Really enjoyed Isla's this evening. We grabbed a reservation as this spot can get busy and received a prompt email confirmation. We started with salads and excellent ceviche and "Down South" oysters as we found the pimento cheese and bacon topping to be a fun twist on oysters Rockefeller. We had the 16 and 13 year old in tow and while our kids have open minds and pallets when it comes to food, there were some slight questions about the menu options. There was a kids menu that was standard and I'm sure would accommodate most kids; but, I would say Isla's menu is sophisticated and can be appreciated by a more mature audience. Our 13 year old ordered the shrimp and grits and won the best entree of the night. It's a nice twist using a grit cake as opposed to traditional shrimp and grits but the flavor of the tomato and chorizo gravy along with the texture of the crispy grit cake was an interesting and nice change from the norm. I will definitely go back and try additional entrees. Overall, all the dishes were well put together, well seasoned and paired with a nice wine list that had variety for all tastes. Last, I will say the service was among the best we've had locally. Brandon was attentive, informative and accommodating throughout our evening experience. Thank you to Isla's for a wonderful first experience. I look forward to returning soon! read more

Isla's On The Square - Apps, Dinner and Wine - Sports Bars Near Me - Spartanburg, South Carolina

Great spot to eat!!! I would say it's a must for downtown!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Got the creole shrimp appetizer with "roasted corn,onions and bell peppers " and side of grits (take-out). The shrimp was undercooked by alot. The corn just seemed like frozen or canned yellow corn with fake grill marks. The side of grits were ok but for $7.00, i would expect a little bigger of a portion. Wont be back. Its unfortunate because its a great location... read more

Isla's On The Square - Side grits - Sports Bars Near Me - Spartanburg, South Carolina

OK - daughter and son in law came to visit. Daughter is a foodie. She travels a lot. This place hit the spot. Great but focused menu. Oysters were great. Red snapper was my favorite. Service was great. Will definitely be going back. read more

Incredible food and extremely attentive service. Scallops cooked perfectly. Enjoyed dinner on the patio. read more

Isla's On The Square - Grilled salmon - Sports Bars Near Me - Spartanburg, South Carolina

See all

What a great restaurant to try during "Restaurant Week". I will say I was pleasantly surprised but mostly because I am not an Oyster person. Well none of us ordered Oysters and we were all pleased with our food. The corn fritters were not soggy like some but maintained the crunchy texture they needed. As you can see from my pictures the Shrimp Cocktail was for a king. The shrimp were gorgeous and tasted great. For my main course I tried the Salmon which is often my go to, and it was delicious. If the service would have been as good as the food I would have given them 5 's. Unfortunately our waiter forgot about us when our neighboring table arrived. There were some menu adjustments that had to be made and because he forgot to make them he just never returned. Overall I would strongly recommend this restaurant, from the glass wear to the presentation it is a gem in Spartanburg. read more

See all

After hearing about this place from our friends we decided to give it a try. The place is cozy with a good atmosphere, we timed it just right because we were promptly seated. We started with a glass of Padrillos Malbec for me and Louis Jadot Pinot Noir for the wife. For appetizer we enjoyed a very delicious dozen of Ostras Borrachas/drunken oysters. For entrees we both ordered Garden Salad with champagne vinaigrette and she had citrus vinaigrette dressings and our dishes were Lobster Ravioli and I had the Parmesan Crusted Halibut, both cooked to perfection (wife mentioned her Lobster ravioli not only was topped with more lobster, but was best she's had). For dessert we shared a Hazelnut Copa (real good). The service was outstanding; our server Leroy was knowledgeable, and took the time to explain each dish and help us with our selections. We will return for special occasions or even if it's just to sit at the bar and have a couple of drinks. read more

Isla's On The Square - Parmesan Crusted Halibut - Sports Bars Near Me - Spartanburg, South Carolina

See all

Isla's is our new oyster bar, seafood restaurant. Not really new anymore since has been open at least two years, but excellent. Great service. Great food. And love the friendly ambience with a good local vibe. Just visited after the new year and was able to get Stone crabs that were huge. Also, had the honey mustard shrimp over corn which was delicious. My husband had their special pasta diss that night with lump crab meat lobster and shrimp. They have a great wine list with various price points. They even take Reservations now. read more

This was our second time to Isla's and it delivered again. From the cocktails to a variety of delicious food my expectations were exceeded! It is a busy place and for good reason - people know that this is one of the best in the area. The service was top notch as well both during our dining and post when I discovered I had left my credit card. Thank you Isla's! read more

Food, drinks, service, friendly staff. You can't go wrong here the eclectic atmosphere offers good vibes. Hospitality and food at its finest, just go - you won't be disappointed! read more

What a cute spot!!! Cocktails. Seafood. You can't go wrong. The blackened cod was fresh and yummy! I want to try and recreate it at home. Our waitress was so sweet and bubbly! My friend and I loved chit chatting with her. We had the best night at Isla's read more

Isla's On The Square - Blackened Cod Puttanesca - Sports Bars Near Me - Spartanburg, South Carolina

Our server. Nate, was attentive and kept the meal moving. Our selection of fresh half shell oysters were wonderful. Cold, salty and briny sweet. Salads were crisp and cold. Dressings are always ordered on the side as my experience is restaurants over dress salads. I had the sandbar porter as my adult beverage. It was excellent. Wine for the wife and cocktails for our guest were very good. Can't wait to get back. read more

Brynn was the host and she was AMAZING!!! So sweet and attentive. She made sure we had everything we needed. if you come to Islas, say hi to Brynn! She's awesome!!!!! read more

My husband and I had a date night here and really enjoyed it! The ambiance was fun and the service was friendly. We sat at one of their window seats since it was busy. Didn't mind it though! I got oysters to start that were plump and delicious. My husband got the red pepper sea bass and I ordered the herb crusted salmon. Both were delicious and we finished our plates! Our drinks were really good too. He got an old fashioned and I got white wine and ended with an espresso martini that was sooo good Overall the quality of seafood was very impressive for being 4 hours away from the beach! lol We will definitely be back! read more

See all

First time to Isla's and very satisfied. From the moment we walked in the staff was so helpful. I said it was cold and the hostess adjusted the AC! Our waiter, Chris , was just the right amount of attentive. He explained all the oysters . When I ordered the sea bass I was informed that it wasn't Chilean, which I knew it wouldn't be, but I really appreciated that we were told. The berry salad was good but I expected more than just strawberries. The oysters, and fish with risotto were delicious . The atmosphere is nice, not too loud. I recommend. read more

We stopped in for Restaurant Week and were blow away by the food and service. It was a busy Saturday night but our server took great care of us. We had a wedge salad, cod puttanesca, blacked sea bass, mussels, a great bottle of wine. It was a fantastic evening. I highly recommend read more

Isla's On The Square - Restaurant week menu - Sports Bars Near Me - Spartanburg, South Carolina

Honestly haven't had a chance to eat here but stopped by for a drink. The staff was very friendly and helpful selecting. Not a great IPA selection but a lot of choices of run of mill beer. ( Isla ipa was good)Has a nice vibe. The back courtyard is very cool spot but I'm afraid the effort to use it falls short. Two couches to sit on, only one actually has a cushion and it was covered with bird poop. The tree provided great dappled shade but the area under it was unseemly, any effort to beautify with plants or flowers would make huge difference in ambience. Upgraded and little increase in the casual seating and clean it up a bit and you'll have a gold mine. I'll definitely be back to try the food. read more

Spartanburg's newest restaurant ISLA ON THE SQUARE opened this week downtown. They created a lovely interior dining area with a large bar and seating both upstairs and downstairs. It was loud when we were there because it was a big crowd. Upon arriving we were seated with a small cocktail and oyster menu. The hostess said our server would bring the dinner menu. (This ended up not being helpful for us as I would have ordered an appetizer from the dinner menu). My dinner partner ordered a dozen steamed oysters.($30) and one of their special cocktails. I had a glass of wine. They have a large wine selection. The oysters were eaten before we ever received the dinner menu. (Again, we will request the menu when seated the next time so I can plan my entire meal at one time without waiting.) I'm not sure why it was done that way. To be fair, they have only been open 3 days so there are things that have to be worked through. For or two entrees we had Clam Linguine ($27) and Sesame Ginger Shrimp Salad ($18). Both dishes were delicious. Sorry no pictures. I was distracted. The Clam Linguine had an amazing lemon garlic broth with a dozen clams and 2 very small pieces of grilled crostini. I would have liked to have more crostini to soak up that broth. The Sesame Ginger Shrimp (my partner ordered) had 6 Large fried shrimp crispy breaded with sesame seeds on a bed of salad. (I didn't eat it however it smelled wonderful!) For dessert we shared a Blueberry/Blackberry Cream Brûlée . It was perfect! This is an upscale oyster and seafood restaurant. They serve oysters sourced from Prince Edward Island, New Brunswick, New England to name a few and fresh fish. The manager stated the entree menu would change several times a year as fresh seafood is sourced. This is not a $1 oyster or fried seafood restaurant. It is a welcomed and needed upscale dining experience for Spartanburg. The managers visited the tables. The servers were friendly and knowledgeable. We will be back. read more

See all

First time visitors last night. We waited a looong time for things to shake out and the local excitement to pass. Islas was just average. Oysters on the half were presented well, they have a great selection . Oysters from the grille were nasty. They arrived cold. Entrees were so so. I had cod puttanesca, it was cold. She had trumpet risotto with shrimp. Risotto was dry and clumpy, trumpets were NOT similar to scallops and were rubbery. The big disappoint was service. We sat at the bar. No one told us there were 25lbs of fresh soft shell crabs in the kitchen, no one told us they flew in blue fin tuna for sashimi. We love both of those things ‍We were told this after we ordered, and for that reason I won't go back. read more

Me and my daughter went here about a week ago, the food was awesome and the service was good too! Get the oysters of you're into that! They were huge!! This is my new spot read more

The food, the vibes, the service and the people! Absolutely loved it and surprised to see such quality seafood here in Spartanburg. Bathrooms were clean and restaurant had a cozy coastal vibe to it. Will frequent this place! read more

See all

My wife and I went to Isla's for my birthday and were not disappointed! Great food, drinks, and atmosphere. We had the herb and butter oysters, seared scallops with apricot jam and bacon, king trumpet risotto, and lobster ravioli. Each dish was fantastic. thank you to our server, Kat, for the excellent service. Spartanburg is very lucky to have a place like this and we look forward to coming here more in the future! read more

Atmosphere is very nice and relaxed. Very friendly yet professional wait staff was close by if needed but not hovering. We didn't get the oysters tonight but our meal was very good. The cognac tenderloin was cooked perfectly and the sesame ginger shrimp salad had colossal shrimp and hit the spot. I had what is now my new favorite cocktail named Premo's Punch". If you're the DD, it will not leave you wanting. We will return. Great ambiance for friends to get together and feel like you're at the beach but in downtown Spartanburg. This restaurant will do well and is much needed here. read more

Isla's On The Square - Sesame Ginger Shrimp salad. - Sports Bars Near Me - Spartanburg, South Carolina

See all

Went on a Saturday night expecting this restaurant to be slow since it didn't seem to have alot of activity. It didn't have activity cause it was under construction and we had gone opening week by chance. I was pleasantly surprised with the ambience and energy in the building. We sat at the bar to avoid the long wait and enjoyed our time. We got a couple house cocktails, appetizer, and two entrees. I feel like you get what you pay for here as it is one of the more elevated restaurants in the area. Returning soon. read more

After a concert in the park across the street we decided to give Isla's a shot. We had a dozen Blue Point oysters with the usual accompaniments. Oysters were cold and delicious. We tried crab stuffed mushrooms and Thai Curry Shrimp. Mushrooms lacked seasoning. One had breadcrumbs that were charred. The shrimp was a bit over done, and I didn't get curry at all. Server was courteous and efficient. Nice ambience, feels like an oyster house read more

Had a fantastic meal here, making it a new neighborhood favorite! We had a dozen oysters to start, and I loved the Chesapeake ones and my partner enjoyed the Long Island ones. My friend had the corn fritters, which were also yummy. The tempura was so so. For entrees, I had the linguine and clam sauce. It was nice, albeit small portion. My partner had the snapper and risotto, and said the snapper was awesome but the risotto was more like plain rice. My friend had the cod and it was divine. I also indulged in the poppy von redenbacher and it was delicious. The inside was also lovely. A great addition in spartanburg and our new favorite. Hope it's the beginning of more awesome places here! read more

Quaint little local place. Service was great, oysters amazing! Would prob not recommend the sea bass, but only because it wasn't seared the way I prefer. It tasted baked with a sticky rice. I prefer seared with risotto. The flavors were good. Will return when I'm in the area! read more

Service was great but the food all three times we went was not good. It arrived cool but the flavor was ok. I won't go back.

Excellent food - especially oysters. Good steak and sides. Great ambience. Good beer selection.

Last night, four of us dined at ISLA ON THE SQUARE, a lovely new restaurant here in Spartanburg and I must say, it's a fantastic addition to the dining scene in town. To start, I enjoyed a cocktail called the Chupacabra, made with tequila and passion fruit. It was so well-crafted that I ended up ordering a few more! My friends tried various other drinks, and they must have liked them because they kept ordering and also trying new ones. We began our meal with a selection of fresh oysters, available in a few different varieties. For my main course, I had shrimp and grits. The chef had the brilliant idea to transform the grits into fried balls, paired with shrimp and an amazing sauce. It was quite a delight! The rest of the table enjoyed the pork tenderloin, which was tasty and well-cooked, the sea bass with a flavorful risotto, and the perfectly cooked swordfish. For dessert, we had a hazelnut creation that was so delicious we had to order a second one, though I can't recall the exact name. The atmosphere was lovely, with great décor, and the service was attentive. Our server, Olivia, made sure we were well taken care of throughout the evening. Overall, ISLA ON THE SQUARE is a wonderful spot, and I will be back! read more

My husband and I had dinner at Isla's on the square Saturday night and it was delicious! The oysters were excellent, I had the sea bass and again delicious, my husband had the bbq shrimp and he really enjoyed it. Patrick did a great job of taking care of us. It is a little pricey but worth it! So go get your oyster on read more