Missed it by that much, Jamie.
Came here for dinner on a Wednesday night, after having booked online SIX weeks in advance (and even then, there were only timeslots past 8pm left). The place was packed! If you want to eat here, you really do need to plan and book it in.
The building is absolutely gorgeous. Located on the corner of King William Street and North Terrace, Jamie's Italian is in the old Westpac Bank building. Despite now hosting diners rather than dollars, the architecture and heritage-nature of the building has not been compromised. A particular feature is actually the bathrooms downstairs, which are inside the old bank vaults. Definitely worth a visit whether you need it or not!
Our table wasn't quite ready upon arrival, so we headed to the bar for a couple of drinks. We ended up getting a Jamie's Italian Mojito and a Holy Espresso. Both drinks were delicious and kept us happy until it was time to be seated.
We were seated at a rather small table for two in the heart of the dining area. After a few minutes, we realised just how little space there actually was between all the tables. This really bothers me as it allows very little room for patrons and staff to move between tables. It also, to me anyway, screams 'we want to make as much money as possible even if that means compromising the experience'. I'm aware that a restaurant is a business, and a livelihood, but still. I'm also aware that Italian restaurants are traditionally a little bit romantic and intimate, but y'know, intimate with your partner/date/friend, not every patron.
Our server introduced himself to us, and he was a delight. Enthusiastic, funny and down-to-earth. I wish I remembered his name! He informed us of the daily specials and left us to decide what we wanted. We chose the Crab and Avocado Bruschetta and the 'Italian Nachos' (fried 3-cheese ravioli with a slightly spicy tomato salsa) for our entrées. How could you go past something with that name? Furthermore, anything stuffed with three cheeses is food of the flippin' gods. Our entrées were brought out promptly, and the portion sizes were good - enough to cure any hunger pain, but didn't ruin our appetite for dinner.
As our mains, we chose the Squid and Mussel Spaghetti Nero and the Summer Truffle Risotto. The spaghetti pasta was a little overcooked, but still tasted as though it had been freshly made. The sauce just wasn't right. Wasn't the right amount, consistency or flavour. It just lacked the kick from the capers and I was a little disappointed. The seafood, however, was cooked perfectly, thankfully! The risotto however, I had one mouthful and just couldn't do any more (and was secretly cursing myself for agreeing to share dishes). The gorgonzola was so, SO overpowering. I could not smell or taste anything other than the funky cheese. If you like strong cheeses and scents, go for your life, but I just couldn't take the richness of the cheese and the intense smell.
One big disappointment is the wine list. There's so much Italian wine. While, yes, it's an Italian restaurant so therefore Italian wine is fitting, I had hoped that local drops would have been given more opportunity to shine. Of the 8 red wines, one is from SA and one is from Victoria. The white wine list is split 50/50 between Australian and Italian. Furthermore, the varieties are not the usual sav blanc/riesling/shiraz etc. Despite having rather extensively toured most of SA's wine regions, the only varieties I'd heard of were rosé, prosecco, pinot grigio, montepulciano, nebbiolo and fiano. While I was able to navigate my way through it okay, I bet it would be pretty difficult for people who have less knowledge.
For dessert, we ordered the panna cotta, which was much-needed to get rid of the gorgonzola taste in my mouth! It was perfectly wobbly and wasn't overly rich. The fruit compote also added an acidic element to contrast the sweet.
Overall, Jamie's is essentially an upmarket Italian restaurant. It's hard when you put a well-renowned chef's name into the mix. Everyone must have such high expectations. It's good Italian food, but it's not great, and not what I expected from Jamie Oliver. I don't think it's worth the hype. The service however, is absolutely outstanding. I came and saw, but won't be a regular. read more