This Jersey Mike's is solid. It's part of a complex, so parking is easy. The employees are always friendly, and orders are made fresh every time. If you order online or through the app, I do recommend checking your order before leaving. There have been a few occasions where an item was missing or something was made incorrectly, but they've always fixed it right away and with a smile. Definitely download the app to earn points. If you frequent Jersey Mike's like I do, those points add up and you'll score a free sandwich every now and then. Overall, a reliable spot with great customer service read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - East Hanover, New Jersey

See all

Worst place to buy a sub. Management smokes a lot of weed and who what they'll do to your sub.

Stopped in and they were training a new person. Great subs, good portions and they caught they put the wrong bread top on the one they were working on for me... they took another half and cut it up and threw out the extra half leftover, I could've taken that home plain, too, instead of getting that thrown away! $20 for a giant, $12-14 for a regular and a mini was only $8-9. Some seating but mostly people taking out. read more

Here's the thing - I tried Jersey Mike's many, many years ago before it became widely popular and had multiple locations. At that time, it was mainly based in the South Jersey area. I was not impressed. I wouldn't call myself a sub snob, but... maybe someone else would. Lol. This may be seem like an odd complaint, but, I hated my sandwich because it was dry and overloaded with meat. Too much meat. The meat to bread & other ingredients/condiments ratio was completely off/mismatched. It is what it is. Bad food experiences stick w/me just as strongly as great ones. So, suffice it to say, as Jersey Mike's popular grew over the years, I was both confused & unmoved lol. Every time I wanted to give in & see what the "new" hype was about, I had flashbacks to that awful sub in Long Branch and said, nope! Now that that's been said, I finally decided to give it another go - several years later. What changed my mind? The menu. My friend & I just had to try a chicken cheesesteak, and just for kicks, I decided to give their cold sub another try (hence the "mini" pictured). So, I enjoyed the hot sub more than the cold sub (I've had better elsewhere like Quick Check, WaWa, and even Shoprite deli). Anyway, the chipotle chicken cheesesteak is delicious, a tiny bit salty, and it's missing something - maybe a few dollops of ketchup would take it from good to great. The turkey & provolone cold sub was just okay, the extra oil & vinegar helped a lot. If I go back it'd definitely be for a hot sub, not cold. read more

See all

There's not too much you can enjoy at Jersey Mike's while pregnant (I'm nearly there) but normally I'm a huge fan of their sandwiches. Prices are fair and sandwiches come loaded with lots of cold cuts, veggies, etc. Service is always speedy. I recently tried a BLT and was actually really impressed with this. A new go-to pregnancy order! The sandwich came with lots of crispy bacon, and hits the spot for a sandwich fix when cold cuts are not an option. They also have some cheesesteak sandwiches that looked good, so maybe next time. Overall this is always a good place to get a sub and I'm not surprised to see how they've grown in popularity. It seems as if there is a new Jersey Mikes opening everywhere I look! read more

I didn't plan for lunch and was going to get some fast food until I saw that there was a Jersey Mike's around! You can place your order, pay online and then go pickup contact free. They have a table with the food in bags labeled by name for pickup. They're quick If you're like me and don't feel like ordering online. The have hand sanitizer, everybody is wearing a mask & gloves and have markings on the floor to help enforce social distancing. You probably want to know about the food though right? The quality of their meat seems decent, I don't think it's boarshead but it also isn't "turkey roll". They have all the obvious stuff and make damn good Italian sandwich. You can chose your size, toppings and drink. They have some hot subs as well; cheesesteaks, meatball parm. I recently stopped eating beef and pork products so I just get the turkey sub and they even have vegetarian options as well. The prices are reasonable. The service is friendly. jersey Mikes is the perfect choice for sandwiches, especially if you're in a hurry. Other good think about Jersey Mike's if your trying to reduce your carbon footprint like me, is they don't wrap everything in plastic which makes it a win/win! Enjoy! read more

See all

I just love Jersey mikes their sandwiches are soo fresh and delicious! We have them three times a week

Jimmy at the Livingston location was great. He showed excellent customer service. He is a great asset to the company. read more

While I'm not as huge a fan of Jersey Mike's as some family members, I do like to occasionally stop in. The sandwiches are consistently fresh. I think I need to diversify from the standard #11! I will say that if we're stuck at home without a plan for dinner, JM's always feels like a healthy alternative. This East Hanover location is convenient and service always very friendly! read more

The subs were yummy as always and decently proportioned with a friendly staff behind the counter. However, despite 6 employees behind the counter when it wasn't all that busy, the dining hall was pretty messy with straw wrappers, sub papers and food crumbs all over the floor. The soda station had dried up spills all over and just generally looked like it hadn't been wiped down all day. Also had some concerns with a young man on the slicer with his hair pulled back into a ponytail but no visor/hat on and an AirPod in his ear while he worked. He sliced meats, took hot sub orders on the meatcase, handled the phone, etc. without ever changing gloves. And as a shortcut for himself I assume, he would slice meat he was going to use on a later sub in advance and leave it sitting on the little flat part of the slicer under the blade. I would almost dismiss this if he'd at least take the time to wipe down that area between meats but when I saw him slice my ham in advance and leave it in the little pool of turkey and roast beef/blood residue that had built up, I had to ask to have it sliced again and placed right onto the bread as should be done. Otherwise the subs were great but with a restaurant set up like Jersey Mike's, employees have to remember they are constantly in the limelight as they are preparing customers' meals. read more

See all

Subs are decent. Food prep people are not. They're all teenagers and the sanitary issues are many. They never actually clean the sandwich board between sandwiches, they just scrape it quickly, which leaves moisture on it from the past sub. i watched the cutter cut 8 sandwiches in a row wothout cleaning the knife. That is horrendous in terms of cross-contamination. If i'm allergic to eggs snd there's mayonnaise on the knife blade, I could have a bad reaction. Food prep 101. Keep the tools clean. When I asked the frat bro idiot to clean the knife he said he always did, which was a blatant lie. So add attitude to the mix. The place needs better training and management. read more

Killer Cheese Steak Subs!! Get the # 43 chipotle cheese steak sub with grilled onions, peppers, white american cheese, and chipotle mayonnaise. Then get a bag of Miss Vickie's kettle cooked potato chips to keep your sub company. Grab a drink and maybe even a cookie or chocolate chip brownie for snack time laters ;) Come and Get your Munch on!! read more

See all

Awful beyond awful experience, sadly my worst experience at. Jersey Mike's ever. Placed a pickup order for 3 sandwiches and they were all completely made wrong. Staff didn't know or care to have it ready and they were made so carelessly. Please avoid this location, such a shame. read more

I work near this location and we get takeout from here often. Typically the food is good, although they do often mess up our orders and ignore the notes we input online. Today I ordered a turkey sandwich and halfway through eating my sandwich, I felt something very hard. It seems there was a bone fragment or something in my sandwich. I called to notify the store and they acted as if I was lying about it and asked that I send pictures. I sent them several images and never heard back. I just called again to make sure they got it and was told the store manager wouldn't be in for another 2 days and to call back then. So nobody cares or did anything about there being a hard and very pointy object in my sandwich I got for them. Awful customer service and QC! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - This was in my turkey sandwich!! - Sandwiches Near Me - East Hanover, New Jersey

See all

Just left this Jersey Mike's... there are just four people working, with several call outs, but they are KILLING it. There's a line that wraps around inside the store, and these four young workers are moving at warp speed, getting people's orders faster than I could have imagined was possible, smiling, laughing, and being super cheerful and positive the whole time. Kudos to them - they all deserve raises!!! Also, our sandwiches were fantastic - fresh and tasty! read more

**** update to review. As I have long suspected, the offer to "make it right" was nonsense. When you see rebuttals from owners/managers on Yelp, one must consider if these answers are purely cosmetic. Server was nice. Kind enough to point out we earned rewards of a free half sub. Bread was at least one day old. Crumbly, crappy. Would have rather paid for a fresh one. Skip it here. **** update to review. As I have long suspected, the offer to "make it right" was nonsense. When you see rebuttals from owners/managers on Yelp, one must consider if these answers are purely cosmetic. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Receipt - Sandwiches Near Me - East Hanover, New Jersey

So the 1st time I came here was when my company was on strike near this location. At the time I came here it was only for convenience because I didn't feel like driving. After trying one sandwich, I was hooked!!! I haven't had a sandwich like that in sooo long! Back then I tried the turkey and cheese; tonight I'm trying the "Chipotle Cheese steak". The reason I gave this place 5 stars is because every time I've come here, the customer service and food has always been good!! I always have a great experience here and will continue to come back! read more

Horrible staff rude and disrespectful. Employees are too busy giving away free stuff to their friends and families and ignoring customers and not listening. read more

Sandwich was tasty. My problem was the brother slicing bread and taking the orders had an attitude and not friendly at all. He didn't offer the different types of bread available for my sandwiches. He was just using white rolls. When I asked for the rosemary he had an attitude. The girls were very pleasant, but he obviously didn't want to be working. Unfortunately with all the eateries in the area I wont return. read more

This evening, the servers were rude and did not want to be bothered by any customers walking through the door. So I left and went to a different location with friendlier staff. read more

Solid sub joint. Real, fresh ingredients. Staff was friendly and fast. Place was clean and bright. They have grew hours and are easily accessible from rt 10 (both sides!) and river road. Huge parking lot. I rolled in starving after work to grab a sub before running some errands on 10 and I was glad this place was easy to get to (and I didn't have to succumb to any dark awful fast food cravings, or settle for chipotle-which I am SO sick of). read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Mmmmm turkey - Sandwiches Near Me - East Hanover, New Jersey

I enjoy a sub from this place ...the bread is soft and the deli meat is fresh! I love that they make it right in front of you. I always get roast beef and turkey and it's always good. I usually get it Mikes way without onions. They have a good story of how they started there business. They are pricey so I usually just get a sub. I also like the one in Stafford. If you want a good sub on a nice fresh roll , try this place out. Also give them your email online and they will give you a free sub on your birthday!! Great deal!!! The coupon is good for a year. read more

Great location. Very clean. Every time I go there the staff are extremely courteous, friendly and will take care of any requests you need. I have never had a bad experience any time i've gone to this location. Food is always fresh! I always want to call and ask for a manager to compliment the staff. I think some people give a hard time, because the people who work there are on the younger side-- I guess people forget what its like to have a first job...be nice! read more

I was reluctant to try Jersey Mike's, with so many local sub shops around the area why go to a chain? However, they've perfected the conveyor belt method of preparing sandwiches, ingredients- including bread- always seem fresh, prices are good, and staff always friendly. As a creature of habit, and someone who enjoys the comforts of home, I am curious to find out how Jersey Mike's does outside of New Jersey where sub sandwiches may not be as much a staple in local diets! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Not quite "Mike's Way"- but no problem if you'd rather go your way. - Sandwiches Near Me - East Hanover, New Jersey

This is one of my favorite places to eat. I love their subs so much! Today I ordered a mini tuna sub and it was super satisfying. It was really tasty and when I went in the store to order it, the employees were all very kind. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #10 Tuna Fish - Sandwiches Near Me - East Hanover, New Jersey

When I'm in the East Hanover area and craving a sandwich, this is the place I'll visit. I've always had good experiences at this location and haven't had a bad one yet. Although most of the employees I've encountered are of teenage age, I've always been greeted when I enter the establishment and they are courteous when ordering. The restaurant interior is well-maintained and clean which is always a plus. I appreciate how this Jersey Mike's location is receptive to taking phone orders near closing time. This one time I got caught in a bind picking up food for my family because it was around 8:50 pm and I was stuck in line at the Smashburger (My family likes different things so I commonly visit multiple food restaurants) across the street. The employee on the phone was nice enough to take my order and told me I was in no rush. Since I knew the place closed at 9 pm I ended up briskly walking across the street to pick up the order. While I pushed the limits of closing time, the employee greeted me in the same way as if I was there during normal hours. With food chain restaurants and younger staff that scenario doesn't always play out so well but I definitely appreciated the customer service that night. All in all, I enjoy this location of Jersey Mike's Subs. The food is fresh and the customer service is great. If this location wasn't out of the way from where I live, I'd probably order here more often. If you are looking for recommendations for food, the #9 Club Supreme and the #17 Philly Cheese Steak are some nice options. Give this place a try! read more

These guys on route 10 east Hanover never follow directions when ordering on the app. I asked for mayo but yet get a dry sandwich with a hot soda so disappointed. This is the 2nd time this happened. read more

Stale bread . Not a good look! Let's get serious mr. mike. We want fresh bread! I'm not a goose

Disgusting store. 6. I count 6, staff members "working" and half of the front doors isn't even opened? The store is a mess when I walk in. You have 6 employees standing around doing nothing and the store isn't spotless? Ordered: Chicken cheese steak just cheese, became beef steak and cheese. Okay. Mistakes happen. They made a new sandwich. Ordered: Grilled chicken sub, mike's way, bacon, cheese, mayo. They didn't do it mike's way. Okay. Mistakes happen. The staff member decided to question me if I ordered it Mike's way. Not I'm sorry. Not let me make you a new one. Just did you order it Mike's way? Do not show your customers disrespect like that. Obviously I was clear when I ordered my sandwich that I wanted it Mike's way, And out of 6 people working you couldn't execute. Oh, and the soda machine, yeah they just don't have some selections. Oh, and American Express cards... yeah they just don't work. To the owner: your staff reflects your business. If your doors can't even be properly opened in the morning, it's a problem. If your store is dirty, it's a problem. If 6 staff members can't get two sandwiches right, it's a problem. If your staff questions the customer, instead of trying to make it right, it's a problem. If you can't keep your soda machine stocked, it's a problem. If your credit card processing machine isn't taking American Express and you don't fix it, it's a problem. I don't see how this store can last much longer. First and last time I will go to this location. Whippany, NJ location makes this location look like a joke. The owners should be ashamed of their staff and the condition of this store. read more

We went in around 8.40pm looking to pick up a couple of sandwiches for dinner. The lady behind the counter could not have looked more bored or annoyed at our arrival (no other customers when we went in). She then proceeded to make my sandwich with white bread without even asking first. When I asked for wheat bread she gave me major attitude as if to say I was really holding her up and it was unreasonable of me to want wheat bread. Our sandwiches were good but expensive for their size. Even though this location is convenient for me, next time I will go somewhere else. I don't want to deal with her again. read more

My last review I said I was done with this place. A buddy reached out the other day & asked if I wanted a sandwich from Jersey Mike's & he was gonna stop by my office. I thought to myself 'what the hell I'll give them one more shot' & ordered a turkey provolone Mike's way with mayo. Open up the sandwich and no tomatoes. That's FIVE sandwiches in a row I ordered from them that were screwed up. I am 100% done with this dump. Do yourself a favor & get a sandwich anywhere else but this place! Unreal!!!!!! read more

Excellent subs! I went there while they were doing a four day fundraiser doing sandwiches for $2.00. The place was packed and I still didnt wait more than ten minutes for my order which means they move fast during lunch time. I went two days in a row and had the roast beef special and The Jersey Shore special and both were excellent. The sandwich meat is sliced to order and are made right In front if you. Free refills in your drinks. Staff was friendly and remembered us from the day before. read more

The unprofessionalism of the East Hanover store is unbelievable. I had walked in to order a "Giant #13" for a kids birthday party. She took the order and said "Pay first"--I did and told the employees that while they were making it "Mike's Way", I was going to run next door and get a balloon at Party City. As I was leaving, the employee had her co-worker take an order and ring up someone she knew personally. When I came back in 10 minutes later, the employee looked at me and said she completely forgot about my order and walked into the back. She had a male colleague start my sandwich and she came back in to finish it. While she was making the sandwich, she asked if I had paid for it (I had). In any other Jersey Mike's I have been to, they waited until the order was complete before asking for payment. This employee (who was not wearing a name tag) seemed to be only concerned about getting payments and hooking up her friends. Don't waste your time dealing with the unprofessionalism of the East Hanover Jersey Mike's. You are better off going up the road to the one in Whippany or Parsippany--those two know how to treat their customers right. read more

Great customer service and tasty fresh subs at the Parsippany location. Employees are knowledgeable, courteous and we are always greeted with a smile and hello. The subs we order are always delicious, and made just the way we like them - Mike's way... Our fav's are #17 Philly Cheesesteak, #10 Tuna, #13 The Original Italian. We can order online pickup or have delivered via door dash, lots of parking if we decide to dine there, and discounts with Mike's rewards - join and earn points towards free subs every time you purchase a sub. A nice experience and good food - thank you! read more

We always get great service at this location and a good sandwich, too. They seem to always have everything in stock, and it's all fresh too. I find it better tasting and a better value for the money than other chain sub shops. My only complaint is that if you're eating in the restaurant, it can be a really hectic place. It's set up so the line (if it's long, and it tends to be on weekends) goes past all the tables. I know it's likely unavoidable due to the setup of the restaurant, but makes for a loud, less enjoyable eating in experience. So, take it home if possible. read more

This place over jimmy Johns, subway, etc any day period. The food is fresh. Fairly priced and the staff always engages in conversation with customers. I eat here about 3 times a week for lunch and I've never witnessed anything negative while eating or ordering here. The lunch lines grow quickly but Rich and his team stay focused and keep the service fast, efficient and friendly. Love you guys keep up the great work and happy 1 year ! Sincerely, Mike and James read more

It's alright but every time I come and get a mini sub here, the bread is always stale. Every single time, never have this issue at any other locations. read more

I love it here! Finally happy my favorite sub place is so close to home now!! They have the best sandwiches ever!! The store is new and clean and the staff is so fun and nice! read more

This location is a standout. It's new so it's clean. Also the staff is very friendly. Their chicken cheesesteaks rock.

The meat is suspect. Watery turkey and def not Thumans or Boars Head quality. If they got real turkey for example instead of ground turkey parts with water in a bag, the sandwich would be great. Good bread, fresh lettuce and tomatoes for sure...but the fake Jersey Mike brand meat is a non starter for us. Take it up a few notches with real meat now that you are making money and i will come back. read more