We were staying at a friend's cabin in Monticello and needed some food delivered. We called up a family member who lives here more regularly who told us to get Jimmy's so that's what we did.
Online, it said that we were not in their delivery area, but when we called to ask, they said we were good and that they'd deliver to us anyway which was really kind of them.
We ended up ordering a Cheese Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, and Jimmy's Deluxe (all larges).
The delivery was great, you pay with card over the phone which means you can tip with card as well so no scrounging around for small bills right before the driver comes.
We got our order in 40-60 min which is a bit long but not too bad, and it's the only option so can't complain.
The pizzas were really small despite being "large". They are only 14" long which is like the same size as a domino's pizza, but here they each cost $22. The pizzas were not very good, to be frank. They were really small for their price and tasted kind of like frozen pizzas. The pepperonis on the pepperoni pizza were under the cheese, but there were barely any of them. The crust on all three was super thin, but in a way that made them more like a cracker than thin bread. The peppers on the deluxe needed to be precooked a little before they go in the oven as they were underdone and cook slower than the pizza.
Overall, not the best pizza, but considering their availability and delivery, I would order again. read more