I recommend this business because the pizza is always hot, the ingredients are always fresh, good at what they do. Quality is A-1. Prices are good. Real Pizza creations. read more

See all

Good pizza for takeout or dine in. I really like the Chicago style pizza. The price is right too!

Best pizza in Columbia, bar none. Order now and you won't regret it. Fantastic cheese sticks too.

Love their giant supreme I use to work over nights And we went to lunch at2am. There is not much open at 2am. The pizza was slaws hot fresh and delivered on time read more

Seriously my favorite pizza in town! If you're looking for deep dish, this is where it's at.

I called and ordered 3 XL pizzas, and 2 orders of wings for pick up. Since the order was over $110 I had to pay over the phone. I was asked if I would like to authorize a tip and I said no, I'm driving to come get it, but thank you. The young man then said "WELL..we are making it for you". I was shocked. I don't care if you felt my response was rude, one should just respond professionally and just say "ok". I have worked full time since I was able to and NEVER asked for a tip for doing my job (unless I was a waitress or something that you typically would tip for) and I certainly was never rude to a customer; no matter what. Do I wish I could ask for a tip every time I helped a client?? Heck yeah, but I don't, and I certainly don't expect one for just doing my job. Not every single job deserves a tip, sorry. I'm sure our order will have something "special" in it now. Yes, I know this is a debatable topic and everyone has their own opinion and this is mine; I am tired of people wanting a tip for just doing their job. Turns out this person was also the manager! read more

I have ordered from here a few times and it has always been very good and right until tonight.My preferred pizza is deep dish with light sauce and cheese onion, green pepper, and mushrooms. The pizza that arrived was a stuffed crust pizza with some of my veggies, ham, sausage, and pepperoni. Not to my taste. Staff at restaurant said that it was Grubhub's fault and to contact them for a refund. Now I am sure they have 2 mishandled orders! I guess I will find another establishment. read more

New FAVORITE Pizza GO TO!! Man, the Deep dish is Stoooppppiiiiidddddddd great pizza goodness. Took me back to my first time ever trying Deep Dish, Chicago style, pizza . What a treat to have in Columbia, Mo!! Really well done I was impressed! read more

Cheap and delicious. Yeah, the delivery can be kinda slow, but they deliver until like 3AM, and will bring you a pizza the size of a monster truck wheel. Is the staff surly, as some reviewers have suggested? Perhaps. But, I've been ordering from them for about 18 years now and have only good things to say. I'm guessing some of these people are pizza prima donnas. I usually just pick mine up, but one can also partake of a pie within the warm confines of McNally's. A solid recommend. read more

Good pizza, hard to find, european-style customer service. Ordered a few pizzas for pickup on Monday. They shorted us a pizza, told us they were going to "refund us" the pizza they didn't send us home with, and must have forgotten to follow through. They do good pizza, but if you want them to make your pizza right, find the actual location, have them make your pizza at all, or charge you correctly for your pizza, you are probably going to the wrong place. You exist to serve them, not the other way around (and they can't be bothered). read more

Ordered a delivery with grub hub at 12am. Was given a 45-50 minute wait. 30 minutes into the order, the eta changed to 1:05 - 1:10. At 1:11 I placed an on line chat with grub hub and they contacted Wise Guys. At this point Wise Guys said they were having fax machine issues and the delivery just left. I had wanted to just cancel the order. So....the waiting continues. At 1:46am there is a knock at my door. One hour and 46 minutes for a small pizza. Phoned today to let the manager know what occurred and got a simple I'm sorry and you should contact Grub Hub. LOL - beyond poor management. Should have read the other reviews. read more

Best pizza in Columbia.. Their prices went WAY UP! Not even a little, but a lot.. Can't debate that they have the best pizza in town, though.. I would order it a lot more often, if they didn't jack prices up so much, which is the only reason I am not giving it 5 stars.. It's always gonna be the best pizza in CoMo. They should find a happy medium, however. I ordered a deep dish pizza that cost me around 25$ a few years ago, now almost $40 Before Tip! You have to tip , obviously, so it was about $45, overall. That seems a little ridiculous for 1 pizza. They don't honor their old, longtime prices of things like "the Boss", even though they still show it several places online, as part of their menu. The high prices are the only thing that's not great about the place, though.. read more

Best pizza in Columbia! The cheese bread is always a must, the deep dish is my favorite, but recently tried this stuff pizza and it's a close front runner for me. read more

See all

The deep dish pizza is amazing!!!! Every time I'm in Columbia I go back for it, would absolutely recommend

Ordered chicago style stuffed pizza after 30-45 minutes of waiting was presented with normal pie. Finally got a refund after I refused to wait another 30 minutes for them to try and figure out what a stuff was. Not happy with the way I was refunded my money I returned and ask to speak with the manager. I was contacted by a man stating he was a mgr and stated "the food industry sucks right now you got a refund " I ask if getting my money back excuse the fact my order was wrong and I wasted almost an hour of my time to which he turned and walked away Really good customer service right read more

I'd choose this place over Shakespeare hands down.I love their pizza and I love that it's hidden in an Irish pub, how niche. Also, they sell a 20" pizza, perfect size for a big party. read more

Highly allergic to onions. Got the wrong pizza and when I was explaining it to the chick she hung up on me! She could have caused me death and she didn't care one bit! Working in the delivery business for 7 years. Pepperoni and sausage should be the simplest damn pizza to make! Called to speak to the manager and the second guy refused to put him on the line! Then hung up on me when I asked why was the order not checked before delivery! That's the first thing a driver does. Worked for 7 years and now a delivery manager! Wow never ordering from this place again. Wondering why columbia is sinking. 3rd time the guy was slick and changed his voice tone to pretend he was manager I didn't fall for it but just ended it there as I have more dignity. If it's not off my card by the end of the week I'll report a fraudulent charge as I had the calls recorded to where they said they would. read more

Wise Guys Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Missouri

Pretty solid late night pizza dive. I've tried the deep dish and the stuffed pizza. I definitely preferred the stuffed.

The Boss, where you can get a ton of toppings for a decent price is awesome. The crust is a bit flimsy, hand tossed but more thin crust soggy. Overall I will order again. read more

Terrible customer service experience. Delivery driver, who apparently is also their manager, almost runs me off the road. Then I confront him and he goes into back and can be heard making fun of my complaint with other works. Notably he was the manager with the bull ring and glitter pink shoes. I hope his coma angers take my complaint serious and hire better human beings. read more

While many idiots will say the most popular thing to get a favorable communal response, their words are useless, the truth persists. And the truth is this: wise guys pizza, for better or worse, is the best "available" pizza in Columbia, MO. Is there better pizza in Columbia? Yes, but they don't deliver or maybe only last a few months before closing down. Wise guys is established, has an insanely late delivery time, is quite good pizza, and will accommodate many different delivery or ordering preferences. They are relatively inexpensive and, despite their ability to do just about everything a local pizza joint can do on a very tight margin, their pizza rarely disappoints. Their service is straight to the point and no nonsense. They're not fucking around. Be ready when you order and be a good customer and you will be rewarded with excellent results. read more

Great pizza after waiting along time for it. Good beers on tap. Get the Chicago deep dish style

The pizza is good enough that I will drive there to pick it up when they are short delivery drivers. That is some dedication to the pizza they make. Nobody wants to go pick their food up. read more

For the longest time this place ALWAYS got my order wrong. And seriously wrong. They would deliver a extra large pepperoni and we ordered a medium Hawaiian. Normally this would piss me off but I loved it because they always let us keep what they delivered and then would deliver what we ordered 30 minutes later. Sadly, they have been delivering what we actually ordered. No longer over abundance of pizza and living off of it for 3 meals a day for a week. I do love the pizza and they have it delivered in good timing. Do the Beat the Clock special. read more

Got a sausage deep dish pizza delivered on a Wednesday night. When it arrived it was all shifted to one side and not cut all the way through. When pizza arrived it was also cold and extremely greasy. Not true deep dish pizza. Very disappointed. One plus was that the pizza was delivered a few minutes before the the time that was estimated! read more

Wise Guys Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Missouri

I think there are some big fans of this pizza for delivery. I had a slice of mushroom and onion after going out to the bars, and it wasn't bad. There were lots of mushrooms and onions. It was decent pizza. read more

Oh, man. What a cool little nook hidden in a bar. Reasonable priced pizza that will make your mouth water. Friendly staff.All the taste you could want and look at the old gangster memorabilia that's on the brick wall. Highly recommended! read more

Lots of people described this place as one of the best pizza places in Columbia! I just don't see it... Been there a couple of times and had there delivery. The place is inside McNally's bar which is s pretty decent dive bar in downtown Columbia. The staff is always nice and the service prompt - Always good drink specials too! However the pizza... It is just plain, and the crust feels like it is a wafer. Had a couple of pies there during my visits. I think a simple garlic and mushroom with pepper jack cheese is the best. Keep all the rest and go to Gumby's instead. read more

I had a great experience with their delivery. For some reason, in a larger college community, not many pizza places are open past 11. I find that strange! However, Wise Guy's is! They deliver quite late any day of the week! I was traveling and greatly appreciated their friendly service both on the phone, as well as that of the delivery driver. Now, for their pizza! I had original crust and it was very delicious! I highly recommend Wise Guy's Pizza. If I am ever in the area again, I will have to try their deep dish Chicago style pizza, I bet it is just as delicious. Try Wise Guy's, you will not be disappointed! read more

Let's just say, I was a rebellious youth. We won't mention what was frequently done, late at night, with my friends, that would sometimes give us munchies. This is who we would call, every time. Even as an adult, it's still some of the best stinkin' pizza you'll ever put in your gullet. But I'm pretty sure most of the staff is still... "rebel yelling," and I think it's run out of the back of a bar? But it's so good! read more

They would not take my call and just kept throwing me on hold. Switched to online and they cancelled my order without a reason given. Just awful customer service. read more

Ordered three large pizzas and after 1-1/2 hours it was not delivered yet. Called back twice and was told it was "out the door" both times. Arrived 2 hours late. Asked the driver for change and he said "f-you, you don't get pizzas" and drove off. Many people here says that's happened to them. I'm pretty sure they won't be in business much longer. read more

Pretty good pizza. Delivery to hotel was exact time they said. Decently priced. Recommend ordering cinnamon sticks...yum! read more

See all