Ordered a Sicilian pizza with extra cheese and pepperoni for delivery. Requested that the cheese be extra done ( brown) on top of pizza. The pizza was $19.61 which included delivery and tax? Scheduled delivery was for 8 pm and that's when the pizza was delivered. read more

Justino's Pizza - Extra cheese and pepperoni Sicilian pizza. Cooked perfectly and definitely was a delicious tasty pizza!! - Pizza Near Me - Newmanstown, Pennsylvania

The pizza was burnt the person that took my order had a major attiude and it was cold when it got to me and im only 6 min away read more

See all

VERY disappointed in the pizza we got today. Besides the fact us was delivered cold, it just didn't taste good like usual. Seems it was t cooked all the way thru! We ended up throwing it out because just the one piece we ate made us sick! Never again. read more

Best meatball subs around. When their balls are in my mouth, I'm a happy person. The cheesesteaks are delicious too. Plenty of tender meat to shove in your mouth. It's orgasmic for sure. read more

Good pizza And it's pretty like really like I mean no actually reallyyyyy good because it tastes good read more

Yummy cheesesteaks put in bread pocket's, calzone is to die for. Nice people, comfortable place to sit and enjoy your lunch or dinner. Very fast delivery also! read more

We love this place! They're the only shop that delivers to our house so we're very glad that the food is delicious. We typically get pizza and wings, the pizza is always great and the wings are always hot and crispy. Would definitely recommend! read more

First i placed a order and it took 1 hour after i called the place they told me they were not delivering the pizza we called agian asking for a buffalo chicken pizza it took 1 hour to come and it was the wrong pizza we got a Hawaiian pizza instead. read more

Not good food at all. Had cheese steaks and pizza. Cheese steaks were all roll. "Where's the meat? Where's the cheese? Where's the sauce?" Pizza had toppings sparingly. Would not recommend. read more

Justino's is our local pizza sho and the only one that delivers- a huge plus, in my eyes. The pizza is good but fairly inconsistent. A couple of times recently, we've received our pizzas with very very dark brown bottoms-- with some black spotting. Other times I feel like our pizza has been underdone. We've had their pizzas, stromboli, calzones and a couple of appetizers. I believe that they have changed cheeses recently. Whatever they're using now is so much better than what they were using before. My only gripe with Justino's is something not limited to them. I won't order subs or sandwiches from places that make their own rolls from pizza dough. Ugh. I think they're horrible, soft, doughy messes. I want a substantial roll from a bakery that has the right kind of crusty outside and these pizza rolls just don't cut it. read more

Love to come here when I'm in the area. Great food and they are really easy to work with about delivering the food too! Always comes fast and hot! Their calzones are seriously my favorite from any other place I've gotten them from and plenty big to share with a group read more

Awesome pizza shop with great subs and wings as well. Staff is amazing and love supporting a patriotic business.

Best pizza in town! Friendly staff! Fried Jalapeños with cheese is excellent! Stromboli

"I hate reviews like this bc they seem like a great family" Sorry about the wannabe professional food critic. I love everything about this place, especially the sandwich rolls. My family gets pizza, sandwiches, wings, fried apps, strombolis, bacon cheese fries and wraps at least twice a month. The food always tastes good and their sauce is never watered down( wannabe food critic) Don't change a thing - 12 read more

Great sandwiches, amazing service, hard workers. We didn't love our mozz sticks but everything else was really great.

Tried their hot wings and several different salads. I have been very happy with the food and the service. Prices seem reasonable. read more

Justino's Pizza - a stone building with a sign on the front - Pizza Near Me - Newmanstown, Pennsylvania

See all

I've been ordering chicken cheese steaks from this place for 10 years for delivery! Excellent food and 9/10 we always get the same super nice delivery man! This is on the top of our pizza shop list! Cons: no garlic knots Limited menu selection Their salads are awful! read more

Ate dinner here. Ordered special cheese steak (sauteed onions, mushrooms, and peppers and sauce). I added lettuce and tomato. Super-sized sandwich. Meat hot and cooked nice and tender. Quick and friendly service. Highly recommend. read more

They make great sandwiches and pizza. I would recommend this place for every one. They make the best Stromboli to their ham rolls are great their salads are awesome too read more

Ok, when you hit 2 stars on yelp two stars states "Could've been better." This couldn't be more perfect. But first let me start out by saying the day I was there they were busting their balls. They were super busy so I give them a pass for that. This is my first time there and they seem like a very hard working family so kudo's to them and god love them. I ordered a Pizza, sandwich and Moz sticks. The reason I always get Moz sticks when I visit a new pizza joint is bc I want to taste just their sauce which you get with the Moz sticks. The sauce was very watery and bland. Their pizza has a fairly wide crust which I don't mind at all. But if your going to have that type of crust, I suggest you baked it a little longer. My pie was doughy and lacked a fair amount of cheese.(which someone else also posted) And again, the pizza was bland, with very little taste, and no crisp whatsoever. I hate reviews like this bc they seem like a great family and they are in a small quiet town. I'm hoping they try and improve bc I really want to come back. Oh yeah, ditch the heavy doughy sandwich rolls, very bad. read more

Really just an average pizza shop. Enjoyable on game days and when I don't feel like driving further to get better tasting food. Pizza is good, but just a little too greasy. I ordered a Stromboli once and it was soaked in grease. read more

This small restaurant, it's made more for ordering pizza than eating in. The pizza is good, and there are many other refreshments there. I recommend people to order here for a local spot. I like this place! read more

We used to love justinos when we moved here 14 years ago, however we stopped ordering from them because the last several times the crust was burnt, the pizza arrived cold even though we only live a mile from them and now we found multiple other shops in our area that now deliver so Justinos is no long our only choice. On the several occasions we picked up our order rather than have it delivered I saw employees go from handling cash to handling food and messing with their hair, sneezing or coughing and answer the phone and returning to food prep and again not washing their hands. read more

Great food and very friendly service. I was pleasantly surprised as this restaurant is located in Newmanstown of all places! I will definitely return and order the pizza again. Great taste, crispy the way I like and priced well. read more

After placing an order around 7pm on a friday night, i finally recieved my food at about 8:15. If the wait wasnt so long i would definitely give this business 5 stars. The food however was amazing. I got a meat lovers boli and bacon cheddar fries. The fries werent crunchy but had that boardwalk appeal, and the perfect amount of cheddar and bacon. I will definitely be ordering from here again, but maybe not at the time i did on a friday evening. read more

We used to love infinitos but for the past year every pizza we order has come with burnt crust. It seems evident that the booming business is more than justin can handle. Staff and owners are far from friendly and treat customers and towns folk like they are above us. We used to order from there multiple times a month now its lucky if its once a year read more

Ordered a Stromboli at the store to carryout and got home (not even a mile down the road) and all of the meat inside was cold. My fiance called and she was pretty much told to bad. I then called and again they were refusing to do anything, after arguing with them they told me to bring the remainder in to get a refund. When I got to the shop they refused to give me the refund they told me they would give me. I've never seen such poor customer service, we will never be ordering from Justino's again. read more

sometimes the food is great sometimes its horrible. they do have delivery service but its normally slow and if the pizza is burnt, which it is almost half the time, yout stick with it. read more