Freshest produce out of any shop I've been to! Love that they have vegan and gluten free items in…read morethe dairy, frozen, snack and pantry sections. Staff is helpful and kind. Beautifully displayed produce and prepared items.

I've been shopping here since it opened. The original owner, Jay, was great. The new owners are…read morenot, to say the least. Everything is completely overpriced, which is acceptable to some degree for the convenience of picking up a few items when needed. But, they are really pushing it. My real complaint is that they are rude and don't appreciate their customers. The latest example is that I bought a loaf of bread and once I got home I noticed that the expiration date was that day. I went back expecting that they, like any competent business owner, would simply replace it. Not these guys, they rang up the new loaf and expected me to pay for it. Incredibly, they said it was my fault for not checking the date. I shop there at least twice a week but won't be going back out of principle. Maybe once they go out of business because of their attitude that they're doing the customer a favor the new owners will be better.

Mathew's Prime is a hidden gem. Everyone who works here is friendly, knowledgeable, any truly work…read morewith you to find what you need. It is an unexpected surprise when you walk into what looks like a factory door. The displays are nothing fancy but the options and the prices are amazing. We were shopping for one item we found frozen in the case and the woman at the counter started asking if we would be making them today. When we said yes, she had some of the employees pack us a fresh package of meat. She didn't have to do that but she went above and beyond. Everything was clean and it wasn't too busy so that helped end an amazing experience. Tip: their mea on a stick is top tier and if you leave with nothing else, get a package of them!

Great wholesale prices for prime. Must get the marinated chicken kabobs!! They are awesome! Great…read moreGreek items too, like sliced gyro assorted meats, bakery, produce, souvlaki pita bread. The staff is wonderful! Hope you have a big freezer!! Big portions. Heard they make the best burgers and used by "All American"!!!

I stumbled on C&C meats about a month ago while book shopping at a store across the street and I…read morehave fallen in love with this family owned kind of nostalgic butcher shop. The staff is super friendly, accommodating, and patient. I have been looking for someplace to get freshly ground meat and this was perfect. I see the difference in quality of their meats versus the supermarket. I will definitely be a repeat Customer. It's extremely busy on Saturday mornings.

This place is fantastic! From any of their sandwiches at lunch, to their steaks, chops, burgers for…read moredinner, I have yet to be disappointed at C&C. There have been quite a few people that have assisted me at the counter over the years but I can always count on Joe & Amanda to take care of me. Thanks guys and keep up the great work!

Great quality fruits and vegetables! I especially love the ready-to-use, pre-cut veggies--they're…read morefresh, convenient, and nicely organized. The store is always well stocked and inviting. Love shopping here!

I have been going to Lucky Farms for years. They are not cheap, but you absolutely get what you pay…read morefor. Their fruit, platters and vegetable platters are amazing!

I just moved into the neighborhood and I have Prime time Butcher a try, I am glad I did there…read morechicken cutlets are great nice and thin just the way my family like them.

Great butcher, but definitely not Kosher. Love their burgers. Service is great. We get catering…read morefrom them for family gatherings.

Awesome local butcher in Bayville , very interesting sausages , great beef /variety of cuts ,…read morepoultry and phenomenal fried chicken, sandwiches. One really cool product they offer is B.A.R.F Dog food (Biologically Appropriate Raw Food ) at a super reasonable price . Well worth a trip from all local towns along the North Shore of Long Island . Awesome local business to have in Bayville, local and family owned always a great combination Fantastic service in an old school butcher shop with some new twists

Got a Pork Cutlet Pasquale which consisted of fried hot cherry peppers with garlic. Also got a Ed's…read morecheesesteak which consisted of sirloin, caramelized onions and American cheese. Cute store.

Incredible gentleman who's run this shop! He was extremely honest, attentive and kind. He had…read moreendless options and can customize the cuts for you. His prices are competitive compared to the other names in the area.

Pleasant, professional and they provide the best service of only the highest quality meats! Highly…read morerecommend

Cute little farmers market on the east end of Islip village, right near the Oconee diner. Lots of…read moredifferent stands - produce, baked goods, fish, flowers. Great place to buy local and fresh, or walk through with kids.

Great place to get Long Island products and great day out. Good quality bread, fresh produce, and…read morethe NutPunch is the best snack.