Jersey Mike&#x27;s Subs

I went in blind -- no idea about prices, wait times, or what to expect. Just an ad online that…read morelooked too good to ignore. So I drove 45 minutes to Red Bank, NJ. The line at the door was bananas. But after a 45-minute drive, I wasn't turning around. Pre-surgery gluttonous me was getting this sandwich. I stood in line for another 45 minutes -- plenty of time to decide on the signature cheesesteak. When I got to the register, they gave me the heads-up: $45 for the cheesesteak. At that point the only thing that could ruin it was if it wasn't good. I also grabbed a few extras -- the prosciutto balls (if you know, you know) and some Italian vanilla wafer cookies that are outstanding. Decision time: eat it in the parking lot, or drive 45 minutes home first? I chose to wait. The smell in the car the whole ride back was borderline sinful. Got home, washed up, unwrapped it -- and this thing was enormous, clearly not just chopped-up steak thrown on bread. First bite in, I knew I wasn't in Kansas anymore. It'll probably take me a few weeks to finish (it's that big), but I'm already planning my return trip. Bonus points: while we waited, they kept coming out with fresh hot cheese tortellini and handing out free samples to everyone in line. When I paid, they threw in a whole separate container of it too. For context -- I'm a Philly guy. I'll drive an hour and a half for a cheesesteak without blinking. This place is 45 minutes away and it's still worth it. That says everything. The space itself is bright, clean, and stacked with an incredible variety of Italian fare. Bring patience, bring an appetite, and run -- don't walk. You will not regret it. 5/5 stars. 544 NJ-35, Red Bank, NJ 07701 talierciosdeli.com IG/FB: @taliercios

The food is great. The ambience smells great, very Italian-deli like. They have to work out the…read moreservice. Award winning...... I luckily I went in at 9:30am. Only 2ahead of me. Warning: going around lunchtime plan on waiting a half hour. It's so damn popular. They have over 60 varieties of sandwiches, heros, paninis with "cute" names. They obviously do home catering.

See all

Johnny Drinks

Elsies Sub Shop

4.3(92 reviews)

0.1 mi

Pickle subs! Excellent! Go there. Staff is super nice and helpful. Heads no public bathroom to…read moreclean up your pickle mess. Great spot!

Starving after trip to sandy hook with my dog so I searched for a sandwich shop & picked this one -…read moreit was surprisingly good - lucky to find a 15 min parking spot available near the shop - only down side no public restroom, they said I could go across the street to use another businesses

Macaroni Salad

See all

A Turkey and Provelone half sub

Brennan's Delicatessen of Middletown

4.1(25 reviews)

1.1 mi

Delicious sandwiches! Everything was so fresh. Large portions and adorable shop with extra snacks…read moreto buy. Highly recommend.

This location has beef open for a while now but I've never been here. I know Brennan's in Rumson is…read morea fine establishment so I had no doubt this would be anything less than excellent. It's Saint Patrick's Day weekend and I was craving corned beef and where else would you go but Brennan's. The hand carved corned beef sandwich was the special today and it's terrific. The place is nice, lots of food choices and a busy staff that's second to none. I highly recommend this place.

The food here looks amazing

Saint Paddy's day corned beef special

See all

The corned beef special on pumpernickel

Filoncino Bakery Cafe

4.2(42 reviews)

0.3 mi

If my husband says "I'll come back for lunch or dinner", you know the cafe is a winner!…read moreSecond time here; we just had egg sandwiches. Quality ingredients l, and home baked rustic roll elevated the sandwich even more!

Great spot for sandwiches. Their house made bread is fantastic. We came back the very next day for…read morebreakfast but it was a miss. The egg bowl left a lot to be desired. Not much flavor. The porchetta and eggs dish was also a miss. They threw some spices on top and it was overly salty--almost inedible. Surprised that the platter didn't come with home fries or some sort of potatoes. I'd come back only for their lunch sandwiches. We also got their chocolate bread to go which was fantastic. Their pistachio bar was also delicious and very heavy on the almond extract which I enjoy.

Dining area

See all

Angelo's Italian Market

4.9(44 reviews)

2.5 mi

Angelos is the best of the best. Fresh and delicious every single time. It's our go to when having…read morecompany and everyone always loves it!

We had 47 people for a barbecue and Angelos knocked it out of the park. Despite the power outage…read morethey worked extra hard and delivered excellent ribs, chicken, corn, burgers, etc. Will definitely use them again!

See all

Monmouth Meats

4.7(67 reviews)

0.1 mi

Friendly neighborhood old-school butcher in the middle of town. From cold cuts and sandwiches to…read morehigh end cuts of meat, Stew G. at MM will take care of you. Has truly superb lamb, beef, chicken and all else. Set up like the old-fashioned mini grocery Stew's father had in Brooklyn back in the day, you may purchase vegetables, fish, pasta, sauces and much more, allowing you to buy a complete meal prep in one place.

Greeted by the owner, very nice, beautiful meats and they sell lunch too! And their soups are…read morefantastic. Had the chicken pot pie soup, wow delicious hearty vegetables lots of chicken.

USDA Prime Bone-In Ribeye Steak

Italian and international speciality products. Hard cheeses, salami, pepperoni, guanciale, pancetta, chorizo, kielbasa

See all

Beef tallow grilled broccoli rabe

Strokers Deli & Subs

3.9(25 reviews)

1.3 mi

There is a new owner and he has cleaned the store up, repainted and reorganized. The food is…read moredelicious with generous portions at affordable prices. I ordered their homemade French onion soup (so difficult for takeout) and it was so delicious that I went back and bought three more orders. The new owner has experience with family restaurants and he brings this to the deli experience.

Well above average spot. Their tuna salad is top 5 for me. They are great with putting daily…read morespecials on social media. Breakfast sandwiches above average too.

Pork Porkroll, Egg & Cheese

See all

Turkey provolone

Johnny's Pork Roll and Coffee too

4.2(77 reviews)

0.2 mi

I never ever leave bad reviews but this one has to said. It is a Sunday morning and a group of us…read morewent to go get some breakfast sandwiches. We found this place and we all were ready to spend money and try. Unfortunately when we walked in. Whoever was behind the counter, had some choice words under their breath. Essentially it was a problem for the cranky man to take more orders because he seemed to have been making a lot of sandwiches already. Maybe you shouldn't own a shop. As we were leaving he said thanks for coming and buying something. Figure out how you feel and what you want from customers before contradicting yourself. As a business owner, disgusting experience and I will be posting this on my social media accounts which are very active and loyal. Have a great day and I wish you nothing but inconveniences with your business. 0/10 Disgusting and inappropriate owner or worker that day.

Johnny made my sandwich today! What a treat!…read more That's delicious pork roast sandwich with a dippy egg and a nice Kaiser roll. I got to split it with my bff. It was perfect and so delicious. I think it's a great New Jersey specialty and Johnny really has great knowledge about the meat and the history of the product. I really am delighted to see his passion for PORKROLL and community. He has quite a fan club. And it's great to know about good eggs like him. Very grateful to his care. I look forward to coming back.!!

Locals enjoy

See all

Bakers On Broad

4.8(23 reviews)

0.3 mi

As soon as i walked in I gasped. They have a full kitchen, several baked goods, coffee and so much…read moremore. The barista was awesome, attentive, funny, and kind. I got an everything bagel toasted with scallion cream cheese, and it was absolutely amazing. The bagel was nicely toasted and crunchy on the outside and nice and soft on the inside. Their food menu looked amazing. The ambiance was very upscale & cozy. I can't wait to go back and try more! They also had some free baked goods as well.

Pros: I loved the open view kitchen into the seating area…read moredesign. It makes the experience personable not to mention you can see how organized and clean the kitchen is. I received friendly and lighthearted service from the man who took my order. One thing that I thought was pretty cool and have never seen before was a "color wheel" for coffee. It was a visual way to show your preferences on what your preferences are on coffee appearance once the milk is added. My chicken salad sandwich was delicious, not too filling and made on very soft enjoyable bread. Room for improvement: Maybe because I stopped in at 1 pm on a Wednesday I felt like the seating area was poorly maintained. The floor really needed to be swept so it actually felt like of dirty sitting there eatting. There were a handful of people spread out with their laptops etc. One person was actively taking a call so it felt like you at work with them. Another had a small dog that she was carrying around people eatting while the leash/harness laid on the floor near her table. I'm all for dogs being allowed to be in eateries but the whole sit in experience felt dirty for me (especially based on the price I paid) and wouldn't be something I'd repeat. Long story short, the customer service while ordering is great but take your order to go.

Crumb cake muffin

See all

Coffee.

Paris Baguette

4.3(38 reviews)

0.3 mi

Great food and service def a great but and i love all the food. Everything looks greatread more

Service was friendly and helpful. I enjoyed looking at all the choices and the different way you…read more"place your order" by taking what you selected up to the register. More good: my cafe latte was good. I like that they had chocolate/cinnamon powder as an item to sprinkle on your drink if you want to. I enjoyed the tiny pastry (maybe it was the pastel de nata). The restaurant seemed super clean and pleasant sound level. The not so good: the Hash Brown Bread with Ham & Cheese. They said they warmed it for me but there was zero detection of warmth (meh, I didn't ask again). I didn't care for the ketchup flavored drizzle on top of it too (made it look nice but too sweet and just didn't add to the item imo). There wasn't really a "crisp" to the hash brown part. Would visit again, wouldn't get that savory hash brown pastry though.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Ed W.

0

1

0

12 years ago

The service is a disgrace. Employees behind the counter running out the door to talk to thier friends that pass by. Your lucky if there is one person working there that knows what they are doing. I asked that my sub be put in a bagand the punk behind the counter tossed the sub towards me and refused to put it in a bag. All the time he is staring me down like he wanted to fight. What a joke. Having children run your business is not a good idea. I will never eat at any of the Jersey Mike's places and I was a regular customer at the Middletown and Shrewsbury stores. I hope all the other Jersey Mikes franchisees appreciate the Red Bank store ruining thier business. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - hotdogs - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Red Bank, New Jersey Restaurants near Jersey Mike's Subs

BEST of Red Bank, New Jersey Things to Do near Jersey Mike's Subs

BEST of Red Bank, New Jersey Coffee near Jersey Mike's Subs

BEST of Red Bank, New Jersey Pizza near Jersey Mike's Subs

BEST of Red Bank, New Jersey Desserts near Jersey Mike's Subs

BEST of Red Bank, New Jersey Burgers near Jersey Mike's Subs

BEST of Red Bank, New Jersey Parking near Jersey Mike's Subs

BEST of Red Bank, New Jersey Takeout near Jersey Mike's Subs

BEST of Red Bank, New Jersey Smoke Shop near Jersey Mike's Subs

BEST of Red Bank, New Jersey Mall near Jersey Mike's Subs

Best of Red Bank

Things to do in Red Bank

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Jersey Mike's Subs also viewed

Sorrento's Subs

3.6

(172 reviews)

The service is friendly and very prompt. The cold sandwiches are very fresh. The cold cuts are…read moresliced per order! It's a good casual spot for a well made sandwich with abundant portions.

Best subs in Central Jersey, can't go wrong here! Fries and onion rings are a must. Service is fast…read moreand pump considering a new amount of volume they do. Typical sub shop looks but they do have indoor seating.

D A Subs

3.7

(95 reviews)

Longstanding Sub Shop serving the Matawan/Strathmore area. Friendly and accommodating staff and a…read moreclean store. This is the quintessential sub shop! It hits all the marks. The bread is one of the best sub rolls around and they put a generous amount of meat on the sub. Not many other places have remained consistent over the years like D.A. Subs has! Cash Only so be aware ahead of time.

I walked into the shop at 6:25 pm and was greeted by a woman with a "What do you want? We close in…read more15 mins the grill is closed!" Very rude and disgusting manner ! I was really excited to try this place and won't be returning here ever again. Very disgusting! Should not be treating costumers this way !

Colts Neck General Store

4.0

(53 reviews)

Every time I visited my friend in New Jersey, I passed by this place thinking, "How cute is this…read morestore?" I didn't even realize it was a small breakfast spot. One day, we finally decided to stop in for breakfast. The space is very cute and quaint, and they also have a small section selling snacks and little knickknacks. The way the place operates is a bit different, you serve yourself coffee, place your order deli-style, and pay upfront like a diner. They bring the food to your table, but there isn't much table service. It was slightly confusing at first, but it didn't take away from the overall experience. That said, it was a bit disappointing that the table wasn't clean. We had a baby with us, and when we wiped the table down, the baby wipe turned brown, not something you want to see. It may have been a busy moment, but cleanliness is still important.

In Colts Neck Township, you will find this store-and-diner after navigating a series of roads. I…read moredid not think I would include this as one of my trips, but I decided that I would come. Brand: 4/5 Colts Neck General Store is located in Colts Neck Township, which is initially a store that also acts as a diner. You will find many knickknacks throughout the walls and the ceilings. The red, barn-house walls definitely gives the store a classic look. The tall sign and the wall sign do have different fonts, with the tall sign having basic font while the wall sign had a more prestigious classic look. Wait Time: 5/5 I did not have any issues with the wait time, for it arrived on time. Ambiance: 5/5 As a store-and-diner, Colts Neck General Store has that unique appeal that I see in Monmouth County. You practically feel immersed into the small town appeal with classic rock playing over the radio at a tolerable volume. The food selection on their menu reflects the small town knickknack appeal, with its varying diversity. You will also find plenty of treats for sale near the counter. The dining area had plenty of space with wide tables, whether on their own or in the booths. Food: 4/5 I ordered the Aztec Specialty Omelet, consisting of jalapeno chips, fried onion, spinach, pepper jack. with a side of toast. Initially I ordered orange Juice, but also include a bottle of water considering the hot jalapeno chips and fried onions. Every well-cooked of the omelet definitely gives it a unique spin, though the buttered toast had an unassuming taste and crunch. The pepperjack cheese brings its hardy flavor to this flavor-packed dish. The Aztec Specialty Omelet held its form, even as I cut into it. Considering how Colts Neck General Store houses many unique knickknacks, I can definitely see how one of those items may have inspired this dish, for the Mexican influence has a pronounced presence. The time it took to prepare this dish accurately matched the waiting time, and the service behind it ensured that I received the meal with my choice of side dishes. The Aztec Specialty Omelet managed to satisfy for a little bit throughout the day. Service: 5/5 The staff managed to get my order without any issues, including asking me specific questions about which side dish I wanted. Based on first impressions, I will say that I felt accommodated while feeling immersed in a small town paradise. The wait time did not try my patience. I cannot say for certain whether the staff dust the knickknacks, but I will say that nothing about the ambiance irritated me, so I presume that they care for them. They also ensured the preparation of the menu items. Cost: 4/5 I will say that as a restaurant in Colts Neck Township, it did not become as expensive as expected. Driving across many varying roads, the arrival to such a unique eatery made the food worth it. I would definitely order differing menu items if I arrive in the future. I do think that having a website would help bring modern relevance to Colts Neck General Store without changing the restaurant itself. The wall sign better represents the store than the tall sign, and if the eatery did make a website, I hope it is used for the brand. Ultimately, the price of the Aztec Specialty Omelet and staying there was worth it. Rating: 4/5 Stars Right now, I will say that Colts Neck General Store has a niche presence in Colts Neck, with its unique ambiance and menu selection. I cannot say I would go back any time soon, but if so, I would enjoy any of the other menu items. Recommend To... Anyone looking for a diner with many knickknacks decorating its walls.

Tre Colore

3.7

(108 reviews)

5 stars. Local spot, no frills, crazy ass menu but they crush it all. Green salsa is .... margarita…read morepizza always wins a crowd and try the burritos while you're at it. Easy stop on your way to the Parkway. That is all.

Terrible pizza. Not only was it expensive, but they made my order wrong. More like cheese on bread…read morethan a pizza.

JB's Diner On 33

3.4

(175 reviews)

Went for the car show and dinner. The diner is very clean and retro 50s. The service was very good…read moreand our waitress very attentive. We both started off with beef barley soup. It was delicious and hot. We ordered a burger, veggie burger and onion rings. They were perfect. Our platters also came with fries. Afterwards, we looked at the beautiful varieties of corvette's. A dream come true.

Very cute inside with the whole 50s motif & vibe; nice attentive staff, our waitress was good &…read morefood came out very quickly--but she had disgustingly long fingernails and kept scratching her face. Long nails & food service industry = no-no. Decent food, nothing too outstanding. Coffee was not good.

New Monmouth Diner

3.6

(226 reviews)

Excellent Food! Excellent Service. Ask for Carly…read more We were looking for a place to go eat after Good Friday Service. As usual, I checked Yelp for restaurants and ratings. This lead us to New Monmouth Diner. The Kitchen Staff sent the food out fresh and hot. It looked great and tasted even better. Kudos to the Kitchen. Kudos to the Cashier Kudos to our Server Carly. **Excellent atmosphere too. The Vintage Car theme was the icing on the cake! We found a new place to frequent when we are in the area.

The ambiance is often crowded, but not too noisy. The diner is well managed. Waitstaff experience…read morewidely varies from competent to inexperienced. What's disturbing is when waitstaff projects an attitude, argumentative and naive. I ordered French onion soup, sandwich with side of tzatziki sauce with the one request to have everything at the same time. Everything was brought out separately, and I was offered more "sauce" and brought au jus with beef drippings and told it was the same thing. Thankfully management is present, they corrected deficiencies quickly and were hospitable.

MJ's Restaurant Bar & Grill

3.2

(123 reviews)

The food was just amazing... AMAZING!! and let me tell you something - i love food *chuckles*. The…read moreservice was super fast and excellent. And don't even get me started on their hostess. She was such a good girl! She reminded me a lot of my discord kitten, username: kittylivvy33 (back off fellow moderators, shes mine). Overall great place to go will recommend to my server on discord and my fellow moderators

Not sure who that was that stated service was bad, maybe they gave off a bad vibe. Food was good,…read morehad a grill chicken wrap. Service was great, came by very 5-10 minutes. Great local spot.

Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen

3.6

(48 reviews)