We had such a great experience at Hearthstone Restaurant. From the moment we walked in, everything just felt warm and welcoming. Our meal was outstanding every bite was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully prepared. And the service? Absolutely top notch. Attentive without hovering, friendly without feeling forced. They made us feel taken care of the whole night. Also... Pear Mule, That drink was delicious. Crisp, refreshing, perfectly balanced. Safe to say, we'll definitely be back. read more

Hearthstone Restaurant - blackberry elk - New American Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

See all

We came for happy hour after a ski day and were really impressed. The historic building is outstanding, and they've retained most of the charm and features. Great location and views if you're lucky enough to be near a window. The cocktails focus on the classics and are well prepared (and using Breckenridge spirits where possible). We shared most of the appetizers, all were delicious and interesting. Everything was a decent value, especially given Breck prices. read more

Amazing experience. I was tasked with planning my mom's elopement last minute while they visited on their annual ski trip. They eloped at sapphire point (stunning) and then we did a dinner of 9 adults and 2 children to celebrate. Hearthstone was the best! They put me in touch with local baker who dropped off the wedding cake the night before and they set it up for a cutting at the end of dinner. Service was excellent. They put us in a semi private room off to the left, perfect. Food was excellent as well (much better than what you typically eat at a wedding haha). Waiter was very patient with us and attentive. Didn't feel rushed even when most of headed back and three people stayed back at the table for another round. Made the night feel so special. Thank you Hearthstone for making the elopement feel so special. read more

See all

Sat at the bar for happy hour and had a fantastic experience. The service was great and the happy hour menu had a really solid selection. The pork belly and beef tips were absolutely incredible, easily the standout dishes and cooked perfectly. This is a must-visit spot for happy hour in Breckenridge, and I'll definitely be back to try dinner next time. read more

Hearthstone Restaurant - New American Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

See all

Enjoyed dinner here with my wife. So far this has been my favorite dinner in Breckenridge. The restaurant is beautiful inside and out. Very well done! Courses were timed well and the staff was friendly and attentive for the most part. Food was fantastic. No picture of the appetizers but the lobster raviolo was top notch. read more

See all

Visited Hearthstone on a Saturday evening. We had Charlie as our server, and he did a fabulous job recommending dishes and drinks preferred to the needs and desires of the group. Our group had the best salad, cheese plate, mushroom soup and octopus for starters. We also had the elk, lamb, beef flat iron steak and the cod for entrees. The front runners were the soup and the elk. The setting was in an old converted house so it was an unusual setup, but entirely lovely. Would highly recommend if you had to choose one location for a nice dinner in town. read more

Had a fabulous meal at Hearthstone. If you're looking to eat good In Breckenridge, Hearthstone should be at the top of your list. Reservations are recommended, we made ours 1.5 months ahead of time. Service was exceptional! Tried both the NY strip Special and the rack of lamb. Both were cooked to perfection. I preferred the lamb, the chefs signature dish, price per head is about $100 - $150 for dinner. Go, you won't be disappointed! read more

Hearthstone Restaurant - Lamb is the chefs signature dish - New American Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

See all

Would rate this place 3.7 stars Our waiter Corbin was wonderful with timing, refills and overall service. No complaints there. The reason for the dings to the rating is because of the food/chef. The wait for our entrees was unusually long, tables were looking around for their food and one table stood up and complained in front of everyone. Upon arrival, the medium filet was medium rare and the medium rare elk was medium well. Overall the dining experience was cozy and romantic, but the food leaves a bit to be desired for the price point. read more

Hearthstone Restaurant - blackberry elk - New American Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

We walked up without a reservation on a Saturday & the staff was able to accommodate us at a 2 top. Super adorable house with a large outdoor space. Very welcoming & warm. The peach app was phenomenal. read more

See all

Wonderful experience from start to finish. They quickly adjusted to add one more to our party. Our waiter, Josh, was fantastic, including our 7 year old in all conversations and suggesting what he should order. We had the charred octopus to start, which was fresh and delicious. Our son had the tempura shrimp and ate every bite. The real star was the lamb shank, perfectly cooked and seasoned with incredible cheddar mashed potatoes. We also had the wagyu flatiron with gnocchi which was great. Highly recommend if you're looking for cozy, delicious dinner. read more

Hearthstone Restaurant - Wagyu flatiron with gnocchi which - New American Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

See all

It was an interesting meal with some high highs and low lows. The service was great and our waiter was really nice. The highlights of the meal were the Ahi Tuna appetizer and Peach Bread Pudding with Raspberry Sorbet for dessert. The tuna appetizer was so well done with all the different flavors and textures coming together perfectly. It was one of my favorite tuna dishes I've ever had. I don't normally go for bread pudding, but both it and the sorbet were delicious. The low point was the burrata appetizer which I had gotten as my main. I love black pepper and would say I use more than the average person, but this dish had so much pepper that it was hard to eat. I had to force myself to finish maybe half of it. I had seen some positive reviews for the burrata so not sure if there was some accident with my dish and the pepper, but I can't imagine it was what the dish was meant to be. The actual restaurant was pretty cool and had a relaxing atmosphere so given that and the delicious tuna appetizer and dessert I'd probably go back. read more

See all

I've been here twice in the last few years and I just don't get why this place is so popular. The food lacks flavor. If you're from a major city, skip this place. It just doesn't compare (we're from Houston). We had the filet (we get this at every steakhouse) and it lacked flavor. The duck was cooked well and was average. Sides were bland, literally no flavor. For the appetizer, we had the octopus and it was cooked well. It was paired with a Spanish sausage (odd pairing) but both tastes great. The complimentary bread was really good too. Falling Corpse and Moscow Mule were good. The waiter was very knowledgeable but the service was extremely slow. For the price (almost $400 for 2 adults and a kid) I'd go elsewhere. read more

Another incredible spot in Breck for a date night. What a perfect meal after a long day on the mountain. The flat iron steak was perfectly cooked and the Parmesan sage gnocchi that came with it just melted in your mouth. The complimentary bread was also incredible to start with. Can't wait to come back here already!! Great staff as well! read more

Hearthstone Restaurant - Flat Iron Steak - New American Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

See all

I went on a recommendation from a friend and was truly pleased with the level of attention and the quality of meal. For an area where I had not received the best service at other establishments this place provided a much better experience. From the moment I walked in I was warmly welcomed and impressed with an elegant and cozy restaurant that apparently used to be a 1900s mansion. I thought about ordering the elk since I don't often get to have it, but I couldn't turn down the Wagyu ribeye and it was amazing, cooked to perfection, juicy, taste full, and the risotto it was paired with was phenomenal. I had the octopus as an appetizer and it was tender and succulent. I will be returning on my next trip to Breckenridge. read more

Hearthstone Restaurant - Rib eye - New American Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

Located in a renovated 19th century mansion this is a place to go for a special celebration. From the ambience to the views to the food every thing is tastefully curated with attention given to details. Weather permitting I'd recommend patio seating! read more

See all

This place is AMAZING! My husband and I went here for our anniversary dinner. First, when you walk in, the ambiance is amazing. It is in such a cute house on the hill with great views, and the interior is so aesthetic- like an old cozy Victorian house. When we sat down we were met with a free glass of champagne for celebrating our anniversary which was a nice touch. We both ordered a cocktail which came out quickly, and ordered 2 appetizers and 1 entree to share. We got the Octopus and the Beef massaman meat pie to share. The octopus was well made but a little salty, but the beef massaman pie was incredible. One of the best foods I have had in a long time and I'm still thinking about it. The philo dough was done perfectly and it was perfect to share (you only get 1 but it is large!). Then we got the blackberry elk to share. The restaurant brought this to us on two separate plates already since they knew we were splitting it which was so thoughtful and made it so easy! And it was so good. Definitely enough to share. We were so full afterwards that we couldnt even get a dessert, though they looked amazing as well. Our server was attentive and kind, and overall this was such an amazing experience, especially for a celebratory evening. There were many people there in their after-skiing outfits, but we were a little dressed up. Both seemed fine for the location! read more

See all

Housed in a converted home this restaurant has lots of character, charm and class. Service was very good although she did forget to tell us about the quail special we overheard the other table was told about. We had ordered already so we didn't change our order. We shared the Radish Salad. It was fresh, crisp and elegant! I'd never had a salad like this before and it was excellent! The perfect starter salad! It was unusual and had light, interesting flavors that didn't overpower. This is why I loved it so much. I was quite happy with the Duck dish. It was a very generous portion and was served with mashed parsnip and roasted cubed beets. The pomegranate molasses was really good with all of it. The duck itself was tender and savory. Delicious! The lamb chops x3 were good size and served with bourbon sweet potatoes. So yummy! A great combo! We ended with the Toffee Bread Pudding. It seemed more like a light muffin with a thin caramel sauce. Different than the usual bread pudding I've tried at other places. Theirs was light and not overly sweet so it was perfect way to end a lovely meal. read more

See all

This used to be a better restaurant. Maybe today was a one-off (it was a Monday - B-team in the kitchen maybe?), but for $90/plate I expect better. Also there's now a 3% kitchen surcharge? I was too food-coma'd to ask about it at the time but really - bill me once, then twice, plus tip - for this the food should be outstanding, but it's not. The filet was dry, the mushroom soup was luke warm, the lobster ravioli was mushy (probably overcooked). Oh - the place is still beautiful and we got the cool-kids' table in the bay window - joy. But the food ain't what it used to be. read more

I can't believe it's taken me this long to write a review for my FAVORITE RESTAURANT IN ALL OF COLORADO. There I said it. Hearthstone is truly special and I've felt that way each and every time I've dined here. Its beautiful Victorian facade beckons you to come in and stay awhile. We've celebrated some wonderful moments here, including our wedding rehearsal dinner (which was the talk of our wedding party for how enchanting everything was). The menu features a modern American approach to locally prepared, in season game, fish, and produce. Each time I've dined here has been like a new experience with some staple favorites that are a must-order every time (like the Black Cod and Creekstone Ranch Beef Filet). I've loved everything I've had here and the Sticky Toffee Pudding remains in the number one spot for favorite desserts of all time. The service is impeccable and it feels like you're having an intimate dining experience in a loved one's home. We've sat in almost every table and our preference is the beautiful window table upstairs overlooking the mountains beyond. I also love the outdoor deck for those beautiful, sunny day happy hours. We've had some seriously exceptional cocktails from Benji (the bar manager) who was kind enough to educate us on whiskeys & the different concoctions he was conceptualizing. They have a comprehensive wine list and nice selection of cocktails. Each time we're in Breck, Hearthstone is a must stop. 10/10 and wish I could give more than 5 stars . I recommend any of the beef/lamb dishes and especially love the Alaskan Black Cod (which cuts like butter it's so silken and tender). read more

See all

Holy moly, we're on a roll! This place was literally one of the best meals I've had in my life. You walk into a warm, Victorian-esque ambiance with fun lighting and picture frames everywhere. Our waiter Cody was very friendly and helpful with deciding what to get off the menu. We started with the burrata and heirloom tomatoes- it was surprisingly delicious. The burrata was house made and so creamy and decadent. For entrees we got the Rack of Lambs and the Blackberry Crusted Elk. WOW! Both were insanely good, cooked to perfection (med rare) and the sides it came with were mind blowingly tasty. For dessert we got the carrot cake, and which was decadent and delicious as well. We took 1/2 of it home. All in all, was a wonderful evening. Yes it's expensive but for a special treat it's totally worth it. Highly recommend! read more

See all

SO GOOD! We had the blackberry elk and rack of lambs, and both were delicious and flavorful. Service was excellent and timely. Will definitely be back read more

Delicious! Our server was Benji and he was awesome. He walked us through the menu and was welcoming and nice. We did a bunch of Happy hour plates to try everything and the dinner plate of steak with gnocchi. Let me tell you, the gnocchi was the best I have ever had, considering I don't like gnocchi. It kind of just melted in my mouth like butter. It was not super chewy like the ones I had in the past. Now I am a fan and the standard is set really high. The steak was good too. We also ordered a bunch of things from the happy hour menu. Hummus, baos, and the beets stood out for me. Ceviche was their special for the day and it was salty. But overall we enjoyed dinner and the happy hour drinks. We were seated upstairs in a victorian house style. Different from where I usually dine at so I like the different decor, but welcoming atmosphere. I'd come back again for the steak and unforgettable gnocchi. read more

See all

Service was excellent as always. Ambiance is always excellent as well. Food was not up to par. My wife and I were both disappointed in our meal on this occasion. We've been coming to Hearthstone every trip to Breck for about 8 years. We ate here in August and both had the same meal as the trip last month. The elk was full of tendons that were both unappetizing and tough. Brussel sprouts were very dry with little flavor. (We both had them). My wife said her creekstone steak was tough but she did enjoy the au gratin potatoes! read more

Hearthstone Restaurant - Blackberry elk, rice and brussel sprouts - New American Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

I never write reviews--so the fact that I'm taking the time to post this says a lot. I was in Breckenridge for a quick 18-hour business trip and stopped into Hearthstone before the dinner rush. Ordered the tenderloin beef tip appetizer and blackberry elk and was completely blown away. Cooked perfectly medium-rare, insanely flavorful, and honestly one of the best dishes I've had in years. Service? Immaculate. My server Brandon was top-tier, friendly, knowledgeable, and dialed in without being overbearing. I genuinely hated to leave. If you're in Breck and want a meal that slaps, go here. Expensive, yes but you get what you pay for. read more

Hearthstone Restaurant - blackberry elk - New American Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

Booked a reservation for a Saturday night date night and it was decidedly okay. Our server was amazing and very knowledgeable. He made excellent recommendations for wine pairings that were absolutely spot on. We started with the Octopus and the Heirloom tomato with house made burrata and those were lovely. When it was time for the main course, I opted for the special of the night - Shrimp, Scallops and fish and it was... ok. The scallops didn't have that lovely sear I've come to expect from a fine dining establishment and the shrimp was slightly overdone as was the fish. The sauce was impeccable though. My partner had the Bison Short rib and it was good as well but honestly, for a $50 entree it was underwhelming. read more

See all

The place is cozy and servers are very friendly. The food is creative, delicious, and specialty cocktails/mocktails are amazing. Best food and drinks we had in the area. You'll be happy ordering anything on the menu. read more

As some have mentioned, the scallops were a tad (honestly almost unbearably) salty. Which took away from the freshness and delightful taste of the dish. But perhaps, it's my bad on ordering seafood in a mountain town? Service was great and ambiance was nice. However, I don't think the price point was reflective of the quality of the dishes. Just my honest humble opinion read more

What a PLEASANT experience this was! After having missed out on Breckinridge for the past decade, I'm so glad I was able to stop by here. This is a twist on traditional cuisine and is perfect for a cozy family night or date. The bison short rib was something I found to be especially delicious with its contrast of full and subtle flavors. I definitely would recommend! A special thank you to our waitress, Carrie Ann for being delightful and attentive. Can't wait to visit again soon! read more

See all

Just popped in for a cocktail and glass of wine. We sat at the bar with Ethan, had great service! We will be back for dinner soon. read more

Hearthstone Restaurant - A nice Cabernet at the bar top floor - New American Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

See all

Wonderful turn of the century decor greets you as you enter. Seated in the front area of the main room had great view of the mountains. Our waitress was very friendly and attentive without being intrusive. Meal choices were varied and nicely accompanied with decorative presentation. I had the filet option which was generous and thick. Medium rare is perfect for this very tender steak. Enjoyed a tasty chocolate dessert and a cheese plate appetizer. Considering other places with similar offerings Hearthstone was reasonably priced. read more

See all

Another fantastic Hearthstone meal! This is our go-to in Breckenridge for upscale meals, and it always delivers the goods. They were ready for us at our reservation time, and the service was on point. Two of us had the rack of lamb (again) and were delighted. We won with the apps - the cheese board (probably the best deal in Breck) and the lobster ravioli - and that set us up well. The seasoning is just enough on the outer crust, perfectly cooked to a medium, and joined with a whipped sweet potatoes and broccolini. The black cod was cooked superbly and the sauce was rich without being too heavy. Our fourth had the scallops and they disappeared fast (likely b/c they were a little small / one was missing for that sort of dish). Thank you for a fantastic night celebrating family on Christmas Eve Eve! read more

It was a very unexpected snowy evening and my in laws were in town. They requested going to one very nice restaurant/meal while we were in Breckenridge. Hearthstone was the perfect place to meet these requirements. We were greeted when we entered, offered to take out coats and promptly seated. Note, I did make a reservation online. Our waitress was friendly, knowledgeable and checked with us throughout the meal. I wouldn't recommend getting out Hearthstone in with an upscale steak house type feel with unique twists on red meat options - elk, bison, short ribs, filet. My in laws were very impressed as well. We didn't get dessert because we were all stuffed from our large portions. It is in a beautiful old restored home and the history is quite interesting. There is information on the history to look through. read more

We were recommended this place by a friend and the food was phenomenal!! I would say I was pretty disappointed by the lack of celebration this place showed us. We were spending our anniversary there and indicated such in the reservation. The hostess was super friendly and even said happy anniversary to us when we arrived. Then not a single recognition from our server or anyone else going forward. This is a special occasion place and the least the server could do is recognize this. This anniversary was a big deal but us and we left the restaurant feeling disappointed because of it. I will end with saying the espresso martini was amazing and every single food item was mouth watering. From the appetizers of mussels and octopus to the special entree, lamb shank. I wouldn't spend a special occasion here based on this especially if I was looking to be celebrated though would consider returning for the food. read more

See all

Review is for their happy hour. They are pretty nut allergy friendly; even ordering the cheese plate, they put the almonds on the side upon request. We arrived at 3:52PM on a Saturday and were first in line for a happy hour. Every table was taken by 4:21PM, along with most of the bar seating. I ordered two beers ($4 a piece), two orders of the mochiko Chicken ($10 each), one order of the artisan cheese plate ($12), and one order of the beef tip steamed buns ($12). $4 beers: can't complain. 10/10 Mochiko Chicken (5/5*): *I would be careful ordering this with any drinks or other dishes. It has some serious spice kick! Artisan Cheese Plate (2/5): Not really worth it in my opinion, one cheese was essentially a basic brie. The other two were ok, but we could have used more crackers. I think my score is lower because I couldn't eat the almonds. Beef Tip Steamed Buns (4.5/5): Two beef buns that have some great flavor, very much like a bulgogi bao. One of my buns had a lot more meat than the other, but they were still both pretty good. Service was fast and friendly. They did an excellent job of keeping our water cups topped off and confirming we didn't need anything else. My friends went to Aurum for their happy hour and said that this one blew that out of the water. Overall one of the best happy hours we did in Breckenridge, would recommend! read more

See all

Food is very delicious and interior was superb. So glad we walked in here. Service was amazing. We ordered lamb and duck. Lamb was so great but my duck was too uncooked to my taste. They quickly adjusted well. Will miss here read more

I really wanted to like it here. It's hyped as one of the best restaurants in the area, but it really was meh for me. We got there early and got seated late. Waited for the waiter for a while, said he'd bring bread, waited until our meal to come. We started with the mussels which was delicious. My bison short rib was really inedible. The kale was too salty and the short ribs were not tender. The dessert was good, but nothing spectacular. The worst part was the ambiance. The table sitting behind me was YELLING the whole time, I couldn't even hear my table sitting right in front of me. I would have expected someone to tell them to quiet down a bit, but it really ruined my dining experience. read more

Hearthstone Restaurant - New American Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

I really loved the old school vibe in this restaurant! Our server was amazing. He was super attentive and knowledgeable of everything on the menu! This place is definitely on the price your side, but the food was delicious. read more

Hearthstone Restaurant - colorado rack of lamb* - New American Near Me - Breckenridge, Colorado

See all

Lovely establishment and wonderful intelligent service. The food was meh. Ordered the snapper special. The dish was severely overcooked and both the fish and rice were dry. I notified the server and to their credit they removed the charge from our bill. All in all we were all let down by the expectations of the restaurant and its chefs. We dined on July 3, so maybe the holiday rush impacted read more

Came here for my birthday and the food was spectacular! Got elk, duck, cake and shake, with truffles they provided for my special day. The duck was so delicious and I love the cranberry sauce! I was drooling waiting for the food because everything sounded and smelled so good! The food does take a while to arrive, but you can start the meal with some drinks-we got cocktail and scotch. read more

See all

Perfection. Every dish: wonderful! Generous, on-point, not overly fussy, creative, reliable. But the best part: caring, attentive, responsive, intuitive, gracious service. All the way around...great management, and it shows. We will be back, again and again. read more