Very good cheese slice. Great old school pizza. Chewy cheesy and delicious. Nothing fancy. Just what I wanted!

Really limp and undercooked. Not utterly terrible but certainly bottom of the three star category. Taste was OK. read more

J's Pizza - Really underdone and totally limp. Not good. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Terrible delivery service. For the 3rd straight time they did not follow delivery instructions!! They refused to deliver pizza to my door and I had to go down and pick up. I am disabled. Will most likely not order again, They cannot follow simple instructions. Too bad, because pizza is pretty good. Wil go back to ordering from Tre Sorelle. read more

Haven't been to J's in over 20 years, mostly because its slices were OK compared to my go-to excellent pizza places in town. Am happy to see this "old school" place still in business considering how many places have been pushed out due to increasing commercial rent. Decided to go for a plain slice for my "reunion" with this pizzeria. It was a tad still chewy for my tastes, with not as flavorful as those 5-star places elsewhere in town - I need that thin crispy crust on a Neapolitan slice. However, if you're in the neighborhood requiring a reasonably priced slice after a few or more drinks, then J's likely meets your job requirements! Given the great pizza options available all over, as a native New Yorker pizza person, while it beats the $1/$1.50 junk slice places it'll be some time until I return there for any pizza. That being said, I might try out J's another time when passing by and hungry - however for something other than their pizza like a Hero, Stromboli or Calzone. Lmk if you have recommendations. read more

J's Pizza - J's Pizza Cheese Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Was pretty good but nothing special. This place had lots of different pizza options. Got a margherita slice and a pasta slice. read more

J's Pizza - pasta pizza and margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Very good pizza. Ask for it extra crispy if you want to fold it. Garlic knots were ok, did not have a lot of the garlic and butter sauce but pizza was excellent read more

J's Pizza - Menu Oct 2024 - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great local spot for an (extra crispy) slice! Good small business to support, too. Dine in or delivery.

Great pizza, lots of choices. No frills, but good stuff. People were cool and the price was right.

I dropped by here late on a Saturday evening to grab a snack. Ordering was quick and easy as it wasn't busy and there was someone at the counter. I ordered a spinach cheese roll and a cheese slice. Both items were cheesy goodness. Everything was reheated in about 5 minutes. I would definitely come back when in the area. read more

Just come in and give them a chance. Amazing pizza! I had thin crust eggplant pizza and can give 5*.

When I travel to NYC and go to some of my old favorites, I find that not only has the quality gone down, but they all taste the same. You can tell that they have sold, and it seems like to a single family who use the same mediocre ingredients. I was thrilled to find J's when I was walking down 7th Ave. It is the old-school taste and quality that has disappeared from NYC over the last few years. There are new "trendy" spots, but if you want the taste that made NYC pizza famous, come to J's. I had a slice of sicilian and a slice of sausage, and they simply could not be better. Service was courteous liked they gave a damn what the customer thought vs. just giving you the bare minimum of attention and taking your money. Looking forward to going back. read more

Grabbed it on the run. Hit the spot. Very friendly. It's exactly what you'd want from a pizza spot. Fast, solid food, and getting what you expect. Wish Boston could hit these notes read more

A local's spot with good prices. Very thin crust. Cheap meats. Depressing lack of variety for dinner. Among the worst variety I've seen. Almost walked out but I gave it a shot and it was decent. Accepts cards. read more

Mind the three-quarters eaten Cheese Slice because I was so hungry and past desperate for something that fit my budget, yet filling enough to get me home on my one and a half hour commute without feeling hungry again. I found the place quick on Apple Maps. Sorry not sorry Yelp. I did look up the photos, menu, and reviews on Yelp though. Oh, as for the pizza slice? It is delicious! I love the texture and thickness; crispy and not too doughy and not too thin. I'm feeling awake enough to now go enjoy the rest of my evening today. I'm one Happy pizza lover! read more

J's Pizza - Cheese Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This place is a gem. I grew up in an Italian neighborhood and this place is authentic. The manager (owner?) is so friendly and gracious. I had a margherita slice that was perfect. Delicious crust, a little olive oil, fresh basil and cheese and a delicious red sauce. Loved! read more

Pizza is always fresh and fast service! Our go-to place in the west village. They also have good garlic knots. read more

J's Pizza - Sicilian slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Great slice. Not too greasy. They grate their own cheese which means something. Feels like NYC.

Pretty solid place that offers a light tasty slice. They can be a bit more on the chewy side but I asked for well done and got a nice crispy piece as a result, so make sure you do so if you're a true connoisseur like me and need crispy pizza. Good stuff! read more

J's Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

the pizza is great. The service is excellent. I always get the cheese slice. It's warm and delicious

New management? New recipes. I always loved the standard NY style thin crust and thick Sicilian pizza that came from our neighborhood parlor. However I realized there was probably new management recipes after our last delivery. Unfortunately the wonderful puffy crust of old was more like a crunchy flat tire. I will sample single slices of thin and Sicilian soon to see if they attend class and improve. read more

Nice decent slices! Looked pretty clean. Toppings for the slices were in good variety at around 11:30pm on a Wednesday. I ordered a pepperoni and olive slice which was $4. Although for being a restaurant I was sad to be turned away from being allowed to use the bathroom as a paying customer (came in with someone else who also bought a slice). Not sure what kind of sit down food establishment doesn't offer a restroom. Staff was friendly but just kind of stupid bathroom rule. But come here anyway- pizza was good :-) read more

See all

This was our favorite pizza while visiting NY! We had the pepperoni pizza and it was hot and crispy. We can't wait to come back.

Our dog is obsessed with J's Pizza. Every day, Gerbert smells the delicious pizza and stalks all sides of the shop outside on his daily walks. His favorite food is, by far, pizza. So when Gerbert's Second Birthday arrived, we knew so did the day when our nine-pound dog could finally have his J's slice. We picked up a piping hot pepperoni slice, while Gerbert pawed on the glass door outside, almost drooling. My boyfriend told the story of Gerbert's love for J's pizza, and the chef himself gave Gerbert his own birthday slice for FREE. On the house! It completely made his day and ours. He devoured a quarter of the pizza at home, and we're doing our best to stretch it over two more days. Photos below. Thank you, J's, for your immense generosity. 5 Stars!!!!! read more

J's Pizza - a dog wearing a party hat - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This is such a great classic NY pizzeria. Better and cheaper than most pizza in the city. It's been my go to spot for 15 years and never disappoints. read more

Great local favorite pizza shop in Chelsea. Their slice of cheese is the perfect NY slice. No frills, reasonably priced, good service, and clean place. read more

Truly delicious pizza. Not fussy. Super nice local place that has been around for years.

The Eggplant Pizza was pretty good. It had enough sauce on it which most places are too cheap to spare enough. This was my 1st time trying eggplant pizza. The slices was abt $3 but they gave me a big slice so that was appreciated. I however didn't like the fact that they told me the bathroom was out of order but they let an old man into it a few mins later. read more

J's Pizza - Eggplant pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Best pizza in the city!! We look forward to getting a pie each time we go to the city.

Good specials on pasta depending on the night. Solid pizza and nots. Best to order a fresh pie with what you want... cook it well done and the crust is crispy! read more

Quick service rly cheesy pizza and the cheese to bread ratio was perfect! (P.s. happy plates were achieved) read more

See all

Standard pizza option in the city. Chewy crust, reasonable cheese and sauce. Definitely gets the job done if you're craving a quick slice!

I've stopped by here a few times recently due to meeting being held at a nearby hotel space. I've only been late night, but when I've stopped by I've always been able to get a seat and they've still had a pretty good selection available even late. The Sicilian slice was very cheesy and tasty. It was a tad bit pricey but basically what you expect from a Manhattan spot. I also had a pepperoni bacon slice that was just okay, and I realized later that I would've been fine with just the pepperoni. Will definitely keep coming here for a slice when I'm in the area. read more

J's Pizza - Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This is strictly based off a Mealpal review. While I work down by Flatiron, my son was in the mood for lasagna and given the great reviews, decided to fetch lunch here. While it was a bit of a walk, I am glad I did. The portion is amazing and they made it fresh on the spot for me (guess my Mealpal order didn't register on their side). Alongside the pasta, they offered 4 garlic knots which was a nice touch. This is honestly good for 2 people worth. Certainly will come back again for sure. read more

J's Pizza - Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Jays Pizza was great! He even stayed open late so I could get my pizza! Super friendly.

Terrible staff! Never have any variety of pizzas in the evening. They reject grubhub and uber eats orders well before closing time. My food was never delivered! read more

I was craving a slice of NY pizza while in NYC. I didn't have much time. I literally finished a workout and saw J's Pizza. I checked them out on Yelp and they seemed to have some good reviews. So why not? I walked in, asked for a slice of Pepperoni. Reasonably priced, friendly & service. If you're looking for a quick bite to eat, give J's Pizza a chance. read more

See all

It was worth walking the few blocks from my job on this cold and rainy day. The pizza around me isn't the greatest so I yelped a location that I haven't been to and I stumbled upon J's Pizza. Service was fast. A slice and a water bottle was $4.00. I will definitely be returning when I need a quick pizza fix! read more

Pizza and little more, (pasta, salads and desserts) J's is a sweet inexpensive find in a very expensive Chelsea neighborhood. Where can you get a Greek salad for $5, topped with feta, roasted peppers, grape leaves, tomatoes, lettuce, red onions and cucumbers , the plethora of toppings is well worth it. Of course, they have a wide variety of specialty pizzas. This no frills joint checks all the cheap eats boxes- good,cheap, convenient and tasty. read more

J's Pizza - Greek salad - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This is good NY style pizza. The guy at the counter was friendly and gave us extra garlic knots. The pizza was thin and tasty. When you imagine a quality NY style pizza place, this is the spot! Check it out! read more

See all

Had a mushroom pepperoni slice, so good that I followed that up with a pepperoni w/crumbled bacon slice. Crust had just the right amount of crunch, cheese and toppings plentiful and fresh. This is the real deal folks - delicious NY pizza reasonably priced sans pretentious BS. Thank goodness a place like this still manages to survive in ever-gentrifying Chelsea! read more