Cancel

Open app

Search

Hey Sugar

4.3 (96 reviews)
Closed • Closed
Updated 3 months ago

About Hey Sugar

Loading...

Read the full summary in the app

Order Hey Sugar Takeout or Delivery

Hey Sugar Photos

HEY SUGAR ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Dogs allowed
Outdoor seating

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Hey Sugar

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Who wouldn't want to get into this tub!!
Charese M.

Omg!! Omg!!! Omg!!!! Hey Sugar is Hey-mazing!!!!! I had no idea what I wanted when I walked in, but it didn't take me long to figure it out! There is sooo much to choose from. It's easy to get overwhelmed, but with the help of a Hey Sugar associate, you will find what your tooth is craving! The location, ambiance and decor are all inviting. Everything in the store says "eat me!" I requested the red velvet cupcake and a strawberry shortcake cupcake with buttercream icing!! Neither cupcake disappointed. I bit my finger while eating.....it was just so good!!! Don't walk, run to hear the next time you have a sweet tooth and need choices. Enjoy a photo shoot with the tub while enjoying your sweet treat!!

Welcome
Alice K.

Cute shop on 3rd street, specializing in desserts and treats. I had a cup of chocolate soft serve and my guest had vanilla/chocolate. Both were delicious!

Cupcakes were good. I had lemon (bottom right).
Liz K.

Incredibly charming sweet shop in downtown Geneva. From the time you enter the doorway and walk in it's whimsical and Instagram-able. The counter girl was helpful. However, for what you get it's pricey. I bought a milkshake, a lemonade and a cupcake and my total was $27. I know I'm paying for ambience (and I am in Geneva) having incredibly special looking treats but the lemonade I had was just OK. The concept was great. It had a lavender ice cube, a lemonade, ice cube and a watermelon ice cube on top and I had club soda poured in, but it took forever for it to melt to get any flavor. My daughter had a red velvet milkshake that she said was really great and it looked super cute when she got it. The lemon cupcake was good. However, there were truffles being sold in the case no bigger than a nickel in size that were $5 each. I couldn't even imagine what kind of magic that must've tasted like for $5. Will I be back? Probably since it was so charming inside but next time maybe I'll just stick to a cupcake.

Ruth L.

Cute spot in DT Geneva, good cafe and dessert options. Teas, lemonades, cafe drinks, cupcakes, chocolates, and various ways to dress up a few flavors of soft serve. Soft serve and mango mousse is a bit pricey at $6, cupcakes $4.50, cafe drinks $5, had 1 cupcake, 3 basic soft serves, 2 mango mousses , and a cold brew and the bill was roughly $40. I will say the soft serve was fairly large and definitely shareable for 2 people which I would recommend. Service was good and quick.

Savanna B.

Everything about Hey Sugar is pretty- from the cupcakes and treats behind the case to the decor to the customers I mean, it was kind of weird- like everybody in there was dressed up to eat cupcakes. We got a selection of cupcakes to go to take to a friend's house and they were all delicious. We ended up cutting them up and sharing them between us and I would definitely go back

Time for dessert
Kathleen L.

Wow when you see this place from outside it looks simply magical! When you open the doors it makes you feel like a kid in the candy store! So many great cupcake, ice cream, and hot drink options! The prices are modest compared to other dessert places we have dined at. We were so happy to see peanut butter options on the menu board because most places avoid it! We will be back for sure! This place is has the most decadent desserts! I have never seen a waffle cone rolled in cereal before so yum! The only complaint it that we did not get any napkins and it would be nice to have a free water station. We will be back for sure!

Bailey M.

This was my first time stopping in! I like the store's layout, it definitely is young and has tons of Instagram worthy backgrounds. The cupcakes I would give 3.5 stars. I review every cupcake shop on a vanilla cupcake because I think basic cupcake flavors can be hard for some places and it makes it the easiest for comparison. The vanilla let me down here. The cake was very dense and slightly dry. The frosting was decent. Good cake to frosting ratio and overall size. I just wouldn't get this again based on the texture. Then I had a carrot cake cupcake and that was so much better! So I would try different flavors from them given this. The cream cheese frosting had a nice flavor and the carrot cake was moist and had different consistencies of ingredients mixed in. They also offer a good selection of ice cream and drinks and a few other desserts!

Cookie Dough Cupcake (Left) Peanut Butter Explosion (right)
Xavier Thomas M.

First of all the vibes of the place is very welcoming. The decoration is adorable and instagrammable. We bought a cookie dough peanut butter which was a perfectly moist chocolate cupcake, edible cookie dough, and a piece of a Hershey's bar on top. It was really good and great for the price! The peanut butter explosion is a chocolate soft serve with peanut butter Reese's, salted caramel dressing, and other peanut butter bits. This was so good. I'm usually hesitant on chocolate and peanut butter desserts because they're usually super overwhelming but this was so so good. The chocolate soft serve wasn't overwhelming, the peanut butter flavors came out even after you finish the top part, and the salted caramel drizzle was the right amount of salt to boost the sweetness. 5/5 will definitely come back!

Cake Shake Flavor: Mint
Andrea M.

Tried this place out for our back to school treats! Very fun and cute place! The flavors and choices were fun, and my son was impressed with Cloud 9 because it had pop rocks and all sorts of goodies like cotton candy! For the 3 kids and myself, it was $43.20, which seemed like a lot - but everything costs so much right now! It was a cute place, and I'm sure we will be back down the road! Service was wonderful - the girls working were very patient with my kids as they weren't behaving the best! Hyper due to excitement!!

Barbara M.

SO much fun and yum having a Sweet Treat Birthday Celebration!! The staff were lovely and accommodating to all of our silliness!! And needless to say the ice cream and cupcakes were a hit!!! The girls had SUCH a great time!

Oreo Shake

See all

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Lauren K.
133
14
2

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Shannon L.
41
147
22

6 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of H V.
0
1
0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

We love trying new ice places and this place was amazing our kids loved the fun ice cream flavors!!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Definitely amazing sweets!! But girls in front aren't the friendliest... they were to focused on their friends!!!

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Super cute, friendly staff and yummy treats!!! Fun little place to pop into to get something to cure your sweet tooth!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

yummy soft serve, coffee, milkshakes and more! I loved this place and highly recommend it!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 3 of 3

Ask the Community - Hey Sugar

You might also consider

Eye Candy Bake Shop - Boston Cream and Coconut gluten free donuts

Eye Candy Bake Shop

4.9(54 reviews)
0.2 mi

Wow. Ron Swanson would hate it here, which means this is the place for me to get the desserts I can…read moreeat without the inflammation! Thank you Eye Candy. This is the cutest little shop right on the downtown strip in Geneva. Inviting atmosphere, amazing smells and even better customer service. You can feel the passion oozing out of the two women who were working there this morning! Bonus...they loved my amazing Barefoot Contessa shirt...did we just become best friends!? I tried the coffee/crumb cake, pecan fudge shortbread square and their chocolate chip cookie. Everything in the store is gluten free with vegan and dairy free options, as well (perfect for us almond moms, at least that's what my a-hole kids call me). I am a baked goods snob, having owned a catering company that specialized in baked goods, and this shit was TOP TIER!! Truly, you wouldn't know it's gluten free...seriously. The cookie was gooey with the crispy edge you're looking for, the cake was light and not grainy, in the slightest, and the shortbread fudge bar was rich and delicious! Make sure you run to this place if you're seeking amazing and allergy friendly treats! You can thank me later.

I love this place! Everything is gluten free, plus they have dairy free and vegan options. The…read moredesserts are absolutely gorgeous and tasty. The turnovers are my absolute favorite followed closely by the salted caramel brownie and cookies and cream cheesecake. Menu items are switched up often with a few staples. Sometimes by the time I can get there the selections are limited. They usually post what they have at the beginning of the day on their instagram and I'm sure people are a lot like me and see how delicious the items look and run in to snatch it up.

Photos
Eye Candy Bake Shop - Pastry case

Pastry case

Eye Candy Bake Shop - Greeting customers with a genuine smile

Greeting customers with a genuine smile

Eye Candy Bake Shop

See all

Mad Batter Bakery and Confections

Mad Batter Bakery and Confections

4.1(63 reviews)
2.2 mi

Ordered a birthday cake to feed 10 people and specified this multiple times but received a tiny 6…read moreinch round. Now I'm scrambling to find another cake for my little girl's party the day of. This was after filling out an order form and 3 separate phone conversations-- one of which was bc I was double charged. On top of that, the cake itself looks very amateur-ish and not professionally made. Had I the time, I for sure could've done better myself. Oh, and as a bonus the girl I spoke to the first time on the phone was super rude then basically hung up on me. Just go get your cake at Jewel's-- it basically looks the same.

Mad Batter Bakery in St. Charles is such a gem. I seriously wish it was closer to me or that they…read morehad more locations. I love the creativity behind each pastry. They are always coming up with fun and unique flavors, and the stuff they post early in the morning is honestly half the reason I check Facebook. The staff were very friendly and gave recommendations on what the most popular flavors were. I always appreciate that in a place. The pastries are on the sweeter side for sure, so having a whole one can be a lot, but that is just me. Still totally worth it. The decor inside is so cute too. Definitely gives you Alice in Wonderland vibes with all the little trinkets and tea time touches. Super charming spot. If you are into sweets and fun vibes, it is a must-try.

Photos
Mad Batter Bakery and Confections - Gender Reveal Cake

Gender Reveal Cake

Mad Batter Bakery and Confections
Mad Batter Bakery and Confections - BEAUTIFUL & DELICIOUS!!!

See all

BEAUTIFUL & DELICIOUS!!!

Hey Sugar - coffee - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...