THE GOOD ---------------- + Pizza is wayyyyyyyy better than expected for "Boardwalk" pizza + Hawaiian Chicken pizza might be the BEST Hawaiian pizza I have everrrrr tasted. All of the flavors (ham, pineapple) of the ingredients really hit the spot + Mushroom pizza was excellent too - was more like a truffle mushroom flavor if you're into that + Plain and Pepperoni pizzas were decent, but nothing out of the ordinary + They offer interesting toppings for some slices - mac and cheese, baked ziti + Plenty of indoor and outdoor seating + They have souvenirs too, specifically hats and t-shirts with the name of the place, for only $10 THE NOT SO GOOD ---------------------------- - Pizza is on the verrry pricey side (but pretty much expected for the boardwalk) - $5.75 for cheese, $6.75 for one topping, $7.50 for gourmet topping, $7.75 for specialty topping - Prices for drinks are not listed on the menu, so make sure to ask read more

See all

- Pricey pizza for sure; $8 specialty, $7 one-topping, $6 plain; $7.25 large fountain drink - Spacious interior with sufficient seating for those seeking relief from the outside heat - Seating available outdoors on the boardwalk - Fast and friendly service; employees stand at the ready to take your order and are quick to clean up to turn tables over to the next group - Though on the expensive side, pizzas were very fresh and tasty! Really enjoyed the Hawaiian chicken--loaded with ham, bacon, juicy pineapple bits and chicken read more

See all

Joey Tomato's 311 Ocean Ave. Point Pleasant, NJ 08742 Plain Cheese Slice The cheese was melted to a golden brown and there were minimal pizza bubbles. The slice was kind of floppy, but I enjoyed the taste as the sauce had a hint of sweetness and blended well with the crust. #localbusiness #jerseyshore #PointPleasantBeach #pointpleasantnj #jenkinsonsboardwalk #joeytomatos #plaincheeseslice read more

Joey Tomato's - Joey Tomato's - Pizza Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

See all

I was down there last week for a beach day and decided to try this place. I know I've had it before, but it's been a little bit. And definitely surprise me because it was actually really good. But as others have stated it's pretty pricey, but everything down there on that boardwalk is read more

Joey Tomato's - Pizza Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

Pizza is SOO good! No pictures because I was starving and couldn't wait. Veggie slice is the best and mini pies are delish. Place is spotless and service super friendly. read more

For a pizza joint right on the board walk, I was pleasantly surprised how tasty it was. Gooey cheese and nice pizza sauce. If you want a quick eat on the board walk check it out. Only bummer is that it os $6 bucks per slice. But again that's to be expected. read more

We ordered a whole cheese pizza pie and ate the whole thing. I thought the dough/ crust was amazing. The staff was very good - we ordered at the front and got a number sign for our table and they brought it over when ready. We grabbed a table inside which was nice because it was a little cooler that day - like 70 degrees. I'm glad we came here as opposed to another pizza spot much further away from the boardwalk because it was awesome pizza and hit the spot and didn't have to spend time traveling back and forth. read more

Joey Tomato's - View from our table inside - Pizza Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

See all

Never thought as Boardwalk as the best pizza I could have till I went to Joey tomatoes. This veggie pie is to die for it was so good Friday. I came back again this morning and made them make me one. read more

Joey Tomato's - Veggie pizza, broccoli, pepper, onion, artichoke - Pizza Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

Sitting chit chatting and telling us to be quiet on the boardwalk... is crazy talk , for 15 a slice , FOH read more

Joey Tomato's - Pizza Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

I happen to love this pie!!! In Point Pleasant, take home if it's too busy. It's delicious! read more

Our favorite pizza on the boardwalk! The staff was so friendly and we enjoyed our slices. read more

Joey Tomato's - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

I had a fantastic time! Service was so easy and simple! Their pizza is 100% the best pizza in New Jersey. Last but certainly not least, it was a fun, Italian, and just casual dining! I cannot wait to go back with more family! read more

$40 for a cheese pie LOL I spent over $150 on TWO pizzas and drinks and they wouldn't refill one soda. What a joke about customer service. I have never spent $40 for a plain pie in anywhere I have traveled nor had an issue with one refill on an overpriced soda that was mostly ice. read more

Listen. Yes it's pricey. Everything is at Jenkinson's. EVERYTHING. The question is, are you going to spend your money at Joey Tomato's or somewhere else?! I'm always going to go to JT. The service is good. These are kids working a summer job 9 times out of ten. I'll never understand the complaints lol. The atmosphere is that of a Jersey boardwalk. If you didn't come for that, you're in the wrong place. The pizza here is EPIC. Pizza Hut is literally gross next to what they serve here. Been eating at Joey Tomato's since I was a kid. We'll def be back. And I live 5 hours away LOL Thank you Joe! See you next time! read more

See all

We arrived late on a Friday and went for our annual slice. They heat the slices up in a real oven- so they stay crispy. The plain variety allows you to really taste the sauce. It was very good, but while waiting, I went to use the restroom. BOTH were "out of order." That was a problem for both me and the restaurant. Taking off a star. I'll be baack- next year. read more

Love stopping by Joey Tomato's for a few slices when visiting the boardwalk. Staff is nice and friendly.

Yes the pizza was good but C'mon $7 for a slice of pizza!! Not even a big slice! Complete rip off!

2 slices and 2 bottles of water $25 whatever The Karen behind the counter throwing out a couple with 3 kids because no strollers allowed is insane. Screaming and yelling like a lunatic the poor kids were crying and meanwhile no sign anywhere that says no strollers allowed read more

Fot me they make the best pizza in NJ. Good food, fun time and nice people too. Five Stars ! read more

Joey Tomato's - Pizza with Joey Tomato - Pizza Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

See all

Marginal pizza (at best) and the staff is unhelpful and unfriendly. So many other choices within walking distance. Choose another. Skip this for sure. read more

I wanted to go to Rosie's, but they were sold out of pies for the night. I haven't had Joey Tomato's since I was little, but remember the pizza being the best on the boardwalk! Decided to call in an order for a large sausage pizza for pickup, was told it would be ready in 20 minutes. I parked at the end of central ave and walked 30 minutes to the boardwalk - pizza wasn't even put into the oven yet because the woman forgot about our order. I was willing to wait until she rang us up - ONE pie was $38!!! Walked back to my car and went to Little Mia's instead which was great. read more

Decent slice on the boardwalk, price want bad either. had it on line waiting for martells the other day read more

Joey Tomato's - a slice of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

Best pizza in NJ! I live in CA now but when I come back to visit my daughter this is a must! It truly never disappoints. It's pricey but so worth it! Yum! read more

Joey Tomato's - Yummy pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

The only reason this place still even exists is because the boardwalk is usually open for them to scam passing tourists out of their money for subpar food. Now that the boardwalk is closed for the pandemic, they've switched to takeout/delivery. Imagine thinking locals are dumb enough to pay almost $30 (plus tax and tip) for a terrible pizza? Who do these guys think they are? Avoid this place at all costs -- you can get an exponentially better pizza from Rosie's for literally $10 less. Shame! read more

Gross overpriced pizza and rude staff - never going back again!! Save your money and go anywhere else on the boardwalk!

Simply not a fan...my taste in pizza keeps me from posting a good review. Jenks hands down is the better pizza on this boardwalk. A matter of taste and my Italian heritage. My review is based on the fact that others who know me and follow me understand that I'm picky that's all. All the best Joey's as you have many fans. read more

Googled "best pizza Jenkinson's." Joey Tomato came up in the top spot. I figured it would be the same frozen schlock, reheated and mass produced to quickly appease tourists and maximize profit. I mean, that's how food on Jersey shore boardwalks work, amiright? Glad to say that's definitely NOT the case with Mr. Tomatoes. In fact, is rank his Pizza top 10 I've ever had in NJ! This is a chorizo slice with red onions and cherry peppers. It was my 2nd fave of 5 SLICES I ate. First place goes to the tomato pie but the picture didn't look as good. And the go get the tomatoes scared out of you by clowns at the funhouse. read more

Joey Tomato's - This is a chorizo slice with red onions and cherry peppers. It was my 2nd fave of 5 SLICES I ate. First place goes to the tomato pie. - Pizza Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

service was horrible i'm a coptic orthodox christian i'm fasting for church and asked for no cheese and since it was the same price i asked for cheese on the side for the pizza and he yelled at us. I am very mad. read more

Best slice in point pleasant. You can complain about the price, but it's listed for all to see. I don't understand how people order a pie, then complain about how expensive it was. Worth the money. Much better than other pizza you can find at the point pleasant boardwalk. Been 100 times will be back 100 times more! read more

just to start - restaurant is filthy and unsanitary and pizza is disgusting and greasy. on top of this we were instantly and incredibly rudely told to leave after putting up an umbrella as it was assumed that normal people like us don't know how to use umbrellas and we are required to ask even though there are no signs sings stating that or anything of the sort, and it's....an umbrella rofl. AVOID AT ALL COSTS read more

Great boardwalk pie. Pepperoni a little greasy but still very good. I'd stick with the plain, it's their strong suit. Older gentlemen working behind counter (owner?) always seems crotchety and annoyed. I would suggest that he cheer up a bit or work non-customer service jobs. The older lady working there on the other hand is quite the gem. She has a great personality and will even expertly cut slices for children. Bottomline: above average boardwalk pie, a bit pricey, good location and outdoor seating area read more

when the lines at jenkinsons and martells are way too long this is the best place to go....very very fast and quick service and great pizza read more

See all

I've eaten many an inebriated slice of pizza here at Joey Tomatoes. Sure, it's a bit pricey compared to slices I get in NYC, but you're paying for the convenience of having it right on the boardwalk and they are open late. Perfect for when craving a few slices after partying at Jenks or the Tiki Bar. Helps fill your belly and soak up the beer. Seating inside and outside. Clean place and friendly service. Nice spot to grab a seat and people watch like a creeper. Actually, it's a pretty tasty pizza here. All types of toppings too. Maybe that is the beer talking, but I don't care. After a dozen beers and a few shots any pizza will taste good. Especially late at night. read more

Pizza at the Jersey Shore is always different. Sure, NY and Chicago has great pizza but just a different feeling. Maybe its all the sand? haha I went to this place a a year ago and never wrote a review. It was a steamy Saturday night and our first visit to the shore that summer. The last time I had gone to this place was as a 5th grader when we visited the aquarium. The pizza isn't cheap but thats because the slices are huge! Very filling to just eat a single slice. I'd say this is a much better option than buying hot dogs or fries at a similar cost just to not be full. My family and I order a pie and were amazed at how huge it was. Big and delicious! I've been meaning to go back and hopefully will within the next few weeks. If you like pizza and visit the Jersey shore then you must go to this place. Oh my this is making me hungry for pizza or anything cheesy read more

Joey Tomato's - Too cheesy? - Pizza Near Me - Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey

It's hard to find good pizza at the Jersey Shore but this place might be one of the best. Joey Tomatoes, right on the boardwalk at Point Pleasant Beach and across from Jenkinson's, has a good variety of specialty slices like Buffalo Chicken, Broccoli Rabe and Cheesesteak. It's 4.50 a slice for the specialty slices which is a tad bit high but better than paying a buck less for cheap frozen tasting pizza elsewhere on the boardwalk. Unfortunately this pizza is still inferior to places up in Northern Jersey (sorry, gotta be honest!). read more

See all

This pizza is the best I've had, and I feel ill whenever I'm done because I finish whatever my wife and kids don't eat. The smoked mozzarella is the best, but sinfully second place is the deep-fried eggplant. My complaint is Type A. They can't seem to decide how to spell the restaurant's name. Signage and cups have all three of these possibilities: Joey Tomato's (on storefront) Joey Tomatoe's (on cups and some internal signage) Joey Tomatoes (internal signage) Note that only the storefront version is correct. E.g., if you're name is Joe Tomato, and you have a restaurant, you'd use the apostrophe. Lame punctuation, but great pizza. read more

I have been buying pizza for my family for many years and I just sent my sons to go pick up 2 plain pizzas for lunch. I gave them a $50 bill. The pies were $$$30 each. Wtf!!!!!! I don't care what or how good there pizza is. No pizza 8 slices is worth $30!!!!! Rip off!!!! $3.75 each for a slice of pizza!!! Oats pizza 100x better!!!! read more

Joey Tomato's is the absolute best pizza in New Jersey!!! Great service, great atmosphere, and great staff!!! Joey Tomato's is a staple place to eat every time we visit Point Pleasant Beach Boardwalk. Thank You Joey!!! read more

Spent a few days by the beach with the family and stopped in at this spot based on other reviews. Pizza was good. Not out of this world but decent. We had cheese, Hawaiian and a ricotta pizza. It was convenient on the boardwalk and they have plenty of tables for outdoor seating. read more

Undercooked, bland and came with hair. I would not recommend eating here. Bathroom was absolutely filthy.