Arrived at 8 pm on a holiday weekend to a packed dining room - which is a great sign. Self seating…read moreand casual atmosphere. Waited about 6 minutes for a cleaned booth and to place our pizza order. A large half pepperoni, light sauce and Oven Combo. Pizza was served piping hot. The crust is thin and crispy. Both halves of the pizza were flavorful and delicious. I would order the same pizza again

Best Pizza in Southern Minnesota. The thick crust slices at lunch are a deal. Everyone in the…read moreregion loves Jake's Pizza in Albert Lea!

This is a disappointing review because I loved this place as a child. It has gone downhill so far…read morethat I have decided to give up on them. The buffet is just gross. The last time I ordered take out, after an hour of waiting, I just gave up and asked for a refund. They seem overwhelmed by high volume, and they just can't keep up. Staff was indifferent to my issues and just offered a refund when they couldn't produce my order. Not going to return.

I get a pizza from here once a year to remind me why I don't more often…read morePizza is flavorless and has very little topping on it Nice staff

I grew up going to Jake's, so when we were on a four hour road trip north this past week, we had to…read moreswing over and have some of that amazing thin crust cut party style- exactly how I remembered it. The restaurant was fairly similar to how it used to be in the 80s, too, from what I can still remember anyway. We called ahead so it would be ready and we could get in, eat, and get back on the road. The server was great! We got two pizzas, both of which were perfect. That crust is unbeatable!

We were in town for a Doctor appointment Fantastic pizza and matching service!…read moreVery extensive menu. We will be back.

Very cute unique Christmas Pop-up bar. Great holiday ambiance, service was excellent too. Fun…read morelittle spot to go to for a fun experience.

Passing through and so happy we stopped! Fantastic drinks and great atmosphere. We would have…read morestayed longer if time allowed. We will definitely be back. Thank you Embars!!

Pizza was crap, wasn't what I asked for. I ordered a pizza that was going to be ready for 7 pm…read moredidn't get it tell it was 30 min late then to top it all off it wasn't what I ordered. Staff wasn't very nice

We got takeout the pizza was delicious and the order was on time. I would like to try different…read morekinds one day.

In a town of amazing pizza, Pagliai's stands alone at the TOP of the mountain! Cheese glorious,…read morecheese! Plenty of staff to crank out the eat in orders. A nostalgic place like this should have Coke products, but I didn't come here to drink soda. They have 6 beers on tap, including Modest, a twin cities best in class craft beer.

We ordered Happy Joe's while camping at Flandrau State Park up the road on a Friday evening. The…read morefood wasn't ready in the time provided, but about 10 minutes after. When we visited, the restaurant seating was closed. Based on the conversations around me, they had not opened it. It seemed like the location was recently opened (or reopened?) and working with limited staff. All in all, we really enjoyed the food. The dough was surprisingly fluffy!

For a place called New Ulm, I think this place compliments the Schell's brewery beer nicely. We…read moreordered the Joe Special with saurkraut and the flavor and texture was on point!! I would order it again. Our server was also super kind, super young, and super social. Really enjoyed the small town feel, arcades in the back for my son to play and redeem in ice cream!! I definitely will return and try other things. Oh yeah the wings were what you would expect, average price...those Broasted chicken though was just spectacular.

This was a decent pizza. I'd happily come here again. The location is very eclectic and fun. They…read moreeven have pinball! I got the taco pizza, which generally I consider blasphemous. But man, they were right. It WAS good.

Went back again after about a month and the experience was still so good. Got the taco pizza…read morebecause it is still the best i've ever had, and gave the Boderline 9 a try and that was outstanding as well. Pizza came out quicker than expected and the staff were very nice even though we came in close to closing time. Good music and vibe inside! Will keep coming back!

Amazing pizza! Friendly staff. It is the only pizza we order. Cash or check only but that is fine…read morewith us!

Excellent Everything pizza. Omigosh, packed full of so much meat and veggies . Delicious crust…read more Couldn't eat the whole medium do we took half home. It even tasted good cold! You can buy it by the slice. Try one slice if everything. Excellent!

Is there a zero star option? 2 Burnt pizzas. After calling…read morein to get new ones they said we had to drive back in the snowstorm to bring the old ones back as proof. So another 30 mile trip just to get two more burnt pizzas again, absolutely horrific. So much for a Friday night off of cooking. $25 and 60 miles later I ended up having to cook supper for our family at 9 o'clock at night .Zero apologies, nothing. Never ever again

Ordered online said it would be a 15 minute wait. Went inside to check in the girl at the counter…read moresaid a few more minutes. sit for another 10 minutes go through the pick window had to wait another 20 minutes. third time checking in we got our food. Wrong sauce on one the wings and the sauce amount should be criminal. not even 4 cars in the parking lot and only 2 tables inside that had already had food. No reason that It had to take 40+ minutes also women's bathroom was out of order told to use mens and it was disgusting didn't even wanna step in there overall 0/10 experience