Jersey Mike&#x27;s Subs

This is probably one of my favorite locations in southeastern Wisconsin. Everything always comes…read moreout so fresh and staff is always so accommodating and friendly. I always ask for no butter on the bun and it's always responded to a favorably. Today I decided to try the strawberry hibiscus, frozen lemonade, and it was outstanding! I hope they keep it longer than limited time only.

Eat more chicken We are never disappointed! Typically, we always order ahead of time to pick up…read morein store. Little to no wait time!

See all

Chipotle Mexican Grill

1.5(13 reviews)

Food was good. Service was not unfriendly. Sat on the patio. It was clean. Was about 8:00 pm…read morewhen we arrived

I'm a big chipotle fan but wouldn't recommend this location. A lot of the food appeared like it had…read morebeen out for a while and many were almost empty. But mostly the people we interacted with were pretty unfriendly and it was a bit disappointing.

This is the worker

See all

Bubba's Frozen Custard

3.5(95 reviews)

0.4 mi

Stopped in for lunch today around 1:30 on a Monday. The indoor area was clean, dated and only one…read morecouple was seated at the time. I ordered the pulled pork sandwich that was on special and went with fried onions on the sandwich at the suggestion of the counter attendant. Also ordered a chocolate malt. The sandwich was disappointing, very stingy on the amount of pork, and very little seasoning made for a tasteless bite. Various condiments were available at the counter and helped to add some flavor. It came with a small serving of Cole slaw, creamy style and very typical taste wise. The chocolate malt was very good, could actually taste the malt unlike other custard places offering a malted drink. The bill came to $14.48 including taxes. Maybe their burgers are better but not sure I would revisit this establishment again.

This business has been around since 1998, and I can tell you they have earned it. The food is…read morewell-prepared, and the menu offers a variety for everyone: sandwiches, fish fry Fridays, burgers, sides, hot dogs, and, of course, custard! Don't forget to ask about the Sandwich of the Week. There is outdoor and indoor seating and plenty of parking. Their special flavors of the day for custard are always interesting and worth trying. The pricing is appropriate. I believe the entire location is ADA accessible which is nice for everyone to enjoy. I started eating so fast I forgot to take a picture of the food, but I got the wrappings! Oops, just shows how good the food was, and I didn't want to waste a moment to dive in!

Only the empty dishes, since I couldn't wait to eat the great food! :)

Bubba's Frozen Custard - This breaded mushroom and Swiss burger is eyes roll into the back of your head good! It doesn't need the ranch dressing, IMO though.

See all

This breaded mushroom and Swiss burger is eyes roll into the back of your head good! It doesn't need the ranch dressing, IMO though.

McDonald's

1.3(55 reviews)

They just remodeled this place and it looks very nice. The customer service I got today was…read moreimpressive, especially for McDonald's. It's a very nice upgrade and deserves a higher rating than your normal McDonald's experience. I need keto options, and they handled my burger without a bun with ease, today. The new self-ordering feature is actually pretty useful, too. It makes a complicated order very clear and concise.

The manager should be fired! I had two mobile orders he would not honor. I had the mobile receipt…read morewith paid on the receipt itself along with confirmation number. He kept telling me they didn't have the order it was declined. I'm out the cost of the meal and he told us we could order again and pay for it AGAIN. IMO this is stealing. He also told me to contact corporate for a refund, they tell you to contact the store... He should be fired. I would not set foot in this store. There are enough fast food places in Pewaukee that offer much better service.

See all

Drive thru

Noodles and Company

3.0(31 reviews)

I ordered food to go. The cashier was friendly. I would order ahead on my next visit to avoid a…read morewait. When I got my food, the noodles were fine, but I ordered Parmesan crusted chicken and it was a bit too charred unfortunately. Was quite bummed about this after adding it on!

So I have long time customer and recently every single time I have got what I normally get dry very…read moredry Mac and cheese!!!!

See all

Taco Bell

2.5(28 reviews)

Honest to god the best bloody T-Bell I've ever had…read more Restaurant is clean, quiet, and orderly. Employee offered to take our order in person or over the kiosk. Food came quickly. But most importantly, THE FOOD!! Ordered 6 hard shell tacos, EACH AND EVERY taco was genuinely hard; not that soggy BS you get everywhere else. EACH AND EVERY taco was intact at the bottom-- no meat and cheese dribbling out onto the paper wrap, easy as pie to consume. EACH AND EVERY taco was layered meat, lettuce, *then* cheese (which I never even realized was a possibility), so that instead of the marshy-glommed-up-muck of cheesy meat (or is it meaty-cheese idk) that is typical of Taco Bell, I got cold, distinct cheese layered in to every bite. If you like Taco Bell, and more specifically Taco Bell's hard shell tacos, I cannot recommend enough.

Ordered ahead and order was not on time waited more than 15 minutes on top of ordering way headread more

See all

Good Eats Cafe

3.8(88 reviews)

First time here, and we ate outside on a nice summer day. Our server, Miguel was terrific, even…read moreasking me for my ID as noted on my credit card. (That hasn't happened in years!). The hot mocha was yummy and rich. The Eggs Benedict with hash browns was cooked perfectly, with the eggs slightly runny and the hash browns crispy. The Yogurt was a full bowl of fresh fruit. Yes, there is a fee for using a credit card, but that is expected these days. Bring cash if you don't want to pay it. The location is pretty nondescript, and I can see that it is not easy to see it as you drive by. However, it is worth finding, so try your next breakfast/brunch/lunch here. They close at 2:00.

I have been to Good Eats a few times and while the food is always good, I wish the service matched…read moretheir delicious food. I know it's hard to get good help these days, but when you have a server who literally stops and chats with a table for more than 10 minutes while they have other tables waiting for food or checks as an example, it just makes it hard to keep coming back.

Seating

Beignets and frappe

See all

London fog latte

MOD Pizza

3.5(22 reviews)

0.0 mi

MOD Pizza - Pewaukee, WI…read more Let me just say--this pizza hit every note. My fiancé and I stopped at this location recently, and as someone who's plant-based and dairy-free, I was honestly blown away. The dairy-free cheese was melty and flavorful, the crust was perfect, and the amount of veggie toppings they offer? A dream. I felt like I could build a pizza that actually fit my body and my tastebuds--and that's rare. No stress. No settling. Just pure deliciousness and a welcoming vibe. Thank you, MOD Pizza Pewaukee, for making people like me feel seen and satisfied. We'll definitely be back.

Mod has changed their menu fyi. Came in on a quiet weekday. Ordered two pizzas. One came out in…read morea timely manner, second was still being made at the counter. Did they just forget to make it? I mentioned to the cut table guy, what happened, I ordered 10 Minutes ago and he says. 'Funny, huh? Yeah that's crazy' and blew me off in a smarmy way. Weird response that of course left a bad taste in my mouth. Not sure if I'll be back to this location again.

See all

The Spanish Traveler

4.1(186 reviews)

3.1 mi

•$$

If you're looking for specialty taco's this is a must. The flavors are absolutely amazing. If I'm…read morelooking for unique flavor taco's this is my spot. The pick, one - two - three meal is good but I wouldn't get the taco in that as it's not specialty and not very saucy, a little dry. The service is different but works well for the setup. Sit down - go up and order. The staff was very knowledgeable and were very helpful. The Special was Marg - Monday FYI.

It continues to be a go-to for quality and uniques offerings. It has many specials and the drinks…read moreare great as well

Interior

Guacamole and chips

See all

Margaria and paloma drink

The Great Greek Mediterranean Grill

4.7(100 reviews)

4.3 mi

Great food, and service…read more This time, I tried their cucumber mint water and it was light and refreshing. I love that they are part of "GiftAMeal". Be sure to a photo of your food to give back to families in need!

Our original plans were canceled, we had a whole bunch of time to kill and it was cold... so cold,…read morethe first time we went to GGM. We were unsure what to order so we asked for a few suggestions. We placed our order, grabbed a couple drinks and found a place to sit. Our food arrived a few minutes later ... not only did it smell and look great, it tasted great too. We don't live in the area but we have been back to GGM a couple times because we really enjoy it. I always get the four dip combo... I share it with my family and then I eat it for two days for lunch. It is fantastic. Service is wonderful. The restaurant doesn't have much seating; it's always clean!

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Mark N.

2 years ago

Was stopped on Capitol today as there was some road construction and witnessed the owner or an employee get out of his vehicle and exchange words with one of the workers. It looked as though he made a left turn when clearly there were signs that said no left turns and he may have almost hit the worker with his car as the man was doing his job. I will also add that all the turn arrows were red which clearly means no turns. He then proceeded to hold up traffic and curse at the young man.Very sad scene to say the least. Needless to say, I will not be spending money at this location If that is how the owner treats people that are trying to make our city nicer. read more

Thomas I.

4 months ago

jersey mike's delivers again! nothing short of impeccable. you can't possibility go wrong with andrew martin and noah! they are the best in the game! the food still slaps and andrew martin has great taste for recommending me the italian! the fact that this business is rated 2.9 is an atrocity! best business in pewaukee hands down!! we love jersey mike's!! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - sandwiches - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Jersey Mike's Subs also viewed

Jersey Mike's Subs

4.0

(8 reviews)

In the Jersey mikes vs Subway Vs Jimmy John's battle, Jersey mikes wins everytime. I order the same…read morething every time I go which is the original Italian sandwich. I get literally everything on it and ask for a couple sides of chipotle Mayo and Buffalo sauce on the side for no charge. Workers there are AWESOME and never forget anything. They even let me know that they didn't forget the side sauces when I pick up! Great place and thank you to those workers!! Y'all are the best!

Usually fast food chains in Milwaukee can result in opposite ends of the spectrum but this Jersey…read moreMike's location is really nice. Clean and nice staff, the worker Steve was very helpful to my boyfriend and I!

Jersey Mike's Subs

5.0

(4 reviews)

Nice that are starting to have a bundle combo instead of à la cart pricing…read more This locals not as busy as some of the other locations in the area As a sub shop it is pricey Clean store overall

Went to Jersey Mike's for a sub sandwich today. The staff was awesome and was able to carry a…read moreconversation. I love their sandwiches! The bread is soft yet crusty and the meat is freshly cut in front of you. The vegetables all look fresh and plump. If you're going to get a sub, make sure you get it Mike's way. I highly recommend and will definitely be back.

Firehouse Subs

3.3

(84 reviews)

Firehouse Subs are delicious especially the Smokehouse Cheese sub…read more We ordered on the app and it was ready in a timely manner. We will be back!

I specifically went over to try the thanksgiving limited time sub and a NY steamer because a…read morethanksgiving and a pastrami sub/sandwich is a rarity in the Milwaukee area. No one was in front me as I ordered my sandwiches which took 15 minutes to make, see my picture of the receipt time and when I snapped a picture with the time stamp when my name was called. The one star is because a guy walked in 5 minutes after me and placed an order and left 5 minutes before me WTF, how does some who walks in after me get their food before me ??????. The thanksgiving sub looked great on the display all big and enticing but in reality it's pathetic looking and skimpy on the turkey, see my pictures. The stuffing tasted just like stove top which isn't a bad thing because I grew on it . Even though the turkey was skimpy it's was moist and more like carved turkey vs lunch meat. Overall it's a great concept but the execution vs advertising is way far apart and watching a customer get in and out before me after walking in after me just blows my mind and totally earned them a poor review. How can JJs with a line in front of me freaky fast hand me a sandwich in 5 minutes ?.

Chick-fil-A

3.1

(54 reviews)

Eat more chicken We are never disappointed! Typically, we always order ahead of time to pick up…read morein store. Little to no wait time!

Potbelly

3.5

(49 reviews)

Stopped by to get something to go for lunch. While the line was a bit long, they work quite fast…read more All the staff were very kind. The place itself was nicely cleaned. I ordered an original Italian sub, and it was delicious! The peppers were nice and spicy, but if you do not like spicy, then I would stay away from them. Overall, great experience, would come back.

Came here for a quick bite and I ordered the avo turkey sandwich and to my surprise my sandwich…read moreliterally had l lettuce and turkey in it, no avocado and no cucumbers, no cheese as advertised. With it being so busy I didn't even bother going back to complain about this, but I was definitely upset. I still ate my very dry sandwich because I was hungry but next time I guess I have to make sure I ask if I'm getting the ingredients listed for the sandwich??? im not sure what im missing here.. We also ordered a cup of broccoli cheddar soup, which of course it was very good . I think if they have new staff, they should definitely be paying attention because this was an awful sandwich and the service was extremely slow! You will most likely never return to this location for a sandwich .

The Original Suburpia

3.7

(146 reviews)

Suburpia subs taste different from most The oil dressing…read moreand tiny minced onions and the bread all stand out from other places

Always a treat to go here. Sandwiches are unmatched in flavor. I get the King Louie double meet no…read moreonions or tomatoes. Sometimes they put too much lettuce on, sometimes it's just fine. Service is quick and friendly. There's seats there but most people get their bag sandwhiches to go. Highly recommend.

Dairy Queen Grill & Chill

3.2

(10 reviews)

Something is going on with their ice cream. Not sure if it was a bad batch but I threw away an…read moreentire blizzard. This was the first time that I have had this experience ever at this Dairy Queen. My husband said his ice cream tasted off as well.

Food is hot and tasty, and their ice cream is the best. Wishing & praying that they bring back…read moretheir Banana Cream Pie Blizzard. If they would do that I'd give them a 100 star rating!!!

Culver's

3.9

(16 reviews)

We went to a Memorial Day cookout early in the day - by the time we left and walked around Target,…read morewe were pretty hungry. My kids (adult kids) both ordered chicken strips and fries. My hubby ordered a burger and fries. I don't eat much so I ordered a kid's meal burger and fries. Service was fine - no problems at all. All of our food arrived at our table pretty quick and it was hot and pretty tasty. I actually cannot think of a time when our Culver's meal was anything less than hot and tasty. The restaurant looked a little messy - the garbage containers were overflowing and the drink area was .... bad... really messy and the parking lot was a real mess.

Brought my two kids and our friend along for a spontaneous dinner and was low key kind of impressed…read morewith Culver's. Haven't been in years and it was the first time to this (new'ish) location. It was clean as can be, and despite being fairly busy, the staff did great cranking out orders. My two littles split the kids cheese burger, which as a meal came with a side, drink, and ice cream scoop. All this for like 8 bucks is a heck of a deal in my opinion. Sizable portions too. I also added an extra side of broccoli (nice they offer that). I went with the grilled chicken sandwich and it was darn good! I'm not someone who regularly eats fast food, and quite honestly am normally turned off by it, but the quality here was good! We sat inside at a booth, and pulled up a kids highchair that came equip with a whole tray attachment. If you're a parent to a small kiddo, you know that's appreciated. They do have plenty of outdoor seating as well. Prefer to take food to go? They've got dual drive thru lines. Maybe we'll swing through there sometime soon since we did indeed enjoy our meals.

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.3

(4 reviews)

I absolutely love Jersey Mike's and the staff is always super nice and friendly! My only complaint…read moreis that they have almost always forget to include the sides I request in the special instructions. This has happened multiple times and it's pretty disappointing to get home and realize part of my order is missing. I really hope this will change but other than that I've always had a great experience and really enjoy the food!

Friendly staff, quick service but it's just another fast food option. The fresh new store was…read morespotlessly clean. The food has no taste distinction over other sub sandwiches. I ordered the Italian sub; it was a " dumbed down" bland version for the US dining public. GVZ

GoldCoast Subs

4.1

(76 reviews)