For my visit, afternoon on 12 17 2018:
Want so bad to love this place as it is a very tidy, generally well run independent hardware store with items you cannot find at the big boxes. Have had some great experiences here buying household tools (blower and weeder for example) but this holiday trip had a few hiccups that I find to be less than impressive....in particular, they seem unusually paranoid about theft and have some archaic checkout procedures:
- First stopped in the Carhartt clothing department. The employee was busy doing something under her counter and did not greet. OK. Not a big deal. Looked around a bit and went to other departments. Came back later. She did not greet the second time, despite my wandering all through the area. When I did find something to buy though, she made a point of interrupting another customer's question to "see if I was going to do more shopping"....aka you cannot leave the area with that item is how I interpreted it....told her "no I am done" She then directs me to check out with the checkers in the front across from her, you know, the direction I was "already heading". This associate seemed to be having a bad day...to say the least.
Pro Tip #1: Clothing security tags like other stores use, could solve issues with clothing that is unpaid for "shrinking" in the other parts of the store. A sign would also help if you do now want customers "traveling" with unpaid clothing around the place.
- Went to area near the tool rental counter to get a type of fuel for the blower. They only had one unit out (wanted at least three), but had others in cases of four. No one around to ask if I can break open a case or to do it for me. I wanted to buy more than one so I took a case up front where.....
- I check out (this employee was all smiles and very nice) She tries to scan the case, told her they are supposed to be scanned one at a time, she calls a manager over, the manager opens the case, makes a joke (which I took the right way no offense) about theft (see why I think they are obsessed in here)....and directs cashier to scan each one....ok. Then we get to the part where I pay. They have a chip reader, but it does not work. You slide your card. THEN you hand the credit card to the cashier....yeah I know, 1998 is back. Anyway, the cashier is then per company policy, asks for ID (which is against VISA rules) She then has to check signatures on your ID against your credit card. Wow. And all for a purchase that was well under 100.
- Another interaction in the store during this visit....I pop my head out an open door to the garden center (while holding a hand basket with merchandise). I look around for the person I came in with. Never mind the rest of my body is in the store, and that most of the year you can walk out there with unpaid merchandise. This gets the attention of a security guard in plain clothing "Do you need some help sir"...."no I am looking for the person I came in with"....he was appropriate overall but my goodness did I just come in here just after a major heist or what?
Pro Tip #2: A sign saying "No unpaid merchandise outside" or similar would be a good idea.
It is worth noting that both prepurchase interactions with employees were security related....and at "no" time did an employee directly ask me if I needed help in a stand alone manner. This despite visiting every side of the main store including plumbing, paint, hardware and stain. And no, the store was not busy.
Pro Tip #3: During the holiday season, having extra help assigned to simply ask customers if they need help is usually the best way to limit shrinkage (aka shoplifting). This lets all customers know that staff is aware of their presence.
Note to self....Buy your Carhartts online or at another retailer.......and maybe give Hills Flat a few months "break" before another visit. Wow. Merry Christmas! read more