Gumby's Pizza - Columbia, MO I was working in Columbia last week when a few coworkers suggested we stop by Gumby's Pizza for lunch. Located downtown near the Mizzou campus, Gumby's is a well-known local spot that's popular with students and residents alike. As with most downtown areas, parking can be a bit of a challenge, so plan accordingly. At first glance, the restaurant looks small from the outside, but once you step inside, you'll find it surprisingly spacious. When you walk in, you're greeted by specials posted throughout the entrance area. We arrived right around noon and, to our surprise, we were the only group dining at that time. Orders are placed at the counter, where we were helped by a woman who was absolutely fantastic--friendly, patient, and accommodating, especially considering that several people in our group were visiting for the first time. After ordering, you can choose to sit at a booth, high-top table, or at the bar. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, with TVs throughout, a music machine, and even a pool table for entertainment. Since I'm currently following a fasting diet and skip breakfast and lunch, I ordered my meal to go so I could enjoy it for dinner. Having had plenty of pizza the night before at Shakespeare's, I decided to switch things up. I went with a pound of boneless wings--half buffalo, half mango habanero--and added a side of beef toasted ravioli. One of our local coworkers also ordered the XL cheese bread for the table, and I can confidently say, based on both this visit and past experiences, it's easily in my top three for cheese bread anywhere. Everyone in our group was happy with their food, from the pizzas to the other menu items. Overall, Gumby's is a spot I'll continue to visit whenever I'm in Columbia. Great service, solid food, and a laid-back vibe make it a go-to for a casual meal downtown. read more

See all

I have to agree with, Rylee. Drunk and Sober me would rate this pizza totally different. Drunk would be a good solid 4+ and sober me would say it's just an average 3. However, I totally did enjoy my small sausage and jalapeno pizza after a night of bar hopping in COMO. I ordered at the counter and took my deliciousness back to my hotel room to enjoy. The counterperson was friendly and professional. There were several of us ordering and waiting for carry-out. She totally kept the line moving and even offered glasses of water for us to enjoy while waiting. My wait was actually a very short time. The set-up behind the counter was easy to view, so I got to watch them make my pizza. When mine came out of the oven, I knew it was mine. There were plenty of topping and the mozzarella cheese was well melted and even had a golden color to it. Is Gumby's the "best" pizza? No, but it is head and shoulders above a national chain pizzeria that is just a few doors down. So, I recommend them over Papa. read more

See all

The perfect setting for a pizza place on a college town.The food was great. The person taking orders was courteous. They could have cleaned the empty tables more especially since seating is limited. Taking is limited. They do have a very good pizza. The chicken was delicious. If I ever visit Columbia again and desiring pizza I can go to Gumby. read more

See all

There is a very well-known pizza establishment in CoMo that has a similar name of a famous English Author- This isn't it! This is named after a fictional character and the pizza here is Non-Fiction! It's the real thing & I'm here to tell you IT IS DELICIOUS! You have to go to Gumby's! Damnit! read more

We always get Gumby's in Iowa City so we had to hit this place when we knew it was in Columbia. We just get pokey sticks. Ordered a medium for 2. Perfect size. Need to get extra sauces. It might be better than the Iowa City pokey sticks. There I said it. read more

Gumby's Pizza - pokey sticks! - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Missouri

Just how I remember it! Took a pitstop because I was starving on the road. Called ahead and the order was placed! They didn't ask for a name but I ordered a half and half pokey stick/pepperoni pizza. It's the only way to do it! Rolled in about 20 minutes later and it was done as soon as i got there. Seating was empty and it looks like they mostly get carryout orders. The environment doesn't look very kept up but the kitchen was clean. The pizza was hot and tasted exactly as I remember it from back in the day. I am glad they haven't changed the recipe and it's definitely a pizza to try when in town. read more

Gumby's Pizza - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Missouri

This is the best pizza in Columbia. That's all you need to know. But I have to have at least 85 characters so I'll tell you a bit more. The bar is cool and the people working are always very nice. read more

Only complaint is that DoorDash requires you pay for an extra ingredient even though you get a free ingredient. Please fix that glitch because I'm sick of paying an extra $1-3 for an ingredient I don't even want read more

This pizza is the closest we have had to New York or New Jersey pizza, which in our opinion is the best in the country.

Food is nothing special, horrible customer service, rude staff, place is dirty and has a weird odor.

Pepperoni rolls, just like I remember from the early 90s. Their pie is still the same too after 30 years. They're doing something right to last in a college town that turns half its population every 4-5 years. Delivery was a little quicker in the day but we fought through it. read more

pretty good tasted just like Costco pizza in my opinion, very fast pizza was ready right when i got there

We loved the food!! Excellent pizza and calzones!! The sizes were so large that we had two meals later.

The worst pizza I ever had don't buy it there they don't know how to make one right. Plus they took a order and made it wrong.

Nothing too hot here. Service is good but the quality of the pizza was average. Ordered a pepperoni and cheese pizza and some type of bread sticks. Usually my family will devour pizza. There were leftovers that no one will touch. Maybe we are too picky but it is not the place for me. read more

I drove to Columbia for Gumby's! It seems people aren't too excited by Gumby's, but this pizza - AND THE POKIE STICKS - are life in college towns! The pizza wasn't as great as i remember it, but it was still itching a scratch i hadn't thought i had. And the store is huge compared to the hole in the wall that comprised their late Lawrence location. Do yourself a favor - or injury - and buy some pokey sticks with a ham pizza! read more

See all

We opted for delivery service tonight and the pizza was delivered before it's scheduled time. We really wanted to love this pizza BUT, it wasn't baked long enough. The dough was gummy. It was totally inedible-we threw the whole pizza out. Needless to say, we were not only disappointed but also were left hungry. read more

Gumby's Pizza - a hand holding a piece of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Missouri

See all

Just got home with my food, the pizza looks and taste like it came out of a dining hall 2/10. Don't let them fool you the wings are wings. They're chicken nuggets! Definitely will not be returning. read more

Gumby's holds a special place in my heart. I am conflicted on how to rate this place because drunk me would give Gumby's 5 stars, whereas sober me would only give it 3 (so I settled for 4 stars). Gumby's has been my go-to late night drunk food in Columbia in the most recent years. Mostly because it's conveniently located on the edge of Broadway in downtown Como. My favorite things to order are the Stoner Pie and the Pokey Sticks. Service has always been fast and friendly and delivery is SO convenient!! I have to admit, Gumby's is a great late night option whether you're hungry after the bars or up late studying for an exam and need a food break! read more

Gumby's Pizza - Stoner Pie - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Missouri

Pokey Stix with ranch are simply the best thing I've ever eaten from a pizza place. Told them what time I'd be there and they were pulling them out of the oven as I arrived. read more

Always good food! Friendly smiles and good service. Only issue is parking. Then again it's downtown they can do much with that.

EXTREMELY disappointed we came to gumpys at 12 at night because the website claims to be open until to 2am only to find that they were closed. Try updating your website or stay open until the time you claim to. read more

Once one of my favorite pizza spots in CoMo but. Has rapidly deteriorated n quality. Got a slice from them recently that they refused to heat up and was fairly bland tasting. If you're ordering fresh, it might be okay despite the other obvious choices better pizza in CoMo like pizza tree read more

Just called to place an order. The girl on the other end took my address and let me know that they didn't deliver here. I stated that their other store was closed and she said "yeahhhh sorry." And hung up. I would have placed a pick up order if she would have let me continue. Not so great customer service. read more

They have weekly specials with good deals. Very affordable and the pizza tastes great.

13 years later and it's still sooo good. Stopped by on our way to KC and the cashier was so friendly, food was fresh and the sitting area was super clean. Cartoons on one tv for the kid and game shows on another for me :) Love that they sell by the slice as well. I'm glad something this good never changes :) read more

One of the best pizzas in the country. I crave it. Quality toppings and dough. Thick just enough without being sloppy. Only pizza I eat with ranch. read more

The food tastes good, but their integrity is questionable. Placed an order today, the pizza was supposed to be a large and the pokie stix a medium. Both were the same size. I called them to let them know so that I could get reimbursed, they asked for a picture, so I sent them a picture of the two side by side. The owner seen the pic and said that the pizza was a large. Not sure how one is a 14 inch and one is a 12 inch when they're the same size, but they definitely lost my business. Here is the pic I sent them, so you all can be the judge. read more

Gumby's Pizza - The restaurant claims that one is a large, and one is a medium. - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Missouri

Oh, hey Gumby's. Gumby's is a place my friends and I frequented after a night of drinking. Since they're open until 2 a.m. on weeknights and 3 a.m. Thursday-Saturday, it's a good place to go to hang out and get greasy food after midnight. The pizza is just pizza. It's not really great or bad, it's just warm and crave-able late at night. The staff at Gumby's is pretty laid back, and with the pool tables, air hockey tables, TVs, and the late night crowd it can really be a good place to be. Gumby's, thank you for being you and staying open late. read more

Gumby's Pizza - Inside Gumby's - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Missouri

Hands down the best pizza place in Columbia. The pokey sticks are to die for. The ranch is from God. Can't wait to visit when I come back.

Nothing like Kate night Pokey Sticks to bring back memories of college days. This is definitely drunk pizza. Not too bad but nothing great. Service inside was nice and efficient. read more

Absolutely disgusting! Normally Gumby's is a good pizza option in Columbia, but tonight I got the greasiest pizza even the crust was soaked bright orange. What a waste of $16! Will not be purchasing from Gumby's anymore. Disgusting, had to throw away almost the entire pizza. read more

Gumby's Pizza - Pepperoni and Pineapple pizza (large) - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Missouri

See all

This is a guilty pleasure for me. Use to order from here all the time in college (different location that is now closed). Was able to stop here on my way from Chicago to KC. Ordered pokey stix and pepperoni rolls. They were just as good as I remembered them! read more

Gumby's Pizza - Pokey stix (minus 1 that my wife couldn't wait for) - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Missouri

Delicious pizza! Love the crust. Not too greasy. Delivery was estimated at 45 minutes, but driver arrived sooner. Cinnamon Dessert Pizza could have used more icing, but other than that is was tasty. read more

Gumby's Pizza - Cinnamon Dessert Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Missouri

See all

I went into Gumby's hoping to try a slice of the local flavor. The dude behind the counter tells me I'm in the wrong place - they don't serve slices. So as I'm considering buying a whole pizza, he goes on to tell me that he thinks the pizza sucks and starts giving me suggestions of other places to go. So. I left. I don't know if the pizza actually sucks. But I do know that this young man does not understand the principles of business. I guess I appreciate his honesty, though. read more

Trash... ordered and delivery took an hour and 35 min... pizza got here and it's ice cold and tastes even worse. Will not eat here when I'm back in town again. read more

Really good pizza after a late night out. Love the pokey sticks and the music here. Pizzas are super good and decently priced. Fun atmosphere as well. Good place to take out or even eat there. read more

I actually prefer Gumbys pizza over Shakesperes. Everytime I go to Shakesperes, its over crowded, overpriced and takes forever to get the food. That being said, these two places are two very different types of pizza. Gumbys is the delicious cheesy pizza with just enough grease on it that you craze it. I recommend the Hawaiian BBQ pizza. Pepperoni is good but this one is SOO much better! And you MUST order pokey sticks...my fiance craves just these from them a lot so we always get them! read more

Pizza was good but light on toppings for a supreme pizza. Dough was light and not heavy not enough cheese to the edge of the pizza.

All I have to say is that eating Gumby's sober was a very rude awakening. Drunk, it's amaaaaazing. Sober, not so much. read more