or anything like that...but I was carrying food, had to kick the door open and when I walked out they were just kinda...standing there...watching a dude pressure clean the parking lot. And as I walked by, it smelled awful and water got on me...I hate to say you had to be there but that's probably all that is, yet I still found it frustrating. Finally leaving and getting home with the food, it's time to eat. Two dishes were ordered, the lasagna and the chicken parmesan...that's what brought this review to life. Normally the food is bearable and, "Fine, whatever, I don't care." Not this time. The lasagna had no flavor outside of some basic cheese and tomato sauce. The chicken parmesan was, frankly, disgusting. I could barely bite into the...stringy? Is that the word...I'm not sure...it was tough, hard to chew and felt mildly bony. That's what it tasted like to me...it was kinda gag worthy honestly. The bread and salads were nothing to write home about in my opinion. In conclusion, I will _never_, _ever_ go out of my way to patronize them again. Admittedly, they lost a customer that _literally_ only ate there every few years...but...considering how much I eat out...had I not had such consistently poor experiences, I would have been a valued, loyal client. In the future...I'll just go to Fazoli's at this point. read more

My family and I had dinner here tonight and it was excellent. This is a great place to relax and have dinner with the family. It is very cozy and they have tons of Coca-Cola stuff everywhere! We've been here a few times before and had their pizza, which is good, but tonight we had our favorite the baked lasagna. They have a nice menu to choose from, so I'm sure you'll find something you like. They have great service here, they are very nice. I'd have to say that it's a bit of an inconvenience that they don't take debit or credit cards, but yet they take checks? If you are driving along US 31 and happen to see Kacey's, give it a try you'll become a fan! read more

See all

5 stars, seriously, 5 stars all around. The pizza here is loaded with a hearty amount of mouth dominating cheese and toppings. The environment is top notch and looks like a mini coca cola museum. Plus, this a ma and pa place in its truest form and the friendly service puts this on display at all times. Pros: Incredible Pizza, serious, maybe the best in the area Friendly People Museum Bottle Cap Tic Tac Toe Glass Bottled Cokes Friendship Cons: They don't take debit/credit Even with the debit card issue, their is a Key Bank ATM directly next to Kacey's so this should be the least of your worries. The 10,000 lbs of friendship at this place should cover any squabbling inconveniences you might have. Much love read more

The interior is basically one giant Coca Cola ad. Lots of cool old pieces, knick knacks, and clippings. Tried a pepperoni pizza and breadsticks. They were delicious! The wife and I both enjoyed it. We were looking for a good local pizza joint and I think we've found a new regular stop. read more

We live just across the street from Kacey's but only eat here about once or twice a year. The pizza is great as well as the pasta and sandwhiches but they are overpriced and portions are pretty small. If you decide to eat here they only take cash so make sure you dont order and show up with only your debit or credit card. The atmosphere is cool and reminds you of an old soda shop. read more

To start off we can walked in the door and thought it was cool looking inside with all the Coca-Cola items. Then noticed it was pretty warm inside. Then asked the lady at the counter if we order from the counter. Her counter was not for pizza orders it was for the other stuff like sandwiches and pasta. She just said go in there for pizza. So we thought she meant go sit down. Only 2 other tables occupied. Seen 2 teenage girls working/ talking to a customer. No one acknowledged us. We sat there for a good while then my mom decided to go order a sandwich so she walked to the front counter and ordered and found out that there was a back counter. "We was suppose to know that" you couldn't see it. So I ordered my pizza and sat back down. Meanwhile breaking a sweat and face turning red. the pizza came I really liked the crust but hated the sauce on the . My mom really likes the sandwich she ordered. If I go back I will have to get no sauce or very little. Oh and the fountain pop machine on the sprite was confusing too. It had a arrow that said push for sprite but doing that tasted like carbonated water or something so I pushed it and pushed the normal silver bar at the same time still didn't taste quite right. read more

. This the best pizza in the area and the sandwitcha's are very good also. The decore is nastalgek and the staff is curtius and frendly. So if you like pizzeria food this is a must try place to go, eat in or take out I recommend it. read more

I really feel strongly about eating local, or shopping small but when a restaurant literally doesn't want your business, you can tell! I ordered lunch today and after I ordered each item she said is that all? No I'll let you know when I'm done ordering. I'm very picky I know this and I try very hard to be extremely polite when ordering things especially when it deviates from what comes on it. I ordered a side salad with extra cheese only no tomato no dressing I heard her say at this annoyance, really I'm saving you money! It didn't get better when I showed up to get my order, I felt like I had done something wrong. And just so you know all of that terrible customer service spilled over into the food out of all the things that my daughter and I and my grandson ordered the only thing edible was her Stromboli. We didn't get napkins we didn't get dipping sauce we didn't get utensils apparently all of that doesn't come with a to go order nowadays. So basically what I'm saying is drive on by this place is not worth it I wish I had my $33 back! read more

Food is great. Sandwiches are the best. Pizza is great. The Owner Operaters Have great customer service. the coke memorabilia is just icing on the cake. It is a must see. read more

The pizza is delicious! However, I've waited over 15 minutes past my pick up time (more then 3 times) on lunch which has caused my lunch break to be over when I got back to work. I always call with 40 + minutes to cook my pizza. I recommend calling in 45-50 minutes before you need it picked up. read more

I love this place. The pizzas are great and I love the stromboli sub. We eat here frequently. The staff is always friendly.

Sausage pizza is the best. Great coke shop. Coke in the glass bottle is the best. Seriously best pizza ever

They do not take debit/credit cards. I have had the lasagna and the pizza and both were way to greasy and rubbery. Not very good in my opinion... read more

Listen I LOVE supporting local businesses, but it is important when businesses at least attempt to keep up with the current century. We are big fans of a local pizza place, so it has taken us awhile to make a point to try Kaceys. We made plans to order take out. The menu online has no prices so I called, explained to the lady on the phone we had never ordered from them and wondered if she could explain their prices. She was kind and thorough, but never mentioned they ONLY TAKE CASH!!! We showed up to pick up our pizza. Mind you we live less than 2 miles from Kacey's. We arrive only to find out that don't take bank cards. The lady at the restaurant told us there was an ATM next door, but we didn't want to pay the bank fee so we hoped in the car ant drove 4 miles to Franklin to our bank to get cash. We turned around, came back only for the same cashier to tell us if we would've used to ATM next door they would've discounted our bill by the bank fee we were charged!!!! The pizza was pretty good, but honestly the lack of convenience will probably end up in us never going back. It might have a lot to do with why a cute restaurant like this place is, with good food only had 4 tables occupied on a Friday night. read more

We have been driving from the Southwest side of Indy for years to go to Kacey's Love this place and the pizzas are the best.