I came in here looking for books for a library we are trying to fill with authors that I enjoy…read morereading. I hit the jackpot here. They had so many wonderful books and they were very well organized. The manager saw how many books I was buying (ended up being 68) and gave me a price break. Instead of $1.50 per hardback book he only charged me $1.25. It was greatly appreciated. I also bought a big picture that was on display at the front of the store. The store seemed to be well organized. I didn't really look at the clothes since I was looking for books. But I will be back. The employees were super friendly. I was greeted by several different employees. Great experience. And I love that the money they take in supports the Muncie Mission.

I think I'm over this place. They do have some good finds but the prices are getting a little…read morecrazy. Then today at checkout the lady at the register refused to look at me or talk to me except to give me my total. Made a point of continuing to chat with her coworkers and wouldn't even glance at me. I couldn't figure it out then I remembered - I'm a woman with short hair wearing a baseball cap. The horror! What if I was a Trans?!?! I'm sure she could never live with herself at the thought of having been polite to someone who might have been different from her. Big pass. I'll be heading back to Thrifty Threads in Indy.

My daughters and I love to visit Keepers to look for things. The variety is endless. The owner is…read moreso sweet and we live to be greeted by their animal helpers.

I had my purchases behind counter bc the owner said ill hold it while you shop for more. Upon check…read moreout i was not given all my items, half my things where behind counter in box. I had my grandson with me and I purchased 100$ plus worth of items. I was handed my sacks and I left. After I got back home I noticed I was missing items. I called , she said yes it's here. I left my name and phone number. I had a surgery and other life events happen, I forgot and wasn't able to pick them up. Instead of calling me to say hey if you don't pick up we will restock etc. I got no phone call she just put it back. When I called her at shop she said I was a manager at Walmart we do not hold things! It's your fault etc. I don't care about your life events! I'm not storing no belongings for anyone! I said that's really rude and unprofessional. They could have at least phone me before they just re sold them. ! No other shop has ever talked to me this way. I phoned another shop bc I lost something they called me back and said if you need anything please call us. The owner of this keepers was very rude, no good customer service! And heartless. I will never shop there again. And I have spent 100s of dollars there! I can not believe the way she spoke to me over the phone. She treated me like I was a theft off the street she didn't want in her store. No courtesy or compassion. Just it's all my fault etc. It was forgotten bc she put it behind the counter, added it up, but upon leaving it was left behind counter and not handed to me . If I was phoned back, I would have been right there to get it. Wasted money, and they got to make double the cash on those items. Just rude!

This is Amanda's location on Carmel Drive. She has been in the consignment business 20+ years. The…read moreoriginal shop was on Main Street in Carmel. They seem to be "the" spot for Indy Northside and Fishers/Carmel consignments.

10 years, but unfortunately, the service and overall experience have continued to decline over…read moretime. The consignment drop-off hours are inconvenient, and now you're required to check yourself in and wait. Today, I was told I would need to wait 60 minutes just to consign a brand-new rug and two brand-new pairs of shoes. As a longtime customer, I find this incredibly frustrating. Time is money, and there should be a more efficient process for customers who are bringing in quality, new merchandise. Fortunately, I was able to sell the rug in the parking lot to someone who was leaving the store, so at least that worked out! After 10 years of consigning here, I'm disappointed that the customer experience has deteriorated to this point. I understand that businesses get busy, but convenience and customer service matter, especially when you're asking people to bring you quality merchandise to sell. I'll be looking for a new consignment store in Hamilton County that values its consignors' time and business.

Clothing prices are equal to Goodwill, but unlike Goodwill, they do offer discounts. Each day of…read morethe week is a different discount type. Active military and first responders get 30% off every day. They have 1 fitting room and sell a few snacks and drinks. The place is pretty big, but parking lot is small. Staff is very friendly. 1st Sat of each month entire store is 50% off, no exceptions. DVDs =$1, books = $1 or less, most jewelry = $3 or less.

I was in there on 03/11/2026 I mentioned how their prices are out of control. The store supervisor…read morecame out and said if I didn't like it I could go to Goodwill and I said I know where Goodwill is. She continue to badger me grab the vacuum bags out of my hand and then grab the cart out of my hand and told me to get out I said I'll would like to make a donation to the homeless because she kept mentioning how the money goes to the homeless. I never felt so belittled in my life. I googled it but I'm not sure if it's right but it says it's battery if someone grabs something out of your hand so if that's true she shouldn't have grab the bags and the cart. As far as the homeless go if it wasn't a man I would have invited him into my house on them very extreme cold days we had but I'm a single woman that lives by myself. Where was that store supervisors time or money when it was really needed??

We love visiting this hidden flea market. Even if we don't find what we need I always walk away…read morewith the cheap candy. Full sized candy bars for 50 cents and other candies and snacks for less than a dollar. Love visiting to see what random things people have made, or what vintage furniture is available. A great place for finding pieces worth displaying or including in a craft project. We stop by every month or so to see what's new. Check them out when you are in the area.

Try to understand customer service and how to take customer feedback…read more We were surprised to see DVD's for $1 and Blu Ray's for $3, but VHS tapes were $5!! I said to the lady behind the counter that not many people would pay $5 for VHS tapes and she responded with "Yeah, well we sell them at that price every day." I said, "You don't have to argue with me" and we left! Goodwill and other Flea Markets average $1 for VHS tapes, including brand new and sealed.

I don't think there is another thrift store in town that compares to St. Vincents. Their prices are…read morelow, inventory great and is constantly being updated. Sales just about every day. Staff is friendly and always willing to help when needed. All sales provide the society with funds to help those people in need in the Muncie Community.

A thrift store tied to the nearby church and a former Catholic high school, St Vincent's prices are…read morevery reasonable and there are many treasures to be had. My one lament is that the store feels a bit cramped and would be awesome if it was expanded. But I love this store all the same because there's occasional treasures to be had for collectors and pickers.

Oh the places you'll go! I'm sitting here on vacation drinking my coffee early morning in my tank…read moretop I got for $3 from the Toggery. This place is the best! We came here on a sleepy Saturday afternoon and hit the jackpot because they were having a sidewalk sale with very nice prices. I walked away with Talbots, Athleta, Rock and Republic, Free People on clearance and splurged on a Lululemon sweatshirt for full price (still under $40 so no complaints there). Not only are the prices great but this store will make any organized persons heart sing! Amazing organization and flow of the store, kudos Toggery! I will be making another trip here next time in the Broadripple area.

I found some designer jeans here for $50 that usually sell for about $200, and they are my favorite…read morego-to jeans, so that's cool. At first, I was a little disappointed in The Toggery because it seemed like the clothes were just a half step up from a regular Goodwill, but then I found the jeans, and now I'm not so sure. I think it all depends on when you shop, and what you're looking for. If you're looking for unusual vintage gems, you probably won't find that here. If you're looking for regional-trendy clothing ... you will probably find that here. I visited on a Saturday afternoon, and the racks seemed a little picked-through, but I think that's because this place is popular and so the racks probably were indeed picked through. They buy clothing during the weekdays, so if you want to find the good stuff, you should probably visit during the week, I'm thinking. The clothing is arranged very nicely, and everything is super organized and clean. They have dressing rooms available that you can just walk into (you don't have to flag down someone!), and they also have sale items that are pretty good. Like most consignment shops, they don't accept returns or exchanges, so make sure you're happy with your items before you purchase!

Stumbled upon this place cruising around Anderson and it's a gem! Tons of high quality antique…read morecollectables and randomness. Had some cool oil lanterns that hung on the wall for 3 bucks but I missed out. If you love findings treasures at flea markets and such then check them out.

Been to this location on two separate occasions and on BOTH visits, when I thought I'd found a…read more"BACKYARD BARGIN," the woman manager decided to DOUBLE the items listed sticker price AT THE REGISTER because she thought they were priced too low. I'm no lawyer, but I believe that falls under false advertising! Honestly, the price isn't even the problem here. The issue is this poor management! I'd pay triple for an item I wanted if it was originally priced as such. But to change sticker prices mid-transaction because you think you can get more out of it is bad salesmanship! Moral of this story... time to get some new leadership at this location!