I had the Black Walnut Soft Serve, size small. It was plenty for me, and the flavor was very yummy…read more There is a nice pavilion to sit under, as well as other benches in the grass, plenty of parking as well. I come here every season and I will continue to as long as they stay open.

Such a cute and beautiful spot for ice cream . Plenty of picnic tables some with games on table…read moretop. Such a beautiful spot for ice cream. Ice Cream and service was not the best that night but sometimes what makes a place great is how issues or when problems arise how it is handled. Management came over to make it right. Top notch service and am looking forward to coming back with friends for an evening of treats and games.

Ice Cream is my go to comfort food...I go through withdrawal during the winter when many Ice Cream…read moreShops close for the season. So when one of my favorites opens for the season you know I will be there even with snow on the ground. While we could not enjoy the beautiful outdoor seating the heated seats in the car were perfect. The Ice Cream after a several month hiatus was amazing as always. Definitely hit the spot even though it was a cold snowy day. This shop is a great place to go when the weather is nice as they have great outdoor seating. They also offer over 20 place soft serve flavors one of my favorite types of Ice Cream. Highly recommend whether it is sunny or snowing.

Delicious ice cream and friendly service. The peanut butter soft serve isn't that peanut buttery,…read morebut it was still good.

Excellent ice cream. I'd seen a recommendation for this place on a baseball thread in Reddit, of…read moreall places, & it was spot-on. Reasonable, good choice of flavors. I got the soft serve "twist," my friend got a hard flavor. We both said it was "as good as any other we've ever had" & we are both ice cream afficionados. Reasonably priced, good-sized portions. A bit hard to find as the address is Rt 28 but it's in the back. Nice array of pigs, chickens, ducks, a cow & several goats in the back. We're "city" people so enjoyed seeing the animals almost as much as we did eating the ice cream.

Cooperstown seems like the ice cream haven or something. As we drove here from my mom's we passed…read moreby like 6 places. I only wish we could have tried them all. I picked this as the 2nd place to try our following night after dinner. No one was disappointed. If you can only go to one ice cream place I'd go to this or the other one I went to if you look at my reviews :P

Used to bring my son here for ice cream when he was little haven't been in quite some time. This…read moreis definitely a quintessential ice cream stand in North Utica and one of the few places you can still get homemade Italian Lemon Ice. My only wish was the lemon ice wasn't as sweet and a bit more tart but it was still good. They have outdoor seating so we took advantage of the beautiful weather and ate our ice outside. Would definitely come back and this time won't wait so long to come back.

Where can I start "BIG" Disapointment . Very Expensive Not very good Food. They are very…read moreProtective of the Beverages. You get a Combo meal that doesn't come with a drink. If pay Extra for a soda it's 3.25 for a small little soda that tastes flat as a board. Tried to get a chilli dog in the combo but they won't let you have it that, Yet they have a Hot dog in Combo, so why can't you simply pay a little more and get a Chili Dog! Of course there are no refills on the soda. They seem kinda CHEAP. Didn't stay for Ice Cream

Such an adorable place! We loved the vibe and the service! Amazing selections of ice cream…read moreflavors. So glad we came here after a late game at Cooperstown Dreams Park.

I came here the other day with my family, and when we went it was pretty great, so we came back …read more The service was friendly unlike what i've read in many of the reviews Also the serving sizes are crazyyy! But not crazy small, crazy big! I loved that we got what we paid for and it was pretty great tasting too.

We stopped here after seeing Leon Entienne, an illusionist at The Strand. It was a great way to…read morefinish the evening. The service was quick and the ice cream delicious!

A must in old forge! The ice cream was good. It is in a cool area next to nutty putty. We enjoyed…read moreour ice cream.

My girlfriend had been here before with her family and really wanted to come back and I totally get…read morewhy. It's a charming little roadside ice cream spot with that classic small-town feel and a solid variety of flavors. We got Lemon Chillo and Toasted Coconut, both creamy, flavorful, and perfect for a summer treat. The kiddo scoop was just $4, which felt like a steal for the quality. Heads up: it's cash only, so come prepared! Simple, affordable, and sweet in every way - this place is 100% worth a stop if you're nearby.

Decent Ice cream selection. Usually has one dairy-free option...would be great if there were two…read more Good service, well-maintained and clean building. Nice covered area with tables. But, unfortunately, right on a really busy road and next to the town much site. It is sort of a standard I use to compare other places against. Only a few are better, but many are not quite as good.

My family and I arrived at Slyvan Beach today. We were full from lunch still but wanted a sweet…read moretreat. We first stopped at a candy store thinking they had ice cream there. They didn't sell any ice cream but they told us about What's the Scoop. We walked down a little ways and ran right into it. It was busy! So many people out enjoying the night and their sweet treats. There were a good amount of tables to sit at. I appreciate the big umbrellas! You can enjoy your cold treat without the hot sun beating down on you. There were big menu boards and lists of ice cream available. There are so many options! There's ice cream, Dole Whip, milk shakes, sundaes. So many goodies to pick from. There was also a non dairy cookies and cream available. The cherry Italian ice listed so that was my pick. My daughter got a small scoop of brownie batter. I ordered a kid's scoop of the cherry Italian ice. Holy cow! I thought my daughter ordered a double scoop but it was their small portion. My kid's scoop would blow competitors out of the water. My scoop was huge for a kid's scoop. In most ice cream joints, my scoop would be considered a small. The brownie batter was very chocolatey! It was very creamy was well. The cherry Italian ice was very vibrant in color. It was also very flavorful. We sat at a cute table on the sidewalk next to the street and enjoyed our goodies. This town is something you see in Hallmark movies and this ice cream joint fits right in it. It's cute, local and they serve some yummy goodies. The staff is really sweet. It's hard not to fall in love with this place. I look forward having goodies here all week.

I went here with my aunt, two cousins, and my sister. My sister ordered a small Kahlua Almond…read moreAmaretto on a cone, my aunt ordered a Caramel Praline Turtle, one of my cousins got a kid's size Vanilla, the other cousin got a kid's Dairy-Free Blueberry Pancake, and I ordered a small Dairy-Free Blueberry Pancake. The staff was friendly, attentive, and great. This place tends to get busy, although the line moves fast. There is no indoor seating at this location, the seating is outside. The area does get packed. It is a pet-friendly area, which is good. Overall, a nice ambiance. My aunt did feel it was more on the pricier side which is why I deducted a star. The great thing is everyone enjoyed the ice cream, we just wish the ice cream was homemade.

We visit every year on our annual trip to Fourth Lake near Inlet,NY. They have Dole Whip, Perry's…read morehard ice cream, Gelato and soft serve. In the past I've gotten gelato and enjoyed it. This year I tried a drumstick flavored blizzard with peanuts and hard chocolate and cone pieces like the classic supermarket cone. My only complaint is the soft ice cream is too icy and melted quickly. My son got dole whip pineapple and strawberry and was happy with it. Another in our group got mint chocolate chip hard ice cream and it was tasty. Next time I'll go back to the gelato. Can't beat the view of the lake from nearby Arrowhead Park.

I have been coming here since I was a kid. I remember when they first added the gelato to their…read moremenu. It is my favorite thing there. But only if they have a flavor I like. When I was there last summer, there was only a small handful of option flavors, just why it is missing one star. My parents love the ice cream here as well. The young servers are always so pleasant and friendly. On a nice day, the line is very long, but the service does not lack. It's near the water so the vibe is very chill and perfect for a summer vacation.