Hoagie city makes HUGE sandwiches. But perhaps too big for their own good. The inside of the restaurant isn't much to write home about, although interestingly they also sell meats and cheese by the pound in addition to making sandwiches. The menu is fairly limited, with mostly cold sandwiches and a couple hot options. The most popular cold sandwich is the Italian and the most popular cold sandwich is the cheesesteak. I ordered the Italian and a bag of chips, no drink. They offer half (8") or full (16") sizes, and I opted for the half. The half sandwich and a bag of chips was $14. The sandwich was absolutely massive, especially for it being the half size. There was so much meat and toppings on the sandwich the hoagie wouldn't even remotely close in order to take a bite, which led me to eating it open faced like a slice of pizza. Don't get me wrong, I'm sure some people love a massive sandwich like this, but the whole point of a sandwich in my mind is to be able to eat it as intended, with the bread on either side and toppings in the middle. Since I was attempting to eat it open faced, it also became extremely messy and the mayo and oil along with other toppings was displaced everywhere. I eventually took off some of the meat to be able to eat it normally, but then the excess mayo caused all of the insides to slide out all over the place. That said, the meat and cheese tasted good, appeared to be high quality, and definitely freshly sliced. I realize I'm the minority here, and can understand why people like the sandwiches but it was just too messy for me. read more

Hoagie City - Italian - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

2 years ago I gave this place 5 stars. When I visited a few weeks ago, I noticed the quality in both food and service has gone down. The wait was ridiculously long (people that came in after me, with larger orders than mine, left before me) and the flavors weren't what they used to be. Makes me wonder if this was the case because the owner wasn't around this time. read more

Hoagie City - Beef cheesesteak-- onions/peppers and cheese whiz - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

After hearing and reading about real "Philly cheesesteak", we decided to try this place for lunch. We ordered the cheesesteak with cheese whiz, onions, and pepper, the "mini" plain cheesesteak, and the half pastrami. We went before the lunch rush hour - the young lady behind the register was helpful with her recommendations, and overall, the service was quick. First impression - it's a lot of food. A half hoagie alone can feed two grown adults. All the hoagies were filled generously, and the ingredients were fresh. Having tried Pat's and Geno's many times in Philadelphia, we were not really impressed by the cheesesteak. It was good, but not great. I felt that the ratio of the meat to cheese could have been more even. Again, not a bad cheesesteak (and certainly better than any of the other chain sub shops in town). The unlikely star of our lunch though, was the pastrami - easily the best we have had outside of Katz in NYC. I would go back to Hoagie City just for this sub alone the next time. I will certainly be back here if I find myself on this side of town to try some of the other subs. read more

See all

Wow. Order a full size steak cheesesteak (with provolone, peppers, and onions) and it was HUGE. It is something you can totally split with another person! I have driven by this restaurant so many times and finally decided to check it out. I placed my order online and it was super simple to do. After I placed my order, it had given me a 30-35 minute wait time but it was actually way shorter than that. I got a text saying my order was ready for pick up 10 minutes after I placed the order! The hoagie itself was delicious. The steak did have a peppery flavor but wasn't overpowering. I want to come back to try other items! read more

See all

Looks like family run. We ordered the Salad and a $22 Cheesesteak. It was mainly a lot of guys there because we love this kind of stuff. First of all the salad was really good as it was a huge portion with so many different meats on it. Blew me away. My work partner ordered the cheesesteak. At first one I saw it I thought, it was kind of small for $22 until he told me the other half was in a bag for him to take home later (8" roll small vs 16" roll - large fyi) ! Cheesesteak he said was decent and I told him the bread was probably really good since they use Amarosa rolls from Philly. Although I prefer more of the meat to be chopped smaller, like what I'm used to, this was a solid contender! Nice to support small businesses! read more

See all

One of the best subs/hoagies I ever had. 1/2 hoagie was even too much to eat and finished it next day. Wish they would offer a toasted bread option to make it perfect. Reasonably priced too for the generous portion. .Service was adequate, but staff didn't recognize product on yelp cover page, and they needed to have the order repeated to get it right. Ambiance: store is sparse, but clean. Menu chart has pasted-over pricing--not a good look. Interestingly, most customers were males. Definitely coming back. read more

I''m here at lunch and it's busy... really busy. Hot sandwiches are taking longer than cold; my small Italian Hoagie took four minutes. Plenty of sandwich! read more

Hoagie City - 1/2 Italian - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Big stuffed sandwiches! We got two cold sandwiches. Half size can feed two people. We had two meals. My turkey was really good. Are you allowed to complain about too much filling? I absolutely want to try the cheesesteak read more

Definitely one of the top sub shops in Central Ohio! They use Dietz and Watson meats ..... the owner has been using them, from what I understand, for decades! Service was excellent! When you get a sub from this establishment, you don't worry about not getting enough quality meat on your sub ! The garnish and the seasoning that I got on mine was just fantastic! They also have old time pickle barrels, or you can even get a hot and spicy pickle . We did also order fresh cut fries, which were cooked perfectly. You also buy meats and cheeses per pound there. There is also a nice indoor seating and area everything was very clean looking from restrooms to eating area and counter. This is the type of shop that I look for when eating out ! PS look for specials... I took advantage of one that was taped on the front door. It was a Italian sub that had extra items on it like prosciutto. read more

Hoagie City - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

A slight disclaimer that because I am pregnant most of the menu is off limits to me. Having said that I love a good meatball sandwich so thankfully I was able to find something to get excited about. The menu is pretty typical for a sandwich shop although a bit more pricey. I ended up getting the large meatball sub which costs a steep $19.50. For some reason I was not expecting two giant sandwiches. My husband got the large veggie and cheese and liked it, but shared that because it was so big, the bread/veggie/cheese dispersion was a bit off and it was hard to get a bite with everything. The meatball sub was really good but the sauce could have been more flavorful. Tons of juicy meatballs and the bread is delicious. The size of the subs makes up for the price but the taste didn't quite live up to my expectations. Although I am definitely going to come back in a few months to try some of the other options and see what the hype is all about! read more

Hoagie City - Veggie and Cheese Hoagie - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

These sandwiches are STUFFED! I ordered the famous Italian and it did not disappoint. This thing was stuffed to the max with meats and cheese. I like my sandwiches with a bit of a bite to it so I recommend ordering the vinegar separately (otherwise it's an oil/vinegar mix that I found to be heavier on the oil). May seem pricy but the ingredients are high quality and the half size was big enough to share for lunch. The owner was super nice to talk to and I can't wait to come back to try the cheesesteak! read more

Hoagie City - Italian Hoagie - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

I want to love this place. And I thought this is something I would never ever say but, they give you way to much food! The Itilain special is a great sandwich but the amount of meat and toppings are just way way to much. You can't really even eat it without taking it apart and getting rid of half the meat and toppings. It's a really good sandwich though just way to much meat and toppings read more

Very good quality and huge portions!! Plan to wait as it can get busy. Nice areas to sit and they have tvs too

If you want a true Philly Cheesesteak, look no further than Hoagie City north of the circle at Main Street & Cemetery Road in Hilliard. The owner, Bob, gets his ingredients from Philly, grew up in South Philly, and had a deli in Philly- so he's a little familiar with the real deal deli! It was our first visit so we had a great original cheesesteak with cheese whiz, peppers & onions and a side of cheese fries. Both were excellent and just like what we've had in Philly. The menu is broad and the deli case is full of great meats & cheeses. Stop by & show Bob some Central Ohio Love!! read more

See all

What a gem. I had a scrumptious cheeseburger and Bill had a mammothly delicious Ruben. The menu, extensive with all things deli including barrels of pickles and scrapple. I even got a sample of the liverwurst with the natural casing. Owner and staff are super friendly. We'll definitely be back. read more

See all

The food was delicious I had their chicken cheesesteak hoagie and my sister got an Italian hoagie. We also ordered some homemade French fries. The only downside side was they seemed to be alittle unorganized in taking orders and knowing who ordered it. But the staff was very friendly and the food was hot. If you are in hillard Ohio and looking for a great sandwich I don't think you will come away disappointed. read more

Fantastic sammies, we had cheesesteak and a Reuben. The staff was awesome and we lucked out getting a seat. We will most definitely be back!! read more

Walked in and ordered 4 subs/sandwiches and was in and out in about 10 minutes. Some of the best deli sandwiches I've ever had. Meat loaded to the point that you can take half off and make a whole other sandwich. The only reason I'm not giving 5 stars is because the lady checking us out kept getting upset when I asked for something not to be on the sandwiches and she couldn't figure out how to use her register. Also could have gone without Fox News blasting on the big screen. But the two guys making the sandwiches were super nice especially the main guy that had to keep helping the lady at the register while he was also trying to do his job as well. read more

Seems like a great place to grab a quick sandwich/sub but the wait is no joke. Took about 20 minutes to send out a corned beef special and a half Philly sub. The poor guy that ordered before us received his singular sandwich after our food was sent out. There is a lack of structure internally when handling multiple orders for customers. The quality was up to par and the quantity is astronomical. The corned beef special is too big to eat! If you enjoy leftovers this is definitely the place to be. Overall, I would recommend giving this place a try if you have some extra time. read more

Hoagie City - Corned Beef Special - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

If you know Hilliard, you know this place is constantly being bought out by a new owner- it was usually froyo shops but hoagie city is determined to stay! & I am so glad because this place is AMAZING! We walked in to some of the best hospitality I've received in a while. I got a bologna sandwich add onion and Swiss cheese and omg it was amazing! Not as good as an Otie baloney but still the bomb!!! My sister got a half size Italian hoagie and that sucker was massive and full of flavor! My nephew got a Philly cheesesteak hoagie and he said it was delicious. The pickle was a 4/10- it just didn't hold enough flavor. The parking here is pretty small but you really don't have an issue as it's not too busy most of the time. It's located right off of a roundabout on Main st. read more

See all

I have been here a few times for takeout and it's always been good but this steak was great. Meat was cooked and seasoned to perfection. Cheese was mixed in nicely. Onions were chopped to my liking. The bread might've been the best part, fresh . read more

Hoagie City - Cheesesteak- fried onions and American - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

The hoagies here are AMAZING! You get a lot of meat! The bread is so soft! The combo is delicious! I always have to my sandwich cut in half! Service is great! They answer your questions and make great recommendations! read more

A real touch of Philly right here in Columbus. The sandwiches are huge and packed with goodness. A "half" hoagie could feed two people. The cheesesteak was honestly not my favorite. Definitely needed more cheese for me, so would suggest ordering extra cheese if you want the cheese/meat ratio more equal. The cold sandwiches are where they shine. Deli meat is fresh sliced and Amoroso rolls are delicious. Tons of varieties of chips and fresh deli barrel pickles to make it a feast. read more

See all

Outstanding ! It's hard to find a great Hoagie. This place has them ! Absolutely one of the best around. read more

Hoagie City - Big !!!! - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Huge Sandwiches you'll be eating for days, great tasting bread, meats, and toppings. You'll need 4-6 friends to devour this $20 Sub: it's that big! read more

See all

Let me preface this review by stating that I LOVE hoagies/subs. But the rumor mill was turning that this official Philadelphia owned Deli was bringing in amarosa rolls for their cheese steaks. So, being a foodie I had to give it a try. I got the Philly for take out lunch and needless to say it was amazing. The meat, the veggies, and the provolone ("witout as they say") were all so fresh and delicious. The roll itself was light and almost airy but very fresh. I love supporting local and can't wait to try more sandwiches. Check this place out. read more

Hoagie City - Philly Cheesesteak - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

We came here on a Saturday afternoon, I tried calling ahead but the phone doesn't seem to go there or they don't answer it. It was kinda confusing because no one greeted us and there was no signage for where you order. I agree with another reviewer that the Fox News is very off putting, not because of any political affiliation but because it is sooooo loud. On to the food. We ordered all of our Subs with Mayo. we didn't get any which isn't a huge deal but is annoying. The portion is huge and it is a good sub. My only issue is there's too much meat for the bread type. I ended up eating mine open faced because there was no other way to get the toppings in the same bite or keep them on the sandwich. I wish that the bread was completely cut, less meat, or completely different bread. The pickles are Amazing. All that being said I would return read more

One of the best Italian subs I've ever had. Service was friendly, store was clean and I will definitely be back.

Great little sandwich shoppe. We ordered a Club, a Turkey, a hot Pastrami and a small shrimp macaroni salad. The food is very good and filling. It seems a bit pricey but they packed a ton of meat on the subs. Very good. I'll definitely be going back again soon. read more

Hoagie City - Turkey and Ham w/ Bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion and Mayo. - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

I had a fantastic experience with Hoagie City. When I first looked at the menu I was skeptical due to the prices, but that was before I saw just how big the serving sizes were. I ordered a half sized Italian hoagie was it was about as long as my forearm. I was super impressed and definitely will be coming back again. The service was very quick and efficient, and there was little to no wait time at all. Hoagie city has a great vibe all around and I will definitely be going back. read more

See all

Hoagie City is too good. Not only do you get an insane value for your dollar (the sandwiches are inSANEly stuffed with meats cheeses and veggies), they are supremely flavorful and made with love. The owner is a real Philly guy and runs this shop appropriately. Hoagie City is goated, best subs on the west side read more

Was out and about today and dropped in this place. The owner is Bob and he is off the chart with information, he gave me a ton of info on the history behind his business. Wish I would have had more time. On to the food, I of course ordered the Philly Cheesesteak. I got it with onions and mushrooms and cheese whiz. It was cooked perfectly but had a little too much pepper on it. Otherwise you get WAY more meat on it than any other place in town. The fresh Amorosa rolls were a major plus. I will definitely go back to check out more options. Great place!!!! read more

See all

As a recently relocated lifelong Philadelphian, I've been looking for a taste of home and boy did Bob and Hoagie City deliver! The Philly Amoroso roll and Dietz and Watson meats and cheeses brought me immediately back to South Philly. I would recommend this place to both transplant and local Columbus folks alike! We got the Italian, Turkey and Special Italian hoagies and a cheesesteak with American and fried onions. All were fantastic but the standout star was the Special Italian with the sharp prov and hot and sweet capicola really brought me back to South Philly and the deli I worked at as a kid. Bottom line, please come here and experience what real Philly sandwiches are all about. Bob has created an awesome establishment that deserves to be in the running for best sandwiches in and around Columbus. read more

Live 30 mins away but was in the area since decided to check out Hoagie City Hilliard to see what all the online chatter was about. Born and semi- raised on the East Coast and can say these subs/hoagies are legit. 8" (domestic) ham & american cheese on a wonderful fresh Italian roll. Love it most because the ham isn't smoked, and easily enough for two to share. Probably could feed 4-5 on the 16". Takeout tip: ask for the oil/vinegar dressing on the side so the bread doesn't get soggy. read more

Hoagie City - Ham & American 8" - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

Every time I order there is a reason why they can't make my order. Last week they claimed they were not making hot food. I asked for my order to be cancelled after I was texted by the store. No refund has been issued, they don't answer the phone and when I texted back the number that texted me from the store that I didn't get a refund I got no response but they read the message (don't use an iPhone if you don't want people to know you are ignoring them). I have only successfully got food from them once and it was okay at best. They compensate for a lack of included toppings and flavor with a ton of meat which I guess is great for most on the American Diet but some of us want to taste more than meat and would gladly give some of it up for flavor. In my experience this is a poorly run business that doesn't care about the customer experience. read more

Hoagie City - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

This place is a hidden gem if you want a good hoagie around Columbus. This is the next best thing to heading to Philly for a steak and cheese - and even Philly shops would struggle to beat this place. Today we had steak and cheese hoagies with peppers, onions, cheese wiz, and provolone. Hands down the best hoagie I've had in a decade or more. We also shared a hot and zesty pickle which was spicy but awesome and some chips. The half hoagies run around $10-11 and are eight inches in length. I ordered a full, 16" and it was way too much for me to eat. However, it worked out because I have a lunch hoagie for tomorrow. Next up will be the Italian with peppers. I would have taken photos of the food but there are already photos of their steak and cheese and the smell over powered my willpower. read more

See all

This is the best cold sandwich in Columbus hands down. Their cheesesteaks are authentically Philadelphian, and rival the best establishments we have here. read more

We love this place. Been here a bunch now and every time it's been incredible. The food is so good and the amount of food you get is unreal. The owners and everyone else are so friendly and it really feels like a family run place. read more

My family and I are from Philidelphia, and finally... a real deal cheesesteak and deli. Bob is from Philly and he made hoagies there for 20+ years. He's a character, that's for sure. You might not know how important an Amoroso roll is to a cheesesteak, but they're the same rolls the are served on all across the city. He gets all his meats and cheeses from Philly, and also offers cheese Whiz. Please, don't get provolone, just don't. Go with the Whiz or white American cheese. Oh yeah, come hungry too. This isn't your local chain that tells their employees to put 4 onions on your cheesesteak either. You get piles of toppings. The Italian is so good, too. Just get ready to eat because a half is 8 inches and a whole is 16 and both piled high with everything you need. read more

The Italian Hoagie was loaded with meats, cheese, and veggies -- it makes for a big bite! The half size is 8 in which we found to be big enough to share for lunch. I recommend adding vinegar separately to help cut thru all the richness from the meat (the oil/vinegar mix was a little too oily for me). I'll be trying the cheesesteak next time! read more

Hoagie City - Italian Hoagie - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio