I have had the honor of meeting Sarah the owner and a few of the book club leaders. Being 3 min away from I-210 is a blessing & a curse as I find myself squeezing in a visit somehow periodically. I wandered in this curated, indie gem a few months ago and am hooked by its atmosphere every single stay. Its inception and presence really feel like you're plopped in the middle of a rom-com or a cosy bookstore fiction BUT whimsy don't pay the bills so go and visit, support this women-owned space when you get a chance. read more

So cute! Found a two books by popular authors and even one by a local indie author. Follow the store on social media because there are even community events. I'll definitely be back. read more

Judging By The Cover - 3 books - Bookstores Near Me - San Dimas, California

I stopped in last week to check this place out. I had heard in a Facebook group that there was a new Independent bookstore in our area and, of COURSE, I dropped everything to go see! Such an inviting, humble store. Street parking directly in front of the storefront, and also a few comfortable chairs to sit down and peruse a book before purchasing. They are building their stock but are able to order any book you may need. They carry bibliophile stickers and have both used and new books. I like that they have an area in the back that can be used for any clubs ie, book clubs, penpal, Silent Reading clubs, etc. You would just need to inquire with the owner on times and make the arrangements--a great place to walk into and talk books and new finds. Respectfully Reviewed. read more

Judging By The Cover - New store! - Bookstores Near Me - San Dimas, California

Such a great addition to downtown San dimas. With the pink walls and comfy couches, it is the perfect escape to read and explore into books. With both new and used books, if they don't have what you want in stock you can let them know so they can order it. Not just a bookshop, but a place for community. They have multiple book clubs for different book genres, they have a audiobook walking club on many Saturday's mornings, and host an assortment of other events. I love that they carry and promote local authors and artists/creatives. They take used books and will give you store credit to use for them. I love that this bookshop is in the little downtown. I will definitely be there often, and hope to join the audiobook walking group soon! read more

See all

I met Sarah the owner of her business. She is so lovely and very welcoming. She makes people feel welcomed in her business. I will be a regular customer. Thank you. Sarah read more

This is a cute little bookstore right in the middle of downtown San Dimas My fiancé and I walk by this place almost every day and ow and then we walk into read or grab a book when we have extra time. The ambience is comfortable and relaxing. read more

It's really wonderful to have a local, independently-owned bookstore here in town! Walking in, the vibes are frickin immaculate! It's very cute and aesthetic but also functional and comfy! Their book inventory is slowly growing but has a wide range of genres that are easily accessible. Not to mention, the staff are very kind and helpful in finding what you need! Besides the books, Judging By The Cover's best quality is how involved they are in the community, with a full calendar of book clubs, signings, private events, and occasionally a tattoo flash sale. If you're walking the historic downtown here in San Dimas, I seriously recommend popping in! read more

See all

This place is a GEM! Sarah has sooo many book options both new and used and also gets you all the literature wants and needs! I swear she is the sweetest! All of her employees are great! She has used books for a great price and can get you any book you want on order! She also has so many genres of book clubs, you will always find a fit! This is my place for my monthly splurge (if not more than once a month)! Swing by and enjoy this perfect little cozy corner for all book lovers! read more

Super cute new little bookstore in town. It is in downtown San Dimas, there is parking on the street, but there is also parking in the lot behind the store. You can bring your used paper back and hard back books in for trade-in and the books to buy are inexpensive and in good shape. The lady at the desk was very friendly and welcoming and I'm looking forward to seeing the events that unfold as they are starting poetry, readings, book, clubs, and a few other activities. If you haven't already stopped by you should give them a try. read more

See all

This place feels like a friend's home! Love the people, the books, the vibe. We need local places like this...come support them!

Such a cute bookstore! From a great variety of books to awesome book clubs, this is definitely a new favorite! Definitely check it out, whether you're an active reader or just browsing you'll definitely find something! read more

Judging By The Cover - Bookstores Near Me - San Dimas, California

It's so cute and feminine. The owner was so kind and helped my daughter pick out a book. They have really fun monthly events. A great addition to downtown San Dimas. read more

I'm always on the hunt for a cute independent bookstore, and when I spotted this shop I knew I had to visit. The selection is carefully curated, with a great mix of new releases, classics, and unique finds that make each visit feel special. Similarly, interior is cute, thoughtfully designed, and full of soft pink tones that give the space a warm, charming personality without feeling overdone. The shelves and displays are arranged in a way that makes browsing easy and enjoyable. It's a bookstore that feels both welcoming and memorable, and one I'm always happy to spend time in. read more

Thrilled that an independent bookstore opened in San Dimas, CA!! Sara carries all genres of books and can order just about any title you desire. The decor details were carefully curated and create a welcoming space. She has a large calendar near the entrance highlighting upcoming book clubs, craft nights, and author events. This is a cool space where the community can come together. Judging By The Cover Bookstore has to be the best little indie bookstore in the San Gabriel Valley!! read more