A cute little place for a meal in Bayfield. Service was great and the food was as expected. Nothing…read morespecial, but cozy enough.

Great food and service. Solid 4.5 stars only because their non alcoholic drinks did not do anything…read morefor us (either tasted like faint fruit water or the canned stuff nit good) but the food was SOOO GOOD!! We got fried fish sandwich with amazing homemade potato chips and fish tacos (only have flour tortillas but still really good with creamy Cole slaw and awesome beer battered fries. Definitely check out this place - they have wonderful view of the water and marina and service was very good, you'll be glad you came

Two words: Whitefish livers…read more Where have these been all of my life? Granted, I'm a liver eater. Chopped chicken liver is one of my all time favorite things. Duck liver, goose liver, calves liver, cod liver, monkfish liver, sign me up. But somehow whitefish livers have evaded me. These were delicious! I also had what might have been the most midwestern meal ever. Cheese curds with ranch dressing, a plate of whitefish livers, and a sweet brandy old fashioned to wash it all down. On the specialty drinks menu I couldn't resist the Berens Brandy Old Fashioned. I mean, I have been a fan of Charlie Berens for a few years but I didn't realize he had his own brandy for the definitive cocktail of Wisconsin. It was delicious, but it also turned out to be $12. For my second round I just got a regular brandy old fashioned which was also quite good, but weighed in at five bucks. Let the buyer beware. Which is ultimately why Pier Plaza fell short of the fifth star. The prices feel a bit high for what it is. Granted, it's right by the water, in a remote part of the state, and thrives on tourists. And that's fine. I have no regrets and would absolutely recommend folks who might be passing through to stop in for a very Wisconsin meal. Portions are large, so plan accordingly.

Bayfield is the cutest little town I've ever visited - and whenever I visit a new place I hunt for…read morethe best pasta in town. Menu hunting led me to Pier Plaza (Pickled Herring). The "Pierly Pasta" with it cajuned up was awesome (breadstick included). I noticed they had a horseradish ranch... yeah I dipped the chicken in it and even threw some on the pasta. Game changer! This place - location, ambiance, water view, food, drinks - the whole package!

Friendly service, generous portions, reasonably priced, great atmosphere, can't say enough about…read moreThe Fisherman's Hideout. We had the Fish dinner with trout and white fish, the fish tacos, and the fish spread with pita. All were amazing. You can also get fish to go, fresh, smoked, or sweet smoked. We bought smoked trout, whitefish, salmon, and the fish spread. Yum!

Any place that offers about 10 dishes should make sure they know what they are doing, and the…read moreHideout does! The fried whitefish was amazing. The kids voted their chicken tenders as their favorite of our vacation (they had them at every restaurant we ate at). We would have liked to eat there again, but they are only open 2 days a week.

Look, this should not be a five star review. I was in Morty's for all of maybe 10 minutes. But in…read morethat time, I had my first ever Wisconsin sweet brandy old fashioned in Wisconsin and on top of that the bartender saved my night with some good old-fashioned empathy and barroom advice. It's a long and convoluted story, but I was with my minor child who was on the verge of a panic attack and needed to sit down somewhere, we were caught in a thunderstorm, and it felt like everything in town was closed. Probably because it was. Bayfield isn't exactly a late night town... nor does Uber or Lyft function out this way, despite the respective apps claiming otherwise. Morty's was close by. It was open. And I remembered that in Wisconsin not only can minor's sit at the bar, if they are with their legal parent they can even have a drink. Man, Wisconsin is the best! But the kid just wanted a soda, and I could have used a drink. So an old fashioned for me and a Coke for the kid. I shared our story with the bartender, and she offered some sage guidance. In a few minutes my wife arrived with the car to bring us back to our cabin. But let's hear it for the good old fashioned bar that provides both literal and figurative shelter from the storm. Wish I could have stayed longer, but even in my short time it left an indelible impression.

Pretty decent bar food!…read more Came here for lunch on our way out of town. Great bar food - had the fish tacos and they were okay. I ended up taking them out of the tortilla because the tortilla was dry. I probably would have had a better burger or wings. Great service, great vibes.

From the moment we walked in, we felt like this was the place to be in Bayfield. It is not only…read morebeautiful inside, but everyone working was warm and made us feel at home. The menu changes based on what they can source from the farmer, so you won't find a menu posted online. I think that is part of the fun of the experience. We chose a beet salad which was beautifully presented and tasted as good as it looked. I chose the burger for my entree and it goes down on my top five burger list for sure. Juicy, salty, cooked to perfection! They don't have a full bar liquor license yet, but are very creative with what they are working with. I had a sake espresso martini, and it was great! Can't wait to visit and The St. James Social again, and it will be on my to-do list next time I'm in the Apostle Islands.

Very inviting, warm, ambience. Service was really terrific. Our salads were very good if slightly…read moreover-dressed (consider ordering your dressing on the side!). The shared pizza was very good, and a fish dish was also good. Our daughter's risotto was a huge fail--completely flavorless--it had the quality of bland oatmeal. Bottom line--hit and miss.

Always great food and excellent service. Friendly atmosphere for all ages. Music was an added bonus…read moretoday.

Loved the Fish and Beer - Fish was definitely fresh and the beer was cold and stayed cold in those…read moregreat aluminum glasses. A definite diamond in cornucopia. don't Miss Out.

Hoops Fish Market is a nice little shop worth checking out when visiting the Bayfield area. The…read morestore has a good selection of fresh and smoked fish, along with other local seafood products. It's a small, no-frills market with a classic Northwoods feel. A great place to stop if you're looking to pick up some local fish to take home.

If you are looking for fresh, delicious fish you've come to the right place. We stopped here…read morebecause we were craving fresh lake fish and to our surprise there was a local band playing. This made the dockside restaurant quite crowded and left only a short wall for my husband and I to sit and eat. One of the workers came out with a foldable table for us since he saw us struggling to hold the food on our laps. That is what I call service!

Nice historic building. A big menu with a huge variety…read more Nut Brown Ale cheese soup is our starter. It was a flavorful soup with crisp popcorn topping. The consistency was thin, yet richly flavorful. No glomming cheese in this bowl! The special was outstanding. A crisply coated Cajun flavored fried chicken with home made cornbread and a coleslaw with pineapple. The bourbon brown sugar garlic honey was superb. Seriously wonderful. The Northwood salad was huge and filled with crisp apples and so much more. Our service was attentive, pleasant and food was prompt. There are three doors to this unique location and much more seating than we noticed at first glance. You really must try this food.

The wings were fantastic, good atmosphere overall and the service was quick! I recommend this place…read more100%

We decided to do a pie-off and bought slices of double-crust apple pie from Rustic and Betty's to…read moredetermine who we thought was the best. Rustic made the purchase process much faster thanks to their Pie on the Fly truck; our slice was ready in a couple minutes, fork and napkins included. Our conclusion: the crust was flaky, messy, with visible cinnamon, and was delicious. It had more flavor through the crust, which we preferred, though the fillings were similar and good. This was our favorite of the two.

We stopped in at the recommendation from a friend during our visit to Two Harbors, and it is such a…read morecute place! We had a 40 minute wait, so we spent some time (and money ) in their gift shop. So many fun things for sale! Our server was friendly and speedy, and very busy! Three of us got burgers--the patties were HUGE! We also got the Rachel sandwich and a kids cheese pizza. We were too full to have pie there, so we took 2 slices home. AMAZING pies! We chose the Blueberry Crumb and the Caramel Apple Pecan. I may be stopping for another slice of pie before we head back home.