I love this spot. The pizza, the beefs, it's as good as anywhere in All of Illinois and Chicago…read more I love going here when I am in Findlay visiting my Dad, but because of Covid, I couldn't visit with him recently. I ordered pizza and beefs for him for Father's Day and not only was it all delicious I have heard, the staff at Rosati's included a Father's Day card for him that really was above and beyond. Thank you Rosati's for rocking the pizza game, and rocking my family's Father's Day.

Ordered boneless wings over the phone as a take out. I drove 20 min to Rosatis excited for my food…read morebecause I have always gotten great service and food from here prior to today. However today when I got home after picking up my order and opening it up they were wings with bones in. I'm usually not picky and never call and complain. However I felt the need to this time so I called and let the cashier know. I did not get her name sadly. But as soon as I explained the situation she was immediately RUDE and told me I ordered jumbo. When I don't eat wings with bones and personally had no idea what a jumbo was until today. And proceeded to tell me there's nothing she is going to do or can do and even if her boss was there still wouldn't help me either. The service was definitely a 0/10 and no cashier should handle a situation the way she did.

Great Sausage, pepperoni and mushroom pizza. Also, they have a routine machines if you want to…read morecontrol the ambiance.

I used to always like villas food and service but tonight I ordered Alfredo and a salad to be…read moredelivered I was hung up on had to call back I was on hold longer than it took to order my meal after a hr I called to see where my meal was and of course had to wait on hold again before I could even speak my food finally arrived after a hr and a half after ordering and was cold the person that took was order was snotty the guy who delivered my meal was a nice guy handed me my food and opened my door for me since my hands was full and I was waiting outside for it to come I used to eat here a lot in the late early 90s and service never used to be this bad I don't know if it was a bad day or what but I was not happy with my service

Pizza was fabulous! Service was fantastic. Only thing that would have made it perfect, if they had…read moreCoke instead of Pepsi.

Ordered Baked Mostacioli with a side Greek for pick up…read more The mostacioli was delicious. Healthy portion with a sweet marinara sauce and melted cheese...alot of cheese! The small Greek salad was a great accompaniment with plenty of feta and a tasty Greek dressing. I would have love kalamata olives instead of black,but a great salad. I kinda regret not eating in after walking in and seeing what a cute restaurant this place is. Like something from an Americana movie. I will go back!!

Great food. Reasonable prices. Good small town pub atmosphere Robotic delivery of drinks is uniqueread more

So we take 2 grandkids to Windsor pub. They order cheese pizza.....the pizza is served not cut ,…read morewhat eating place serves food not ready to eat? The wife had baked potato and steak bites, worst steak bites she's ever had. I all wanted was a cold beer and a burger, I got my cold beer, the burger was no better than a half warm burger from McDonald's how's is this place open and serving low quality food

After a long day of driving was ready for a bite to eat and came to Monical's to grab some pizza to…read morego. I've really only seen their name on the highway food/restaurants signs, and those restaurants I feel like tend to be a little meh so my expectations were dampened. BUT all the reviews here were so high I didn't know what to expect. Didn't realize I was going to have one of the best pizzas I've ever eaten before. We ordered the Rams Special which is like a supreme pizza but with bacon which makes it the best supreme pizza I've had. We demolished that pizza. Besides that we ordered at the counter and they were very quick with the order, I feel like we didn't have to wait very long for the pizza, especially considering this is a sit down restaurant as well. They had lots of local decor on the walls which was fun to look at and pass the time.

My husband and I went there for lunch. The whole experience was great. Pizza was out in no time and…read morethe BEST I've had since going home to Effingham. Definitely worth the drive from Ashley. Definitely will return.

The food, service and ambiance was outstanding. Such a special place. You can see the love and care…read morethat goes into every dish that is prepared as well as the personal treatment they give to every guest. We met the owner, who cooks many of their signature dishes, his daughter who manages the restaurant, and his granddaughter who was the hostess that night. We happened to be traveling through the area, celebrating our 50th anniversary, and they went out of their way to make it a memorable night for us! The restaurant has the feeling of a your smaller, neighborhood Italian restaurant that makes their dishes from recipes that have been passed down from one generation to the next. By the time we left, they made us feel like we were part of their extended family, if only for an evening. And when you're traveling on the road, that's a mighty nice feeling! Do yourself a favor, the next time you are in the area, plan on making this a destination. It's well worth it! (Consider making a reservation or at least calling ahead because they are pretty popular.)

The good: The food was absolutely magnificent. The chef is likely classically trained. Presentation…read morewas excellent. The sauce was as good as i have ever had. The bad: The wait staff was not very engaged. I wanted this review to be about the food but that just wasn't meant to be. The Ugly: I am very well travelled on 3 continents. I've dined elegantly as well as from street vendors and I have NEVER had service that was this off putting to the point of being overtly rude, and I am an American who has eaten in France and doesn't speak much French. When we wouldn't sit at the bar, even though the main area was only 1/4 occupied They moved our party of 2 into the side room with chairs up on tables. It went downhill from there. Due to this, it wasn't possible to really enjoy what should have been a fine meal. I will say it is a wise policy to ask for payment and tip ahead of this type of service before it is provided.

Make sure and read all of the negative reviews. They are probably the most objective and they hit…read moreall the highlights. Disclaimer: this visit was on Mother's Day so we understood that it would be crowded with longer wait time. First time in restaurant. The tables are packed claustrophobic tight. Or table was smack up against the side of the salad bar. I was afraid my hair would get in the lettuce. Every time someone walked past our table they bumped into the chairs. Payment is No cards, cash/check only and this info is NOT published anywhere but on a notecard taped to the cash register which was blocked from view as we were seated. Not on the door, not on the website. I see it's here in the comments on Yelp, but I had poor signal and didn't do a review search, just looked at the website. Poor treatment by owners - attitude was not "I'm sorry for your poor experience" but "I'm sorry you're complaining, get lost." Carry out orders and friends and locals seemed to receive priority service. Mediocre, overpriced food. "Baked" pasta dish was runny, mozzarella barely melted, meat sauce with barely any meat, way too sweet. Garlic bread with very little garlic. Pizza crust was hard, flavorless, over cooked on edges. Sauce (to me) has a weird chemical-like taste. Toppings were not fresh, mushrooms were canned, pizza was under cooked in the middle. Wait time - it was one hour until someone told us it was ready to come out in a couple of minutes..... then it actually was another 30 minutes or more later, during which the waiter avoided us like the plague until we flagged him down and asked when our food would be out, then another ten minutes after that. After reading reviews, it would seem that the time deception is a sanctioned tactic. Finally, after going to the car, retrieving an old checkbook, and writing a check with a generous tip in spite of the deficiencies, we politely expressed that they should publish their payment policy and how wait time was misrepresented. Received a very curt response. Left an honest comment on the community fb page and was threatened, cursed, and called every name in the book by most of the friendly "locals." But hey, social media, right? The rudeness on a busy day could have been easier to forgive if everything else had been five star, but the food really isn't worth the price and the wait. And jeez, Monticello....I'm afraid to drive through town, much less eat at this restaurant again.

Our experience was similar to Daune S (see below). Not likely to return. Most of the problem…read moreseemed to be in the kitchen. The floor staff were all nice and tried to be attentive.

This is a really good pizzeria! I had it delivered to the hotel I was staying at, and if I'm back…read moreagain, I will definitely order from them again!

This is by far the best pizza in Vandalia. Always fresh toppings and baked to perfection.read more

Fantastic Pizza! Been eating it 44 years and it is still perfect! Great family dinner spot and…read morereasonably priced.

Out of state visitor, wanted to order the spaghetti dinner to go, but they only sell the 1\2 gallon…read moreto go. i got it and i am glad i did, it fed me for 2 nights. sauce made just whe way i like, nice and meaty. Great family vibe and atmosphere here. service was quick, ready when i arrived. love it here, coming back next time in town! thanks