Cancel

Open app

Search

Hometown Pizzeria

5.0 (8 reviews)
Closed 11:00 am - 8:00 pm

Hometown Pizzeria Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Hometown Pizzeria

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

I've never gotten anything that I don't like here! Great good, great pizza and I love their sauce.

Helpful 0
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Don M.
38
28
10

3 years ago

So far, the best pizza sauce in Barbour County! And everyone of the six people eating the two pizzas we ordered agreed!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Lisa G.
12
10
0

6 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Hometown Pizzeria

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 114 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Appalachia Kitchen - IT'S BACK! 34 Oz Tomahawk Ribeye For 2

Appalachia Kitchen

4.1(171 reviews)
42.4 mi
$$$
Family-owned & operated
Locally sourced ingredients

Outstanding farm-to-table dining in Snowshoe…read more For anyone visiting Snowshoe Mountain and hoping to find a truly elevated dining experience, Appalachia Kitchen stands apart. The concept is simple but well executed: locally sourced Appalachian ingredients, seasonal menus, and careful preparation. In an area where "upscale" dining often leans heavily on pricing instead of execution, Appalachia Kitchen focuses on what actually matters--quality, balance, and consistency. Highlights included: * A perfectly cooked filet paired with root vegetables and a rich, restrained sauce * Thoughtful plating without unnecessary theatrics * A wine list that complements the menu instead of competing with it * Attentive service that feels professional but relaxed One standout moment: the staff happily accommodated a custom French press paired with vanilla gelato and chocolate chips--a small detail, but one that shows how much pride they take in the guest experience. Snowshoe attracts visitors from across the Mid-Atlantic and Southeast, and for many, this will be the memorable meal of their trip. If you're deciding where to spend your money for a special dinner, this is the restaurant that delivers on both quality and value. Appalachia Kitchen sets the benchmark for what higher-end dining in Snowshoe should be.

Food was delicious with scallops and lamb stew. Unique dish with chicken Wellington. Carrot cake…read morecould feed four. Service was good and attentive.

Photos
Appalachia Kitchen - Mountain State Trout Satay

Mountain State Trout Satay

Appalachia Kitchen - Mushroom Toast

Mushroom Toast

Appalachia Kitchen - Black Cherry Chocolate Torte

See all

Black Cherry Chocolate Torte

Firewater Kitchen + Bar - Bourbon BBQ Chicken Thighs

Firewater Kitchen + Bar

3.9(155 reviews)
46.6 mi
$$

We visited Firewater Kitchen & Bar on a cool October evening to celebrate my wife's birthday,…read moremeeting up with friends for the occasion. While the hostess initially quoted a two-hour wait and came across a bit cold, things improved quickly. As we settled in with some truly delicious cocktails--a smoked old fashioned and a playful Plum-P Up the Jam--we ended up being seated in just about 20 minutes. Once at our table, the experience really shined. Our waitress was wonderful: warm, knowledgeable, and incredibly friendly. The food was excellent and beautifully prepared. I enjoyed the steak frites, cooked perfectly, while my wife had the scallops, which were rich, tender, and full of flavor. Despite the rocky start, the evening turned into a fantastic birthday dinner in a stunning part of Maryland. Firewater Kitchen & Bar delivered a memorable meal, and we were glad we chose it for the celebration.

We were in Deep Creek for a few days and I wanted to visit a spot right on the water so this was…read moreperfect! Gorgeous views. We went on a Thursday night and while it was busy, we were able to be seated right away. It just happened to be their "steak night" so that was a pleasant surprise. I got the filet and my husband had the cowboy ribeye. Each came with a salad and baked potato. My steak was cooked perfectly and it was delicious. We ended with the firewater pie which has an oatmeal cookie crust and a caramel filling - lemon bar vibes. It was out of this world! Definitely would recommend this spot!

Photos
Firewater Kitchen + Bar - Bar area

Bar area

Firewater Kitchen + Bar - Crab Hush Puppies

Crab Hush Puppies

Firewater Kitchen + Bar

See all

Pizza & Sub Shoppe - Roadside view

Pizza & Sub Shoppe

4.3(4 reviews)
20.5 mi

Great food! Great service! I stop here every chance I get when I'm home. The calzones are my…read morefavorite.

I've been in Mill Creek for a few months, after living out of state for many years. I've travelled…read moreextensively across the US and eaten in many major (and not-so-major) cities. I rarely make time to leave a Yelp review because I'm busy and there are usually countless other reviews, but I'm taking a few minutes to leave this one because I saw that the only other Yelp review for this place was in 2015, a 3-star, which I found after Googling the hours for this restaurant because I wish to place a take-out order today. Otherwise, I would've never seen it. This restaurant has some of the best food I've eaten in a long time. I'd say "ever" instead of "long time," but I'm trying to temper my review to avoid setting abnormally high expectations. But honestly, this food is amazing, and much better than I expected in a small town in WV. The bread / pizza dough is homemade, and delicious. I'm not sure what the prices were in 2015 when the other review was left, but I consider these prices to be too low for the portions received and the quality, which I'm afraid to say because I don't want to encourage a price hike. Whether dining in or taking out, the food always takes a while to prepare, but I think that's why it's so good. I've waited inside the restaurant for pizza for nearly 30 minutes, but it was worth it. My take out orders usually take 25-30 minutes as well. I highly recommend the calzones and the funnel cake fries. My only complaint is that this restaurant doesn't have consistent "open" hours. They may take days off, or even a whole week, and it's always when I crave their food the most. But this is a small business and they have the right to close whenever they want. They're always closed on Sundays. When they're open, you can tell when you drive by because they put out flags that say "open." They don't seem to have a great social media presence, so there's no way to check online. I suggest calling ahead to make sure they're open if you're planning to eat here on your way to Snowshoe.

Photos
Pizza & Sub Shoppe - Dining room

Dining room

Pizza & Sub Shoppe - Entrance

Entrance

Pizza & Sub Shoppe - Fireplace dining room 2

See all

Fireplace dining room 2

Ari's Pizza

Ari's Pizza

3.5(14 reviews)
38.9 mi

The food is very tasty, hot and fresh, super friendly staff and very clean establishment!!read more

2.5 The thing about…read moresmall resort towns is that there isn't a thing... ya know? Things are what they are and if you don't like it... well... I don't know what to tell you. You're stuck. Oh, before I go any further, this was a pre-lockdown experience. I made my way to Garrett County in late fall. I was catching up with some of my oldest guy friends for a much-needed guys weekend. Being the Type A sort I am (and having never been to this part of the state before), I arrived earlier than everyone else -- much earlier. After gorging myself upon arrival on chips, Oreo cookies and Coca-Cola (a balanced lunch if ever there was one), I realized that I needed to eat something for dinner. I wasn't familiar with the area and the next shipment of attendees weren't showing up until midnight. Oh, and did I mention that I was at a lake house -- with a first floor of all windows -- by myself? And, it was snowing. AND I didn't have cell service. Yes, I was in a horror movie. Trying not to think about my impending doom, I found a drawer of menus and pressed my luck with an easy bet: pizza! In the real world, I have gluten issues. But I knew better than to come to a small(er) town with dietary restrictions and other needs. That was doing too much. Pizza, it was. The young lady on the phone was lovely and when she found out where I was staying, she had to get the okay for delivery (if that gives you any indication of how remote I was... and how I was going to have to fight for my life later). She got the ok and I ordered a pepperoni, sausage and onion pizza. No problem. I was charged a king's ransom for delivery and quoted a long time for arrival but I was alright with both things. I was off the grid, it was snowing and was thankful for any sort of delivery options. After a while, the food eventually showed up. The driver was polite. I paid, tipped and thanked him and I was ready to dig in to the first non-gluten-free pizza I'd had in a while. Despite the oncoming gastric distress, I was looking forward to the familiar taste of flour-y goodness. Imagine my shock and disappointment with what I received. It was not good, y'all. In fact, it may have been some of the nastiest pizza I'd had in quite some time. You see how the earlier review wrote about 'soggy' food? Yep. That. The dough was soggy (see picture), the cheese was congealed and the sauce was tangy. The pie was incredibly greasy and the middle was undercooked. None of this was a good combo. Despite my hunger, I could only suffer through one piece.* I don't want to kick a business when it may be down so I'll reiterate that the employees were very nice. I also thought the sausage (when eaten by itself) was good. The pizza I got was pan-style and the crust was enjoyable. But, I'm afraid, that's the extent of the good things I can say. *My buddies eventually arrived, started drinking like fish and knocked off the rest of the pizza in a drunken stupor -- as one does.

Photos
Ari's Pizza
Ari's Pizza
Ari's Pizza

See all

Hometown Pizzeria - pizza - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...