I've been in Mill Creek for a few months, after living out of state for many years. I've travelled extensively across the US and eaten in many major (and not-so-major) cities. I rarely make time to leave a Yelp review because I'm busy and there are usually countless other reviews, but I'm taking a few minutes to leave this one because I saw that the only other Yelp review for this place was in 2015, a 3-star, which I found after Googling the hours for this restaurant because I wish to place a take-out order today. Otherwise, I would've never seen it.
This restaurant has some of the best food I've eaten in a long time. I'd say "ever" instead of "long time," but I'm trying to temper my review to avoid setting abnormally high expectations. But honestly, this food is amazing, and much better than I expected in a small town in WV. The bread / pizza dough is homemade, and delicious. I'm not sure what the prices were in 2015 when the other review was left, but I consider these prices to be too low for the portions received and the quality, which I'm afraid to say because I don't want to encourage a price hike.
Whether dining in or taking out, the food always takes a while to prepare, but I think that's why it's so good. I've waited inside the restaurant for pizza for nearly 30 minutes, but it was worth it. My take out orders usually take 25-30 minutes as well.
I highly recommend the calzones and the funnel cake fries.
My only complaint is that this restaurant doesn't have consistent "open" hours. They may take days off, or even a whole week, and it's always when I crave their food the most. But this is a small business and they have the right to close whenever they want. They're always closed on Sundays. When they're open, you can tell when you drive by because they put out flags that say "open." They don't seem to have a great social media presence, so there's no way to check online. I suggest calling ahead to make sure they're open if you're planning to eat here on your way to Snowshoe. read more