Jersey Mike&#x27;s Subs

Let's start with the main draw... open 24 hours, in a place where us 8pm dinner hour people find it…read morehard difficult to locate dining without eating far too early for our usual schedule. It came up FAST and HOT. it must have weighed 5lbs. I can express how happy I am that we opted to split a meal, as we still had leftovers. The shredded beef burritos were tender & juicy, in need of some hot sauce but that's personal preference. The tortilla was good - the beans, meh - but a bite with the burrito paired well enough. I didn't eat the rice so I can't say there. It looked like an acceptable version. Given the price, it was far better than I expected. Skip the guac, seriously, skip it.

I was craving Mexican food and I used the drive-through service..so many options but my go-to is…read morecarnitas. I ordered the plate. It came loaded with crispy shredded pork, lettuce, Pico, beans and rice. Four containers, 2 each of sauce salsas Roja and Verde. There was so much food it made 2 whole meals. The tortillas were probably 12" wide. I spend a lot of time down south in Arizona and I am used to seeing Carnitas being prepared in a cubed state, so the pulled pork was a surprise. I would go again. It didn't blow my socks off, but service was fast and friendly and the food was pretty good.

Dining area

#3 Cheese Enchiladas, w/ Beans & Rice.Sauce great, sadly enchiladas trash as not cooked through since o styrofoam.Never again.

See all

Beans Tostada. Trust me it's under there. It's huge. Also ordered a 4 ounce side of pico de gallo($1.39).

Taco Bell

2.0(15 reviews)

0.8 mi

Newer remodeled Taco Bell that's probably about five years old. Inside is tiny and most likely…read morecan't seat more than twenty. It's your standard Taco Bell menu and food service. Nothing to get too excited about. Like I say "eat at Taco Bell, and give your pooper hell." The drive thru is much slower than the east side location and it has a tight turning radius for big truck.

Teach your people how to make the food. Taco supreme had no tomatoes, sour cream or cheese. Mini…read moretaco had no beef on it and extra extra extra dressing. So everything was pretty much disgusting but I got to pay for it. This location is consistently horrible.

See all

QDOBA Mexican Eats

2.8(25 reviews)

0.5 mi

Always excellent and well managed. The cleanliness has improved at this site, and I salute…read moremanagement who has the initiative to make sure conditions are sanitary and orderly. Also, I've had this store cater to 3 different events and at all times everything was outstanding. Keep up the good work and thanks again!!!

I have never left a review but felt this one was necessary…read more I've enjoyed Qdoba before, but this was the worst restaurant experience I've had. Staff joked, "Are we poisoning people?" while holding questionable guac they nearly served me. Employees were cussing and arguing openly. The unprofessionalism was staggering

A burrito bowl topped with freshly grilled adobo chicken brings the flavor!

QDOBA Mexican Eats - Grilled quesadillas are stuffed with chef-selected ingredients like grilled steak and hand-sliced,
sautéed-in-house fajita ve...

Grilled quesadillas are stuffed with chef-selected ingredients like grilled steak and hand-sliced, sautéed-in-house fajita ve...

See all

Earn points, score rewards, and place your order on the QDOBA Rewards app.

Arby's

2.8(9 reviews)

1.0 mi

Good Lord, your employees are lazy and rude. Doesn't matter what time a day your employees are…read moreconsistently lazy and rude. I'd rather drive 15 minutes across town and eat at the other one then to deal with your employees at this location.

I'm from out of town and that is one of the nicest Arby's inside a little bit outdated but very…read moreclean. The service was great and the food was nice and hot. Love your Arbys ben Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Steamboat Deli & Outlet

4.5(41 reviews)

3.0 mi

Going back for lunch ! Just had dinner there last Friday... going this week for lunch !! Can't wait…read more.. this place has it all ... great food .. great service.. you won't be disappointed at steamboat deli..

They were closing early for Thanksgiving but were more than happy to take a last minute phone…read moreorder. When walking it has the look and feel of a local deli. The chicken salad is fresh & served on a wheat cranberry walnut bread. I felt like that chicken salad was missing something, but it's still good.

Cool flag on wall

Roast beef and great flavor, way underwhelming size.

See all

Exterior

Little Shop of Burgers

3.8(91 reviews)

3.7 mi

We stopped here on our way to Tetons and were glad we did! We ordered the Huffle Puffs, The…read moreTremor, and the Freddy. The Huffle Puffs were some of the best sweet potato tater tots I've ever had. The insides actually had pieces of sweet potato with a crunchy outside. The dipping sauce wasn't my favorite but went very well with the sweetness of the potatoes. The Tremor was a solid bacon cheeseburger. The patty was not too big or too thin, and cooked perfect. It also came with fries which were great. We also got the Freddy, which was good but after a few bites the seasoning was a little overwhelming and the big strips of jalapenos were burning our mouths. A decent pick if that's what you like but a little more than we bargained for. Inside, the restaurant was decked out in horror movie décor and the staff was very friendly and attentive. Given the few options for lunch in Casper, we will definitely be back!

Great themed restaurant, but horrible food (greasy and salty)…read more We should have left when the picked fries came. Tasted like fish and super greasy. It was really inedible. Clearly the cooking oil was old and needed to be changed. The hamburgers tasted like they were preformed, packaged and previously frozen . My wife could only eat half of hers and I pretty much forced mine down. For the price, I expected way better. On the good side, the service was good. Again, loved the theme of the restaurant. Just change your cooking oil daily, use less salt and source better hamburger meat and you should do well.

The Tremor!

Fungus Amung Us

See all

Thankskilling Burger

McDonald's

2.0(15 reviews)

0.3 mi

Used coupon and got two great sandwiches.. great service place was clean ... now you can get any…read moresandwiches with a survey

11:33 pm and I was told they could only take cards because they pulled the drawer early. A guy in a…read moretruck left without food, I left without food and the car behind me, left without food. You lost 3 orders ($$) because your people are trying to leave early. This store is never good but damn.

M&M McFlurry in new Paper Cup. No longer the weird square handled spoon either.

Choking hazard

See all

French Fries Salt Packet

Guadalajara

3.6(108 reviews)

0.8 mi

Nice big place with interesting decor. The service was fast and friendly…read more The chips were brought to the table with salsa and a bean dip. The chips were fresh, light, and crispy. No complaints. The bean dip was a pleasant surprise. The salsa was good enough. We tried the diablo wings and saved most of them for leftovers as they reheat nicely in our air fryer. We both had fajitas which are a large serving with ample tortillas provided which was also a surprise as I usually have to ask for more. We ended up with another meal made up of fajita leftovers and wings for the next day.

The food is usually pretty spot on. My favorite is the pollo con crema. My hubby's is the grande…read morecombination platter. The problem is the service. It is always slow as if you've just straight been forgotten, even when it's slow. Wouldn't be near as much of a problem if you couldn't see the servers all just standing around shooting the breeze, ignoring you. The place is usually quiet enough and you can carry on a conversation without having to shout.

Entering!

Green Chili Chimichanga with pork carnitas and chilis filling. Smothered in pork green chili and cheese. Sadly burnt.

See all

Chile Relleno lunch combo.

Wendy's

2.3(9 reviews)

1.8 mi

Your night crew is so rude and lazy. However, the angry and bitter person that calls herself a…read moremanager, she's the worst and definitely makes the customer understand why the crew is so miserable. It's a shame too because your day crew is amazing

We typically stop here as we travel through Casper. For the most part the service is quick and food…read morehits the spot. Bathrooms are clean. We order with a person or kiosk.

Out to the street indeed lol Must be great food

4 for $4 w/ Jr bacon cheeseburger & Jbc (jr. Bacon Cheeseburger)

See all

Taco John's

1.4(9 reviews)

0.3 mi

Went through the drive through and ordered 2 combos. 1 scrambler and 1 Jr bacon combo (which should…read morehave 2 burritos). Got our bag and drove away to realize we were missing the two Jr breakfast burritos. Drove back and explained the issue. Was told that it was impossible and that they needed their manager to fix the issue as they didn't have the authority to fix their mistake. Also had employee shut door on us during conversation. No other customer in the drive through either time would make it pretty simple to keep inventory in order. Will never be back, not for the mistake of missing burritos but because we were called liars as if we had nothing better to do besides steal 2 burritos.

Disgusting and disappointing. ZERO STARS! We've been loyal Taco John's customers for nearly 30…read moreyears, and this location is by far the worst. Not a single clean table in 2 visits, and bathrooms so vile I couldn't even wash my hands. The walls were dirty, everything was sticky, and both toilets were smeared and splattered with poo. Despite having plenty of staff (5-6 at least), no one was cleaning or even trying. None seem willing to clean, engage, or put in even minimal effort. Portions were tiny compared to other locations. We gave them a second chance--same awful experience. Avoid this place: Taco John's 4035 Plaza Drive Casper Wyoming

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Wendy D.

102

9 years ago

chicken parm is microwaved chicken...rubbery nasty

C M.

10 years ago

just another sub shop but high priced

Jersey Mike's Subs - sandwiches - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Jersey Mike's Subs also viewed

Schlotzsky's

3.7

(17 reviews)

We used to have them in northern Nevada, so when we saw that they had one here we jumped at the…read morechance to try them again. They have good sandwiches. This is a new business model where they put their businesses inside a gas station. I hope their new business model brings them lots of success.

Food was good. but the service was not! The Guy never even asked if I wanted a side or a drink it…read morewasn't till after I paid he asked "oh did you want a drink".

Five Guys

3.4

(62 reviews)

Lets start this story with the understanding that while I have dined at 5 Guys restaurants across…read morethe nation, this is the first time I used the Five Guys app. I was using it because we were having a busy day and I didn't want to have to go into a diner, wait in line, hob knob around with a bunch of people. We had been moving stuff around in a storage unit and we were tired, dirty and hungry and we had our dogs in our vehicle. Ok now that you know the setting lets get to it. I downloaded the app and navigated through the usual annoying app set up and got to the menu without any issue. My wife and I made our selections. Two burgers and one regular fry, no drinks. Navigate through the tip section. I am picking up, no drive through. No tip. Hate me if you want. $28.53 or 14.26/per person and we are sharing an order of fries. As I said before I have dined at Five Guys all over so it was no shock what the bill was, but we wanted a decent fast food burger and no hassle, so I was happy to pay it. They app said it would tell me when my food was ready. I headed to the restaraunt and jockyed for a parking spot for a few minutes and went in the diner. It was packed. I Looked around for the little shelp most places put up for door dashers and pick up orders. Nada. I opened up the app and it said it would be 8/10 min. So I went back to my truck to keep my dogs company while my order was cooking. After 10 min the App said my order was complete. Awesome. I walked up to the counter where the servers were handing out orders and after a few orders were called out for pick up, I asked the server if this is where the PU was for App orders. The server asked my name and then disappeared back into the fray. A few more orders came and went, and I began to think that my order had been picked up by some other guest. I waited for the incoming line to die down and then asked the cashier if my order was available. He took my name and asked the line cooks to find my order. Which they did, and he told me that I was in the queue and would be notified when it was ready. At this point it was already 15 minutes since the app said my order was complete. So I milled around as another batch of orders were called out. I waited until I started noticing a people who had arrived after me began to get their orders. Mind you I didn't order anything crazy, 2 hamburgers one fry. I had now been in the restaurant for 38 minutes after the App told me my order had been complete and considering my order was 84 and the orders that were leaving the window were 94, 96 I was beginning to get irritated. While I was standing waiting order at least three orders came back missing food or mis prepared, but as this is not their review, I won't elaborate. My wife was texting me asking if I had left for milk never to return. The only reason I had ordered by the App ahead of time was to not be hanging out in a diner while stinking and sweaty, but there I was, 45 minutes standing around waiting for two burgers. When the server called out my order (the same one I had asked to check on my order 30 minutes before and never returned) another diner stepped up and put hands on the bag of burgers. I had to interject and ask if that was for me and swooped in to rescue my lunch from another hungry guest. No thank you, no sorry for the wait. No regrets about no tip. Now for the rest of the story, for those whose life is sooo boring that they are still reading this tome, the burgers were good. As good as any I had ever had from a Five Guys, the fries were ok, just like they are from any Five Guys. That is why I left a two star review, because at lest the food was what I expected. But here is a pro tip, if you are going to use an App or Call ahead number, or a order by web, live up to your end of the deal. If the App says your order is ready, your order better darn well be ready. If you can't live up to that, take down the App, and set fire to your online web business. Then people can make a better decision about where they want to pay exorbitant amount for their pre ordered food. Because your food may not leave a bad aftertaste in your guests mouth but your customer service definitely will. Furthermore, put up a shelf, or a sign to let your dashers and your pre orders know where to pick up. That way they are not hanging out wondering WTH is going on, along with all your other guests. It will also keep your other guests from picking up someone else's food. And if you are the manager at Five Guys in Casper WY and you are reading this. I told you to expect a blistering review, at least I deliver on time.

Found the tip of a rubber glove in my hamburger. They remade the burger but I had trouble eating it…read moreafter that. Will I go back? Absolutely not. The fries used to be good but are now slimy brown things.

Hamburger Stand

3.4

(29 reviews)

first ever visit hit the spot ! FOOD SLAPS ! , good flavor, not overbearing with seasonings, and…read morethe front counter girls are cute! :P

I pick up a double cheeseburger and an order of fries at the Hamburger Stand on a regular basis. I…read morelove their hamburgers. They never disappoint Their fries are always hot. The service is always good and friendly also. And you can't beat their prices!

Blimpie

3.2

(5 reviews)

Oder a toasted sandwich and not one part of the sandwich was toasted would of asked again for it…read moreto be toasted but I had the feeling that would of not went over well for my sandwich.

Awful customer service. Left before we even ordered because the woman behind the counter was rude.read more

Arby's

3.2

(5 reviews)

Great sandwich, restaurant is very clean. Crapper was clean and had toilet paper. Ice on sidewalkread more

Ordered on the app and had a 25% off! Pulled up and they were finishing the order. 7 orders, 17…read moretotal items, and everything was in the bag. No errors. Fries and sandwiches were nice and hot. Staff was friendly. Bathrooms, tables, and drink station were all clean.

Cheba Hut "Toasted" Subs

3.8

(4 reviews)

Wow! The coolest, most modern new sandwich shop in all of Casper. Family owned & impeccably…read moredecorated, stop by soon to see what all the buzz is about. Lunchtime crowds (on a weekday, no less) can extend the wait line out the door, so plan your visit carefully and be ready to enjoy some incredibly tasty sandwiches. We got to meet the owners who are wonderful, caring people. They care about what their customers are experiencing! Fantastic, creative experiences await anyone giving Cheeba Hut a try.

A welcome addition to Casper. A lot of people complain about this place on Google, but my…read moreexperience on a mid-day Thursday was great. Food came out fast and fresh, no complaints, only praise. Think of an upgraded Quiznos that also has a bar. That's basically what you're getting. Friendly service, nice patio. I'll be back.

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

3.4

(67 reviews)

we came in a little late (sorry) at ten pm, and our server was ava. she was GREAT. ask for her if…read moreyou can, seriously the best server i've ever had. pasta was good and came out promptly.

It's good and filling unless it's take out. It depends on who takes the order. You will pay full…read moreprice but the portions are smaller and the salad price is outrageous!

Peaches Family Restaurant

3.7

(40 reviews)

Pretty decent food. Good fries! Wish you'd bring back the…read moreolder style of fish sandwiches you used to serve. They were so good. Newer style is just average.

Stopped in for lunch and got the bacon rancher. Was exactly what I was expecting after reading…read moreprevious reviews. Good burger. Really good fries. Perfect crispiness on the outside and soft on the inside. Service was average, however lightning fast. Will be back.

Subway

3.0

(5 reviews)

The food was amazing!! It's always super clean and has a good vibe. I come in at least once a month…read moreand im always served by this young lady named Ryleigh. She's always super friendly and is quick to help customers. Somebody better give this girl a raise for her hard work

The casher took customers money and then went and stuck her hands in the cheese with out gloves on…read more she would not bag my stuff up I had to my self. she was real rude. was at 12:30 on 9/26/23

Perkins Restaurant & Bakery

3.1

(55 reviews)