This is a review of the VINYL RECORDS at this particular location...
I have, since this location opened, tried to make it in here with some regularity (I teach in the area, which makes it easier to stop by from time to time). So I feel I actually have something consistent based on numerous experiences to be able to say when writing a review of this location. Compared to other area HPB locations (I also frequent Palatine and especially Bloomingdale), the selection of records here is pretty good. Like other HPBs, they take everything that comes in the door, so a good deal of the records are beaten up, with various degrees of marks which may (or may not) affect play, varying degrees of groove wear, and covers that vary in condition from quite nice to quite well-loved. However, tucked away next to these records are also some that can actually be in quite good shape. If you are wiling to do the footwork to comb through the gunk to find these good ones, you can do well re: finding some nice stuff to take home.
However, you also have another concern to deal with at this particular location once you find these good records you don't run into as often as you do at the Palatine or Bloomingdale HPBs, and this is the *high prices* this location charges for their music. As a another customer noted, the used CDs here are quite pricey, and the same thing is also true of the records. I regularly see records here that would sell for a good few dollars less in the same condition at the Palatine and Bloomingdale locations. (In a few cases, like some of the Jazz records, 2 to 3 times less. More often, though, the price difference has been less than this, at least on items I was able to make a direct comparison on.)
Why they are higher here--I am not sure. My theory is this may be because there is less competition in this area than those other HPB locations have. For instance, HPB Palatine has Rainbow Records very close by, and they usually have fairly low prices on used records, so this leads to better price control at that HPB location, I believe. The next closest used record store to the Naperville HPB is Kiss the Sky (FYE is the closest new record store), and they are known for overpricing their records, as well. (See the reviews here on Yelp--there are a lot of complaints about this issue for KTS.) So it seems like there just isn't the price control pressure here constraining them and keeping the prices lower.
The one area where this isn't the case are the clearance records. Here, much more often, it's the case that clearance records seem to go for just .50 cents, whereas more often clearance records at Bloomingdale go for $1.00. (Palatine also tends to have a lot of 50 cent records though. At all 3 places, the clearance records seem to be all over the map in terms of the shape they are actually in at these price points. That is, a .50 record is not necessarily in worse shape than a 1.00 record, and not all .50 or 1.00 records are of equal quality with other records of the exact same price, either. This is another HPB quirk that seems to happen at all HPB locations, and not any particular location.)
Given the overpricing issue here, I don't feel comfortable giving this HPB higher than 2 stars. (The complaints regarding low pay out people have left here for this location are also true. However, that's an across the board issue that HPBs has a chain, at least throughout the Chicagoland area, and not just an issue specific to this location. Given this fact, I haven't reduced the score more based on that factor relative to other HPBs I've rated here on Yelp.)
[Note: If you want actual money for your records, but you don't want to sell them yourself on say, Ebay or whatnot, HPBs is not the place to do it. I recommend you take them to either Dusty Groove or one of the Reckless Records locations in Chicago, because you will get more money--in some cases, a lot more (depending on what you are trying to sell, of course). You'll likely get even more if you do trade ins at these places rather than a straight up sale.] read more